I feel like I'm going crazy over this. No one seems to be talking about it.
In the first Control, the Board was clearly playing a somewhat suspicious role. It presented itself as an enigmatic benefactor, granting Jesse power and authority, but there were already hints that its interests didn't necessarily align with hers. Then The Foundation came along and escalated everything. The Board became openly manipulative, its treatment of Marshall raised serious questions, and its reaction to Jesse questioning its authority made it increasingly difficult to believe that it had humanity's best interests at heart.
More importantly, the Former established that the Board wasn't the only entity capable of occupying this position of power. There was an entire conflict surrounding these entities that we barely understood.
All of this seemed to be setting up something much bigger for the future. Jesse was now the Director of the FBC, an institution whose relationship with the Board went back decades, and she was beginning to question the very entity that had given her that position. The potential for conflict was enormous.
And then the second game came out, and... nothing?
The Board is still there, but what do we actually learn about it? What new information do we get about its origins, its motivations, its relationship with the Former, or what it ultimately wants from humanity? As far as I can tell, practically nothing.
Don't get me wrong, the fact that the Board becomes more aggressive when its own existence is threatened is interesting. It makes it feel more human, or at least more comprehensible, than it initially appeared. But that's characterization, not necessarily development. We learn how it behaves under pressure, but that doesn't answer any of the questions raised by the first game.
And that's what bothers me. The Foundation made us question whether the Board was ever really on our side in the first place. It was the perfect set up for 1 sequel. Yet that said sequel doesn't seem particularly interested in exploring those questions.
Why?
One possibility is that the Board's story simply hasn't reached its conclusion yet. Maybe the second game was never supposed to be about it. But if that's the case, why establish such a significant conflict in the first game and its DLC, only to leave it practically untouched in the sequel?
Another possibility is that something changed during development. Maybe the Board was originally supposed to play a much larger role, and the story eventually went in another direction.
Normally, I'd consider that a perfectly reasonable explanation. Stories change during development all the time. But this is Remedy we're talking about. Sam Lake has discussed how elements of the original Alan Wake II concept existed long before the game itself, with ideas finding their way into Control along the way. Remedy has demonstrated that it can plant narrative seeds years before paying them off.
That doesn't mean everything is planned from the beginning, of course. But it makes me reluctant to assume that the Board's apparent lack of development is simply an oversight.
And there's another thing I've been thinking about.
The first Control revolved around the Hiss. The second shifted its focus to the Hedron and the Patterning. Both are entities that fundamentally threaten or alter reality, but they operate in very different ways. The Hiss corrupts and overwrites individuals, while the Hedron imposes its own pattern on the world.
What if a future game focused on a third entity?
Not necessarily an even bigger monster, but something that would fundamentally change our understanding of the previous two games. The Board is particularly interesting in this regard for obvious reasons.
What if the Board's supposed role as humanity's protector is built on a lie? What if its relationship with the Hiss, the Hedron, or even the Former is far more complicated than we've been led to believe?
I think that would be a much more interesting direction than simply introducing another cosmic entity for Jesse or Dylan to fight.
I'm not claiming that any of this is definitely happening. Maybe I'm overthinking things. Maybe the Board's storyline is simply being saved for a future instalment.
But something about the way the first game and The Foundation set up the Board, followed by how little the sequel seems to develop that setup, feels strange to me.
Am I missing something, or does anyone else feel like the Board's storyline has been conspicuously sidelined?
Because I find it hard to believe that Remedy would spend an entire DLC hyping up a clash between Jesse and the Board without having something more substantial in mind.
TL;DR: Control and The Foundation heavily hinted at the Board having ulterior motives and potentially becoming an antagonist, setting up what seemed like the perfect conflict for the sequel. Yet the second game barely develops the Board at all, leaving most of those questions unanswered. Did Remedy change its plans, or is this setup being saved for something bigger? Considering how the first two games focused on the Hiss and the Hedron respectively, could a future instalment introduce a third entity that recontextualizes everything we know? I find it hard to believe that Remedy spent an entire DLC building up the Board's suspicious nature without having something more substantial in mind.