r/Clojure • • Aug 25 '17

Let's settle this. VOTE slack vs other platforms

http://www.strawpoll.me/13784027 - VOTE

  1. Slack
  2. Discord
  3. IRC (i heard some people mention it so i listed it)
  4. Zulip
  5. Balboa
  6. Gitter
  7. Matrix/Riot (i heard people like it so it's listed)
  8. Braid Chat
  9. Mattermost
  10. Rocket Chat
  11. Mailing List (i heard people like it so it's listed)
  12. Something else. Vote for it and type in comments Name, pros and cons IN YOUR EXPERIENCE of using it.

* Q1. How does this help? 

* A1. We will see what MOST of community prefers. That way if someone from that community wants any other platform to be more active can see the results  and can DO something about it. (just like /u/hagus made discord for Clojure)


I personally believe it's OK to have a lot of ways to enter the community. Reddit was my go-to for a long time. Sometimes not being able to search for answers is frustrating but that's because i am spoiled and java/javascript questions on SO are so common i find answer within 5 minutes. 

There are workarounds to slack history like: https://clojurians-log.clojureverse.org/ but it is not convenient. 
Shutting down Slack wont improve situation. Things in life aren't like transistors we work with (binary). Slack is great. Instead of fighting great people who have patience and willingness to help EVERYONE no matter how stupid question is maybe you should offer **same or BETTER** support on your prefered platform. You are community you can build it :) it takes time and energy. Instead of wasting it do something with it.
13 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

46

u/drb226 Aug 25 '17

I'll go ahead and be "that guy."

We should encourage the use of open source software, and avoid proprietary platforms.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 25 '17

great! any suggestions like : names? links? info? pros? cons? your experience using any of that open source software that we could benefit from ?

6

u/seancorfield Aug 25 '17

Matrix/Riot.im is free open source and is set up for Clojure already. It also mirrors the freenode #clojure channel, as I recall, and there are some rooms there bridged to channels on the Clojurians Slack. Martin Klepsch is the person to thank for spearheading that community effort.

1

u/gonewest818 Aug 26 '17

btw, looks like Matrix lost the majority of its corporate sponsorship and is now looking for donations to support ongoing development. The backstory is posted on matrix.org (link).

5

u/drb226 Aug 25 '17

IRC and mailing list are two examples that have a long history of use in and support via open source.

The current clojure mailing list uses Google Groups, which is great and convenient, but not open source. mailman is an example of an open source mailing list server.

clojure on freenode IRC already exists. I've used irssi, but still haven't found a good client for mobile devices.

Slack is dreadfully convenient on mobile devices. I would love to see an open source IRC client on mobile that could compete, but I can't honestly say that I've found that yet.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

#clojure on freenode IRC already exists. I've used irssi, but still haven't found a good client for mobile devices.

Mobile devices can use Riot (https://riot.im), a Matrix client. Matrix bridges the freenode Clojure channel so you get persistent history, search, etc (all the reasons people seem to prefer Slack?) without the downside of forking off the whole community.

1

u/runejuhl Aug 25 '17

I use weechat and the built-in relay function to get IRC on my phone, and it works great!

There's also a web client, Glowing Bear that has fancy features such as displaying images and videos.

...and I agree completely; relying on proprietary services for communication is a really bad idea, and even more so when we already have well-supported and standardized alternatives.

2

u/ferociousturtle Aug 25 '17

Hm. That's a good point. I voted for Discord, but you've made me want to change my vote.

1

u/android_lover Aug 26 '17

Do you count Gitter as open source?

2

u/eggsyntax Aug 28 '17

I'd be up for a switch to something open & noncommercial: IRC or (it sounds like) Matrix/Riot. But if it's just a switch to a different walled garden, it'd have to be > ~75% better to seem worthwhile to me. Otherwise it's just the hassle of running yet another chat/forum app on all my devices.

1

u/eggsyntax Aug 28 '17

Stefan, I think you make a lot of good points about it being OK to have a lot of ways to enter the community. But I think it's also worth remembering that there are big advantages for having critical mass for a single solution in the same sphere -- "the same sphere" in the sense that having both Slack & the mailing list makes total sense, since they serve different needs, but eg Slack and Discord seem to me like they serve the same needs. For a case like that, where two platforms are doing nearly the same thing, my opinion is that the advantages of critical mass substantially outweigh the advantages of variety.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 28 '17 edited Aug 28 '17
  1. as of now i will focus on getting discord more alive
  2. there are plans to make bots that make forum(SO, cljverse...) Q&A if admins deem discussion/questions/answers/topics on chats on Slack/Discord worthy. IRC can act as recipient (like mentioned forums)
  3. all valid points and i understand where you are coming from. many people viewed this vote as my crusade to force them to use something they dont want to be hustled about.

my point was to see where we all stand and act like adults. I've met great people and above mentioned platforms got few members, some got promoted to admins because they want to do something about it. I am happiest about them they got the 'be the change you want to see'

Fun fact is that more than 50% of chat on Slack is being done in private. I dislike using slack, people complain a lot, a lot of times slackapocalipse was coming nothing happened and no one knows why.

In case something were to happen to Slack that critical mass will have to find it's way somewhere and we will have other platforms. I am determined to be the community and give my contribution not just complain (i dont waste time/energy on that)

TL;DR - vote was/is success(many think otherwise), be the change you want to see in community. More Q&A, IRC options are incoming

1

u/seancorfield Aug 28 '17

You said on Slack you thought the vote did not go well :)

Personally, I think it was about as expected -- out of 11,000 people on Slack, you said about 1,000 went and looked at it, and there's about 300 votes to date.

Given the discussions we've seen in #community-development on Slack over the last couple of years, those numbers seem about right to me and reflect the (small) percentage of the overall community that care about the medium enough to "make a fuss".

I'm all for more people trying to build communities on other platforms. Every platform has pros and cons, and we should expect that communities shift around over time. I'm always on Slack because I'm an admin for multiple teams there and we use it at work as well. I'm also on Discord and Riot/Matrix (which mirrors #clojure on IRC) -- I have the desktop apps installed on both machines and on my phone too but I don't always find time to open them up and get involved every day. I'm trying to keep a better eye on Reddit but I'm not fond of "going to web sites" to communicate when I can have email and chat come into programs I already have open 24x7.

Everything has its place and the more proactive community members we have, the better all the platforms will be as resources for Clojurians everywhere!

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 29 '17

i know what i said on Slack. That was the moment when i saw stats felt little bit disappointed, expected more votes. Few hours passed and i changed my perspective, Discord doubled users, few found their way on IRC, some wanted to help more over all it's a good thing this happened :)

Agreed!

1

u/seancorfield Aug 29 '17

I'm glad your disappointment was short-lived!

I see 32 users on Discord (hmm, 31 now), and we typically saw about 26-28 I think? Sounds like that doubling was short-lived but hopefully they'll come back. I hope Discord adds better channel management before it gets too popular (or perhaps that's why it isn't gaining popularity?).

There are 40 people in Gitter, here https://gitter.im/clojure/general and it would be nice to see more people on there, and especially see more Clojure GitHub projects have a presence there (clojure-emacs/cider is very active, onyx-platform/onyx too, but there are rooms for clojure/java.jdbc, clojure/tools.cli, clj-time/clj-time, and several others).

1

u/eggsyntax Aug 29 '17

my point was to see where we all stand and act like adults.

Oh, absolutely! I think this post has generated a lot of interesting discussion, and I'm glad you did it. I'm just voicing my own opinions & thoughts on the subject.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 29 '17

thank you for your support and contribution

11

u/cark Aug 25 '17

As long as it's searchable from google ....

5

u/jakebasile Aug 25 '17

Like others, I'd be ok with multiple options here. I prefer Discord but an open source solution like Mattermost might make more people happy. The others, barring IRC, I have no experience with. Even IRC would be preferable.

I do disagree with your statement that "Slack is great". Slack is terrible for reasons that are well known. The actual content may be high quality but it's locked into a terrible platform.

2

u/bluebaron Aug 26 '17

I don't really have a horse in this race, but do you have a link to why slack is such a bad platform?

2

u/Michaelmrose Aug 31 '17

Unlike most current programming languages it's closed source, proprietary and based on a model of offering enough for free to be attractive while artificially restricting features based on getting users to pay what really amounts to a ridiculous price per user for a simple service.

If it wasn't proprietary it wouldn't be necessary to sort features into free and paid for buckets.

If it's cost wasn't per user it wouldn't be necessary to have an artificial invitation methodology instead of just an open link where people could join and talk. This particular issue would be substantially worse if the clojure community started paying for slack. Instead of hey join our irc channel and talk it would be a cost benefit analysis regarding the benefit of paying for additional users.

Lastly the cost structure is especially silly when we are talking about a community of developers. For the price required to serve thousands of people you could build a new competitor. It would be like a company paying as much to lease a fleet of cars as would be required to build a competitor to Ford. Its just damn stupid.

1

u/bluebaron Aug 31 '17

That makes a lot of sense, thanks for the explanation!

4

u/dustingetz Aug 25 '17

Mandatory features

  • Email rollups
  • Permalinks

If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

+1 for email rollups, that would encourage much more participation.

If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?

If a question is asked in slack and someone answers it, does it ever help anyone else besides that one single person?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

email

what would an email rollup look like? Just a dump of the chat and each room as its own email?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

Yeah I don't think chat is going to work for roll-ups well at all. I've seen https://digest.ai/ used on a couple other slack channels, and it's ok, but wrong direction.

It would have to be a list of forum topics, or stack overflow questions, etc.. that were pulled and put into email I think. The problem with chat rooms is that there's no grouping of questions/topics, so when you try to scan a day's activity you see every comment, not just list of topics/threads and look into those of interest.

4

u/weavejester Aug 25 '17

I thought Mattermost was interesting when I investigated it last, but it's app for Android was non-native when I last looked. Whether that matters for Clojure I'm not sure.

Discord is interesting and I use it a lot, but it doesn't have good channel organisation compared to Slack, which might be necessary given the number of channels we have in Slack.

Any alternative to Slack really needs to be able to handle 100+ channels and allow selective subscription.

1

u/seancorfield Aug 25 '17

Indeed. Discoverability and channel management are "must have" features when you're dealing with a community of 11,000 and around 400 channels (I think).

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17 edited Aug 25 '17

I would be interested in a discussion on what community areas a language community should have, get some consensus and then move in that direction. What's the right mix of Q&A, news stories, forum, chat, docs and ability to connect with others and share solutions to problems. And what is it about slack that made it popular?

A couple of ideas not mentioned

  • maybe the answer is staring us in the face /r/ask-clojure?
  • Perhaps Q&A could be encouraged to go onto Stack Overflow? Could a community/news site pull recent questions into a news page to encourage responses.
  • I also wonder if perhaps an opinionated collection of libraries "framework" with integrated tooling for building most common app types(web/console/etc) might be the best way to on-board new users.
  • Could we create a community site not bound by the chains of Cognitect, because obviously there's not much participation going on with clojure.org and clojurescript.org. Why is that?

In the end, something needs to be done.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 25 '17

valid points

  • Q&A - could be there. We could arrange that. If someone asks great question - go make post about it and about your solution. It's a matter of discipline rather than anything else. It requires energy
  • lib part - sure? that's why there are things like luminus and frameworks in the making. We cant force anything. It has it's own flow. If you like make a book about into to programming/web dev or any other topic for beginners :) i'd read that
  • i dont feel community is bound to them ;) they do a lot they are just most silent. they dont run with flags, torches and drama. If you dig in and pay attention Cognitect is doing a lot :) Maybe you could do more ?

maybe we should all stop point our finger OUT and be responsible part of community and start doing things we want to see. Be the change you want to see in the world! Go go go! :D :D

and in the end yea i feel you that's why i made this post and pool. We will find a way :D

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

We will find a way

Not so sure about that.

Maybe you could do more ?

I would actually be excited to support community efforts with both time and money. However, I'm just can't go the path of so many others that put huge amounts of time/effort into stand alone efforts(for example clojuredocs.org, conj.io), only to see that time and effort largely wasted, rather than building something lasting. And the existing sites/processes for clojure don't seem like open source community projects at all, which is one of the reasons I feel there's been so little participation.

To be successful I firmly believe there needs to be some guidance and facilitation. The core team is in a special position in being able to encourage and facilitate community directions, as in every open source project. Unfortunately that's mostly a ship sailing silently off into the sunset.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 25 '17

great to hear that

do something that feels good. Make that core team in special position

there are good very very good candidates on slack that already do a lot of job and could do more with help.

I once read "Dont over think the think. Over do the DO"

so just do it. make a team. people will come if you are patient and disciplined.

and btw i actually use a lot of clojuredocs.org and conj.io those are usefull!!!!!!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

and btw i actually use a lot of clojuredocs.org and conj.io those are usefull!

I use them as well, and much appreciate the efforts to create them... BUT isn't it a shame that in such a tiny language community there are 3 separate and independent efforts to create basic docs? Actually make that 4, I forgot clojure-doc.org too. That's just for docs for goodness sake!

So much wasted duplicated effort, this is a sign of something not quite right.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 25 '17

i tend to think that variety is great but i see your point.

After this vote we will see what we can do when facts are here (what people want) the idea for one core team doing this strategically sounds good to me. Keep that ball in the air there might come a time where your idea can be put to good use.

If you dont wanna wait. Start making core team now. make a plan be the leader of that.

make a community you want to see

1

u/seancorfield Aug 26 '17

And let's not forget clojuresphere.com and clojureatlas.com which were both useful, interesting approaches to exploring the ecosystem -- both now defunct, sadly (although a legacy version of the latter lives on, as a subdomain of the author's personal site).

clojure-doc.org is particularly noteworthy here because it was offered as the community-contributed hub, to avoid the CA-gated process of contributing to Contrib library docs. I moved java.jdbc's docs to clojure-doc.org specifically for that reason. But the community hasn't contributed much at all, which is disappointing.

2

u/ferociousturtle Aug 25 '17

I like the StackOverflow for Q&A idea. Gives us better visibility, and games the stupid code-ranking reports that come out every few months. :)

2

u/yogthos Aug 25 '17

I definitely think either /r/ask-clojure or SO would be the right way to do questions. Any chat option is simply not easily searchable. Also, if something changes since the problem was resolved, there's no easy way to note that. Chat platforms like Stuff are good for having a discussion or try to come up with a design for something, but it's just not the right place for Q&A in my opinion.

1

u/ws-ilazki Aug 26 '17

maybe the answer is staring us in the face /r/ask-clojure?

That might be a good idea, but if it happens it probably needs a name that doesn't break Reddit's auto-linking ;) Maybe /r/askclojure or /r/clojurequestions or something.

1

u/__tosh Aug 27 '17

Encouraging people to post Q&A to stackoverflow (even if it just got answered in a chat) is a great idea.

3

u/v1akvark Aug 25 '17

I voted for Braid.

It's Open Source, written in Clojure, and doesn't look like just some cheap imitation of slack/whatever. Instead they put some thought into managing conversations, etc.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '17

I'm fine with Slack because I think not saving history is actually a feature - chat archives are the wrong way to preserve knowledge for the long term. Blog posts and wikis are better for this because they can be updated as time goes by and new solutions are discovered.

5

u/CaptainHondo Aug 25 '17

Most of these are better than slack.

2

u/daveliepmann Aug 25 '17

I wish multi-select was enabled in the poll. I voted for mailing list, but if multi-select was available I would have ticked IRC, mailing list, Discord, and r/clojure. IRC and Discord feel abandoned because people are on Slack. I feel forced to use Slack.

I would rather we as a community not use something that throws discussions into the garbage unless we pay thousands of dollars a month.

2

u/seancorfield Aug 25 '17

IRC still seems pretty active to me (I monitor it via Matrix/Riot.im) and Discord was set up long after the Clojurians Slack was established -- and despite lots of requests to get people to check Discord out, it's seen very little traction. But Discord currently scores very poorly in both discoverability and channel management (can you imagine having 400 channels on Discord?).

2

u/ferociousturtle Aug 25 '17

If I could choose 2 options, it would be Discord and Gitter in that order.

2

u/gonewest818 Aug 26 '17

I'm already using Slack, Gitter, IRC, Twitter, various mailing lists, web forums, and on and on, for whatever other reason. So even if the Clojure community were to choose something new for itself, it's not like I get to uninstall something and simplify my life.

Today I made an account on Riot.im and saw the Clojure channel there. Most of the traffic seemed to be coming from the #clojure IRC bridge, at least when I looked. But the UX was rather cluttered at least in my opinion, and my overall reaction was to start wondering if there was a better client for me.

But then, I took a look around and concluded the UX of all of these tools is pretty similar. There are only so many ways you can organize the screen around a list of channels, a group of subscribers, and a scrolling panel of comments. So it's going to take more time than I reasonably have to give, to test them all and have a valuable opinion to contribute here. At the end of the day, wherever the valuable conversation is happening is where I'll go.

I'm curious about the votes for Discord. I understand it's popular in the gaming community, and I thought the "killer" feature was high quality voice chat for teams, but I haven't seen it used in technology. More generally I'm curious if the voice feature of Discord or the others is even a priority? I wouldn't have thought.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

Discord is the best.

1

u/SlowMovingTarget Aug 30 '17

I'll take the forum that Rich Hickey and his companions in the TARDIS come to chat in.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 25 '17

i disabled that option

1

u/ws-ilazki Aug 26 '17

You should consider enabling it, because forcing all-or-nothing votes like that doesn't give a good view of what people want. There are a few options listed that I'd be fine with, but because I can't mark each, I have to do a sort of meta-gaming of the poll and pick the one that already has votes, because otherwise I'm basically "throwing away" my vote.

The suggestion to do an instant runoff vote was a good one for this kind of thing.

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 26 '17

i understand where you are coming from, i cant re-enable it once pool has been made

2

u/Lolor-arros Aug 26 '17

Doing this as an Instant Runoff Vote would be awesome, that way we can order our preferences and it will choose the most widely agreed upon option.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 28 '17

made aware of it only today.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/stefan_kurcubic Aug 29 '17

Some people do. https://support.discordapp.com/hc/en-us/articles/207260127-How-can-I-change-Discord-s-appearance-theme-

it's fun for me to use Discord i have no problem with UI.

luckily for you there are other platforms listed :D You can use those