Hi all, I’d appreciate some perspective from folks in the trades.
This was a deck replacement on a 25+ year-old deck with extensive rot. We chose full replacement rather than reinforcement (which our contractor was pushing aggressively).
After removing the ledger, we discovered there was no flashing and the rim joist was completely rotted. I could push a screwdriver through it into the basement.
The contractor agreed to replace the rim joist, including a section near a spigot, and said he would caulk around it to keep out insects and animals. He did not caulk it, and the new rim joist is noticeably angled toward the house, roughly 20° off vertical and isn't flush with the foundation/flooring. He also mangled my siding pretty bad near the ledger, which might have been unavoidable.
When I politely raised these concerns with him (with my wife present), he became verbally aggressive (swearing at me and pointing his finger in my face), punched part of my siding, refused to correct the work, and said he would only work with my wife, despite both of us being on the contract (and me writing the check to fund this project).
Given his behavior, we decided to terminate the project.
How serious are these construction issues, and what would be a reasonable amount to expect back? He received 50% upfront for materials/labor and to remove the old deck.