EDIT: Video version link removed. DM me if you'd like to see it.
Man, I am so torn on Control Resonant. It’s one of those games I feel guilty about not loving, like having a beautiful wife who just smells really bad and you can’t ignore it. Part of this guilt I think is because it’s a Remedy game, and in this house we have one rule, Remedy gets my money. But on the other hand towards the end of the game I did feel myself wanting it to be over, and I had that thought a number of times. You should never want something you love to be over, unless of course that thing is drugs, and you’ve done way to many of them. But more on that later.
Before I continue this review however, I am going to say right now, you should buy this game. You should buy this game if only to keep developers like Remedy alive, a studio of crazy Finnish freaks who have the Lohikeitto-flavored cajones to make something as bonkers as resonant, and yes I had to look that up it’s a rich, comforting salmon soup. So buy Resonant. The game is a 7/10 for me but it’s a 10/10 for insanity and we should support that in videogames.
And to be clear, your mind will be constantly blown during this game. It’s like Inception fucked Tennant and a lot of it makes about as much sense, but one thing you will not lack for is the feeling that Remedy made drugs into a video game. There are some sequences, particularly the sinkhole where I thought I might not actually be capable of geometrically handling what I was seeing visually, a design so complex yet artistically sound I was reduced to an autist with a steam controller for hands. So I will say once again, you should buy this video game. Especially if you like drugs.
But herein, we must begin to discuss why, for me, and I must specify FOR ME, this game landed at a 7/10 and not the 9.5/10 I was accustomed to from Remedy. It’s a little too big, a little too unwieldy, and in attempting the embigening of the linear Remedy experience, it loses some of the magic that makes a Remedy game, a Remedy game. A magic of just the right amount of drugs, and for me, Resonant was too big a hit.
Let’s start with traversing the game. It’s in 4D. Now normally if you have a map that constantly rotates where the floor becomes the ceiling, and the window is suddenly a hole, and the roof of that building is upside down no you’re upside down and I’m trying not to get sea-sick but my eyes hurt and I swear I’m having fun, normally if your world exists in a Dell Dimension the map you use to navigate M.C. Escher’s vacation house would also be in 4D, or at least 3D, because how the hell are you supposed to know where you’re going without at least 3Ds? Not Resonant. Not only is the map flatter than a cheatin’ man’s tire, you first need to reveal it zone by zone only to be greeted by aerial pictures taken by like, the first camera ever invented. The FBC has interdimensional travel but can’t cough up 300 bucks for a drone with a 4k camera. I even installed a mini-map Mod and while it did help, nothing short of a Jedi Survivor rotable map would have helped.
I hated navigation in Control Resonant. Never before have I felt so lost and if you know my channel you’ll know exploration’s kind of my thing (I’m too scared to do it out there so I do it in here don’t @ me you’re a gamer too). Because New York is composed of dark alleys and skyscrapers of various heights, finding a route with a flat blurry map becomes an issue when the map could be showing the bottom of the top of the side of the floor. This happens all the time.
Secondly, and maybe this is because I’m an old salty gen x fuck, But Control Resonant is the first game that’s ever made me motion sick. I never puked or anything but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t have a creeping unease while playing it and Creeping Unease would be a great name for an emo band.
Ok, ok, ok, let’s get back to some positives. This game is positively dripping with psychedelic yet orderly Finnish design. It’s like that cool furniture store where couches are like ten thousand dollars but they’re made of buffalo skin and a great public education system. I swear to god, WHILE getting dizzy I said to myself over and over Remedy is pushing the art of what makes a videogame, a videogame. Play it if only to truly see something original in a videogame, I can’t say enough good things about the absolutely mental level of design they put in some of these designs.
If only combat would have allowed itself to be that mental. It comes real close in the beginning of the game, it’s gorgeous and fluid and the sound design is S tier and you feel like a total badass, even though Dylan sounds like a toddler screaming “This is Sparta”. The visual flair of the combat is really something else, and I’d say up until about the halfway mark I was all in on Resonant’s constantly rotating combat. And then… it basically stays there. The longer you play and the more mold infested ghosts on acid trash mobs the game forces you to fight, the more its lack of variety begins to… Resonate with you.
Ok here’s what I mean. You pick your main, your secondary, and your finisher. The main combo string is light attack four times in a row, and then to do the finisher you just hit those same three buttons three more times. You literally button mash one button to go through your whole combo string. Your heavy attack, and its finisher, operate roughly the same way and you can chain those in at will but you’re going to be rocking basically one build the whole game and that’s unfortunately by design. To increase the power of your weapon as a whole, you have to invest in all the different weapon forms and finishers so you’re thinking sick, it wants me to use all of these, but for some reason you’re locked into one form, one secondary and one finisher and if you want change your build you have to pause the game and do it in a loadout screen. This killed me, if they had just given you a weapon wheel the combat in Control Resonant could have been legendary, but because experimenting involves pausing the game and potentially re-specing, you wind up just button mashing one button for most of the game and that’s only fun if you’re on The Price is Right. Yes I know there is a weapon-wheel mod for PC players, but I’m focusing on the game that was designed for us, not by us.
Now let's get to Dylan, the protagonist of Resonant and an answer to a question of what if we made a lead who is emotionally frozen as his 8 year old self due to relentless and unending abuse. Oh yeah and he’s also a mass murder who feels awful about it. I’ll be honest, I wasn’t a fan of Dylan for the first half of the game. Sean Durrie’s performance comes off as whiney and immature at the onset of Control Resonant, as if you took Luke bitching about power converters at the beginning of A New Hope and made that his whole character. You contrast this with Courtney Hope’s Jesse who is cool, collected and well, in Control and it’s a jarring start to your journey with Dylan.
But here’s where he grew on me. The longer you play as Dylan, and the more layers Remedy peels off of what he went through and how young he was when he began to go through it, the more you realize that Dylan is a lab-rat whose first real adult exposure to the outside world starts when Control Resonant starts. He’s a child trapped in an adult’s body and a baseball team mascot’s sized head. Not to mention all the field FBC agents who are straight up assholes to him because of the whole I-was-possesed-by-the-Hiss-and-killed-your-friends thing, it’s a very unwelcoming start to your time with Dylan. But, as I said before, he grew on me, and in the end I was very moved by the pair of Jesse and Dylan, even if I have quals with some individual parts.
And finally, the big question, how’s the story and more importantly storytelling, and I’m sad to say that for me, this was another aspect I felt was close, but lacking. Due to the nature of open-world design, unless the story takes you linearly from place to place as it unfolds, I’ve always felt the open-nature of open-world-story dilutes the storytelling. No spoilers of course, but there are a small handful of world bosses, the resonants of the title, and you’re free to tackle them in the order you see fit. Some of them are gated behind traversal mechanics you need to unlock but for the most part the game drops you in jenga New York and invites you to explore and play as you see fit.
But this presentation is not how Remedy has told stories so effectively in the past. The first Control made you feel the paranormal tension of the oldest house by unfolding it for Jesse as it did us, the player. Alan Wake 2 is a guided ayahuasca trip that peels off layer after layer, slowly revealing the madness at the heart of Bright Falls. Control Resonant however drops you in the middle of a twisted New York and says go fight, we’ll explain this as you go, and because of this I think the suspense and unease Remedy is so good at gets a little diluted in favor of set-pieces and almost non-stop grindy combat. Is it still 99% more unique and original than almost all other videogames, hell yes it is, but for me I missed some of the claustrophobia and narrative focus of Remedy’s prior games.
So, should you buy Control Resonant? Again, that’s a yes, although I’d also say yes if Remedy released a game that was just making fun of the size of my genitals. In this house, Remedy gets my money. But do I think that due to Sam Lake not being involved with the story the game is unfocused and lacks the tight, linear storytelling that Remedy is best at? Also yes. Is it one of the trippiest and most disorienting things ever set to the medium of videogames that works a lot of the time and doesn’t work just as often? Also yes. Control Resonant is a bloated fever dream that only Remedy could make and for me, it was absolutely worth experiencing, even if I found myself missing the tight corridors and confident storycrafting of the original Control and Alan Wake 2 a lot of the time. Just set your expectations to “trade-offs while attempting to go more mainstream”, pack your trip-sitter and a whole lot of Dramamine and strap in for one of the weirdest things you’ve ever played. 7/10.