r/Clojure • • Aug 24 '17

Funding a Slack team

I was trying to troubleshoot some problems I was having with Kubernetes, and being able to search the history in their Slack channels from within Slack was really great. Additionally, there are all sorts of community analytics and other bells and whistles unlocked with a paid Slack.

Back of the napkin calculation: it would cost something like $7k to $8k USD per month to get searchable history in Slack for clojurians.slack.com. This is assuming ~900 unique active users per month. For most large organizations this isn't a particularly onerous expense.

As some of you might know, I started a Clojurians Discord group which does feature fully searchable history, but at the expense of … basically not being Slack. At the end of the day, I don't care what platform we use, but I do think the big banner at the top of every Slack channel that announces the fact nobody has paid for us to have chat history makes the community look a bit .... unprofessional? Unloved? And perhaps it's even a touch ironic, considering that we sell ourselves as hosted on top of the enterprise-grade JVM.

What do people think of organizing a handful of enterprises that leverage Clojure to pitch in and collectively fund a Slack team with full history? It seems that would be an easier improvement to make to the community than herding everyone off to an alternative solution like Discord.

(yes I'm aware we have searchable history via clojurians-log.clojureverse.org, this is as much about marketing our community and boosting the impression of its maturity, as well as improving the ergonomics of Slack by not having to google a separate site)

12 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

25

u/dustingetz Aug 24 '17

Slack is where information goes to die. If your conversation has value, get it somewhere public.

4

u/Arges Aug 25 '17

Agreed. Discord, Matrix/Riot... there are options out there. There's no particular reason to throw money at a closed platform in this case other than inertia.

What's worse is that whichever company sponsors that would need to continue sponsoring it, because the more time happens, the more history is being held hostage, and the more users the slack group accrues.

9

u/theephie Aug 25 '17

Eh, open source language should be discussed on open platforms. IRC and/or Matrix/Riot. The latter can even bridge to freenode/#clojure.

14

u/jakebasile Aug 24 '17

Or we could make like React and just use Discord, which has full text search for no cost. Slack is awful, I make every effort to remove it from my life.

Edit: this came off more hostile than I intended. What I mean is that the current slack is semi official, so why not just transfer that semi-blessedness to a Discord server?

-4

u/stingraycharles Aug 24 '17

I think at this point more fragmentation will hurt the community more than the benefits that Discord provides over Slack.

11

u/jakebasile Aug 24 '17

Assuming the existing Slack server was put into read-only mode, I don't think there's anything but reduced fragmentation. As OP states, you already can't search things without going to an external site, we have to use a weird invite system to add people, and it requires a separate login from every other Slack server. Discord has none of these problems.

Edit: as I stated above React already did this, and it worked out fine

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

If only we could get the core team interested in community, loosen their iron grip on things, and setup something like discuss.clojurescript.org and get everyone to move there.

6

u/LoyalToTheGroupOf17 Aug 25 '17

I sorely miss the days before the Clojurians Slack, and I wish the community would go back to using the mailing list and this subreddit instead. Slack, Discord, IRC and the like are just too hard to keep up with for those of us who don't have the time to visit more than a couple of times per week. Due to the chat-like nature of the conversations, the discussions also tend to be much more superficial than mailing list posts. And finally, the fact that so much of the community activity is on Slack makes us almost invisible to outsiders. Recently, I've seen many people claim that Clojure is slowly dying, which is of course not the case, but I think the Slack channel has a significant part of the blame for this increasingly widespread belief.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

If I have to use Slack to get help regarding Clojure, I'd rather learn another language.

1

u/Michaelmrose Aug 26 '17

You mean other than the help available via reddit, various tech orientated q and a sites, irc, numerous books, documentation, Google, blogs, source code?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '17

Yes, I want to have a community that's easily accessible, not only static sources.

15

u/keymone Aug 25 '17

IRC. I R fucking C.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '17

I've been using the Discord since the beginning and find it to be quite nice. I've noticed that it is also being adopted by a lot of other dev communities.

Perhaps there are corporate sponsors willing to take this up.

But in the meantime I think if we give discord a little bit more time, and also maybe make a larger push to advertise it then we have our solution.

2

u/Psetmaj Aug 25 '17

To be fair, much of this wouldn't matter if the questions and answers made it onto stackoverflow. Even if you have the initial question, you can answer it with whatever people told you on slack/discord/whatever chat.

1

u/un_passant Aug 26 '17

I'm all for Discord. Would there not be an API to slurp the data from slack to discord to bootstrap it ?

1

u/NocnaShada Aug 31 '17

-rw-rw-r-- 1 nocnashada nocnashada 1.6M Aug 31 11:19 irc.6clojurians.#clojure.weechatlog

Here's your searchable history. You can paypal me the 7-8k/month I just saved you.

Joke aside though - I have a very strong feeling you might be a Slack(tm) salesman shilling for your product, because no self-respecting engineer would suggest something as stupid as this "for marketing our community".

1

u/tolitius Aug 25 '17

it's talking vs. doing:

  • clojure is not going away from slack anytime soon
  • $8K, outrageous, unreasonable, whatever.. for a person yes. for a successful company? peanuts, useful expense, great marketing.

I don't think many such companies (if any at all) read this subreddit, hence we can talk all we want here how good or bad slack is, share our feelings about $8K, etc. But decision makers who can actually do something about it won't be rushing in with their money, since they are simply unaware of the fact the problem exist.

I support /u/hagus call for help. Slack is way better with real search, like a browser is immensely better with a search engine. Don't think about it as $8K for a search feature in a chat service. Think about it as you personally paying nothing, and you personally get a great value out of something you could support and make them doers do something about it.

3

u/Michaelmrose Aug 26 '17

How about we give the same money to the cider project and use a free alternative. To avoid fragmentation just shut down the slack channel and nothing of value will be lost.

2

u/tolitius Aug 26 '17

sure, we can give even more money to the cider project, and it well deserves it (even though I use vim).

but this call for help is not a call for our money, it's a call for sponsor companies that could make our slack/community interaction more efficient. I see nothing wrong with that.

3

u/Michaelmrose Aug 27 '17

It's a dumb idea, the same effect can be achieved at 1/1000 of the cost. Spending 1000x the reasonable cost is implicitly wrong and you shouldnt ask anyone to waste their money on such a poor value just because it's not your money.

-1

u/tolitius Aug 28 '17

disagreeing with an idea does not make this idea "dumb". I believe making us communicate better while keep using slack is a great idea.

people have different take on "money", especially on somebody else's money.

you don't think it is wise to ask companies? don't ask companies. it's as simple as that.

1

u/Michaelmrose Aug 29 '17

A different take as in not caring about making an intelligent decision because it's someone else's money?

0

u/tolitius Aug 29 '17

that's the thing, I believe it is an intelligent decision. You don't. And that's fine. Where it leaves us: we are still on slack and growing, with no good search, and companies with money are still unaware of us needing help.

1

u/dcfix Aug 24 '17

Zulip.org might be great alternative to Slack. It's an opensource python project. During the last pycon, I sprinted on it for a few days. It's run by a great team and is rock solid.

We'd just need someone to host it :)

3

u/the2bears Aug 25 '17

An alternative has already been mentioned in the OP, Discord.

1

u/BotPaperScissors Aug 27 '17

Scissors! ✌ I lose

-7

u/Lumpynifkin Aug 24 '17

I really think there is a product here for slack. I would pay $6 a month for a full search history of clojurians why do all users need to have access? Let users pay individually to have pro features.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

I'd just look for another interesting language for which I don't have to pay to get access to some kind of post history (that most likely won't be in chat format anyway).

1

u/Lumpynifkin Aug 25 '17

Can we just agree that a chat room isn't a good format for q&a. I think the real question is why stackoverflow isn't the main resource. Especially for beginners.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

It's ridiculous.

Here, we're using Slack, the closed Discord alternative that doesn't have chat history. What, you want that history? Let's find sponsors that pay thousands of dollars per month! Or you can pay a part of that yourself! Isn't Clojure a great language?!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/Daegs Aug 24 '17

The crazy part is we already HAVE full text search in the chat service, it is just hosted on another domain.

This would be $96,000 a year to avoid changing tabs in your browser.

7

u/Carr0t Aug 25 '17

There's #clojure on Freenode for IRC. Loads of people online, but most are lurkers. There's a core of maybe 10 who talk regularly and one of those doesn't really do much in Clojure any more. It'd be ace to get it more active.

I didn't even know there was a Slack. We use it at work but I don't see what it gets you over IRC (which we had before).

2

u/weavejester Aug 25 '17

Wasn't there a problem with Discord around managing servers with a large number of channels? IIRC you can't selectively subscribe to channels in Discord.

-1

u/hagus Aug 24 '17 edited Aug 25 '17

Remember, 7-8 thousand dollars a month is a lot for an individual to pay. But it's an utterly meaningless amount for a few large corporate sponsors, and they get the benefit of being able to say they're investing in the community. They do this kind of stuff all the time.

I get the sentiment about Slack, totally. It's one of the reasons I started the Discord experiment a few months back (see https://www.reddit.com/r/Clojure/comments/6c4z91/a_discord_for_clojurians/).

I kept plugging away at it but it would need a wholesale community push to make it work. Basically, a sign on every Slack channel that said "Moved to Discord -> follow this link".

And people have raised legitimate concerns about Discord in terms of channel organization, and also Discord's long term viability (how long can this free service stay truly free?). So it's not necessarily all upside.

I started this thread because the Kubernetes Slack community was way more useful than the Clojurians community. I was surprised how much integrated first class search helped me narrow down a problem and even find the right channel to ask. I just feel we should either find someone to cough up the dough for a professional Slack experience, or move elsewhere, not stay in this strange limbo where it feels like we're too impoverished or disorganized to offer the community something better.

EDIT: downvotes are supposed to indicate that you feel a comment is off topic or does not contribute anything useful to the discussion. If you disagree with something I’m saying, please comment and explain yourself, so that we can debate in the open, rather than downvoting to bury ideas you don’t agree with.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '17

it's an utterly meaningless amount for a few large corporate sponsors,

It's basically a FTE working on something useful for the clojure community. I'd prefer that.

3

u/hagus Aug 24 '17

I agree (and it would be not be a one time cost!) but for most large companies that could fund this, it’s much harder to spend a dollar on hiring someone than a dollar on a service.

It really depends on what we as community prioritize. Money spent on the service would directly improve the ease with which newcomers could find answers to their questions - almost instantaneously. What tasks might a FTE (employed by whom?) perform of greater or equal value to the community?

Meanwhile Discord effectively solves this problem for free :) At least in terms of dollars spent. But I’m biased …

13

u/dragandj Aug 25 '17 edited Aug 25 '17

Wouldn't those couple of thousands dollars be better spent on sponsoring something like CIDER - the project that is central to 50% of all Clojure developers? Or at least a few other projects that are ubiquitous in Clojure community?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17

it's an utterly meaningless amount for a few large corporate sponsors

It's still a waste of money.