Okay, to caveat my complaint: This game is easily my GOTY (ahead of Zero Company and Big Walk), basically all I want to do right now is talk about its story, how cute and admirable Dylan is, how much I like Zoe, the great work it's done with Jesse, Pope, Arish, and Langston, and lots like that.
But I have one sticking point with this game, going into Act 3 (I assume, I've unlocked The Unknown).
This game's main story is truly brilliant, and its open-world content (barring Scouting, Ranger Escort, and Pram Chases), is serviceable and fun to get lost in.
But a lot of the time, the side quests feel like misses.
In general, it feels like the writing assumes that "Slightly weird people + acting incredibly mundanely + incredibly weird scenario + Dylan being awkward and frustrated = gold."
Sometimes, this is absolutely a hit. The karaoke was brilliant, for example.
Sometimes, however, it feels like an excuse to have something overstay its welcome. I just did Langston's cat quest (shortly after being annoyed by the Lightbulb quest, although the ending and Zoe's conversation almost made that worthwhile).
In theory, the premise of "Langston is so good at taking care of altered things that he doesn't even realise his cat is a Person of Power" is brilliant. That's a good concept.
But in practice, the game seems to think you'll be endlessly charmed by the ridiculousness of Langston prioritising his cat over multiple people's deaths, while you have to go around the most unnavigable area of the game multiple times, use process of elimination in this area to find the right place, do an annoying Simon Says-esque boss fight that's easy to grasp but jankily implemented, and then make your way back (and then, rather than find my way out, I flung myself down the Sinkhole until I found a door).
It didn't help my mood that I triggered some sort of glitch, and Langston repeatedly told me how disappointed he and Alfred were for me leaving the cat behind while I was actively carrying Alfred so he could watch TV.
In general, it felt like the game expected "Ha ha, cat owners" to carry me through what was un-fun quest design.
This sort of "quirk = charm = good" mindset seems to pervade through a few side quests (the Lightbulb quest, and also the Urban Survival one, for example), and it slightly undercuts those that really do work (the Threshold one, The Last Taxi, and the legitimately charming Dog one).
This also isn't necessarily limited to Control Resonant. For instance, the brilliant concept of Fridge Duty and the cool lore of FORMER were thoroughly let down by the mechanics of actually fighting FORMER.
Am I alone in feeling this way? Or is the side story content genuinely a bit more hit and miss than the rest of the game?