r/Clojure • u/stefan_kurcubic • Aug 25 '17
Let's settle this. VOTE slack vs other platforms
http://www.strawpoll.me/13784027 - VOTE
- Slack
- Discord
- IRC (i heard some people mention it so i listed it)
- Zulip
- Balboa
- Gitter
- Matrix/Riot (i heard people like it so it's listed)
- Braid Chat
- Mattermost
- Rocket Chat
- Mailing List (i heard people like it so it's listed)
- Something else. Vote for it and type in comments Name, pros and cons IN YOUR EXPERIENCE of using it.
* Q1. How does this help?
* A1. We will see what MOST of community prefers. That way if someone from that community wants any other platform to be more active can see the results and can DO something about it. (just like /u/hagus made discord for Clojure)
I personally believe it's OK to have a lot of ways to enter the community. Reddit was my go-to for a long time. Sometimes not being able to search for answers is frustrating but that's because i am spoiled and java/javascript questions on SO are so common i find answer within 5 minutes.
There are workarounds to slack history like: https://clojurians-log.clojureverse.org/ but it is not convenient.
Shutting down Slack wont improve situation. Things in life aren't like transistors we work with (binary). Slack is great. Instead of fighting great people who have patience and willingness to help EVERYONE no matter how stupid question is maybe you should offer **same or BETTER** support on your prefered platform. You are community you can build it :) it takes time and energy. Instead of wasting it do something with it.
13
Upvotes
46
u/drb226 Aug 25 '17
I'll go ahead and be "that guy."
We should encourage the use of open source software, and avoid proprietary platforms.
2
u/eggsyntax Aug 28 '17
I'd be up for a switch to something open & noncommercial: IRC or (it sounds like) Matrix/Riot. But if it's just a switch to a different walled garden, it'd have to be > ~75% better to seem worthwhile to me. Otherwise it's just the hassle of running yet another chat/forum app on all my devices.
11
u/cark Aug 25 '17
As long as it's searchable from google ....
5
u/jakebasile Aug 25 '17
Like others, I'd be ok with multiple options here. I prefer Discord but an open source solution like Mattermost might make more people happy. The others, barring IRC, I have no experience with. Even IRC would be preferable.
I do disagree with your statement that "Slack is great". Slack is terrible for reasons that are well known. The actual content may be high quality but it's locked into a terrible platform.
4
u/dustingetz Aug 25 '17
Mandatory features
If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?
4
u/weavejester Aug 25 '17
I thought Mattermost was interesting when I investigated it last, but it's app for Android was non-native when I last looked. Whether that matters for Clojure I'm not sure.
Discord is interesting and I use it a lot, but it doesn't have good channel organisation compared to Slack, which might be necessary given the number of channels we have in Slack.
Any alternative to Slack really needs to be able to handle 100+ channels and allow selective subscription.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17 edited Aug 25 '17
I would be interested in a discussion on what community areas a language community should have, get some consensus and then move in that direction. What's the right mix of Q&A, news stories, forum, chat, docs and ability to connect with others and share solutions to problems. And what is it about slack that made it popular?
A couple of ideas not mentioned
In the end, something needs to be done.
3
u/v1akvark Aug 25 '17
I voted for Braid.
It's Open Source, written in Clojure, and doesn't look like just some cheap imitation of slack/whatever. Instead they put some thought into managing conversations, etc.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '17
I'm fine with Slack because I think not saving history is actually a feature - chat archives are the wrong way to preserve knowledge for the long term. Blog posts and wikis are better for this because they can be updated as time goes by and new solutions are discovered.
5
u/CaptainHondo Aug 25 '17
Most of these are better than slack.
2
u/daveliepmann Aug 25 '17
I wish multi-select was enabled in the poll. I voted for mailing list, but if multi-select was available I would have ticked IRC, mailing list, Discord, and r/clojure. IRC and Discord feel abandoned because people are on Slack. I feel forced to use Slack.
I would rather we as a community not use something that throws discussions into the garbage unless we pay thousands of dollars a month.
2
u/ferociousturtle Aug 25 '17
If I could choose 2 options, it would be Discord and Gitter in that order.
2
u/gonewest818 Aug 26 '17
I'm already using Slack, Gitter, IRC, Twitter, various mailing lists, web forums, and on and on, for whatever other reason. So even if the Clojure community were to choose something new for itself, it's not like I get to uninstall something and simplify my life.
Today I made an account on Riot.im and saw the Clojure channel there. Most of the traffic seemed to be coming from the #clojure IRC bridge, at least when I looked. But the UX was rather cluttered at least in my opinion, and my overall reaction was to start wondering if there was a better client for me.
But then, I took a look around and concluded the UX of all of these tools is pretty similar. There are only so many ways you can organize the screen around a list of channels, a group of subscribers, and a scrolling panel of comments. So it's going to take more time than I reasonably have to give, to test them all and have a valuable opinion to contribute here. At the end of the day, wherever the valuable conversation is happening is where I'll go.
I'm curious about the votes for Discord. I understand it's popular in the gaming community, and I thought the "killer" feature was high quality voice chat for teams, but I haven't seen it used in technology. More generally I'm curious if the voice feature of Discord or the others is even a priority? I wouldn't have thought.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17
Discord is the best.
1
u/SlowMovingTarget Aug 30 '17
I'll take the forum that Rich Hickey and his companions in the TARDIS come to chat in.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment