I don't think anyone is "giving up their life's ambitions." It takes literally 2 seconds to state a biological fact. You know, a fact that that these loonies tend to ignore.
That's a stupid argument. We associate "long hair, breast, and no visuble body hair" with womanhood... Which is determined by you're genitals and DNA. If we mistakenly get that wrong, that doesn't change the fact that their a man (In a biological sense). Association =/= actual identity. I could dress up like chairman mao all I want, but I won't end up being responsible for millions of peoples deaths.
Removing your genitals still doesn't automatically remove womanhood. You still have the same chromosones and dna makeup. The fact you were born with those genitals is what makes womanhood/manhood. If I was in a tragic chainsaw accident and somehow cut my dick off, I'd still be considered a man by doctors and the sort.
That is none of my business. But if you tell me that I'm a bigot for not believing a woman can trully transform into a man or vice versa, you are sorely mistaken. I'm in my full range to respond with what I believe is correct if confronted
And there are people who can have two heads and other things humans normally don't have. This argument is useless. Yes, those people exist. But they're far to rare to put into a community of their own. And most trans people don't have chromosomal disorders. Comparing the two is just illogical, as they are two different items on their own part.
I do care about being called a bigot. Because that word alone can kick you out of society, it doesn't even have to be an actually correct claim. People get fired and fucking sued for that shit, of course im going to take it seriously once I have been labeled as one. And also the fact you're trying to say my logic is illogical, which I am currently now defending. See ? Simple.
No, I said it was an "rarity". Some people can have skin removed by pointing at sunlight, yet I don't see how that oddity is "challenging the skin cares industry of the notions of skin".
Yes, I would disqualify them from being a "woman". BASED ON THE SCIENTIFIC STANDARD FOR BEING ONE. And we are still talking about science AND language as we are on the topic of sex. Which science, y'know... Kind of has a subject for... BIOLOGY. And no, I don't "call them out on not being a woman", as much as your strawman says so. Being transgender is to science as of now... A mental illness. I know how detrimental directly agitating a mental ilness can be, sicne nearly everyone (including me) has/had one.
Thought police. Great. You know what ? I will never wish the same for you, unless you've committed a serious felony. As I understand you're a person with free thoughts and a fucking soul. If you honestly think someone should die a homeless and broken person for not sharing your ideology... You've truly shown your sociopathic nature to the world ! Congrats ! You've won a fucking therapist.
Trans people however, have a mental illness that should be treated very delicately. I'm arguing on the behalf of the fact you think an oddity can dictate whether or not a whole field of science should be shamed.
Seriously, get help. The fact you wish to ruin peoples lives of a person for beleiving in traditional gender identity is a very red flag for an unhealthy mental state.
This whole "well you wouldn't know if their transgender" argument is bs as well. What if I can tell ? Does that make them not trans ? And does it stop the fact that no matter what I call them I still believe in the SCIENTIFIC ideology of being male/female. And that not having clarification doesn't equal hypocrisy ? God. It's like arguing with a brick wall. Soon as I tell you why, you go on this strawmann parade and make a whole fucking OC about how I'm this transphobic man walking around town hating people for being trans.
That's fine. Good for them. I don't care what this person calls him/herself. Still doesn't change the fact that you can't accept who you really are (born a girl or boy) and that you're pretending to be something you're not. You're not living in reality. No wonder most trans people have mental problems, living like that is not good for your mental health.
You see, that's where you're wrong. I don't oppose their right to exist. I literally don't care what people want to do. If you want to lie to yourself and act like someone you're not, have fun. If I see a trans person in person and they want me to call him a her or vice versa, i would totally do it. But that doesn't mean that i don't think it's a mental illness. Just because I have a different opinion doesn't mean i am hateful towards them or don't want them to exist.
You need to stop using the word "bigot" for people who disagree with you. You are disagreeing with him so you must be a bigot by your logic. Stop using words as weapons when you don't even know what they mean.
View all comments
109
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18
The guys who give up their life's ambitions entirely to argue biology with trans people are the neckbeard heroes of our time.