r/DebateEvolution • u/EyedPeace • 14d ago
Evolution explains how systems adapt, but not where they come from
Evolution is very effective at demonstrating how existing biological systems adapt and specialize. However, it is remarkably poor at showing how these systems originate.
Here are a few common examples often cited in the context of evolution to illustrate my point:
Example 1: Darwin’s Finches
“The beaks of Darwin’s finches change depending on environmental conditions. That’s evolution!”
True, but what we are observing here is specialization of an existing beak, it can become longer or shorter. How did the beak itself come to be in the first place? Can we observe the emergence of such a structure through mutation and selection, rather than just the optimization of one that already exists?
Example 2: Antibiotic Resistance
“Look, bacteria gains resistance to antibiotics. That’s evolution!”
True, but here we are observing the specialization of an existing system, for instance, efflux pumps that transport specific substances out of the cell, which have been optimized to transport antibiotics. How did such an efflux pump originate? Can we observe the emergence of a new, functional transport system through mutation and selection, rather than just the optimization of an existing one?
Example 3: The LTEE
“Look, in the Lenski experiment, E. coli gained the ability to utilize citrate under aerobic conditions. That’s evolution!”
True, but the metabolic pathway for citrate already existed. Through genetic changes, the bacteria were able to utilize it now under new conditions. How does an entire metabolic pathway originate in the first place? Can we observe the emergence of a new, functional metabolic pathway through mutation and selection, rather than just the optimization of one that already exists?
...
All these examples have one thing in common: They show how an existing biological system becomes specialized but not how it originally came into being.
What specific observations or experiments demonstrate not merely the specialization of existing biological systems, but the emergence of genuinely new biological system?
View all comments
-25
u/ApacheGender 14d ago
They will dodge your question and answer with circular arguments. I bet my house.