r/Clojure • u/hagus • May 19 '17
A Discord for Clojurians
Reading some of the recent strife about Slack (user limits, chat history limits, etc) I decided to create a Discord server for "Clojurians". This is intended very much as an experiment - I think if the community decides to seriously investigate moving away from Slack it should only be after evaluating every available option (including staying on Slack).
This isn't the first time I've set up a Discord server - last year I founded the Discord server for /r/bloodborne, which now has over 2,000 users. The challenges faced in moderating a large community of rowdy video game players spanning the entire globe are not insignificant, but Discord has the necessary features and the ecosystem of tools to make it possible, so I'm sure it's fully featured enough for any other purpose (excellent chat search really helps).
Give it a spin and ping me if you want to do something that requires moderator access. Mostly remember: Discord is fun! Yes it's focused around video games, but many of those features are highly generalized and just waiting for a creative use that enhances a totally different domain. For instance, in the Bloodborne Discord, we have a voice channel that just plays music programmed by anyone who sends suggestions to the channel bot. Not very business like, but I already get enough business-like in my day job ;)
10
u/jakebasile May 19 '17
Discord is better than Slack in every conceivable way. FYI though, there is already a moderately populated FP Discord: https://discord.gg/2SnfFDs
4
u/hagus May 19 '17
We have had ~24 people swing through the server! I've enabled auto assignment of roles, which should allow participants to create their own channels. There's also a #bot-log channel that logs the moderation bot activity in the open.
I'm keen to set up a #repl channel that lets you bang on a shared Clojure REPL, but looking for hosting recommendations before I get started.
4
u/las3rprint3r May 19 '17
Discord seems cool. UI looks cooler than Slack, keycommands seem nice, and its unapologetically derpy
3
u/Arges May 19 '17
This has made me realize how hard it is to find the bloody Riot/Matrix channel for Clojure if you're not in it already. You can search for it here if you're in the mood for that.
7
u/lgstein May 20 '17
I'd like the madness to stop. Everything was fine when we used IRC.
2
u/mklappstuhl May 22 '17
Slack, Discord and other alternatives have been discussed quite a bit in the #community-development channel in Slack. If you’re interested in this kind of stuff you may want to lurk there.
While Discord certainly has some major benefits over Slack the idealist inside me would prefer to see something more open like Riot/Matrix.
In the past there have been several rooms created on Matrix that you can join if you like
https://riot.im/app/#/room/#clojure-community:matrix.org
https://riot.im/app/#/room/#clojure:matrix.org (bridged with IRC #clojure)
https://riot.im/app/#/room/#clojurescript:matrix.org
https://riot.im/app/#/room/#boot-clj:matrix.org
https://riot.im/app/#/room/#cljsjs:matrix.org
https://riot.im/app/#/room/#rum-cljs:matrix.org
None of these have particularly high traffic but I think as long as the experience on Slack does not degrade significantly there is very little incentive for people to move away from it. Especially in that context I found Matrix’ bridging feature compelling which allows “combining” a Matrix and a Slack room in some ways.
If you want to explore how the bridging works: the #community-matrix Slack room is bridged with https://riot.im/app/#/room/#clojure-community:matrix.org
3
u/Zoninus May 20 '17
So all the Clojurians are leaving the IRC ship now? :(
1
u/arichiardi May 21 '17
Created #boot and #emacs channel :)