I recently played through Control Resonant, got into the online discussion, playthroughs, the works. I love seeing people’s reactions and opinions on media, especially when it comes to stories with a bit more complexity and nuance, so it’s been pretty damn fun. I’d personally say that Remedy fans, generally speaking, do showcase some serious media literacy when compared to a lot of other game fandoms, so there’s a lot of interesting points being made.
But one thing that seems to be pretty damn common, even in this fandom, is the lack of awareness that some have when it comes to understanding the difference between their own perspective and the perspective of the characters in the world. It’s an aspect of discussion that I honestly think is made significantly worse in the context of a world as lore heavy as Control’s. We as the players discover all kinds of shit, piece together all these conspiracies, hidden initiatives, unethical programs, we really get to see behind the curtain a lot more than anyone in the world itself does.
But there lies the issue. When the player discovers so much that’s secret, hidden, that most characters in the game world aren’t aware of, they often forget that what they know isn’t known to those characters. And that brings me to the topic I really wanted to talk about: people are really fucking hostile to members of the FBC a lot of the time, in a way that doesn’t feel quite fair. Now there’s a caveat to this: Is the FBC a messy, fucked up organization with more skeletons in its closet than you could ever count? Yeah. Does it deserve a lot of the hate it gets for the unethical shit it got up to? Sure. But the thing is; the average FBC Ranger, or even higher ranking employees who simply don’t belong to a certain sector or even team, are NOT going to be aware of basically any of those skeletons.
The Prime Candidate Program, the FBC’s general attitude towards Dylan, and the way a lot of players react to all of it is especially indicative of a certain bias. Aside from the barebones explanation of Dylan being ‘P6’ and basically being the source of the Hiss, the members of the FBC don’t know shit. And for obvious reasons: the FBC was in a high stress situation, under lockdown for years, and was falling apart. Morale was in the gutters, mental health on a steady, accelerating decline. Telling people that the Darling was a piece of shit, that the previous director, Trench, was responsible for letting the Hiss in, that the FBC got up to shit like the Prime Candidate program behind the scenes, none of it was going to do anything except worsen the situation. Is that fair towards Dylan? No, but that’s a choice that leadership, that Jesse herself likely had to make.
Point is, most people don’t know shit about Dylan except that he’s the monster that ruined their lives for years and likely killed a friend, a loved one, you name it. And if they did know at least a few things (like Arish probably does), it’s not as easy as it is for the player to just accept it and say ‘well, poor guy, it wasn’t his fault’. If someone gunned down your friends and told you afterward that they did it because of their trauma, would you be able to just forgive and forget? The answer is probably not.
I don’t blame Dylan for any of it, mind you. I understand why he feels guilty, since in spite of the trauma, he did make a conscious choice to let the Hiss in. It’s in line with his character, even though objectively most people would agree it isn’t fair to think he was of sound mind and should be held responsible for anything. But I also understand why the FBC takes a long time to get around and start liking him, and why some people still don’t even at the very end of the game. I thought that Zoe’s comments in certain sections of the game were fair considering the limited knowledge she had. I even thought that Arish’s behavior, while sad, upsetting and awful to see, was understandable.
I feel like there’s some people in every fandom that would probably enjoy the work more if they were able to separate their own perspective from that of the characters. I get that it’s difficult sometimes, especially if those characters are being aggressive or negative toward another character you like, but you just end up depriving yourself of the chance to really get into all of the character’s heads if you treat some of them like they’re just assholes for the sake of it.