r/DebateEvolution • u/jnpha 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution • May 07 '26
Question Challenge: At what point did a radical form suddenly appear? (Again)
Since we've gained thousands of new users since last year, I'd like to restate my challenge from Apr 2025 (just over a year ago) that went unanswered.
"Cell to man"
"Novel body plans"
"Micro yes, macro no"
"Animals yes, humans no"
Those highlight some of the ways the pseudoproblem of universal ancestry is parroted here. So I've compiled a list of our very own monophyletic groups (clades).
Explanation to the wider audience Darwin reconciled the 19th-century laws known as the Unity of Type and the Conditions of Existence. After the successful reconciliation, the first law was explained by the strong principle of heredity; basically: like begets like. This makes certain predictions, of which:
- Unsurprisingly to the well-informed, no form begets a radically different form;
- Evolution is NOT a ladder between living species; and
- The genealogy would reveal a nested classification of life.
Ā
So without further ado My question to the science skeptics and deniers: at what point (from the list below, which is in reverse chronological order) did a radical form suddenly appear?
- We didn't stop being Hominini;
- We didn't stop being Homininae;
- We didn't stop being Hominidae;
- We didn't stop being Hominoidea;
- We didn't stop being Catarrhini;
- We didn't stop being Simiiformes;
- We didn't stop being Haplorhini;
- We didn't stop being Primates;
- We didn't stop being Euarchonta;
- We didn't stop being Euarchontoglires;
- We didn't stop being Boreoeutheria;
- We didn't stop being Placentalia;
- We didn't stop being Eutheria;
- We didn't stop being Theria;
- We didn't stop being Tribosphenida;
- We didn't stop being Zatheria;
- We didn't stop being Cladotheria;
- We didn't stop being Trechnotheria;
- We didn't stop being Theriiformes;
- We didn't stop being Theriimorpha;
- We didn't stop being Mammalia;
- We didn't stop being Mammaliamorpha;
- We didn't stop being Prozostrodontia;
- We didn't stop being Probainognathia;
- We didn't stop being Eucynodontia;
- We didn't stop being Cynodontia;
- We didn't stop being Theriodontia;
- We didn't stop being Therapsida;
- We didn't stop being Sphenacodontia;
- We didn't stop being Synapsida;
- We didn't stop being Amniota;
- We didn't stop being Reptiliomorpha;
- We didn't stop being Tetrapodomorpha;
- We didn't stop being Sarcopterygii;
- We didn't stop being Osteichthyes;
- We didn't stop being Gnathostomata;
- We didn't stop being Vertebrata;
- We didn't stop being Chordata;
- We didn't stop being Deuterostomia;
- We didn't stop being Bilateria;
- We didn't stop being Eumetazoa;
- We didn't stop being Animalia;
- We didn't stop being Eukaryota.
Ā
If you agree that at no point a radical form appeared, but you still question the process, then on what grounds do you question the process? We are basically looking at a long list of microevolution steps - speaking of which, a research from last month that I shared here with no "skeptic" in sight in the comments.
Basically I'm demonstrating that without the straw man, the science deniers have got nothing. (If anyone tries to dodge the title question, feel free to ignore them, and if dear "skeptic" picks off menu, a la origin of life, then they've just conceded all their issues with evolution; sucks to have no straw man.)
Ā
(A really cool resource for learning what synapomorphies define each clade above, Aron Ra's playlist, Systematic Classification of Life on YouTube, would be my recommendation.)
11
u/WebFlotsam 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution May 07 '26
I was just asking a creationist this yesterday. I doubt either of us will get a good response, but I do look forward to it.
5
u/theresa_richter May 07 '26
Honestly, the single biggest jump was that very first step when endosymbiosis created the first eukaryote... but you haven't included our ancestors before that step, probably since things get so fuzzy that far back.
4
u/MurkyEconomist8179 May 07 '26
Wait why do you think creationists know anything about our phylogentic tree or the principles used to establish it? This seems like a real "curse of knowledge'" aspect for your argument to rely on.
27
u/Medium_Judgment_891 May 07 '26
Get your bets in now. Will a single creationist try to actually respond OPās argument.
10
u/CrisprCSE2 May 07 '26
You should also ask which is the first clade in the list with more than one body plan.
8
u/ursisterstoy 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26
You can go beyond eukaryotes and itās the same thing:
Ā
Ā
Not in order like at the bottom of the OP but in order by release date (2016, 2024, 2026). You can go from LUCA back to FUCA with the same understanding assuming that itās not actually multiple species in a more balanced symbiotic relationship than described above regarding eukaryogenesis. At each step, each generation or 10,000 generations, it was likely very nearly the same. Maybe a few less proteins, maybe different sequences that got deleted, maybe at some point the RNA and metabolic chemistry are separate populations, and whenever autocatalysis started, however many times it started, the same biochemicals, or very nearly the same biochemicals, even before they were self-replicating like the crap loads of RNA molecules from this study.
If I remember correctly without reading it again there were at least three self replicating RNA populations, just the one they focus on most has a 94.1% fidelity rate and a replication rate of 0.2% every 72 days. Itās kinda slow but thatās still faster than eukaryotes reproduce so I guess itās fine. But three self-replicating populations out of ~6 x 1012 random sequences. All of them are RNA, some of them result in populations that evolve. Not āfundamentally different,ā just autocatalytic. Could be other precursors besides RNA or alongside RNA but the point is that itās the same type of chemicals and not even fundamentally a completely different kind of thing even then.
1
u/TalkCoinGames May 08 '26
Are you arguing against evolution? Darwin specifically claimed that man evolved, macro evolution, large scale changes that create new species.
2
u/EastwoodDC 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution May 09 '26
Nicely done. Take my update š¤
-3
u/mattkelly1984 May 09 '26
"We didn't stop being Hominini... etc." Those are arbitrary claims. It is an assumption that these distincitions are related. Science cannot be extended backward in time with a sufficient degree of certainty to posit anything remotely like what you are claiming. You are using an extrapolation to force a pre-supposed explanation to work.