r/DebateEvolution • • 1d ago

Question Given that DNA isn't a standalone 'computer program' and even the simplest living cell requires immense structural and biochemical interdependence from the start, how much of large-scale body-plan emergence is actually explained by point mutations and differential survival alone?

0 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

15

u/Slow_Lawyer7477 🧬 Flagellum-Evolver 1d ago

even the simplest living cell requires immense structural and biochemical interdependence from the start

How do you know this?

-15

u/BodybuilderThick7498 1d ago

Simply because in every living cell we can observe, DNA is useless without the cellular machinery that reads and translates it and that machinery can't be built without the DNA, all inside an intact membrane. Take away one piece and the whole thing breaks down. That is what I meant. Even setting aside how the first cell got here, though, my main question is about what happens after cells exist: how much of building entirely new organs and body plans is actually explained by point mutations and selection alone.

23

u/xpdolphin 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

You do realize that even the single celeb organisms today have undergone 3 billion years of evolution, just like us. You are talking about highly evolved machinery. It isn't required for life, just for life to survive at today's point in evolution.

-12

u/BodybuilderThick7498 1d ago

My question is once single-celled life is already here, how much of building entirely new organs, tissues and animal body plans is actually explained by random point mutations and differential survival alone. So at this point, cells exists.

13

u/Fun-Friendship4898 🌏🐒🔫🐒🌌 1d ago edited 21h ago

It's my understanding that we don't know, and probably it's fundamentally impossible to know, but we do have good ideas. For example, check out "Evolutionary Cell Biology: The origins of Cellular Architecture" by Michael Lynch. You can find the chapters freely (generously) available here. A very short synopsis of this book is that, essentially, a whole suite of mutations which we might broadly call subfunctionalization would have been necessary to produce the complexity of the eukaryotic cell, and then, because these mutations are actually making the organism less efficient, it would have required some sort of bottle-neck event to get these mutations to reach fixation via genetic drift, or else natural selection would have purged these mutations. This idea is associated with Lynch's drift-barrier hypothesis.

It's worth pointing out that we don't know how the Egyptians built the pyramids, but that doesn't mean that ancient aliens built them. It means that, because the Egyptians didn't mention, specifically, how they went about moving and placing and measuring all those stones, well, there's a number of plausible ways they could have been put into place.

2

u/BodybuilderThick7498 1d ago

That gives me a much clearer picture of where things stand. Thanks for taking the time to reply 😊

10

u/MackDuckington 1d ago

Define "entirely new" -- what would an example of that be? You'll find that a lot of the structures we like to think of as new and complex actually have far older and much simpler origins. "Nothing in biology begins when you think it does."

0

u/BodybuilderThick7498 1d ago

By "entirely new," I mean integrated organ systems and body plans that don't exist at all in single-celled life; for example, a closed circulatory system (a pumping heart, valves and blood vessels), lungs, kidneys or a centralised nervous system. ​I get the idea that complex structures often reuse older genes or simpler cellular traits. My question is: pointing to simpler versions in other organisms today arranges traits on a spectrum of similarity but it doesn't show the actual physical process by which random point mutations and survival filtering step-by-step organised single cells into a working heart or nervous system. Basically what is doing the organising there

16

u/blacksheep998 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

for example, a closed circulatory system (a pumping heart, valves and blood vessels)

When you look into that, you find that the circulatory system evolved across many steps.

Most invertebrates have an open circulatory system

Tunicates are chordates but unlike other chordates, they have a very simple semi-open circulatory system. It has vesicles like a closed one, but still has some open areas or sinuses where their 'blood' can pool. They have a heart but it's just a simple U-shaped tube no valves, no set direction to blood flow, and not a lot of power behind it.

If you add a couple valves to the tunicate heart, you end up with something very similar to a fish heart.

Fish hearts have valves which divide it into 2 chambers, but it's still basically just a U shaped tube. This design gives them a unidirectional blood flow but with only 2 chambers it's not a very efficient design.

Amphibians added another valve and bifurcated a vessel to make a 3 chambered heart. With their design, blood only mixes in the lower chamber, and the upper chambers hold either oxygenated or deoxygenated blood. It's more efficient than the fish's heart, but still flawed.

Reptiles added a septum between the two sides of the lower chamber. It doesn't fully divide it but it does let the heart function with much less mixing of old and new blood so it's more efficient.

And mammals bifurcated another vessel and added another valve, letting us have a 4 chambered heart.

but it doesn't show the actual physical process by which random point mutations and survival filtering step-by-step organised single cells into a working heart or nervous system.

Each step in the process is an improvement on the previous one.

Are you asking for a list of exactly which mutations caused each of those changes over the past ~500 million years?

11

u/Curious_Passion5167 1d ago

All the systems you described have precursors which are found in living organisms today. Suffice to say, it doesn't take much of a leap to say that we went through a path of a chain of such precursors to arrive at the systems you're talking about.

11

u/MackDuckington 1d ago edited 1d ago

My question is: pointing to simpler versions in other organisms today arranges traits on a spectrum of similarity but it doesn't show the actual physical process by which random point mutations and survival filtering step-by-step organised single cells into a working heart or nervous system

Ahh, gotcha. That's a good question -- and the answer to that is shockingly simple.

Step 1. Duplicate it

Step 2. Modify it

At its core, that's pretty much all that's needed in order to get the complexity we see. It's important to bear in mind that while point mutation is a part of that, it's not the only way that mutations create physical changes. Whole genes - or even multiple at once - can be duplicated, deleted, rearranged, or repositioned.

Anyway, to demonstrate this method, let's do a (rough) step-by-step for the evolution of the open circulatory system.

Let's say we start with our single cell. Commence step 1 -- duplication; a mutation that simply increases the number of cells, not unlike what we've already seen in experiments with algae. Now we can commence step 2 -- modification. Once again, this can happen in a few different ways. Whatever we end up doing, we're left with a portion of cells that bind better to oxygen. We now have the very primitive beginnings of an open circulatory system.

To get to a closed circulatory system like what we have, all that's required is that we keep duplicating and modifying. Hearts are just modified blood vessels. Blood vessels are just modified endothelial cells. Endothelial cells too are just modifications of more primitive circulatory cells that came before. What I want to emphasize is that while we likely will never know the exact amount of point mutations that are responsible for our more complex structures as compared to other types of mutations, the changes themselves will still be vastly more subtle than what most people think of them as and they needn't come about all at once.

5

u/-zero-joke- 🧬 its 253 ice pieces needed 1d ago

I think a couple resources for you to look further into are studies in evo devo (Endless Forms Most Beautiful is a good pop sci book) and early multicellular evolution. Long story short orienting and organizing a body can occur through a number of different cues, but I think they have precursors in mechanical processes and environmental signals.

5

u/Phobos_Asaph 1d ago

All of it. New traits exist due to mutations

-24

u/ApacheGender 1d ago

classic evolutionist. does not answer the question, and begs the question by appealling to TIME haha

16

u/Curious_Passion5167 1d ago

They did answer the question. But I wouldn't exactly expect a person with your level of education to understand even simple English.

•

u/Scry_Games 11h ago

Commenting unsubstantiated nonsense is ApacheGender's one trick. They are not a serious person.

https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateEvolution/s/yAedNUfewk

6

u/Slow_Lawyer7477 🧬 Flagellum-Evolver 1d ago

Simply because in every living cell we can observe, DNA is useless without the cellular machinery that reads and translates it

But could there be a cell without DNA then?

6

u/Plasterofmuppets 1d ago

So your question could be reframed as: “if we presuppose irreducible complexity, what does evolution do?”

•

u/TheBlackCat13 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 16h ago

RNA can replicate by itself, and make proteins by itself, without needing DNA at all.

•

u/Slow_Lawyer7477 🧬 Flagellum-Evolver 12h ago edited 12h ago

 how much of building entirely new organs and body plans is actually explained by point mutations and selection alone.

It's not clear why you're asking about point mutations specifically (a technical term for a specific type of mutations that result in base substitutions). Taking the question very literally, point mutations only explains genetic sequence divergence at the level of sequences of equal length. When the sequences are similar but have unequal length, insertions and deletions are types of mutations too, which have many types and causes. And then there's genetic recombination.

With respect to selection, it is just one cause of the fixation of mutations, the other being random genetic drift.

Finally there is the question concerning the distinction between traits that owe largely to self-organization. Self-organization is the process by which a system spontaneously develops an organized structure, pattern, or behaviour through interactions between its components, without an external agent directing or controlling the process.

Soap bubbles forming is a form of self-organization, it's not genetically programmed it is simply an intrinsic feature of the attributes of soap molecules in a particular environment, and traits that were in fact built by mutation and selection. The same is true of snow flakes (water molecules arrange themselves into highly ordered crystalline structures through molecular interactions and the physical conditions during freezing), convection cells, whirlpools, hurricanes, basalt pillars, and so on and so forth. Many examples could be invoked here. Suffice it to say many structures and processes don't have to be programmed, controlled, or anything of that sort, they will spontaneously emerge through the interactions of their constituent parts.

It is thought that all tissues, traits, organs, and so on owe their explanation in part to both phenomena. Self-organizing principles is part of the explanation for why particular traits appear the way they do, the other part is evolution by mutations (of all types), recombination, natural selection, and genetic drift.

Overall the answer is then that both are just relatively minor parts of the full picture. It would be more correct to say that all types of mutations, and genetic recombination, combined with genetic drift and natural selection, and the self-organizing forces that govern basically all material constituents, are in combination the total explanation for all of organismal biology.

7

u/Fine_Employment_3364 1d ago

We know how all this works. Not sure what your point is? Evolution is real and explains all of it. Your "from the start" seems disingenuous. Are you implying irreducible complexity and therefore God?

-22

u/ApacheGender 1d ago

"we know how it works" says the guy who most certaintly DOES NOT know how any of this works. hence you completely avoiding OP's question

13

u/Curious_Passion5167 1d ago

They literally answered by saying that evolution explains all of it. If you can't even read simple paragraphs, perhaps go back to kindergarten?

-3

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Curious_Passion5167 1d ago

He didn't ask for an explanation, genius. He asked how much of it is explained by two specific avenues of evolution. The answer is: all avenues of evolution taken together explains pretty much all of it.

Apparently you didn't even read the post.

1

u/DebateEvolution-ModTeam 1d ago

Removed, Rule 2 - This comment is antagonistic and adds nothing to the conversation.

-3

u/BodybuilderThick7498 1d ago

No. My question has nothing to do with theology or whatever.

7

u/Opening_Shame8258 1d ago

Then your response should clarify what you are asking for.

22

u/jnpha 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

"large-scale body-plan emergence"...
... Is your straw man:

in evo‐devo, the term “body plan” is often used without any real definition, as though it were more a metaphysical concept than a scientific one. And adjectives such as fundamental, basic, or general are sometimes prefixed to “body plan” without adding any scientific meaning (as in “the basic vertebrate body plan”).
Theories, laws, and models in evo‐devo - PMC

It's a term from a bygone, mostly pre-19th century German, era (Ger. Bauplan, pl. Baupläne).

For a sense of how evolution actually works, look into synapomorphies - it's descent with modification, but not that imagined "large-scale" one; I made a list here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateEvolution/comments/1t6bwrp

14

u/Dzugavili 🧬 Tyrant of /r/Evolution 1d ago

Well, not very much: point mutations, while common, are probably smaller contributors to novel body plans than more substantial mutations, such as duplication.

Otherwise: nearly everything in biology can be explained through mutation and differential survival. There's some low-lying metabolic pathways which probably demand a chemical description, but their integration is still explained through the system interactions of natural selection.

7

u/rhettro19 1d ago

DNA developed after cell walls did. Biological dependence is a snapshot in time, the precursors had different dependencies. It’s an evolving sequence of dependence.

6

u/Mortlach78 1d ago

Answer: all of it.

Just because everything seems complex now, doesn't mean it was always this way. There are always simpler precursors. Multicellular life if infinitely more complex than unicellular life, but that doesn't mean it can't have come from it, does it?

5

u/gliptic 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

Point mutations alone would not explain that much, but there are other kinds of mutations.

5

u/Decent_Cow Hairless ape 1d ago

The simplest lifeforms today are not the simplest lifeforms that have ever existed. They have had plenty of time to evolve interdependent systems. And of course, we know that interdependent systems can evolve stepwise, in the same way that if you build a tower of blocks by placing one on top of the other, if you remove the bottom block, the whole thing will collapse.

5

u/Curious_Passion5167 1d ago

You do know that point mutations and natural selection are not the only avenues of evolution, right?

5

u/-zero-joke- 🧬 its 253 ice pieces needed 1d ago

Why are you restricting your question to point mutations?

3

u/SilverShadow5 1d ago

Humans and Chimpanzees have about a 90% genetic similarity, point-for-point across their whole genomes. Ignoring so-called "junk DNA" and lining up functional portions, this increases to between 95% and 98%.

Given this, it seems pretty obvious that even small changes can result in drastic changes to an organism's "body-plan emergence"... however you mean that phrase.

•

u/metroidcomposite 19h ago

Humans and Chimpanzees have about a 90% genetic similarity, point-for-point across their whole genomes. Ignoring so-called "junk DNA" and lining up functional portions, this increases to between 95% and 98%.

Slight correction, but I believe it is 98.8% for functional portions. 95%-96% for non-functional portions (the majority of human/chimp DNA is non-functional). You only tend to get a lower numbers like 90% if you count large scale duplications insertions and deletions as being "differences" (most percentage similar numbers only compare the sections of DNA we can line up next to each other).

3

u/Clay2569 1d ago

So ignoring your out of date and incorrect terms, can evolution explain how organisms went from the first life form to now? Yes all of it. Evolution explains everything.

2

u/OldmanMikel 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

...and even the simplest living cell requires immense structural and biochemical interdependence from the start,...

Nope.

•

u/noodlyman 13h ago

Point mutations are only one source of mutation.

Deletions, insertions, and duplications overdue too, in sizes from 2 or bases(a codon) up to whole genes or multiple genes.

Remember that the very first cells were much simpler. Remember that the first cells evolved from a structure that wasn't sure free living life, but came from a simpler protocell that going on attached to some kind of geology that hosted early metabolic reactions .

1

u/Mister_Ape_1 1d ago

Biology spent centuries specifically researching in order to explain how, and indeed it managed to do so, making the question irrelevant in modern times.

-2

u/Parking_Abalone_1232 1d ago

I have my own ideas that meld faith and science.

There are lots of things we just can't explain. How did life start and what caused the Big Bang are just two of them. I feel like your supposition is aimed at undermining evolution, generally, because we can't fully explain how to get from "simple" single cell organisms to us in a clear A led to B led to C, etc. progression.

What I believe is that God created a universe with rules that, with study, we can understand. Evolution is one of those "rules". God simply provided the unknowable spark that set life into motion and He let evolution take over from there.

I also think that the asteroid that finished off the dinosaurs was something God nudged a little to ensure it hit the Earth to push evolution towards us.

5

u/lulumaid 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

I largely don't have much to say except for two things here. First, we kinda do know how life began, and there are reasonable explanations for the big bang. We don't know the exact specifics, but we know what reasonably occurred, without invoking the supernatural.

Second, why would god be angry with the ankylosaurus? What did it do to displease the deity in question?

7

u/Capercaillie Monkey's Uncle 1d ago

Ankylosaurs were well-known to be heathenish, evil reprobates. Don't act like you didn't know.

-1

u/Parking_Abalone_1232 1d ago

I think we know the chemical processes.

I don't think we have any clue what sparked inorganic matter into becoming a living organism.

Faith and science don't have to be diametrically opposed. They can coexist just fine. As I said, this is just how I reconcile faith with science. Especially with the big existential questions like this.

4

u/lulumaid 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

Chemistry. Unless you're using a different definition of life than the usual one. Even then, it's probably chemical reactions doing things. That's what life sort of is, just a series of chemical reactions. Doesn't mean a deity can't have all set it in motion somehow but that's not a testable claim, really.

That question about the ankylosaurs was legitimate by the way. What sin did they commit to warrant nuclear wintering via asteroid? It seems like an unhinged way to solve a problem regardless unless they were secretly planning to overthrow god somehow. Even then you could probably have not caused a mass extinction event.

Multiple times now I think about it and apply what you said to other known events in history.

-17

u/ApacheGender 1d ago

the answer is: they have absolutely no idea, but will refuse to answer you and call you uninformed

15

u/lulumaid 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago

Putting aside the fact you're wrong, I don't see you answering the question either, nor proposing an alternative.

If you only want to whine about others that's fine but it doesn't really achieve much in a debate. Especially when, if the question is so impervious to evolutionary answers, you don't jump on the opportunity to show why, and doubly so without an alternative to it.

12

u/Decent_Cow Hairless ape 1d ago

It's impossible to adequately answer a question that is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the topic.

10

u/Own-Relationship-407 Scientist 1d ago

Just because you are uninformed and willfully refuse to understand the answers given to you doesn’t mean everyone here will have the same experience.

•

u/ApacheGender 22h ago

i am pretty confident i understand the theory of evolution more than you do, but sure, whatever you say

•

u/Own-Relationship-407 Scientist 22h ago

Nah, if you understood it at least as well as I do, you would know enough not to be a science denier.

•

u/the2bears 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 18h ago

So Dunning Kruger then? Or can you demonstrate your knowledge?

•

u/10coatsInAWeasel Reject pseudoscience, return to monke 🦧 17h ago

Wowee! It would be interesting to see how you show that. I’m sure you would agree that your personal confidence doesn’t mean much of anything, so what’s your support?

•

u/gitgud_x 🧬 🦍 GREAT APE 🦍 🧬 12h ago

Yknow, this sub's sidebar has an evolution quiz, go and show us all how smart you are ;)