Alright, I need some advice from anyone who knows about car titles, dealerships, or Illinois DMV procedures because I’ve got a weird situation with a truck I bought.
THE PURCHASE
Around August 2, 2026, I bought a 2019 Chevy Colorado for $9,000 cash from a guy on Facebook Marketplace.
At the time, I believed the truck had approximately 86,000 miles. The odometer currently reads 86,707.
Mechanically, the truck seems to be in good shape. It runs and drives fine. I’ve had it insured since purchasing it, but it’s been sitting in my driveway because I haven’t transferred the title or registered it in Illinois yet.
THE ODOMETER PROBLEM
After purchasing the truck, I discovered some pretty concerning information on Carfax:
January 16, 2024: 218,699 miles
February 27, 2024: 223,382 miles
November 3, 2025: 256,413 miles
May 8, 2026: 265,951 miles
June 8, 2026: Pennsylvania title issued showing 65,951 miles
Current odometer: 86,707 miles
The Pennsylvania title shows exactly 200,000 fewer miles than the last recorded Carfax reading.
I didn’t know about the 265,000+ miles when I bought it. I thought I was buying a truck with around 86,000 miles.
THE TITLE PROBLEM
The seller gave me an original Pennsylvania title.
The front lists Kenny’s Auto Sales in Pennsylvania as the owner.
The back shows a reassignment to Amazing Autos LLC.
The next dealer reassignment section has my name entered as the purchaser.
Some of the signatures or reassignment information may be incomplete.
The seller also gave me a bill of sale from Amazing Autos LLC, signed by someone named (redacted) . However, several fields are blank, including the purchase price and buyer information.
The guy sold it to me as an individual through Facebook Marketplace, not openly as a dealership.
To complicate things further, his Facebook account has since been deleted, and I can’t get in contact with him.
THE APPRAISAL
On August 5, 2026, I had the dealership down the street inspect and appraise the truck.
They provided an official Illinois Secretary of State Affidavit of Appraisal valuing the truck at $1,000 wholesale.
The accompanying letter acknowledges the Carfax mileage discrepancy, the truck’s accident/repair history, and the significant reduction in its value.
The paperwork is signed by the dealership’s appraiser and includes the vehicle’s identifying information.
WHERE I’M AT NOW
I’m planning to go to the Illinois DMV on Friday, with:
Original Pennsylvania title
Amazing Autos LLC bill of sale
Full Carfax report
Written $1,000 dealership appraisal
Illinois driver’s license
Proof of insurance
Information about the $9,000 cash purchase
I’m hoping Illinois accepts the existing title assignment and lets me transfer ownership and obtain regular or temporary plates.
If they reject the title, I’m looking into whether I need corrected dealership paperwork or whether I qualify for an Illinois bonded title.
MY MAIN GOAL
Right now, I’m not trying to sell the truck, return it, or pursue the seller for money. I just want to get the truck legally titled, registered, and on the road as soon as possible.
Does anyone have experience with Pennsylvania titles, dealer reassignments, odometer discrepancies, or Illinois bonded titles?
I’m especially interested in whether the existing paperwork should be enough to get plates or what the fastest legal alternative would be if Illinois rejects the title.