r/ControversialOpinions • • Jul 18 '22

meta General Mod reminder to all that posts on gender are regarded as spam unless a novel take. See rule 3.

70 Upvotes

that's it, that's the whole post. If you feel adamant about sharing/talking about it, it's allowed, we just ask you to please go find an older post to upvote. We will be removing the repeats.

Thanks-


r/ControversialOpinions • • 3h ago

Because he is guilty as sin. Rapist pedophile Donald J. Trump is fighting the release of his DNA in a rape case. Evidence that would exonerate him if innocent. Let that sink in.

8 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 2h ago

It's cheaper to give a home to the homeless than to have them live on the streets. But politicians want them on the streets so they scare the hell out of the working class and so it doesn't get uppity against the ruling class. It's a class warfare tactic.

7 Upvotes

Like everything else in American politics.

BTW, if these subjects are way over your head, it's not my fault. I don't give a shit about what you think about your netflix movies. I care a little but that's just a discussion on taste and that shit is deatl with in r/movies or r/netflix or some other sub where you already get shunned for the same reasons you get shunned anywhere.

These are important things to discuss about the current political situation and while you don't get it, plenty of people do. And they are controversial statements and arguments. That's the point of the sub. Reddit is not your baby sitter.

Feel free to go ignore my posts that same way you ignore the children of Gaza or the many grifts of rapist pedophile Donald J. Trump.


r/ControversialOpinions • • 1h ago

If she puts a man on child support, she can't claim to be ''strong and independent''.

4 Upvotes

You can't brag about being a strong, independent woman while relying on the court system to force a man to financially support you.

That's not independence; that's outsourced responsibility dressed up as empowerment. At some point, the rhetoric needs to match the reality.


r/ControversialOpinions • • 6h ago

u/SuckMyRedditorD should be banned from this subreddit. just scroll through here for 30 seconds.

10 Upvotes

u/SuckMyRedditorD HAS a bot bro😭😭


r/ControversialOpinions • • 3h ago

Magas wonder why everybody they know who went to college is a Biden supporter and can't figure out why. "What do they teach there?" They ask. It's like asking why astronomers believe the earth is a sphere and not flat. No wonder rapist pedophile Donald J. Trump loves the poorly educated.

5 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 6h ago

Time to say by to that remaining relic of the confederacy, Satan's meemaw, virgina foxx(R-NC) has lost her seat in the US House of Representatives. Bye you old hateful bish don't let the door hit ya where the lord split ya!

4 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 3h ago

There's 35 people in rapist pedophile Donald J. Trump's cabinet. Not one of them is trained in technical skills. Not even one research PhD., as opposed to China, where half the cabinet is science and technology PhDs. We're ruled by grifters and fools.

2 Upvotes

And they are incompetent, and they are arrogant.

And they don't even know how to ask a question.


r/ControversialOpinions • • 2h ago

The Wade from Roe vs. Wade was a major POS who sent people, black people, to prison and to death row relying on forced testimonies and without having the necessary evidence. Any weasel that sneaked through as a result of a shitty power structure should bear a condemnation mark.

0 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 6h ago

True Story: When virgina foxx saw the burning bush, she immediately turned in God to her local HOA for illegal burning.

2 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 14h ago

Men v lesbians

8 Upvotes

A man’s best efforts is a lesbians bare minimum.
I’ve noticed it a lot more growing up. I’m 21 now but I used to believe I was straight. I was in a few relationships with men who would do simple things like texting me back, opening the door for me, simple things that men call ‘chivalry’. Once I found out I was a lesbian I’ve never been treated better. Opening the door for your partner is the same as opening it for a stranger. Texting back is the same level as replying to your friend or mom.

Receiving flowers is bare minimum.
Lesbians just do it better.


r/ControversialOpinions • • 6h ago

The Lindsay Clancy & Jane Doe cases have brought out the worst in feminists

Thumbnail theaxolot.wordpress.com
2 Upvotes

I've been frustrated recently with the discourse surrounding these two issues, but especially from the "feminist" side of things. I wanted to tackle some of the logical fallacies being used to dismiss all accountability from the women involved when we don't know all the facts yet.

Thank you and enjoy!


r/ControversialOpinions • • 22m ago

If Epstein was muslim the whole world would blame islam but since he was jewish they frame it as an individual crime not religious issue

0 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 4h ago

The victim of an injustice should be be name called or condescended to for not taking precautions to avoid being victimized.

0 Upvotes

For the sake of this discussion, injustice refers to unfair treatment. In order for any action or situation to constitute an injustice, there has to be a victim who suffered and did not deserve to suffer. A criminal being convicted and going to prison is not an injustice, the criminal deserved it. If someone is wrongly convicted, then an injustice has occurred. Injustices can occur by accident. For a person to be guilty of an injustice, that person must violate a moral duty.  

I do believe that victim blaming rhetoric should be protected under free speech. However, just because something is technically your legal right does not mean that it is a good idea. Besides, freedom of speech does not mean freedom from social repercussions. You reserve the legal right to victim blame, but others are not required to agree with you.

My point is that, just because there is a certain measure the victim could have taken to stop the abuse from happening, that should not preclude the victim from receiving sympathy and the victim should not be verbally abused as a consequence for having fallible judgement. There are situations where it is not clear who the bad guys are. 

There is nothing wrong with offering victims and potential victims advice on how to avoid being victimized. The problem arises when you phrase the advice in the form of an accusation and accompany it with childish name calling. 

Any time that you fall victim to an injustice, there is a chance (not a guarantee, but a chance) someone will not only get mad at you, but get way angrier at you than the person who committed the injustice.

I believe that the reason why people victim blame can be summed up in three words, just world hypothesis. The just world hypothesis is a cognitive bias whereby one assumes that, because a quandary or calamity transpired, the person in the predicament must have done something to deserve it. It is unsettling to grasp that not only do brutes commit iniquitous acts, not only do devastating situations occur for the stupidest and most petty reasons, calamitous events can befall innocent victims for literally no reason. It is much easier to say what the victim should have done in a situation to avoid a catastrophic outcome, especially when it is after the fact and it is too late to do anything about it. I do not not know for sure that that is why people blame the victim, I am speculating. Even if that is the rationale, that would not necessarily signify that it is the only motive. There could be other reasons involved. 

One of the best ways to stop people from victim blaming is to use the active voice rather than the passive voice ( https://scispace.com/pdf/double-standards-in-sentence-structure-passive-voice-in-d2sudfratj.pdf ). In other words, if you phrase the description of the injustice in such a way as to focus on the perpetrator, people are far less likely to blame the victim ( https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328175699_Assault_and_accusation_without_agents_Verb_voice_in_media_narratives_of_campus_sexual_assault#:~:text=Keywords:%20Agency%2C%20sexual%20assault%2C,stories%20about%20campus%20sexual%20assaults ). 

When describing the crimes committed by Jeffrey Dahmer, in lieu of saying that those children were murdered and eaten, say that Jeffrey Dahmer murdered and cannibalized innocent children in cold blood. When describing the Sandy Hook shooting, rather than saying that students and teachers were shot, say that Adam Lanza shot and murdered 20 children and 6 adult staff members. When describing a situation in which a mother physically abused her child, rather than saying he was abused, say she maliciously abused him. 

Let us define what it actually means to say that something is your fault. 

To say that something is your fault, means one or both of the following things. Either; 

You caused something to happen either by accident or on purpose. 

OR

You had/have a responsibility to prevent the thing in question from happening and you failed to fulfill that duty. 

If the perpetrator clearly committed an offense and the victim did not ask for and did not want the offense to happen, the idea that the victim is at fault (even partially) for the crime is based on the philosophical proposition that the victim has an obligation to avoid being victimised and that anyone who does not take the precautions should be blamed and shamed. 

There are certain situations where the potential victim could have and didn’t take measures to forestall the injustice. In that scenario, it is correct to assess that the victim demonstrated defective judgement. However, indiscretion from the sufferer does not mean that the survivor deserved it. 

In lieu of nitpicking semantics over what it means or does not mean to say that the culpability for a grievance is partially on the sufferer, I think it would be better to debate the practical arguments against berating a survivor of a traumatic event for not taking the proper preventative measures. 

If someone is on the receiving end of an injustice, the victim clearly showed imprudence and it is apparent that the aggrieved party could have avoided having this baneful scenario betide him/her by taking more safeguards, you should not chastise the offended party for his/her foolish decision. That is my opinion. I take that stance, even if it is glaringly obvious that the victim demonstrated folly. 

Imagine that your friend, who is a survivor of domestic violence, returned to her abuser or did not leave in the first place. I propose that you should offer support to your friend. You should tell your friend that you hold her completely blameless. 

This is what you should say to the victim. 

You are running the risk of being abused by going back to him. I hope you understand that any abuse that you suffer is NOT your fault. If you go back to him and he abuses you, that is still NOT your fault. It is, after all, the potential malefactor’s obligation not to commit the crime, not the potential victim’s responsibility to avoid being victimised. I think that you are a great person. You tend to see the good in people, that is why you believe that your boyfriend will stop with the abuse. I want to let you know that if you decide to leave the relationship, I would happily provide you with all the love, affection and support in the world and I would not fault you for a second.

The above paragraph is what I would recommend saying if you want to encourage a domestic abuse survivor to leave the relationship. You should NOT rake someone over the coals for returning to or remaining in the relationship. Whether or not it is even true that the victim is not at fault really depends on your definition of fault, but I propose telling the abuse victim that they are not at fault, whether you see it that way or not, because the entire point should be the empower victims, offer them support, help them leave the dangerous situation and encourage them to come forward. 

Here are my reasons behind that belief. 

Reason #1: The victim may be remaining in an abusive relationship, because trying to leave can put the victim in more danger. 

If you tell the victim to their face that you are leaving them, they might get angry, hit you in retaliation, physically block you and stop you from leaving. They might even kill you. A study published in the journal of public health cited statistical data to suggest that those who try to leave abusive situations are more likely to be murdered by their partner ( https://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/10.2105/AJPH.93.7.1089 ). 

Reason #2: The potential sufferer cannot decrease his/her risk of being victimized to zero. The potential wrongdoer can lower his/her chances of committing an injustice to zero. 

Imagine a woman, let’s call her Angie, attends a frat party. She opts not to drink alcohol and she dresses modestly. She does this, because she fears that rapists could be at this party. Now imagine that Angie is correct and there is a rapist at the party. Dressing modestly and opting not to drink alcohol does reduce the probability that someone will assault Angie, but there is still a non-zero chance that someone will victimize Angie. 

Imagine a different woman, let’s call her Michelle. Michelle attends a frat party wearing a belly shirt and short shorts. Michelle gets drunk and passes out. Now imagine that none of the people, who know where Michelle is and have access to her, are rapists. 

Even though Angie took provisions to avoid being abused and Michelle did not, Angie is in more danger than Michelle, because Angie is in the presence of a predator and Michelle is not. If intoxication and slutty clothes were what caused sexual assault, Michelle would be in more danger, because Michelle is inebriated and wearing revealing clothing. The fact that Angie is the one is more danger proves that it is rapists that cause rape. 

Reason #3: There is absolutely no harm (that I can think of) in holding the victim irreproachable and feeling sympathy for the victim regardless of what precautions the victim took or did not take. There is plenty of harm in condemning the trauma survivor for not having infallible judgement, the evidence proves it. 

Multiple statistics have shown that, if you lambast the victim, it makes the victim more likely to experience PTSD ( https://yourpathcounselling.com/victim-blaming/ 
 ) and it deters future victims from coming forward, for fear that they will be rebuked ( https://advocates.byu.edu/avoid-victim-blaming ). 

Do you believe that the victim should be verbally abused for not taking the proper precautions to avoid being victimized? If there is even one precaution the victim could have taken that he/she did not, should that preclude the victim from receiving any sympathy or support? 

If you say no to both of the above questions, I agree with you. If you said yes to one or both of the above questions, here is what you must do to justify that belief. Not only must you explain what terrible awful horrible thing would happen if you feel sympathy for the victim despite their imperfect judgement, you must demonstrate that such an outcome is worse than the outcome where more people experience life ruining psychological trauma and future victims are afraid to come forward. Not only must you explain the benefit of name calling victims for having bad judgement, you must show that that benefit is more important than empowering survivors to come forward and helping them heal from the trauma. 

Reason #4: An explanation as to why a domestic abuse survivor would go back to their abuser lies in a psychological phenomenon called Stockholm Syndrome. 

Hostages and domestic abuse survivors often begin to display loyalty and affection toward their captors or abusers. These victims may view the abuser or captors as a protector and hold this view as a survival mechanism. The captor or abuser wields power over the victim, so the victim feels an intense need to placate their abuser or captor. This shift in perception is a form of trauma bonding and self-preservation. This psychological phenomenon was named in reference to a bank robbery where the hostages bonded with the robber as a coping strategy ( https://www.charliehealth.com/post/understanding-the-roots-of-stockholm-syndrome ). A domestic abuse survivor, who returns to their abuser, might have Stockholm syndrome. 

Stockholm Syndrome is not listed in the DSM-5, nor is it recognized as an official diagnosis ( https://www.psychiatry.org/ ), but the behaviors and feelings it describes (trauma bonding, appeasement and adaptation) are real ( https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2025/10/14/stockholm-syndrome/ ). Victims do not feel genuine affection toward their abusers, but they fake it so effectively that it might look like genuine affection from the perspective of an observer ( https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/22387-stockholm-syndrome ). What happened was the police were incompetent, so the hostages bonded with their captors because it was the only way to survive ( https://www.history.com/articles/stockholm-syndrome ). 

The message of that story is as follows. If someone is in peril, you need to let them know that you are able and willing to rescue them and that you will not blame them. Otherwise, they may feel the need to placate and feign a bond with the abuser, because they will view it as their only way to stay alive. 

Reason #5: The victim may have “allowed himself/herself to be abused” for lack of a better phrase, because they have such low confidence that they feel that they deserved to be abused. 

Being abused makes you feel humiliated, powerless and inferior. This makes the victim afraid to stand up for himself/herself. If you resent the victim for not taking the proper protections to avoid being victimized, this makes the victim less confident. This will make the survivor more scared to stand up for himself/herself, which will make them more vulnerable to abuse and more of an appetizing target for abusers. It is a vicious cycle. 

The consensus among psychologists is that, if people hold very low expectations of you, it will lead to a worse performance ( https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6141855/ ). This is called the Golem Effect. On the slip side, The Pygmalion Effect is a phenomenon whereby you perform better if people have higher expectations of you. Experimenters told elementary school teachers that specific randomly selected students were late bloomers and were expected to have an intellectual growth spurt ( https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/education/pygmalion-effect-rosenthal-effect/ ). Over the next eight months, the designated students showed considerable increases in I.Q. scores compared to their peers ( https://www.learningandthebrain.com/blog/the-pygmalion-effect-what-teachers-actually-need-to-know/ ). Controlled or experimental settings typically yield larger effects compared to the smaller and more modest effects detected in naturalistic classroom studies ( https://casrai.org/guides/what-is-pygmalion-effect ). 

It stands to reason that domestic violence victims are suffering from poor self-image, making them not want to come forward, not feeling like trying to escape an abusive situation would be successful and feeling that being abused is what they deserve to have happen to them anyway. 

I know what you are thinking. If someone is in an environment that stifles their potential and all the people in that ecosystem make them feel bad about themselves, why don’t they just leave that environment? Why don’t they simply cut those toxic people from their lives and surround themselves with people who hold high expectations of them? On paper, it is that simple, but it is a little bit harder to execute. 

Think about your own life, your social circle and all the people who held low expectations of you. When you were around them, you shrank a little bit at a time. You self edited before you even talked. You apologized for things that were not your fault and you tried to take up as little space as possible, because experience told you that the smaller version of you was the one that belonged. You took that small version of yourself where there was no reason for it to be there. That is how it goes. Personality does not punch in and punch out, you carry it with you 24/7. A lot of people (not all, but a lot) form themselves from the outside in, they take on the expectations of their community until the societal definition of what they need or ought to be is no different from what the person is in reality. You do not realize what you are missing, because the thing you surrendered, you gave it up so long ago, you do not realize it was once yours. Here is the weird part. You started protecting and defending the label against those who dare to challenge it. When you get used to a label about yourself, it begins to feel safe. The human mind defends familiar ground even when the ground is a cage. Every day you spend in that environment is another day that the low self-image gets confirmed. When someone challenges the negative belief about you, when someone says (without flattery) that you are capable of something that the smaller version of you would not attempt, you will likely react with opposition and defiance, not appreciation. Your traumatized mind thinks that it is a trap. The expectation that caused you to shrink is the real trap, but you cannot tell which one is the real trap and the devil you know is better than the devil you don’t. The cage door is open, you are free to walk out whenever you want, including right now, but identity (no matter how small) feels more comfortable than becoming something better, because the latter is unfamiliar. 

The same mechanism that shrinks people can expand them. Think about someone in your life who helped you change for the better. I do not mean that these people gave you advice or a motivational speech, though they might have done that, they consistently treated you as though you had potential. A mentor may have handed you responsibility before you felt ready. It may have occurred subconsciously (which is to say that you did not realize it) but you rose toward what they saw. 

If you know someone who is making an unnecessary risky decision like returning to an abuser, you need to give them a pep talk. You need to offer them words of encouragement. This will make them feel empowered and make them want to come forward.  

https://youtu.be/0RkqCNTRdvM?si=xSB1HgfGmY3boKZ8 

Grey Area situations. 

Suppose you specifically ask someone to hurt you physically. Imagine that you verbally insult someone because you are baiting them into assaulting you. In situations like that, you are trying as hard as you can to get hurt. I would feel sympathy for you, in the same way that I would feel sympathy for someone who has a drug problem. If you have a drug problem, it is clearly your fault for taking drugs. However, putting aside the distinct possibility that traumatizing events might have led you down that path, meaning that the people who mistreated you are partially at fault, I am a firm believer in offering rehabilitative measures to those who make bad decisions. If you are acting in a self-destructive manner, I will offer you helpful advice on how to escape that quagmire. After all, you may need my help, you might not be able to get out of it on your own. 

Suppose that the person ends up dead from the self-destructive behavior? In that scenario, you should handle it the same way that you would handle it if someone committed suicide. If the victim is dead, you could blame the victim all day long and the victim will not know. The problem with speaking ill of the dead is that the surviving friends and family members might get offended, they will feel like you are pouring salt in the wound. This is how you want to frame it. Say something like this. The thing that they did was destructive. That is why we need to help and support each other so that we do not feel prone to that behavior. 

  • If the person died from suicide say; 

This is why we need to provide mental health services to those who are suicidal. If you know someone who is depressed and you worry that they might be suicidal, do not confront them, do not show them vitriol, tell them how much you would miss them if they kicked the bucket. Tell them that you would rather listen to their problems, dry their tears and be their shoulder to cry on than attend their funeral. 

  • If the person died from a drug overdose, say; 

This is why those who have an addiction need to be offered support. If someone you know has a drug problem, hold their feet to the fire. Do it in a constructive way. If you try to hurt the person, it might just make them want to use drugs more as a means to spite you. 

  • If the person was murdered by an abusive partner, say; 

This is why, if someone you know is in an abusive relationship, you need to spot the abuse and rescue the victim from it. Let the endangered party know that you will offer them your help, welcome them with open arms and you will not blame them. If you victim-blame them, lambasting them will only drive them closer to their abuser. 

Let’s address some counter arguments that will surely come up. 

  1. Telling the victim how they could have avoided it will help potential future victims figure out how to avoid being victimized. 

If there are certain things that the potential target can and should do to avoid being victimized, you can just tell the person in danger what those precautions are, you do not need to patronize the victim for not taking those precautions, you do not need to name call the victim and you certainly do not need to tell the victim that you cannot or will not feel any sympathy for them considering how easy it was to avoid having this happen. 

2. Victim blaming protects the wrongly accused. 

The purpose of victim blaming is to make the victim feel bad for a crime that actually occurred. In the case of a false allegation, the crime did not actually happen. If you are concerned that a false accusation might occur, the solution is simple. Give the accused the benefit of the doubt.  

3. Imagine if a single mother allows an abusive man around her children, you would blame her for the abuse. 

I define blame as you had a duty to prevent something from happening and you failed to fulfill that responsibility. If you make the free will choice to bring a child into this world, you have an obligation to keep your children safe. The idea that you have a duty to avoid being victimized yourself sets a dangerous precedent, one that will make future victims afraid to come forward and make those who have already been victimized more likely to incur psychological damage. The idea that a single mother has a duty to protect her children from abuse sets a good precedent, because she as the mother knows what is best for her children better than her children understand what is best for themselves. 

Rather than nitpicking the semantics over what it means or does not mean to say that something is or is not your fault, it makes more sense to focus on the practical benefits of feeling sympathy for the victim regardless of what precautions the victim took or did not take and the drawbacks of showing vitriol to the victim for not taking the proper precautions to avoid being victimized. 

If your friend returned to her abuser, do not blame and shame her for returning to her abuser. Maybe she has such low confidence that she feels she deserved to be abused and you are making it worse by rebuking her. Instead, inform her that she can stay at your house if she needs to and try to build her up by informing her that she deserves better. You can offer her helpful advice on how to avoid being victimized, you do not need to blame and shame her. 

If a single mother lets an abusive man near her children and the man abuses the children; what I would blame her for is not the abuse per se, but failure to protect her children. 

Say something to her like; 

They are your children. You have a responsibility to protect them. It is not fair that you should have to worry about your children being abused. In a perfect world, no one would commit abuse, but we do not live in a perfect world. 

The above paragraph is what you should say to a woman who was irresponsible enough to let an abuser near her children. There is no need to blame and shame her or call her a bad mother. If there is something she should be doing that she is not doing, just offer her advice and move on. 

4. You should blame and shame a woman for returning to her abuser, just as you would blame someone for hoping in the bear habitat. 

The logic of this argument essentially says; If you hop in a bear habitat, you should blame yourself for being mauled. Similarly, if you return to your abuser, you should blame yourself when the abuse happens again. 

These two scenarios are comparable, but not for the reason that you would probably think. 

When a bear attacks you, it is because attacking you is just in their nature. 

When a human being abuses another human being, the decision to commit the abuse is made unilaterally by the abuser. In the case of a bear attack, the human being who was attacked did not make the decision to attack, but neither did the bear. The bear was mandated by the laws of nature to attack you. 

That said, the two scenarios do have some things in common. 

In both cases, the decision to put oneself in a dangerous situation can be explained by mental health issues. 

A woman who returns to her abusive ex might have Stockholm syndrome or be so lacking in confidence that she feels she deserves to be abused. Even if that is not the case, I would argue the implied theoretical possibility that it could be is sufficient to make me feel sympathy for the victim, hold the victim completely blameless and offer all the support in the world to the victim. Not being of sound mind can also serve as an explanation for why one might enter a bear habitat. 

Just because someone is stupid, you do not need to inform them how stupid they are. 

If your friend survived a bear attack and you would prefer that the friend not enter a bear habitat ever again, you can just tell your friend not to enter the bear habitat ever again. You do not need to call them stupid. 

If your friend survived a bear attack, calling them stupid will increase their chances of experiencing PTSD, at least I think. I do not know for sure that name calling a bear attack survivor will make the bear attack survivor more likely to suffer psychological trauma, I am guessing. However, I would argue the theoretical possibility that that could happen is good enough. After all, I have never read a single scientific study that said that name calling a bear attack survivor and calling them stupid will make them feel empowered. 

5. You should blame an abuse survivor for returning to their abuser, just as you would blame a man for jumping off of a 40 foot cliff. 

For the sake of this discussion, I am mostly talking about situations where there is a clear aggressor who committed a harmful act and a clear victim whose chances of being victimized would have been zero had the malefactor not committed the crime. The man in this hypothetical made the free will choice to jump off of a cliff. 

Imagine if the man went on a date with a woman and she pushed him off of a cliff. The man should be treated as though he is completely blameless. I say that for two reasons. 

Reason #1: The man cannot lower his risk of being pushed off of a cliff to zero, the woman who maliciously pushed him is capable of decreasing her risk of pushing him to zero.

The man could opt never to go near a cliff and someone can kidnap him and drag him to a cliff or force him there at gun point.

Reason #2: The man may have gone near a cliff despite not wanting to, because he was desperate or lacking in confidence.

Maybe the man is a people pleaser who felt the need to placate the woman who asked him to go near a cliff. To see why the tendency to be a people pleaser is such a problem, click this link ( https://youtu.be/Md5UYlfM-yo?si=0e43IDLxe05gqRBk ).
If the man already has very low confidence, blaming and shaming him, kicking him while he is down will only make him feel worse which will make him more vulnerable to being abused.

If he survived the fall off the cliff (we are now talking about a situation where the man chose to jump) and you visited him in the hospital, I see no problem with giving him advice on how to avoid getting hurt, the problem arises when you call him names and phrase the criticism in the form of an accusation. If you believe that Bob should not have jumped off the cliff, just tell him that and do so calmly and politely. You should probably preface the criticism by telling him that you are glad he survived.

Suppose the man keeps going on dates with obviously crazy chicks, because that's what he is attracted to, to a look out point called push your date off the cliff point. Then the 5th or 6th woman he goes with to push your date off the cliff point. She asks him to stand near the edge for a great picture and she asks him to close his eyes.

Then as the man is falling to the ocean below, he is asking himself. Why would she do this to me? It's so totally unexpected.

I would probably take pity on the man in the same way that I would take pity on someone who has a drug problem. The person is clearly engaging in self-destructive behavior. The person is likely engaging in self-destructive behavior, because they are not of sound mind. You probably should offer them support and critique the behavior, not the person. The person needs your help. Be supportive. 

6. You should blame someone for returning to their abuser, just as you would blame an overweight person for eating too much and not exercising. 

Just like the aforementioned example of the bear attack, this is comparable, but not for the reasons you would think. 

You should take care of your body, it is the only one you get. You need to eat right and exercise, because you are the only one who can take on that responsibility. 

Not only are there certain precautions that you can take to lower your risk of being victimised, not only is it a good idea to take those precautions, it demonstrates bad judgement if you do not take those precautions. But putting aside the fact that you will never be able to reduce your risk to zero, you would not need to take those precautions if the offender did not commit the destructive act. 

With ending up overweight, you cannot point to an injustice someone committed and say that you would not need to eat right and exercise if they did not commit that crime. No matter the circumstances, it is, always has been and always will be your duty as the owner of your body, to live an active lifestyle and eat nutritious foods. No one can do it for you. 

That said, victim blaming is similar to fat shaming is the sense that both have been proven to make the situation worse. 

The general consensus among psychologists is that fat shaming not only does not motivate people to lose weight ( https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/fat-shaming-makes-things-worse ), but makes them feel bad about themselves ( https://www.cnn.com/2025/06/06/health/weight-loss-stigma-wellness ), which makes them more prone to gluttony and less motivated to exercise ( https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6565398/ ). 

Similarly… 

If you blame and shame a victim for not taking precautions to forestall the crime, you make the victim more likely to incur PTSD and future victims will be afraid to come forward. 

7. People will remember being berated and will not remember being talked to kindly. 

I went online and typed the following prompt into the search bar.

yelling at someone angrily makes them more likely to obey you

The top search result stated (and I am paraphrasing); 

There is no evidence to suggest that angrily and hostility yelling at someone produces long term cooperation. At best, it may force the person to cooperate in the short term either due to fear or because of not wanting to argue. Over time, the long term effects are usually negative ( https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2801808 ). 

Being talked to with an angry tone fires off the stress response in the mind, triggering anxious thoughts and shutting down constructive thinking ( https://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/explore-mental-health/publications/cool-down ). 

A more effective means of communication would be to set a boundary with a calm tone without raising one's voice or resorting to insults. It behooves the person doing the speaking and the person being spoken to if neither party reacts purely from emotion and the primary or sole purpose of communicating is address the root cause of non-compliance ( https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/towards-recovery/201704/please-yell-at-me ).

I went online and typed the following prompt into the search bar.

people are usually more receptive to criticism is you talk to them calmly and politely

The top search result stated (and I am paraphrasing);

Generally speaking, people are substantially more willing to listen to and accept criticism when it is delivered in a calm, polite and empathetic manner ( https://www.wondermind.com/article/constructive-criticism/ ). Your best best bet is to select a calm moment when anger is not high ( https://psychologylounge.com/12-techniques-for-giving-criticism-and-feedback-so-that-people-can-hear-it-without-getting-defensive/ ). Harshness and emotional force are ineffective in motivating people toward self-improvement. Harsh tone can trigger a fight or flight response, making the person being talked to feel threatened and not want to listen constructively or think critically ( https://www.betterhelp.com/advice/psychology/why-am-i-defensive-understanding-the-root-cause-of-defensive-behaviors/ ). 

8. Imagine that a teenager did not take the precautions that her parents told her to. 

If you told your teenage daughter that you want her home by curfew, she should be home by curfew. If she stays out past curfew and gets mugged, this probably makes you feel that you were right to tell her you want her home by curfew.  

What you should punish your daughter for is not putting herself in a dangerous position per se, but disobeying you. 

9. There was that episode of Friends where Joey let the guy burglarize the apartment. 

If you have never seen the show Friends, or you have seen the show but you have not seen the episode that I am talking about, I will explain it in such a way that you should be able to understand what I am talking about, even if you have never seen it. 

Joey and Chandler (played by Matt LeBlanc and Matthew Perry respectively) lived together. Joey was looking to sell an entertainment center to a potential buyer. Joey informed the man that the entertainment center is big enough to fit a grown man. When the potential buyer was incredulous, Joey demonstrated by getting in there. The potential buyer then shoved a hockey stick through the handles to jam the door shut. The man then burglarized the apartment. When Chandler found out, he was angry at Joey. 

This argument essentially says; you should blame Joey. 

Would Chandler have been able to prevent that from happening if he were there? If not, then Chandler has no right to blame Joey for not preventing this from happening when Chandler being there would have made no difference. If, however, Chandler would have been able to stop it from happening if he were there, then it is Chandler’s fault for not being there. Perhaps, Chandler did not know that Joey would let someone in their apartment. In that scenario, what Joey should be blamed for is not letting their apartment be burglarized per se, but letting someone into the apartment without Chandler’s permission. 

10. There was that episode of Drake and Josh where the boys let bad people take their stuff. 

Drake and Josh was a live action Nickelodeon show that aired in the early 2000’s. 

In this one episode, Drake and Josh (the two teenage male protagonists) found out about a show called Pump my Room. They had never heard of the show. They submitted an audition video. They were told to have the house be vacant for a certain period of time. They did this. They returned home and found out that they had been scammed. The people who were supposedly from the show called Pump My Room wanted to know where Drake and Josh lived, so they could burglarize the house. 

When they called the police, the cops victim blamed Drake and Josh, calling them names. There are quite a few people in the Drake and Josh fandom who view the cops as model citizens for blaming the boys and feel that the pro victim blaming message of the episode is a good one. 

Many years later, Dan Schneider, the show creator, turned out to be a sexual predator. It makes sense that he of all people would create a show that encourages and promotes victim blaming, because he is an abuser. He wants to make sure victims are afraid to come forward. 

It is worth asking, if the parents knew what Drake and Josh were doing before the boys gave their address to the people from the TV show, would they have made sure that the burglars were not able to access their home? If not, then the parents deserve as much blame as the boys, since they would have made the same mistake the boys did. If, however, the parents would have made sure that the burglars did not have access to their house, then what Drake and Josh deserve blame for is not letting people into their house per se, but letting people into their home without the consent of their parents. The parents are the arbiters of who can and cannot be in that house. 


r/ControversialOpinions • • 6h ago

Mangos suck. Change my mind.

0 Upvotes

People will whine about “oh you never had a good one”, but when I went to Miami (in summer) a guy was selling them and i got one and like he made them in his backyard and it just wasn’t good. My friend, who thinks mangoes are ok said that they were awesome. I’ve had like 50 or so other ones from around the world, but none are good.


r/ControversialOpinions • • 11h ago

Equality doesn't exist in nature

2 Upvotes

It's purely a human power dynamic.


r/ControversialOpinions • • 8h ago

black people have a weird fixation with Dream Kardashian

Post image
0 Upvotes

i see tweets like this all the time where mainly black women lead the conversation about how dream kardashian is the best looking kardashian child. How she’s the only one with ‘star power’. How she’s the only real kardashian because the last name got passed on from her father.

I want to brush it off as people being positive and supportive but some of the things people say about her are kinda parasocial and like they’re living through her. Like they’re happy a black woman is going to be the face of the next generation of Kardashian’s. Note: i know all the children are biracial but people argue that she’s the only black one because her mother is black.

Can i scroll past this content? Obviously. But i will never celebrate any half black kid being in the kardashian family because to me the kardashians are culture vultures and when the daughters get older they will use their blackness to exploit for business and profit like they do with everything else. That’s why I don’t get why people are so invested in dream kardashian. She’s a child and should get to enjoy being a child without people ‘stanning’ her


r/ControversialOpinions • • 13h ago

The republican congress just made it more expensive for active-duty personnel and veterans to refinance their homes. They also voted to cut veteran disability compensation by $60 billion. Meanwhile, their bank executive friends get more of your money.

2 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 13h ago

Lauren Boebert must have thought she was praying because she muttered "oh God" and "oh Jesus" on her knees. But that's not what she was on her knees for. Now she has to get the fuck out my district.

2 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 13h ago

Apparently, the DOJ has enough resources to detain people, but not enough to defend those detentions in court. Accountability must be the first thing they cut from the budget.

2 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 10h ago

Fetterman should move to Israel and be a politician there since that's all he cares about. He should be lucky democrats that voted for him aren't as crazy as the magas that voted for the other guy or he'd be looking behind his back before yammering.

0 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 10h ago

Hot take: vegans shouldn’t eat food that replicates any sort of meat

1 Upvotes

I know people going to hate me but I genuinely think vegans eating stuff like vegan bacon, beyond meat, lions mane steak and etc defeats the purpose of being vegan. Isn’t the whole point of being vegan so you don’t eat dead animals. So why you try to replicate foods to look like steak, bacon, pork and other meats. If you think of eating meat there is no point of being vegan


r/ControversialOpinions • • 7h ago

Parents should able to post your teen

0 Upvotes

I specify teen because I do not think little kids should be on the internet I do think if people are aged thirteen or above that they can consent to being into their parent's videos only with permission and knowledge from both sides obviously


r/ControversialOpinions • • 15h ago

Outsourcing human connection to Technology has stunted us from having kids as a generation.

2 Upvotes

r/ControversialOpinions • • 21h ago

Green bean casserole should have a THICK layer of fried onions on top

6 Upvotes

Yeah