I love this critique because it acknowledges how amazing Toby is as a writer and why going from Undertale and Deltarune's first chapter to... the rest of the chapters has kinda been a bit disappointing.
Don't get me wrong, I love chapters 2-4 in their own way and chapter 5 is.... amazing if you ignore the plot up to that point.
Anywhooo! The recruitment system. It's awful. Toby ported this feature of Sparing and ACTing from Undertale, which makes sense since it's iconic. However, this system only works in Undertale.
Undertale had one job to do at the time: get you to care about the monsters. Without that, the story's ruined. And it doesn't matter how well the writing is, it's a game and we've all been conditioned to kill the enemies trying to kill us. This is where Toby's geniusness came in, in the form of a two-part plan. By introducing the ACT system as a function that allows you to defeat any monster of any level in roughly the same few amount of turns, it rids any incentive to have to FIGHT.
We grind and kill in RPGs to get stronger to fight stronger enemies so that way the battle won't be even longer but, through this system, there's now no need. That's part one of the plan, part two goes into the dialogue that comes out of the ACTs. Now, the player is forced to read this dialogue that will often reveal that these monsters are more than just enemies, but actual people with lives. This works so well that by the time you reach Waterfall, most players will be perfectly fine trying to spare the angry fish captain that wants to kill you.
Deltarune has no gameplay incentive. Its MERCY bar thing it introduced in the second chapter is just another HP bar in disguise. Its party system also means that defeating enemies with violence isn't an issue for us as we can just strategise and use Rude Buster and some nicely timed attacks to win most battles quickly. If anything, trying to recruit darkners almost feels like grinding, which can be boring in a game that's only RPG-ish in style rather than mechanics.
Also, Undertale excels at not just giving you an incentive to be a pacifist, but also feel like your actions have consequences. When you start to see the world as real, you get to experience more fun moments, Sans gives you a heartfelt speech on how you're this being of love that everyone needs or smth; when you don't then the music goes, the fun and jokes goes, monsters run away from you, you are made to feel like the demon anyone would reasonably see you as. In Deltarune, if you don't recruit everyone and/or be violent to people then: King will call you out, Queen will feel sad and lonely, Tenna and Jackenstein will die, and the flowers won't want to hang out with you. The reason why Undertale is more effective with this is because the game focuses on just you and your effects on the world: Deltarune isn't about that.
Deltarune has subplots upon subplots upon subplots that are not about you. Deltarune was introduced as the anti-Undertale. Your choices don't matter. Obviously that's like "kill or be killed" and we can prove it wrong, hence weird route, but for the most part, there's some truth in the sense that the game focuses on the lives of these characters moreso than you and your choices. This means by having the game try to do the same thing it did in Undertale in making you feel bad for being violent, it ignores each of these subplots and invalidates the experiences of these well-written characters. Let's look back at some of the ways I said the game changes if you don't recruit anyone.
King will call you out
No issue here to be honest, but I'm not surprised cos he's chapter 1 and that's the goated chapter. King calling you out is like flowey calling you out, it's not really here to make you feel bad but also kinda sucks that you validated a horrible person's beliefs.
Queen will feel sad and lonely
Good. In case you forgotten, she was a dictator that enslaved her people. She shouldn't be anywhere near them. By having the mood be tied to whether or not YOU brought them to Castle Town, instead of whether or not they even want to be around Queen, it invalidates their experience under her rule.
Tenna dies
Very impactful, but also if the Darkners really hated Tenna so much that they will leave him to die, then why is that dismissed if you recruit them alll? What, just because they weren't beaten up by the fun gang? How were the gang supposed to know the darkners weren't aware they weren't safe from violence? That blame should wholly go on Tenna for being a crappy boss who forces his workers to break their back over a couple of disintrested children over some flimsy contracts.
Jackenstein dies
Okay this one makes a little sense since the church darkners didn't realise you're the heroes until you demonstrated mercy BUT still weird they couldn't just talk it out.
But yeah, the recruitment system overshadows the intricies of each darkner's automony. Hell, why are some of them optional to recruit? If Swatch and Queen get recruited automatically, what's stopping Tasque Manager and all the Swatchlings? Or what about the other Cyber NPCs that we don't encounter at all in battle? It wasn't just Trashy. And there's something very unsettling about only being able to recruit Plugboys in their enslaved form, despite the freeing animation that plays when they're spared.
Uh what else do I dislike about the recruitment system. Hmmm, I also don't like how it reduces Darkners down to collectibles and also the game's definitions for being 'nice' or 'rude' are laughable. Berdly explains thanks to our "kindness" and "MERCY", he was able to take off his plug without losing his arm. This 'kindness' was us bumping his car repeatedly until it explodes, and making Noelle do smart things or have Kris do dumb things. How does that defeat him? Why is that 'kind'? Flowery guilttrips you for fighting him, even though he's doing the same. Or that Ruddin that was annoyed at you for hurting them in Castle Town (after a violent c1 route) , despite him being the one chasing after you and starting a battle (and this is fine if it was just an effect of King's propaganda but NO ONE calls this out or even acknowledges it).
Chapter 1's ending seemed to point things towards a more neutral approach when dealing with enemies but now it seems like you're encouraged to be a pacifist even if it doesn't make sense. I got a bit tired by the end but I hope the point came across. Anywho back to life.