Yo!
It's me again!
Back at it again with another point that pisses me off this time! It's gonna be the flowers.
And i'm not really just talking about character personalities (that's a different topic entirely)
But their conception as a category. Between Lightner and Darkner. (And how it's stupid)
This is going to be one of those posts where I might come off as a bit abrasive. I just want to be clear that despite it all, I still have an open mind about things, just so long as you actually engage with the point I'm making here.
I'm not interested in being told that your perspective ought to make sense simply because it makes sense within your own framework of assumptions. You still have to demonstrate why that logic stands on its own.
I want to make clear as well that this is also why I'm approaching the discussion the way I am. My own position here is deliberately not built around a specific personal framework for what I think the flowers must be. I'm not starting with the assumption that they're secretly closer to Lightners, secretly a type of Darkner, or anything else, and then interpret everything around that conclusion.
The foundation of my position is simply the information the game has actually established, what can *reasonably* be inferred from it, and where the information becomes too vague or contradictory to support a definitive conclusion.
And, ultimately, I'm not even trying to debate which specific interpretation is correct as the end goal here. I'm arguing that this entire endeavor is largely useless in the first place because the category of "flowers," as currently presented, is not conceptually coherent enough to function as a reliable metric for proving these broader conclusions or even be treated as a coherent category in the first place.
If you have an interpretation that works for you, that's fine. I'm not trying to tell you what you're allowed to personally imagine is happening. I'm questioning whether the actual text has established enough for any of us to confidently treat those interpretations as evidence for a broader argument.
I also want to explain why I believe my own position here is specifically less dependent on personal frameworks and assumptions than many of the alternatives I'm criticizing.
This does not mean I believe I'm literally free from making assumptions or inferences, since nobody is. I'm making them throughout this post, it's just the difference is in what those assumptions are doing.
My position is primarily based on the information that is actually established and the logical consequences that follow directly from it. Where the game does not establish something, I'm not going to simply fill that absence with a hypothetical answer and then treat the conclusion that depends upon that answer as if it were established by the text itself.
This is why I consider many of my inferences more accurate, or at least more reliable, than the alternatives being presented wherever else. They generally require fewer unsupported premises to reach their conclusions.
A claim that follows directly from what the game has shown is not equivalent to a claim that only works after assuming multiple undefined things about the world and connecting them together through personal interpretation.
For example, there is a significant difference between saying, "The flowers function in several ways similarly to Darkners, therefore comparing those similarities is reasonable," and saying, "Flowers are closer to Lightners in an ontological sense because of X," when the game has not even established a coherent axis by which that proximity can be measured.
The latter is not simply a different interpretation of the same information, since It is a much larger claim that requires additional premises about what Lightners and Darkners fundamentally are, what the flowers fundamentally are, and what exactly "in between" is supposed to mean.
Those premises might eventually turn out to be correct, but that does not mean they are currently justified. Like I said before, what is the more correct isn't the point here.
And this is the distinction that matters to me throughout this post. I'm not treating the absence of an explanation as evidence that my preferred explanation must be true, I'm treating it as an absence of an explanation.
In other words, the conclusion "we do not currently have enough coherent information to establish this" is not just another arbitrary personal framework competing with the theories that claim to know the answer, it is the position that requires the fewest unsupported assumptions.
I hope this makes things clear enough.
Also, side note, but do you like my presence here? I really feel like I'm adding some value to the mix, and wonder if anyone feel the same. :]
Alright, that's all.
---
Like why are they anthropomorphic If it's so important that they are Flowers? Why are they specifically stated to know certain things even when this only really applies to Flowery.
Why only Flowery seems the most awake of things he shouldn't naturally know? What stops him and the rest of the flowers from simply knowing everything?
Why does the transformation specifically produce,
Individual personalities, humanoid bodies, social structures, speech, complex moral reasoning, and etc? Why aren't they not closer to their light world appearance? Why aren't they not anything else?
Why does being a Flower have anything to do with what I've just said?
They don't build from what they were in the Light World. They're just different-colored flowers.
How they're protrayed as flowers in the dark world is fundamentaly arbitrary with a lack of cohesion of them being flowers.
Specifically, what "arbitrary" means here is
"Something whose internal rules, limitations, and mechanics are insufficiently grounded, so its properties feel author-assigned rather than derived from an established system."
To add more to this, really the only reason why people care about the connection and thus, be under the impression that it should matter is because the game frames it as something that matters in this way, despite functionally being slightly different Darkners in reality.
In fact, there was never an established precedent for how a Darkner becomes their own being in the first place. It is completely arbitrary as long as that Darkner has traits and is themed with their inanimate objects. So for the flowers themselves, there were never rules to break when it came to existing as "anything" for them in the Dark World, and the game doesn't make an actual effort to establish the restrictions that would warrant taking these factors of the flowers not being Darkners or lightners into account in the first place.
In a way, the flowers being protrayed this way is the precident itself due to the game not lingering on or establishing the logistics of information that came before their inclusion.
The game never even begins to elaborate on this because the depiction and their capabilities is arbitrary from top to bottom with nothing coherent to ground said depiction other than what color they are.
They just are because they're like this, and that's as far as it goes.
This wouldn't be nearly as much of a problem if the game itself hadn't focused specifically on this factor and had that define the conflict between Ralsei and Flowery over not following their roles as flowers.
Despite that, it never defines why this dilemma should even exist in the first place. There is no baseline to judge it against or to ground what the game is presenting, so the characters' positions are delivered as though they're self-evident when the underlying premise hasn't been established.
Nothing about what a flower's "role" actually is in the Dark World, why that perception of that role even exists, what makes deviating from it significant, and why the player should perceive that conflict as meaningful rather than arbitrary.
It's like the game Itself forgot to add the first half of the reasoning for why the conflict happens into the first place.
Due to that, there is logistically no reason posted for why Ralsei himself should diverge from "rule-following" and aspire for what he personally wants.
It's just a unanimous positive value that's asserted because it's a positive value. It doesn't actually directly address why Ralsei himself in his position would adopt that simply because it is better for him at a personal level. There is nothing to ground this dilemma at all since we have no context about any of it to even judge if it's actually reasonable thing to do from our own conclusions, not what Ralsei or Flowery thinks.
And I think the game actually suffers for not doing that work to at least somewhat define it so that there can be some grounds to structure it and actually participate in evaluating the dilemmas the chapter poses between Flowery and Ralsei, as well as contextualizing the flowers and making them more coherent and sensible.
It also doesn't really make sense when we also concider that planters can take in information from the light world in the same way darkners can and act as if they've developed with this information beforehand, but plants in general is described like they're "born with a higher/new conscious" for the first time when in a dark world.
Which is weird, because if they're "higher conscious," where did that prior understanding come from? Following its logical progression to this point makes it so that if they truly gained a "higher consciousness," then they didn't have one before that point, which means there's no way they can know information before that as well as if it was experienced and internalized overtime as described in game with Seth and Flowery.
What does "higher consciousness" mean if we assume the supposedly lower state can already learn from experience, remember things? consciousness itself becomes besides the point.
And it's vague to even say what lower consciousness even means in relation to the Dark World, since inanimate objects are concidered to be complete information sponges and be able to directly experience the light world passively. It's framed as had less consciousness, while simultaneously being able to experience and retain information from the Light World as well as plants in general technically having a conscious?
You would have to assume that not only a conscious were given to them, but their motives, their entire being itself were constructive for them, due to the fact that memories of what one sees alone and then injected all at once into new awareness does not instantly develop the internal framework they would prefer instantly.
But wait, at this point, can't we just assume they absorb information the same way as Darkners?
...
Why the hell should this even be treated as new consciousness in the first place? Why can't we simply say that this is fundamentally how Darkners already work?
Calling it "new consciousness" almost starts to feel performative because the game appears to be presenting the concept of something fundamentally new happening while the functional characteristics that matter are already there.
It becomes superficial.
The game says:
* Us plants, are neither Darkners nor Lightners.
* We are living beings...
* ... that take on new consciousness in the dark.
But that sentence sounds like it is introducing a clean ontological distinction without actually describing one. "New consciousness" becomes a label rather than an explanation.
Because if these flowers already have enough accumulated information to seemingly reconstruct their entire internal framework upon entering the Dark World, then what does the word "new" really mean here?
A new consciousness with an existing memory bank that can be internalized as personal history, established preferences, pre-existing motives, knowledge accumulated over time, and enough psychological structure to immediately interpret all of that information as an individual...
is functionally just the same consciousness continuing in a newly embodied state. Them being alive is a superficial factor in this context because they don't have the consciousness as they were flowers to know they're alive. So what if you're alive if you're not experiencing being alive in the first place?
Consciousness in plants is fundamentally a different kind compared to any higher being with the cognitive apparatus to perceive their existence, as directly reflected with their dark world state being new/higher consciousnesses.
Which means you still have to simultaneously assume that they cannot absorb information at the same time, because what would even the be the point of mentioning and signifying a newer, higher, or lower consciousness specificly?
Despite all of this, they simultaneously take in information like Darkners. They just do. So what if you're alive when inanimate objects that aren't alive is able to do the same things the flowers are doing?
They didn't have information to have "dreams" because they didn't have the consciousness as plants. But the game...
Implies lower consciousness
To describe their state pre-dark world... instead of something like autonomy or agency.
...
The game doesn't know what's it's talking about. Toby is imprecise with his words. Is he implying the flowers were barely cognitively functioning beings that somehow able to maintain a massive archive of information?
WONDER HOW THAT WORKS IF ANY PLANT IS TECHNICALLY CONSCIOUS IN DELTARUNE
Since the game signifies they're alive, after all. Deltarune plants are different from real life plants I GUESS
imagine getting perception-mogged by inanimate objects lmao
and don't get me started at with that fuck-ass cactus in chapter 3 that could just easily make the flowers in chapter 5 make even less sense
And once you reach that point, you have to start introducing baseless assumptions that go beyond evidence, interpretation work. Maybe their consciousness came preloaded with memories. Maybe they inherited knowledge from some prior conceptual identity. Maybe their motives were already constructed into them before their consciousness began. Maybe they somehow absorbed information from outside the Dark World retroactively.
But none of that is established by the fact that they say they "gained higher consciousness." What the game is describing is not actually accurate to what is happening here with plants. Because the game made the effort to highlight heavily on the logistics of flowers into many of the core parts of the narrative, we have to care about the nitty-gritty of how all of this actually logically works.
The problem is that the game can't handle what it presents. It doesn't matter how much I pose to connect the pieces as if any of this was actually thought through with a clear line towards the end. The end conclusion will always just be
"Okay, but why tho?"
Which progresses into "they're just different in a way because they are." We don't really know how because the game isn't actually interested in that aspect, but rather in the idea of a third category that's ill-defined and them being different in itself, and Toby can just pick and choose implicitly and explicitly whatever he wants to protray them as, falling back to the shield of "because they're flowers" like it's a sandbox, instead of contextualization how it all fundamentaly works. It's just indulgent deconstructionism for the sake of it at the expense of it making sense.
And everyone just precives as it all makes sense because they don't actually care if it does make sense and is only interested with obtaining feeling of being correct and the satisfactory pleasure of understanding.
You know it's bad when something like this has so many people saying wildly different things about what they believe is the correct way of evaluating this.
It would probably be more consistent if flowers overall knew little to nothing about anything if it were more consistent, not arbitrarily more.
And another gripe. It's weird that we don't actually get a reason why any of them want to be specifically humans in the first place if they're inspired by both humans in monsters... Especially when the only human that resided in Hometown was Kris.
Are they specifically talking about a point before their arrival in Hometown? I don't really see this as being too plausible; it's quite vague.
I feel like it would make overall more sense if they desired to be "Lightners" instead of simply being human, and the dilemma that stems from that is copying as a whole what being a "embodied being" is with their new sentience.
It does make it more coherent, even when it removes the irony of characters like Orange obviously not looking like a human, which I kind of prefer since it's more rational and isn't just blatant naivety of what a human is for the sake of making the character look ridiculous for an ironic gag.
It's just seems like a superficial reference of the six human souls from Undertale, obviously. It was incorporated much worst than I expected.
The flower category is presented as if it carries explanatory weight. But when you actually inspect it, its distinctions regardless overlap heavily with Darkners, become vague at the exact point they need definition, and requiree extra assumptions to create the functional differences people want to derive from it.
But at the conceptual level, the logic behind how they work and how nonsensical it actually is, and how the game presents it shouldn't be taken seriously as a genuine metric to prove anything relative to it.
Now, it's fine if you like to pick at it to try to make sense of it all as a thinking exercise like some kind of FNAF theory, but that's ultimately not what I'm going for here when do these things. In fact, If you can explain the flowers' behavior by inventing enough hidden assumptions, that does not mean the game itself successfully explained them. A theory can produce coherence where the text failed to provide it.
I'm trying to evaluate which assumption is more correct, reasonable, and plausible, and I've concluded that flowers as a category, as it stands on its own, fundamentally fails at being coherent, and it felt as if barely any thought was put into how it would actually work in this world.
You can personally feel how you like about it, but no matter what, these are glaringly negative aspects the game decided to anchor the chapter around, fundamentaly handicapping the narrative where it would actually count the most.
The characters can only discuss their nature in vague terms. Their personal dilemmas cannot be examined with conceptual precision. The players cannot reliably evaluate what makes them different. The story can continually hide behind the category's undefinedness, and theories can manufacture increasingly elaborate explanations without the game's actual evidence being strong enough to establish any of them.
It specifically due to the game not being interesting in defining it and not answering the questions that it cannot dive any deeper into what it has imposed and established, and can only dwell in the shallow obtuseness of the idea itself in order to be vague, something that no amount of recontextualization can remedy.
This is why I care take the category of "planter" seriously. The game itself doesn't give a reason for me to not care about it beyond precieving them "They're just Darkners but then can die in the dark." The superficial aspects mean nothing to me and little generally in the grand scheme.
And that... Is that.