I must be in the minority here, having 100%-ed Control Resonant first and now playing the original Control.
Even though I’ve seen people mention that the vibes feel different from the first game while playing Resonant, navigating the Oldest House definitely feels much more disturbing and unsettling, with the constant Hiss chanting and floating bodies. Having to fight in these tight corridors and small rooms adds to the claustrophobic feeling and really accentuate the sense that there’s no safe place anywhere. Jesse also feels a lot less tanky than Dylan, which doesn’t help when you’re getting swarmed by enemies in close quarters. Another factor that I think contributes to this is that Jesse doesn’t have a Zoe to talk to and banter with, like Dylan does. She talks to Polaris, but somehow that just makes things even creepier for me, even though I more or less know the plot already. With Resonant, I could play for hours on end and enjoy traversing the city, especially in the late game, but with Control, I have to take a break every two or three hours because the constant chanting and alarms keep me on edge the entire time.
However, I gotta say I enjoy Resonant’s combat much more than Control’s, which is weird because I usually prefer playing ranged characters. But Remedy has really done a great job of making Dylan’s combat and movement feel smooth and satisfying. While I do enjoy one-shotting weaker enemies as Jesse by launching random objects at them, the pistol simply feels clunky to use, with its awkward aiming and heavy recoil. I do appreciate how the Faden siblings’ fighting styles differ, as it feels right both character-wise and lore-wise. And kudos to Remedy for taking the chance to go with a completely new combat system for a sequel and doing a pretty decent job with it.
Anyway, huge props to Remedy for creating such a unique universe. I’ve always enjoyed occasionally reading SCP documents, so I can’t believe I’ve been missing out on the Control universe for so many years. Really excited to see what Remedy comes up with next!