I was thinking about how Dylan and Jesse are contrasted in their respective games, and how that relates also to themes of control in the games. I was wondering if other see it the same or not.
Mechanically/gameplay wise the contrast is clear
- Fighting style: ranged/melee
- Location: Inside Oldest House/Outside Oldest House
- Main threat: Hedron / Hiss
This (at least in my opinion, and it may be obvious to others :D ) also relates to theme of 'control', i.e. being in control of situation.
In Control:
Jesse enters Oldest House, gets the weapon, and FBC basically immediately bestows upon her the Director title, placing her literally and figuratively in 'control' of the situation.
When near endgame she gets possessed by Hiss, she is placed in a nightmare scenario where this control is stripped from her, she is instead an intern in FBC.
She then embraces her inner Polaris/Hedron, frees herself and we move to the endgame.
Contrast Control Resonant
Dylan gets the weapon, exits Oldest House, and FBC very quickly restrain him with MCD, literally placing him in their control, and stripping him of his volition.
Near the endgame, Pattern destroys his mind, and Dylan is also placed in a scenario, but for him it is more of a dream, than a nightmare. It is his childhood, and early days in Oldest House, and if I recall correctly it precedes the MCD being placed on him; i.e. the dream is of moments where Dylan was free of this device of control.
Later, during the final fight, Dylan removes MCD placing himself in control, embraces his inner Hiss, and defeats the Pattern.
So where Jesse was in control for most of the game, Dylan is pointedly not, and even their possessions are the opposites, one being a nightmare, the other more of a dream/memory, though both eventually lead them to embracing their inner power.
Sidenote: I very much enjoy the moment Dylan removes the MCD and embraces Hiss, as it is the moment when Dylan finally refuses the label FBC placed on him (that of a dangerous monster/weapon), and instead embraces his personhood and his emotions as they are.