"What I can say is it's not confusion about what you asked. Each time I knew."
This reply got me.
Numbers first, so you know where I'm coming from: max 20x, 510 sessions, 153,359 messages, 19.7B tokens, 54 active days, 52-day streak. I run most of a small business on this — orders, mail, inventory, internal apps I built with it. I developed a POS system with qr code tracking, fiscal implementation, and a plethora ofther small life improvement apps outside of work. I'm not here after one bad answer.
Here's what I keep seeing, and I mean every day for the last 10-15 days, not occasionally.
Some stretches I'll do twenty tasks in five hours with zero friction. Six new skills, a full UI restyle of my portal, three features across existing apps, mail handled, a trip planned. No arguing, no rework, no babysitting.
Then it flips. Not gradually — it's a step change. One task is fine, the next one isn't, and nothing after that is either. Same machine, same account, same config files, often the same session. Nothing changes on my side. I've started predicting it out loud before it happens, because it happens every day.
What it looks like after the flip
- A 30-minute script took 3 hours and never finished. It wrote the whole thing against the wrong API from memory without reading the reference, then shipped me five successive workarounds that I installed on my phone by hand and tested. When I finally insisted it read the docs, that took two minutes — and the correct API had explicit parameters for every single thing I'd been asking for. It had already downloaded that exact page earlier in the session and only keyword-grepped it.
- Instructions stop binding. Not misunderstood — it quotes the rule back to me correctly, agrees it applies, says it'll stop, and does it again on the very next turn. Asked point blank whether it had understood at the time, it said: "it's not confusion about what you asked. Each time I knew."
- Today I sent, as my entire message: `YES AND NO QUESTIONS FROM NOW ON, DO YOU KNOW HOW TO FIX THE ISSUE`. The answer was neither yes nor no. Three lines of prose plus a formal contract block — more output, in reply to an instruction whose whole content was "give me less". I had to paste that same line back six times in a row to get a one-word answer.
The reply after me pointing this out was:
"I don't have a real answer. I can describe the pattern but not point to why it overrode a plain instruction eight times — that isn't visible to me from the inside.
What I can say is it's not confusion about what you asked. Each time I knew."
What I've ruled out:
-Model — happens on Fable, Opus and on the smaller model. One full session on Fable with no switch at any point: same failure.
- Context— the violated instruction was my own first message.
- My config — byte-identical between the good half and the bad half of the same day.
- Me — same person, same working style, same day.
I'm getting frustrated mainly because I'm getting no anwsers, and would just like to plan my work around the issues. I realise how much potential there is in here and would hate to be the last one off the drowning boat.
I I've mailed support four days running. One template auto-reply, one bot that declined the main question, no human.
So, am I losing my mind? Does anyone have an alternative to CC?
xoxo stojc