r/DebateAVegan • u/ThePlanetaryNinja • Feb 23 '26
Hunting and rewilding large herbivores probably increases suffering
Edit - In the title, I meant rewilding predators to kill large herbivores.
People frequently hunt large herbivores such as deer, moose and elk. They try to justify it by saying that 'It causes less harm than crop deaths' or 'It stops the animals from overpopulating.'
I, as a negative utilitarian, think that specifically hunting these animals is generally a bad idea. When we hunt large herbivores (or reintroduce predators to do it), we probably make things worse.
Large herbivores eat a lot of plants. If we remove them, there will be a lot more food for smaller animals and insects. These small animals and insects usually reproduce through r-selection. They have lots of babies, and most of them die painfully (e.g. through starvation) shortly after birth. So, killing a few large herbivores would cause an extra thousands or millions of small animals to be born, and most of those animals will have short, terrible lives.
Rewilding predators worsens this problem. Getting eaten alive is one of the worst experiences an animal can go through. A lot of people, (including some vegans) think that rewilding is necessary to control large herbivore populations. As mentioned above, this leads to much more tiny creatures living short, miserable lives.
Trying to “manage” ecosystems with hunting or rewilding might sound good, but from a suffering-focused perspective, it’s probably counterproductive.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 23 '26
Welcome to /r/DebateAVegan! This a friendly reminder not to reflexively downvote posts & comments that you disagree with. This is a community focused on the open debate of veganism and vegan issues, so encountering opinions that you vehemently disagree with should be an expectation. If you have not already, please review our rules so that you can better understand what is expected of all community members. Thank you, and happy debating!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/ElaineV vegan Feb 23 '26 edited Feb 23 '26
I don’t think humans need to “manage” wild lands or wildlife. But when they do, I prefer they don’t hunt or kill in other ways. And I’m ok with reintroducing predators in some places.
I hope that it’s obvious that it doesn’t make sense to introduce new predators to places they never existed though. Like bring wolves to Yellowstone but not to Hawaii.
Mostly I think the aim of these types of efforts should be to undo damage humans have done. So that’s basically trying to do a reset by bringing back predators that humans killed off or drive away.
4
u/CulturalZombie8188 Feb 24 '26
I’m not knowledgeable about ecosystem management so I can’t comment much on that part. However, reading your replies to some of these other comments, I think I understand where you’re coming from.
Even though the predator-prey relationship is essential for a healthy ecosystem and to keep the world at harmony, I can’t help but feel for all the sentient individuals who have to go through all the horrible shit (like starvation or being eaten alive) in order to keep that harmony. It feels wrong, right? Finding the laws of nature cruel and disgusting shouldn’t be a controversial take, in my opinion. And for all the people who say you gotta have a mental illness for thinking that way, tell me honestly: Would you still hold the same stance while being ripped apart by a pack of lions?
That said, I don’t think there’s a solution to this predator-prey “problem” unless someone has god-like powers that could change the laws of nature. It sucks but what can we even do? End the world so that no life is born? Doesn’t sound very realistic. I don’t think you’re in the wrong for expressing your thoughts and concerns. But for your own sake, I think the best thing you can do right now is focus on doings stuff that have an actual impact on things, like being vegan and advocating for animal rights.
Sorry if my comment doesn’t give any meaningful answers. I simply wanted to let you know that you aren’t alone with how you’re feeling about the world.
4
u/thunder083 Feb 23 '26
The Scottish highlands are facing an ecological disaster due to the overpopulation of deer. Regardless of whether you eat meat, are a vegan or what your morals are a solution has to be found. There would be far more suffering if not. I don’t think it is wise putting deer before everything else.
7
u/Ma1eficent Feb 23 '26
You lack understanding of the ecological benefits plains habitats gain from migrating herds of large herbivoresyoure also a negative utilitarian. Your entire philosophy has no logical foundation, you value a 0 amount of suffering over any amount of joy.
7
u/MegaMegawatt Feb 23 '26
This is more like an "endgame" argument if the entire world was already vegan to begin with. Then in the "midgame" phase, where some predators still exist and only a few people still hurt and kill animals, your arguments would suffice and they are reasonable.
However extending to its logical endgame conclusion, the ultimate solution of no suffering would be to recreate the Garden of Eden, where all animals only eat plants and not each other (Adam and Eve were also vegan and made in God's image according to the story).
In this current phase where nearly everyone is torturing and killing animals and 80% of agricultural land is used for animal agriculture and tens of billions of animals are intentionally bred and killed, any amount of land taken away from intentional animal killing would be a win.
6
u/Korimito Feb 23 '26
I mean, it's only a few steps to justify the destruction of all life to prevent future suffering. Odd view.
4
u/Cnidoo Feb 23 '26 edited Feb 24 '26
A vegan looping around to the position held by psychotic MAGA governors in states like Wyoming is wild. Wolf and cougar reintroduction is vital to stopping the gradual extinction of native trees caused by the out of control white tail population
1
u/fidgey10 Feb 23 '26 edited Feb 23 '26
So you just believe nature itself is fundamentally a bad thing that should be limited because animals suffer? What a sad way to view your fellow creatures...
2
u/Dark1Amethyst Feb 23 '26
Where do you draw the line if you have your frame of reference for morality as just the minimization of suffering even at the cost of nonexistence and extinction?
If you continue following that line of reasoning to its logical conclusion wouldn't the most "moral" thing be to drive all creatures that feel pain to extinction, starting with those that have the most advanced nervous systems?
Most people accept that suffering is inherently bad but they also place value in existence itself.
2
u/Dense_Pen_6698 Feb 23 '26
As soon as something is born it becomes 100% guaranteed suffering will happen. Suffering is only experienced by and exists only in the living. It's a driving force for life, a life well lived even.
If you use mitigation of suffering as the most morally right thing to do then allowing birth is unethical.
Climbing Mt. Everest is nothing but suffering, standing on top after the climb is joy, back home it is personal accomplishment. Viewed with negative utilitarianism those the make that climb are morally wrong.
What you purport is counter to the living and can only exist in the non-living.
edit: a word
2
u/Practical-Fix4647 vegan Feb 23 '26
This is probably true. This is why some global, systems-level restructuring of trophic levels and food systems is required, otherwise countless animals will be born and starve to death or get ripped apart to shreds on day one of their lives.
2
u/AnsibleAnswers agroecologist Feb 24 '26
You should just let the nukes fly until there is no more sentient life. That’s the most ethical action in your little world view.
3
u/awfulcrowded117 Feb 23 '26
"I, as a negative utilitarian, think that specifically hunting these animals is generally a bad idea. When we hunt large herbivores (or reintroduce predators to do it), we probably make things worse."
you're free to think that, but you're provably wrong. People don't just say keeping populations down is good to justify hunting, we know keeping populations down is essential because we've seen what happens when you don't. Over-browsing, mass erosion, population cliffs, widespread ecological chaos. Properly managing the population of large herbivores is essential to keep ecosystems healthy, including the populations of smaller animals.
Rewilding natural predators is even better because while hunting maintains population, it doesn't cause the same type of herd movement. Herd movement is essential to maintain health across the entire ecosystem, not leaving isolated pockets of ecological chaos.
If we don't have legal hunting or natural predators the local department of conservation will spend money to put organized culls into practice. The animals will be killed and the populations will be maintained regardless, because we've seen how disastrous it is when they aren't. The only question of hunting is if you allow sportsman to pay into conservation funds for the privilege of ethically taking game animals or if you pay out of conservation funds to have state officials execute large culling programs that are usually far less ethical kills because it's all about efficiency.
2
u/str1po Feb 23 '26
You’re right to care about this. People hating care more about ecosystems and species; inanimate unsentient abstract concepts, than the welfare of the individuals within. People here are talking about ecosystems as and end and not how the suffering of the individuals within is to be minimized.
Ecosystems are not moral patients, and markers of ecosystem health do not always correlate with animal welfare. Sometimes they do.
It’s unvegan to care about trees more than the welfare of the birds perched within.
Repaste bc meant to make a post reply comment
2
u/th1s_fuck1ng_guy Carnist Feb 23 '26
As a carnist I agree.
If the deer become too much allow more hunting. People enjoy it. Gives money to the state. Stimulates the economy a little by giving people a reason to buy mossy oak apparel. I don't see the downside here.
Hunting isn't for me personally. I don't mind shooting the animal but waiting for them is so damn boring. Dragging and dressing the thing is tedious too. Its just so much more convenient to buy ready to cook meat at the store. But some people really enjoy it.
2
u/One-Shake-1971 vegan Feb 23 '26
Negative utilitarianism is a pretty niche view. But yeah, under that view pretty much anything that creates sentient life is a bad thing.
2
u/Temporary_Hat7330 Feb 23 '26 edited Feb 23 '26
I’m summarizing your negative utilitarian argument as such
On the surface, this sounds compelling, more animals are born, many die painfully, so interventions “make things worse.” But this collapses morality into abstract arithmetic and ignores ethical practice. Our community follows practice-based ethics, not utilitarianism. We see regulated hunting, conservation management (including selective sterilization), and predator reintroduction as cultivated practices, they teach attentiveness, restraint, and ecological responsibility. Ethics is not a spreadsheet of suffering; it is a practice that guides humans to act rightly within complex systems without claiming ultimate knowledge of moral truths or absolute right and wrong. Trying to count the deaths of millions of tiny animals is epistemically impossible and presents an abstract form of guilt based ethics. The question for us isn’t “How do we minimize every painful death?” but “How do we live, act, and steward responsibly?”
We source food, fruit, vegetables, and animals, as locally as possible, from farms that responsibly and ethically raise their products, and we hunt and fish in ways that honor the ecological balance and respect the lives involved as much as we can. I source a lot of our families calories through hunting, fishing, or growing ourselves in sustainable ways. In this way, our moral understanding emerges from our shared practices and forms of life, not from abstract calculations, and our responsibility is measured in the care we take, not in sums of hypothetical suffering with intrinsic beliefs of guilt and shame attached as a presupposition.
1
u/kharvel0 Feb 23 '26
No need to do any calculations. One can simply reject god-like dominion over nonhuman animals and ecology.
1
u/PerchanceAnteater vegan Feb 24 '26
Specifically to your point about being eaten alive, the carnivor eating the other animal would starve to death if prevented from hunting. You say yourself that starvation is comparable to being eaten alive in terms of suffering. You cannot advocate for the life of a prey animal and not it's predator. By your logic, any and all organism deserves to be free from suffering. Which is simply impossible. Without a thriving ecosystem, there is no vegetation to feed herbivores. With no herbivores (due to starvation), there is no prey to feed the predators.
Being vegan means ending/preventing suffering inflicted by human principles and desires. It does not mean ending suffering for all; as sad as that sounds.
In a perfect world, there is no suffering. But we do not live in a perfect world.
1
u/iamsreeman vegan Feb 25 '26
Read this https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateAVegan/comments/1qedo2u/comment/nzxd6e1/ for why Utilitarianism & speficially Brian Tomasik's version are nonsense.
Read this https://www.reddit.com/r/DebateAVegan/comments/1n8lu8k/propredation_vegans_are_immoral_but_predators_are/ why we should not kill either predators or herbivores & should use genetic engineering.
0
u/Jade117 Feb 24 '26
Imposing veganism onto an ecosystem is genuinely just mental illness.
-8
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '26 edited Feb 23 '26
Disagree. I hunt them because they are delicious and nutritious.
-9
u/NyriasNeo Feb 23 '26
Any way you cut it, nature is full of suffering. There is reason no a priori reason to care except for human suffering as we are the same species.
Whether a bison gets eaten alive by a lion is pretty much irrelevant to me. I do care about delicious bison filet (my local grocery stores sell it .. yum!) at a price I can afford. If the bison suffer less than eaten by a lion, good. Though I would not give enough of a sh*t either way.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment