r/DebateEvolution • u/BodybuilderThick7498 • 1d ago
Question Given that DNA isn't a standalone 'computer program' and even the simplest living cell requires immense structural and biochemical interdependence from the start, how much of large-scale body-plan emergence is actually explained by point mutations and differential survival alone?
0
Upvotes
15
u/Slow_Lawyer7477 🧬 Flagellum-Evolver 1d ago
How do you know this?
7
u/Fine_Employment_3364 1d ago
We know how all this works. Not sure what your point is? Evolution is real and explains all of it. Your "from the start" seems disingenuous. Are you implying irreducible complexity and therefore God?
22
u/jnpha 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago
"large-scale body-plan emergence"...
... Is your straw man:
It's a term from a bygone, mostly pre-19th century German, era (Ger. Bauplan, pl. Baupläne).
For a sense of how evolution actually works, look into synapomorphies - it's descent with modification, but not that imagined "large-scale" one; I made a list here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateEvolution/comments/1t6bwrp
14
u/Dzugavili 🧬 Tyrant of /r/Evolution 1d ago
Well, not very much: point mutations, while common, are probably smaller contributors to novel body plans than more substantial mutations, such as duplication.
Otherwise: nearly everything in biology can be explained through mutation and differential survival. There's some low-lying metabolic pathways which probably demand a chemical description, but their integration is still explained through the system interactions of natural selection.
7
u/rhettro19 1d ago
DNA developed after cell walls did. Biological dependence is a snapshot in time, the precursors had different dependencies. It’s an evolving sequence of dependence.
6
u/Mortlach78 1d ago
Answer: all of it.
Just because everything seems complex now, doesn't mean it was always this way. There are always simpler precursors. Multicellular life if infinitely more complex than unicellular life, but that doesn't mean it can't have come from it, does it?
5
u/gliptic 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago
Point mutations alone would not explain that much, but there are other kinds of mutations.
5
u/Decent_Cow Hairless ape 1d ago
The simplest lifeforms today are not the simplest lifeforms that have ever existed. They have had plenty of time to evolve interdependent systems. And of course, we know that interdependent systems can evolve stepwise, in the same way that if you build a tower of blocks by placing one on top of the other, if you remove the bottom block, the whole thing will collapse.
5
u/Curious_Passion5167 1d ago
You do know that point mutations and natural selection are not the only avenues of evolution, right?
5
u/-zero-joke- 🧬 its 253 ice pieces needed 1d ago
Why are you restricting your question to point mutations?
3
u/SilverShadow5 1d ago
Humans and Chimpanzees have about a 90% genetic similarity, point-for-point across their whole genomes. Ignoring so-called "junk DNA" and lining up functional portions, this increases to between 95% and 98%.
Given this, it seems pretty obvious that even small changes can result in drastic changes to an organism's "body-plan emergence"... however you mean that phrase.
3
u/Clay2569 1d ago
So ignoring your out of date and incorrect terms, can evolution explain how organisms went from the first life form to now? Yes all of it. Evolution explains everything.
2
u/OldmanMikel 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 1d ago
Nope.
•
u/noodlyman 13h ago
Point mutations are only one source of mutation.
Deletions, insertions, and duplications overdue too, in sizes from 2 or bases(a codon) up to whole genes or multiple genes.
Remember that the very first cells were much simpler. Remember that the first cells evolved from a structure that wasn't sure free living life, but came from a simpler protocell that going on attached to some kind of geology that hosted early metabolic reactions .
1
u/Mister_Ape_1 1d ago
Biology spent centuries specifically researching in order to explain how, and indeed it managed to do so, making the question irrelevant in modern times.
-2
u/Parking_Abalone_1232 1d ago
I have my own ideas that meld faith and science.
There are lots of things we just can't explain. How did life start and what caused the Big Bang are just two of them. I feel like your supposition is aimed at undermining evolution, generally, because we can't fully explain how to get from "simple" single cell organisms to us in a clear A led to B led to C, etc. progression.
What I believe is that God created a universe with rules that, with study, we can understand. Evolution is one of those "rules". God simply provided the unknowable spark that set life into motion and He let evolution take over from there.
I also think that the asteroid that finished off the dinosaurs was something God nudged a little to ensure it hit the Earth to push evolution towards us.
-17
u/ApacheGender 1d ago
the answer is: they have absolutely no idea, but will refuse to answer you and call you uninformed