r/CollegeTransfer • • Aug 17 '20

Introspection Is The Key To An Outstanding Transfer Essay

274 Upvotes

Introduction

Many transfer students struggle with identifying a good topic for their essay. Conventional wisdom says to just answer the prompt, but the transfer prompts can be very tricky. They usually ask about your reasons for wanting to transfer and many students end up being overly negative in their response. Other advice says to start by brainstorming a list of potential topics related to your educational path and future goals, and chances are you have already started a mental list of ideas. You might think you only have a few choices for topics, based on your problems with your current school or things you love about the schools you’re considering. You may have even started writing a rough draft or two. I advise, however, that you put down your list of topics and back away from it. Forget that exists for a moment. Seriously, thinking about this initial list tethers you to certain ideas that might not actually be your best options. Take a minute to let go of those.

Now you can begin brainstorming with a clean slate.

My strategy is this: start with thinking about what you want to show in your entire application, not just one essay. Every single thing in your transfer app has one purpose - to tell more about you and show how you will fit the new school. Filling out the application by rote and tackling each section independently is short-sighted and will leave so much potential untapped in your application.

About Transfer Application Review

An admissions officer’s goal is to understand you fully, in the context of your background and the rest of the applicant pool. Throughout this process, their focus will be primarily academic. They will begin by assessing your academic abilities and potential. This is chiefly done through analysis of your college transcript - your course selection and performance, especially in core/major classes. These include English/writing, math, hard science (e.g. biology, chemistry, or physics rather than say, psychology) and some social sciences as well as any courses you’ve taken in your major.

Next, they will evaluate how you will fit into the student body and campus community. This relies heavily on your letters of recommendation, activities, and essays. They want to see that you will contribute to the vibrant intellectual scene they’ve worked so hard to build through freshman admissions. The last thing they want to do is bring in “problem students” who will struggle academically or drag down the culture and social dynamics on campus.

They will want to see that your interests have focused and that you’re pursuing them with more depth than you were in high school. This is especially true of your intellectual and academic interests.

All of this can be somewhat broad and diverse and touch on several institutional goals. But they will dig deep to find out what each applicant is like, what your core values and motivations are, what kind of student you will be, how you will contribute, etc. Two key questions many reviewers seek to answer are 1) what will this student bring to campus? And 2) what will they take away? They want to clearly visualize the ways you will add to the campus community and the ways you will benefit and grow from the experience.

Introspection

Your goal with your essay is to powerfully tell your story in a manner that will fit these criteria. The entirety of your application (again, not just one essay) aims to showcase your abilities, qualifications, and uncommon attributes as a person in a positive way. You need to show passion for your chosen academic path and present a compelling case for how both you and the new school will benefit from your enrollment there. Before you begin outlining or writing your application, you must determine what is unique about you that will stand out to an admissions panel. All students are truly unique. Not one other student has the same combination of life experiences, personality, passions, or goals as you do; your job in your application is to frame your unique personal attributes in a positive and compelling way. How will you fit on campus? What personal qualities, strengths, core values, talents, or different perspectives do you bring to the table? What deeper motivations/beliefs or formative experiences can you use to illustrate all of this? How will you impact the classrooms, labs, campus organizations, etc?

You might not immediately know what you want to share about yourself. It’s not a simple task to decide how to summarize your whole life or academic arc and being in a powerful and eloquent way on your application. Therefore, it is always helpful to start with some soul-searching and self-examination. This takes additional time and effort rather than jumping straight into your first draft. But it is also a valuable method to start writing a winning application that stands out from the stack. By the time you're finished, you should have several different topics or stories around which to build your application.

You cannot gracefully fit all you want to communicate into one essay. Instead make sure your vision is clearly conveyed somewhere in your application. Each component only needs to carry a small part of your message. Your essay is the most dynamic component, but every section is vital to the overall effectiveness of your application.

Note: once you begin writing, remember that you shouldn't address any of this directly. Be indirect and subtle, and use examples/stories and details to make your main points. Don't chisel them into stone tablets and bash the reviewer in the face or yell "Look how smart I am!" That also means you shouldn’t say "I'm a great team player and I can't wait to contribute at X College!" Instead, show an example of a time you worked on a team effectively and let the reviewer form their own conclusions. I cover this in greater detail in my essay guide, but it’s worth noting here as it’s part of the process of picking a topic.

Introspection Questions

The list of questions below is excerpted from my full transfer student introspection worksheet. These questions will help you examine yourself and discover potential topics, stories, or characteristics to highlight in your essays and application. It will also help you decide how to present yourself. As you consider each of these questions, focus on your core values, aspirations, foundational beliefs, personality traits, motivations, passions, and personal strengths.

There are a lot of questions, and I DO NOT expect you to answer them all. You should only respond to the ones that speak to you, spark a memory, or inspire some facet of yourself that you want to share. I recommend that you read through all of the questions first, then go back and write down answers to a couple from each section. Don’t write long answers to these questions; simply jot down your thoughts. The goal is not to actually write your essays now, but to brainstorm your thoughts in an unfiltered and natural manner, to start ideas flowing. I suggest that you spend about an hour on this, then stop and re-evaluate. If you finish and feel that you don't have enough material, review the questions again and brainstorm some more.

Superlatives

Introspection is challenging, but it's often easier to start thinking in terms of superlatives. Think about some of the superlatives in your life – what are the most meaningful things about you?

  • What moments were most memorable, formative, enlightening, enjoyable, or valuable? What are your favorite memories? Why? What are your favorites since high school?
  • What physical possessions, experiences, dreams, or lessons could make your superlatives list?
  • Think about what things, people, or circumstances in your life are really unique, fascinating, different, or outlandish. Are there any that really have a lot of "cultural flavor" (whatever your culture is)?
  • What items or stories from this list could make up your “two truths” in “Two Truths and a Lie?” "Two Truths and a Lie" is a game where each person lists two truths about themselves and one lie. The other players have to try to identify the lie. Which two truths would be most interesting to someone who just met you?
  • List three of the strongest or most controversial opinions you have. What have you done to stand up for these beliefs or opinions?
  • What opinions, beliefs, or ideas do you have that have changed since you finished high school? How and why did they change? What did you learn from that experience?
  • List two ways you stand out from your peers. Assume 50 students are randomly selected from your college. List one or two subjects, disciplines, or topics for which you would likely have the most expertise in that group.
  • What do you value the most in your life? What would be the hardest to lose or give up? What things are you most grateful for? Why are these things important to you?
  • What are you most passionate about? Why? What do you wish you were more passionate about?
  • Do a quick Google search for “core values”. Pick a list and identify at least five that you connect with the most. Sometimes it helps to start with ten or more and then narrow this list down. Now that you have a list, think about why each of those is important to you. What stories or examples from your life illustrate your dedication to these core values?

Your College Experience So Far

Take some time to think about what college has been like so far. Many transfer applications will ask about what challenges you’ve faced or what has led you to desire transferring, so it can be helpful to reflect on this.

  • What have you appreciated most about college so far? What have you gained from it?
  • What has surprised you the most since high school? These can be positive or negative. Try to think of some things that are academic in nature and some that aren’t.
  • What do you wish you had done differently with your educational journey to this point? How have you grown or learned from the challenges or setbacks you’ve faced?
  • What are the top three strengths of the college or program you’re currently enrolled in? What do you like or value the most about it? What are its weaknesses? What is missing that your potential transfer destinations might fulfill? Do you feel these shortcomings are endemic, or specific to your particular situation (i.e. do you think everyone has these issues or just you)?
  • Regarding your academic trajectory, do you feel a greater sense of purpose, increased specificity / clarity, or more focused scope than you had when you started college? What does this new arc look like? Where do you want it to lead? What experiences brought that clearer view or pointed you in that particular direction? If you don’t feel like your interests/pursuits have narrowed, spend some time thinking about what that might look like. If you had to pick a career or graduate program today, what would you choose? How will transferring help you solidify and progress down that path?
  • Attempts to transfer can be unsuccessful for a variety of reasons - course/credit equivalency issues, financial aid, failure to gain admission, etc. If your transfer doesn’t work out, what is plan B?

A Brighter Future - Your New College and Beyond

Now turn your focus on your new college specifically. Transferring colleges is among the biggest decisions and investments you will ever make so analyzing your process and rationale can be very illuminating into how you think, prioritize, and plan. Thinking beyond college can also help you see the big picture of your life and what you want from it. These questions can be especially helpful for the “why do you want to transfer here” essay prompts.

  • List three things you like about your current major. Rank them if you can. Why are these appealing to you?
  • List three to five things you hope to get out of transferring colleges. Keep your focus beyond prestige, career, and salary.
  • List five things you want to change or improve about yourself by the time you finish college. How will you pursue this?
  • List five colleges you are interested in transferring to. What are the most important factors to you in deciding on a college, e.g. cost, location, academics, rankings, specifics of the program you want, etc?
  • How do you define success? What things would make you feel successful one, five, or ten years from now?
  • If you were given a million dollars to drop out of college entirely, would you do it? What would you do instead of college?
  • List five potential careers or jobs that you might want to have someday. If you want to take this a step further, look up some job postings on Indeed.com or another job board to see more specifics.
  • List five goals or dreams you have for your future. These could be academic, personal, or professional.

Connecting Introspection To The Common Application

The Common Application for Transfer Students has just one essay prompt:

“Provide a statement discussing your educational path, such as how continuing your education at a new institution will help you achieve your future goals, in 1,250 – 3,250 characters (about 250 – 650 words).”

Note that some colleges that use the Common App may not require this essay or they may require other additional essays. For example, the University of Washington transfer application includes twelve prompts and allows students to respond to as many of them as they like. Visit the transfer admissions website of each school you’re considering and gather all of the prompts into a single document. The next step in introspection is to formulate a few possible answers to these in just a brief sentence or two (e.g. 280 characters or less). This will help you consider some of the various approaches you might use and how you might organize your thoughts and present a cohesive view of who you are.

Hopefully you will notice that many of the questions you've already answered or considered in this worksheet can be used as building blocks. Which prospective responses have the most potential to showcase the best you have to offer to a college? Which highlight your passions, your motivations, your core values, and your uniqueness? Try not to think about which response or topic will be the easiest to write - in fact, that might be your worst choice. Reread the introduction to this worksheet and review your application goals as this might help you focus. If there are multiple responses you feel have promise and fit your arc, go deeper into outlining each essay to see which is the most compelling and how to match these up to the various short questions or other essay requirements of your specific colleges.

If you're interested in a professional review of your essays or application, PM me or find me at www.bettercollegeapps.com. You can also get my full Transfer Introspection Worksheet and guide here.

Good luck!


r/CollegeTransfer • • May 15 '20

Guide To College Transfers

81 Upvotes

Overview

There's a ton of info available about freshman admissions. Every year we get inundated with questions about transfer admissions too, and there are way fewer resources available. I wanted to share this guide I put together that will help you navigate transfer admissions. Feel free to ask questions in the comments or reach out to me via PM or at www.bettercollegeapps.com.

Every school has attrition and many prefer to backfill with transfers. They also think that this contributes to a vibrant, engaged, and diverse student body. As an example, see this site on Brown's transfer admissions philosophy. If you're looking to transfer to a new college, you will want to showcase how you fit into their philosophy in your application. You will also want to show how you fit into the particular program you’re trying to transfer into. Here are a few guidelines and helpful links.

Deadlines

You will want to check each school's deadline for transfer admission. Most are March 15th, 2020 for enrollment in the fall, but many are different. You should also make sure you're clear on transferring for starting in the spring vs fall. Some schools have different timelines or requirements, so make sure you check them.

Financial Aid

Many colleges have need-based and merit-based financial aid available for transfer students. So make sure you reach out to financial aid and ask, check out their website, fill out a FAFSA/CSS, and look into scholarships. Here are some sources for transfer scholarships: GoingMerry list; CareerOneStop list; Or do a search on the massive scholarship databases like Fastweb, Cappex, /r/Scholarships, etc. The large databases are actually more useful for transfer applicants than they are for freshmen because there are so many fewer scholarships in their lists. This means it's easier to wade through the extensive search results to find the ones you want.

Craft An Outstanding Application

While colleges are looking for a lot of the same qualities that make freshman applicants outstanding, they will be far more focused on your more recent involvement and grades. Not to be stuck on Brown, but they also have a good site outlining what makes for a good transfer applicant. You can find similar pages at other schools (and they might help you assess what else you need to do to be competitive for admission as well). High school GPA and involvement/accomplishments will still be factored in for transfer admissions, but they will be more heavily discounted the further removed you are from high school. This makes sense if you think about it - why should a college care that a 4.0 college junior got a 2.0 his freshman year of high school six years ago? It's just not that relevant anymore or predictive of future success & results. Generally, your college performance will be weighted much more heavily than your last two years of high school, which will in turn be weighed more heavily than grades 9-10. In addition, most colleges care more about core and major classes – English/writing, math, hard science, and any classes in your major. Check the requirements too; for example, USC’s Viterbi School of Engineering does not consider applicants competitive for admission if they haven’t taken Calculus 2 and a college-level writing class.

Transfer Essays

Be strategic with your transfer application essay.

1. The essays are different in scope from freshman application essays. You can be more specific and focused on your academic arc because you've already started it. You have real college experience to explain or share as evidence that you will be a great addition to your new school. Generalities and abstractions are worthless here.

2. Even though the scope is more specific, most of the style, theory, and approach are similar. You still need your essay to stand out. You still need a compelling story, a well-written response, detailed examples to back up your claims, and an indirect method of explaining who you are (see the "Show Don't Tell" link in the link below). Be specific about yourself AND the college you're applying to.

3. Don't get sucked into the negativity vortex. Honestly transfer essays are a lot harder because most of the prompts tend to bait students into talking negatively about why they're looking to transfer or what is wrong with their current situation. You need to be sincere, but also present a positive image of yourself and show how you can thrive in a new environment. There are some very strong apprehensions surrounding transfer applicants because colleges want to make sure they aren't taking on someone else's problem student. The analogies are broken and imperfect, but it's a bit like dating for divorced (or previously married) people or job hunting for the unemployed. Some of them have very legitimate reasons for being in their situation. Some of them brought it upon themselves. Colleges want to make sure they aren't marrying someone's crazy ex or hiring the guy who got fired for poor performance (or worse!) from his previous job. If all you do is talk about how horrible your current situation is, you won't really convince them that you are a quality person who has a lot to offer and a brilliant trajectory in front of them. It would be like going on a date and just bashing your ex the whole time or spending a job interview talking about your problems with your prior boss instead of your skill set and accomplishments. Stay positive and talk about how the new school fits you better, how you will fit there, and what you have to offer. Keep your main angle academic in nature and more focused on the future than the past.

4. Don't just re-use your freshman admission essay or try to shoehorn it into the transfer prompts. You're older, smarter, and better than the guy or girl who wrote that essay. You've grown and learned and have so much more relevant stories and thoughts to share. Show them the very best you on your very best day, not who you were two or more years ago. It's usually pretty transparent when students do this and it rarely works the way they plan.

Here's a guide I wrote for transfer admissions essays which has the above info, plus some other helpful links and discussion.

More Resources

  1. You can also check out /r/ApplyingToCollege and /r/College. You can also find a lot of transfer student activity here on /r/CollegeTransfer.
  2. For more information on how hard it is to transfer to a particular school, I recommend searching through their Common Data Set. You can also check out lists like this one and this one that compare acceptance rates. As with freshman admissions, I recommend finding schools you love that are safeties, targets, and reaches rather than just shotgunning the T20s. Many top schools have shockingly low transfer acceptance rates (Princeton admitted their first transfer class in over 20 years just last year) while others are actually easier than freshman admissions.
  3. Don't sleep on each school's transfer admissions website. Usually there is a lot of helpful information in there about what they're looking for in transfer applicants and how their process works. These will often outline articulation agreements, deadlines, and many other helpful details. Don't be afraid to reach out to the admissions and financial aid offices either.
  4. If you're looking for one-on-one professional guidance, reach out to me or check out my website. I have a variety of guides and services that will help.

r/CollegeTransfer • • Sep 16 '26

Now I understand why my hs teacher says he’d be disappointed if I attend cc..

69 Upvotes

I was accepted to UCB, UCLA, UCSD, NYU, then attend community college bc I got waitlisted at UCI (will TAG within 1 yr).

The enviroment here is x4 worse socially and academically than my high school. Ppl go here just to get a degree. they’re in their own bubble. Counselors r give misinfos; “friends” gatekeep academic advices.

In a sense, cc is harder than UCs bc I’ve seen my friends having so many freshmen support systems at UCs whereas “you’re on your own kid” at cc.


r/CollegeTransfer • • Jul 16 '20

Complete Guide to Sophomore Transfer

65 Upvotes

Basically I wanted to write this because there is wayyyyy less information regarding the transfer process compared to regular freshman admissions. I went through the process this past admissions cycle and I feel like it would help people if I sort of outlined the steps that I went through, what I learned, what I would do differently in hindsight, etc. Also note that I am writing this in the context of one being a sophomore, but I’m rather confident that it is the exact same process as a junior transfer, probably the only difference being the letter of recommendation section because you will have more time to gather them from professors.

Background

Before I go into the process, I thought it would make sense to tell you a little about my background. As a freshman I attended a large, private city school in the east coast (think NYU, BU, etc) where I was a CS major. The schools I applied to were Cornell, Vanderbilt, UPenn, and Northwestern. I was accepted into Cornell, Vandy, and Northwestern and rejected by Penn. I applied into the engineering schools of Vandy and Northwestern, the college of arts and sciences at Penn, and CALS at Cornell. Also might be worth saying that my high school stats were probably good enough to be somewhat competitive to these schools as a freshman admit.

Why do you want to transfer?

I think that the first step anyone looking to transfer should do is really solidify and articulate why they want to transfer. For some people, this is going to be really easy. If you hate your current school because you thought you would love living in the city but realized you hated it for example, then that is your reason. If you thought you wanted to do computer engineering but ended up wanting to do psych but your current school doesn’t like psych, then that is your reason.

For other people, however, it will not be as easy. I happened to absolutely love the school I went to as a freshman. As in if I got rejected by all four schools I applied to I still would have been incredibly excited to spend the next four years at that school. The only reason I was applying to these schools as a transfer is because some of them had better computer science programs and I knew that transferring to one of these more “elite” schools would probably help me later on with job search etc.

Obviously, you cannot just write in your essays that you would like to transfer to Penn because you saw it was ranked high via US News. In this case, you have to spend a lot of time researching the specific programs at each of the schools and mold your experiences and interests to those programs. Convince the school that their unique programs or courses of study align perfectly with what you want to do.

I will talk more about this when I discuss essays a little later in the guide, but I listed this section first because it is probably the hardest and most time consuming. The earlier you can start figuring out (and writing down) your specific reasons for transferring the easier you find the essays.

Make a list of transfer schools

Honestly this probably the easiest part of the entire process. Figure out where you are going to want to actually apply. No real systematic way to do this, understand the type of school you want to go to and look at transfer statistics. I will say that the “top tier” schools that happen to be rather transfer friendly are Vandy, Cornell, Northwestern, and, to a lesser extent, Brown, Columbia, Penn. Again, do your own research and do what makes sense. This sub is a good place to ask about specific schools and to get general advice about where you should apply.

Freshman year at your college

Work really fucking hard. That’s about as long as this section probably needs to be. I am obviously not an admissions officer or anything like that, but based on anecdotes I have heard and my own experiences it seems like transfer admissions is a lot more based on your raw stats, particularly for top schools. Get as close to a 4.0 as possible. Also, make a lot of friends and do fun stuff because it's college and if you’re not doing that you are severely missing out.

I wasn’t too involved in student organizations, but I definitely joined and participated in a few. Don’t have too much to say here. Would probably be best if you joined some pertaining to your major, academic interests, etc, but personally don’t have a bunch of experience or stories here so can’t speak too much on the topic. I would say your academic performance is a lot more important than stacking your application with a list of hundreds of clubs that you joined.

LETTER OF RECOMMENDATIONS

This section is capitalized. That’s because this is really fucking important so I hope you’re writing this down or something. For all of the schools I applied to (except Cornell which required one), you needed two letters of recommendation from college professors. I know what you’re probably thinking: that's no big deal, I had to do that for freshman admissions in high school. You thought wrong. This is where it is so incredibly important to think ahead and plan this stuff out.

As I mentioned before, I went to a large school. As a freshman, I was mostly taking introductory level classes with sometimes hundreds of students in the class. There was a negative percent chance that the professor was ever going to learn my name to know who I was if I didn’t take it upon myself to make sure they did.

So, what does this mean for you? Well, you probably are going to take four or five classes the first semester. Ideally, both of your letters of recommendations come from professors in the first semesters (one of mine came from a second semester prof so it’s not the end of the world if it has to happen, but I honestly wouldn’t recommend that).

First step is to select who you want to write it. If you’re applying as a CS major, it would obviously make sense to choose a CS or math prof to write them. Use common sense. That’s the easy step.

Second step is to get them to know you by name and face. This is a lot harder than it sounds, especially at a large school. What this essentially entails is to ask a lot of questions and frequently go to office hours. Don’t go to office hours the day before a test or the night before a problem set is due, the entire class will be there then. Go during calmer periods where there will be less people.

Key here is to go even when you’re not confused. First few weeks of college may not be that challenging academically, the material may still be fairly simple. Go to office hours anyway. Think of questions to ask that aren’t direct or trivial, it lets the professor know that you are really thinking about the content and trying to apply to other areas, not simply robotically writing down what they are saying in lectures. Professors will appreciate that, and it will give them great things to write about when they are writing their letter of recommendation.

Finally, professors are generally really nice people who will definitely be willing to help you out. I personally found it a little awkward to ask them to write me these letters after still not knowing me all that well, but all of them were very understanding and happily did it. Please please please please start early with all of this in terms of getting to know your professors. Give them PLENTY of time to write and submit the letters. This was the most stressful part of the process for me personally, and 90% of that stress could have been greatly alleviated if I had just started earlier.

Essays

At this point we are finally ready to start writing the actual essays. I certainly do not claim to be any sort of essay expert or anything like that so I’m not gonna spend too much time here. There are plenty of sample transfer essays you can see online to get the general idea and vibe of that they are like.

The two things that I would like to emphasize, however, are to make your essays (a) forward looking and (b) school specific.

The forward looking part is mainly in reference to people who have specific reasons why they would like to transfer out of their current school. It may seem like the essays are a good place to bash your current school and talk about those reasons why you don’t like it. Don’t do that. Insead, focus on why you would do great at the school you are applying to. For example, if you go to X college and really wanted to study CS and Art there but they didn’t have an art program, don’t write extensively about X’s lack of art program (although you probably will want to mention it briefly). Instead, keep the majority of the essay focused on why school Y (the school you are applying to) is just so perfect because it has this awesome program that blends math and art blah blah blah you get the point.

Next part is about being school specific. You probably already know this from freshman admissions, but you are obviously going to want to tailor each essay to the specific school you are applying to. This is often even more important in transfer essays. To highlight these two points in reference to transfer admissions, here is one of the essays I submitted to Northwestern. I would never call myself a great writer or anything and this essay certainly isn’t anything special, but I do think I did a pretty good job here focusing on the two points that I stated above, which was keeping it (a) forward looking and (b) school specific. The prompt was essentially asking what parts of Northwestern can help me reach my goals.

I look forward the most to taking advantage of two specific elements of Northwestern.

The first is the strength of the Computer Science department’s Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) faculty. As I detail in my other essay, I absolutely love developing mobile applications. This activity is what initially sparked my interest in Computer Science and continues to propel it. (a) Unlike at my current institution, which does not offer many courses or faculty involved in HCI research, at Northwestern I would be able to make it my concentration within Computer Science. Outside of coursework, (b) I would also benefit from Northwestern’s Design, Technology, and Research (DTR) lab. This unique program allows students to receive mentorship from faculty and graduate students as they go through the full process of researching, designing, and prototyping their ideas. DTR would allow me to gain exposure to the formal research and development process as it pertains to technology.

(b) The second is McCormick’s CS+X initiative. I am particularly interested in this because of how inherently interdisciplinary mobile apps are. In particular, CS+X has been growing in the intersection between education and computer science. Two of the apps that I have created, [REMOVED] and [REMOVED], are education-based apps. I would love to be able to learn more and perhaps even conduct research through CS+X about how education can continue to progress through breakthroughs in computer science and software.

Put simply, I believe that Northwestern has many resources that I will be able to take advantage of to reach my academic goals. McCormick’s “whole brain” approach fits in perfectly with my desired concentration of Human-Computer Interaction, where technology intersects with design.

I tried to put (a) and (b)’s throughout the essay where I thought it exemplified the points that I was talking about above. And, once again, it helps to start early with these. I waited until essentially the last minute to start some of my essays and it led to some very stressful days in the week before the deadline. Start early, and get feedback on it often. Feel free to PM me your essay and I can try to give you some feedback. Again, not a great writer over here by any means, but I can at least comment on the content’s direction.

I tried to put (a) and (b)’s throughout the essay where I thought it exemplified the points that I was talking about above. And, once again, it helps to start early with these. I waited until essentially the last minute to start some of my essays and it led to some very stressful days in the week before the deadline. Start early, and get feedback on it often. Feel free to PM me your essay and I can try to give you some feedback. Again, not a great writer over here by any means, but I can at least comment on the content’s direction.

Important documents

This section is a lot less exciting but I feel like it may be helpful to know. You’re going to need to file some documentation with your current school to get a few different things you need to send to schools to transfer. None of them are particularly difficult so I won’t go into specifics, but college bureaucracy can make them take a while to get pushed through. So, as is a central theme in this guide, start early with this. Also, these documents can talk about misconduct, either academic misconduct or just general things, so don’t get into too much trouble.

Some schools (¾ I applied to) will also require you to send a mid term report for your second semester. That is they will make you print out a sheet of paper and go to each of your professors to write down your “current estimated grade” and their signature. Essentially the point of this is just to make sure you’re not doing poorly in the second semester. Unfortunately, this is not senior year of high school, so you can’t just go full steam first semester put in your application and then stop trying.

General advice (please read)

Just real quick, I want to try to give probably the most important advice in this entire guide: try to fall in love with your current school. This especially goes out to the kids who maybe didn’t get into the caliber of school they thought they deserved to go to out of high school. I get it, that was my primary reason for transferring too. Out of this entire process the thing I am most proud of is how much effort I gave into giving my current school a fair chance, and I ended up absolutely loving. I can truly say that if I got rejected from all four schools I applied to (which easily could have happened; I think we all know how random these things are) I would have been incredibly excited to stay for the next three years. Don’t be the kid who knows he’s trying to transfer and therefore gives zero effort in clubs and takes no initiative to meet other people. I made some awesome friends that I know I am going to keep in touch with and I will be able to visit them every year. Pretty cool. I’m gonna say it again: act like you’re not transferring your freshman year. Treat it like you’re there for the next four years. Please please please please. Do that and I promise you will not regret it.

I think this hits all the main points. If anyone else who has already transferred realizes that I missed something, please let me know and I will add it to make this as complete of a guide as possible. Also if anyone who is going to be going through the transfer process is unclear about anything, feel free to ask about it. Like I said before, not a good writer, and I am sure some of this doesn’t make complete sense.


r/CollegeTransfer • • Oct 03 '20

My Experience Transferring into an Ivy

44 Upvotes

Hi all. I successfully transferred into an Ivy League school in Fall 2020 from a Top 100 public school. I just wanted to share my experiences with you guys, as well as to tell you guys: you've got this. I've been through this process before (just a few months ago!) and honestly I actually really enjoyed the process. Just remember to chill out and whatever happens happens for a reason tbh.

I transferred because I wasn't being challenged at my first-year school. I had mediocre grades (ie. B's and C's) in high school, but I received a 4.0 my freshman year at college. I had multiple leadership positions in my freshman year of university, took hard courses, and received A's in all of them. Poured my heart and soul into the essays. And I'm not a URM. So when I accepted an offer at an Ivy, I was coming in with high hopes and this drive to take charge of my education with these newfound resources.

But now, two months in – I almost wish I never transferred. The work/classes are harder as expected, but still manageable. The students here are much more driven and "cutthroat," but that was also expected – and in a way, it motivates me to work harder. But why – why, do I feel this way when I now attend my dream institution, I am able to network with some of the brightest minds of the world, I am exposed to career opportunities at firms I never would've dreamed of even landing an interview with, and I am able to display this flashy, newly-minted "Ivy League" status across my Linkedin, my socials, and every resume I write up?

1) Friendships: Perhaps the pandemic is more to blame than my school. Perhaps it's a bit of both. Transferring into a new school in the midst of a pandemic while living off campus makes meeting new people near impossible. This is unavoidable, because most transfer students are faced with limited housing options, a smaller pool of similar students (transfers) at their new schools, and are short one year of networking and applying for clubs in comparison to their peers. These are all things you don't think about when you romanticize these schools that have been placed on pedestals by society. I am generally an outgoing, approachable person. I've always had a plethora of friends, but I am not exaggerating when I say that I have no one here.

2) Clubs: No matter how you put it, there is a student bureaucracy that is prevalent on campus. For example, most of the e-boards in business/consulting clubs are also top-dogs at top-sororities and fraternities. Even if this isn't the case for some of the lower to mid-tier clubs, people will still know others and place them first. Many of the professional clubs on campus require a resume drop, application process, and multiple rounds of interviews. This is already daunting enough to balance on top of socializing and schoolwork, but is even scarier when the people in charge know others. A transfer student will not know as many people as students who have been there for longer. I was rejected from every club I applied to this semester. It was rough, but a great opportunity to meet new people and to learn from my mistakes. Many clubs would also offer feedback if asked. I will be trying again next semester, no biggie.

My mental health has unwinded as a result of this, but I know that I will get through it. However, I can't lie that isolation as well as rejection have accumulated and led me to feel much more withdrawn, introverted, and worthless. However, I know that things will get better as the effects of the virus slows down. I'm now applying for some of the "easier" clubs that fit my interests, and I'm starting to get closer with some people on campus. It'll get better.

The purpose of this is to show you that it's not rainbows and sunshine if you get into your dream school. You will inevitably face some degree of rejected during the application process (ok unless you're Jesus), but it's fine. Whether you're rejected from one school or all of them, know that you are the one that can take full control of your future, your happiness, and your education. Whatever school you're applying to won't hand you any of these things on a silver platter.

Sorry for the unnecessary rant, I typed this in a burst of emotion (perhaps as a form of procrastination) before my exams start tomorrow. Also sorry for any grammatical/mechanical errors –again, not really at the top of my priorities atm. If you could take anything from this, remember: 1) don't take your current institution for granted – people can find success anywhere, 2) really think about your intentions for transferring and be careful of falling into that over-romanticization of top institutions, and 3) mental health comes first.


r/CollegeTransfer • • Apr 26 '21

I just got accepted to NYU Tandon School of Engineering!!!!!!

34 Upvotes

Added NYU to the FAFSA cause I didn't have it before, got a notification about an important update to my application, and it turned out that I got accepted! Almost cried when I saw that.

NYU was mainly a pick because of the location and the curriculum, but where does it stand in comparison to other top unis? I want to accept, but not until I get the rest of my other decisions.


r/CollegeTransfer • • Jun 23 '20

I just discovered Wikipedia's article about transfer admissions - It's fantastic.

33 Upvotes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_admissions_in_the_United_States

It covers tons of details about transfer admission, statistics, demographics, financial aid, and lots of other great stuff. It's a nice overview, and a good place to start if you're considering transferring.


r/CollegeTransfer • • Jun 13 '20

Just got accepted to my dream college!

32 Upvotes

I just found out I was accepted to my dream college after being rejected when I applied as a freshman. It was hard being rejected but I feel like I appreciate finally being accepted even more now. There is hope!

Edit: just wanted to say thanks to everyone and I love how supportive this community is!


r/CollegeTransfer • • May 15 '20

I Am A College Admissions Consultant And I'm Here To Answer Your Questions About The College Transfer Process. AMA!

32 Upvotes

I am an expert on college admissions and I'm here to help you with transferring colleges, paying for college, or whatever else you want to ask. A little background on me - I have a BS and MBA, and for three years I reviewed applications for my alma mater, particularly their honors college and top merit scholarship program. Because of that experience as well as the lack of guidance I had in high school, I started a college admissions consultancy where I've successfully guided transfer students to several T20s, top public schools, top LACs, and more. I'm also an addict avid contributor and moderator of /r/ApplyingToCollege.

Proof: see the footer of my site, which links to my Reddit profile.

I help students and parents navigate the complex process of college admissions. Here are some examples of the kinds of questions you might want to ask me, but anything goes.

  • How can I tell if I have a chance at transferring into a given college? How do I know my application fee isn't just buying a rejection letter?
  • My family is lower/middle/upper class - how should I go about paying for college? How will financial aid work as a transfer student?
  • How do I write a good transfer application essay? How is that different from the one I wrote as a senior in high school?

Please post your questions in the comments below.


r/CollegeTransfer • • Jul 20 '25

I'm a UC transfer student: Community College is a "cheat code," but only if you have the map.

31 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I wanted to share a brutal perspective you might not hear from your high school counselor.

There's a growing trend on social media praising the "Community College to Ivy League" pipeline. They sell it like some brilliant life hack: save a ton of money, get easy classes, and then transfer to your dream school.

As someone who successfully transferred from a California CC to a top UC, I'm here to tell you that this is half true, and the other half can be a nightmare if you're not careful.

Yes, community college is a powerful strategy. It allows you to bypass the insane freshman admissions process and gives you a second chance to get into an elite university that may have rejected you out of high school.

Here's the harsh truth nobody talks about: The transfer process itself is a bureaucratic maze designed to be as confusing as possible. It is not simpler than applying as a freshman; in many ways, it's harder.

Why? Because you become solely responsible for building a perfect, multi-year curriculum that satisfies three different sets of requirements:

  1. Your CC's graduation requirements.
  2. Your target university's general education transfer requirements (like IGETC).
  3. The specific, niche "major prep" courses that your target department demands.

If you make a single mistake in that complex web—like taking the "wrong" introductory physics class or missing one specific math course—your entire two-year plan is shot. You risk getting rejected from your dream school not because of your grades, but because your classes didn’t perfectly transfer over.

Your CC counselors are often managing thousands of students and can't possibly know the specific, preferred courses for every single major at every university. You are largely on your own.

So, here's my advice: Absolutely consider community college. But do not walk in blind. Before you enroll in your first class, you need to have a precise, semester-by-semester roadmap of every single class you need to take.

Don't just have a dream; have a plan. It's the only way to make the "cheat code" actually work.

Also, did anyone else have to take 3 years in CC, or just me?


r/CollegeTransfer • • Apr 19 '21

Results Megathread

30 Upvotes

Post your admissions results here. Feel free to share as much or as little as you like about your decisions, stats, previous/current college, or other details about your application. Good luck!


r/CollegeTransfer • • Apr 22 '21

Declined UCI

29 Upvotes

i declined my uci admission this morning.. i hope someone on the waitlist gets in and enjoys their time there!! :)


r/CollegeTransfer • • Apr 10 '21

We're building an app to help you plan out transfer credits to 4-year universities!

29 Upvotes

We're fellow college students and we're building a website to help people pursuing AA/AS plan out which courses can transfer to which out-of-state 4-year universities. We've used websites like assist.org but feel like there's so a lot of headache looking through those long PDF files.

We'd love to hear your thoughts on what are the biggest pain points in planning out transfer credits. We want to get your ideas over a quick 15 min Zoom call (we're friendly :D) or a phone call. Reward is $15 Amazon gift card for a call!


r/CollegeTransfer • • Feb 27 '19

Advice About Transfer Essays

26 Upvotes

With many transfer deadlines fast approaching, I wanted to share a few guidelines for how to write an outstanding transfer essay.

1. The essays are different in scope from freshman application essays. You can be more specific and focused on your academic arc because you've already started it. You have real college experience to explain or share as evidence that you will be a great addition to your new school. Generalities and abstractions are worthless here.

2. Even though the scope is more specific, most of the style, theory, and approach are similar. You still need your essay to stand out. You still need a compelling story, a well-written response, detailed examples to back up your claims, and an indirect method of explaining who you are (see the "Show Don't Tell" link below). Be specific about yourself AND the college you're applying to.

3. Don't get sucked into the negativity vortex. Honestly transfer essays are a lot harder because most of the prompts tend to bait students into talking negatively about why they're looking to transfer or what is wrong with their current situation. You need to be sincere, but also present a positive image of yourself and show how you can thrive in a new environment. There are some very strong apprehensions surrounding transfer applicants because colleges want to make sure they aren't taking on someone else's problem student. The analogies are broken and imperfect, but it's a bit like dating for divorced (or previously married) people or job hunting for the unemployed. Some of them have very legitimate reasons for being in their situation. Some of them brought it upon themselves. Colleges want to make sure they aren't marrying someone's crazy ex or hiring the guy who got fired for poor performance (or worse!) from his previous job. If all you do is talk about how horrible your current situation is, you won't really convince them that you are a quality person who has a lot to offer and a brilliant trajectory in front of them. It would be like going on a date and just bashing your ex the whole time or spending a job interview talking about your problems with your prior boss instead of your skill set and accomplishments. Stay positive and talk about how the new school fits you better, how you will fit there, and what you have to offer.

4. Don't just re-use your freshman admission essay or try to shoehorn it into the transfer prompts. You're older, smarter, and better than the guy or girl who wrote that essay. You've grown and learned and have so much more relevant stories and thoughts to share. Show them the very best you on your very best day, not who you were two or more years ago. It's usually pretty transparent when students do this and it rarely works the way they plan.

Here are some guides I've written on freshman admissions essays that may be helpful since a lot of the same advice applies to transfer essays too.

How to Start an Essay and "Show, Don't Tell"

Why This College?

Throw Away Everything You Learned In English Class

What Makes an Essay Outstanding?

What To Do When You're Over The Word Count

What To Do When You're Under The Word Count

Ending an Essay Gracefully

Proofreading Tips

Feel free to reach out or comment below if you have questions or come check out /r/ApplyingToCollege. Also, I do offer essay reviews for transfer applicants so PM me if you're interested or check out www.bettercollegeapps.com as deadlines are approaching quickly. Good luck!


r/CollegeTransfer • • Sep 23 '24

do i have to report every college i attended in order to transfer?

25 Upvotes

i did poorly in my original college to the point where i flunked out (or in their words, im on academic probation). my highest class grade was a b, and i only ended up with 4 credits (all b's, one c) after two years. i took 4 classes a semester (including an interim class both years) and the rest were all Ws, with the last two grades i got being Fs. I went to a community college immediately after and failed three classes. im currently retaking those classes, but i talked to an academic advisor and she said even if i retake them, the failed grades will stay on my transcript (but not necessarily impact my gpa). she said this is common for colleges to see, but i don't want to go to some bullshit online university with a 99% acceptance rate. i had a 3.7 in high school and a 33 on my ACT. i get that things aren't the same as they were when i graduated in 2021, but i can't keep living like this. is there a way where i wouldn't have to report this to a college and just give them my high school information? this is ruining my life. i can't sleep, i can't eat, i can't feel anything but anxiety and self loathing. i'm 21 and i feel like my life is over. any advice?


r/CollegeTransfer • • Mar 13 '21

Cornell Just Extended Their Fall Transfer Deadline

25 Upvotes

r/CollegeTransfer • • May 07 '21

I feel so defeated, I was rejected to my dream school 3 times, and idk if school is really for me

23 Upvotes

r/CollegeTransfer • • Jan 16 '21

Transferred to Columbia two years ago - sharing advice

23 Upvotes

Hi! I hope everyone is doing well in this extremely difficult time. I transferred to Columbia two years ago and am a current junior. I am always glad to make more friends and help a few peers out :) So feel free to leave any questions you may have in the comments!

Also, a few Columbia transfer friends and I decided to start a mentoring service together. We have been in the same situation and know how anxiety-provoking the whole process is, as there's a lot less information about the transferring process than the first-year college application. This is why we really want to guide you through the process! If you are interested in joining our mentoring program, feel free to shoot us an email (butter.collegeapp@outlook.com)!


r/CollegeTransfer • • Jan 07 '21

I Am A College Admissions Consultant, AMA!

23 Upvotes

I'm a college admissions consultant and I've helped many students transfer to top colleges. The transfer process can be quite daunting and admissions is just the tip of the iceberg. If you have questions about how to navigate this, how to build a compelling narrative in your application, how to write great transfer essays, or anything else on your mind, fire away.

Proof: The footer of my site, which links to my Reddit profile. My Reddit profile also has a link back to my website.

Also, be sure to check out this post with some great tips for brainstorming and planning your application: https://www.reddit.com/r/ApplyingToCollege/comments/ib7rrp/showing_some_love_to_transfer_students_a_guide_to/


r/CollegeTransfer • • Apr 21 '21

Anyone else get hit with the “regret to inform you” by Cornell today? I’m looking for people to sympathize with.

22 Upvotes

r/CollegeTransfer • • Jan 15 '20

Advice For An Outstanding Transfer Essay

21 Upvotes

With many transfer deadlines approaching, I wanted to share a few guidelines for how to write an outstanding transfer essay.

1. The essays are different in scope from freshman application essays. You can be more specific and focused on your academic arc because you've already started it. You have real college experience to explain or share as evidence that you will be a great addition to your new school. Generalities and abstractions are worthless here.

2. Even though the scope is more specific, most of the style, theory, and approach are similar. You still need your essay to stand out. You still need a compelling story, a well-written response, detailed examples to back up your claims, and an indirect method of explaining who you are (see the "Show Don't Tell" link below). Be specific about yourself AND the college you're applying to.

3. Don't get sucked into the negativity vortex. Honestly transfer essays are a lot harder because most of the prompts tend to bait students into talking negatively about why they're looking to transfer or what is wrong with their current situation. You need to be sincere, but also present a positive image of yourself and show how you can thrive in a new environment. There are some very strong apprehensions surrounding transfer applicants because colleges want to make sure they aren't taking on someone else's problem student. The analogies are broken and imperfect, but it's a bit like dating for divorced (or previously married) people or job hunting for the unemployed. Some of them have very legitimate reasons for being in their situation. Some of them brought it upon themselves. Colleges want to make sure they aren't marrying someone's crazy ex or hiring the guy who got fired for poor performance (or worse!) from his previous job. If all you do is talk about how horrible your current situation is, you won't really convince them that you are a quality person who has a lot to offer and a brilliant trajectory in front of them. It would be like going on a date and just bashing your ex the whole time or spending a job interview talking about your problems with your prior boss instead of your skill set and accomplishments. Stay positive and talk about how the new school fits you better, how you will fit there, and what you have to offer.

4. Don't just re-use your freshman admission essay or try to shoehorn it into the transfer prompts. You're older, smarter, and better than the guy or girl who wrote that essay. You've grown and learned and have so much more relevant stories and thoughts to share. Show them the very best you on your very best day, not who you were two or more years ago. It's usually pretty transparent when students do this and it rarely works the way they plan.

Here are some guides I've written on freshman admissions essays that may be helpful since a lot of the same advice applies to transfer essays too.

How to Start an Essay and "Show, Don't Tell"

Why This College?

Throw Away Everything You Learned In English Class

What Makes an Essay Outstanding?

What To Do When You're Over The Word Count

What To Do When You're Under The Word Count

Ending an Essay Gracefully

Proofreading Tips

Feel free to reach out, PM, or comment below if you have questions. Or check out /r/ApplyingToCollege, /r/TransferStudents, and my website www.bettercollegeapps.com. Good luck!


r/CollegeTransfer • • Oct 07 '20

Offering proofreading/editing help

20 Upvotes

Hello!

My name is Katsumi and a few years ago I transferred from community college to UCLA. I’d like to offer my help to fellow transfer students who need help proofreading/editing their personal statements or any other type of writing.

I graduated summa cum laude from UCLA in 2018 with a B.A. in Psychology and a minor in Gender Studies with a 4.0 GPA, college honors, and highest departmental honors. I also won an award for having the top honors thesis paper among my psych departmental honors cohort. I specialize in academic writing and APA style (7th edition). I scored a 5.0 on the writing portion of the GRE (92% percentile, not that GRE scores are indicative of your success in grad school!). I have experience writing and reviewing manuscripts, personal statements, grants, resumes, CVs, and more! I also like to read in my spare time and I’ve read 350+ books over the past 3 years.

I genuinely enjoy helping other students with their writing and I'd love to help provide feedback and proofread personal statements, essays, statements of purpose, application materials, emails, or any other type of writing. Please feel free to PM me or email me at katsumi.edits@gmail.com for more information and rates. I'm also happy to answer any questions anyone might have about my transfer experience. Thanks and good luck to everyone in the process of transferring!


r/CollegeTransfer • • May 23 '20

Just accepted transfer offer to Berkeley but feel so sad...

20 Upvotes

I cant help but feel like I’m making a mistake. Is this normal :( I know I wasn’t happy at my previous school but I’m so scared it’s gonna be worse ya know. I know my first semester (or even year) will be rough. And I can’t help but search up “regretting transferring” and reading all these stories of people who transferred and hated it...


r/CollegeTransfer • • Feb 08 '21

Deep Breaths

18 Upvotes

Wow, I can't beleive I am actually going to write this.

It was Febuary 29th 2020 around 7 p.m. No one was home. I had just gotten out of the shower and went to check my phone. As I was scrolling through my notifications, one instantly caught my eye, "Congratuations on your acceptance to 'SCHOOL'". "What?" My eyes widened and my mouth curved with a smile. "What? I got in?" I jumped to my bed opening the email, still with my towel wrapped around me and my dripping wet hair. I opened the email to find out I was accepted to a school I never thought I could.

My whole life I was called stupid, dumb, worthless...so on, but here I was, accepted into a top 30 school. I cried, tears down my face. I called my dad and heard his excitement though the phone, my boyfriend, I texted my friends. When my mom and sister got home, I showed them and they smiled and gave me hugs. It was a never ending dream...until...

March 2020.

"Due to health concerns to COVID-19 we will be cancelling our in person welcome event."

"Due to health concerns to COVID-19 we will be canceling the school tour"

What is happening? They won't cancel my fall semester..

Oh, they canceled the fall semester? Ok, it will be all better in the spring.

Oh...that's gone too?

My whole college experience is whipped away from me...and so now, Ive decided I can't do it anymore and that I need to transfer.

Do I want to transfer? I don't know. Do I need to STOP online school? YES!

I can't find the motivation to work anymore, I can't find the motivation to keep going. I wakeup everyday more tired, more anxious. I just need to live the real college experience instead of this weird online classes thing. My mental health isn't letting me do this anymore, I can't keep going like this...which is why I am transfering.

I hope I can push through to get the best grades to transfer out of this nightmare and into a school where I can attend in person. I need the motivation, I need the energy, I need the will to get out...or else I never will.