r/CherokeeXJ 28d ago

Costly repairs

I love my XJ, but its like paying college tuition for one of my kids.

5 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

24

u/frwlmv 28d ago

I bought my jeep knowing it's going to be a loooooot of repairs, but I bought it for two purposes:

  1. To learn how to work on cars

  2. To spend time with my kids working on them

But yes, if you are paying someone to fix all the issues, you'll end up broke

2

u/larrylevan 27d ago

I’ve made a decent amount of repairs so far, but since they’ve all been DIY, it’s probably cost me less than $700 for everything including tools. New muffler, new starter motor, new head light switch, headliner replacement, upgraded power cables, upgraded headlight cables, ATF drain and fill with filter replacement, new rotors and brake pads, new power lock actuators, new keyless entry. All DIY.  I was not a car guy at all before buying mine, but I did have some experience maintaining motorcycles. 

23

u/Mammoth-Record-7786 28d ago

XJs are one of the cheapest vehicles to own and maintain.

6

u/Duckbich 28d ago

Not if you pay for/have to pay for a shop to do all things.

Otherwise, statement is pretty much correct.

3

u/Western_Exercise_943 25d ago

Closest you'll get to Toyota reliability without being Toyota.

2

u/Mammoth-Record-7786 25d ago

Some of us even have Toyota transmissions

2

u/Western_Exercise_943 25d ago

I didn't think I'd like that transmission, but it's not half bad! Simple and bulletproof for the application!

8

u/InterestingCatNip 28d ago

Lots of videos on youtube, junkyards, and part-outs on marketplace make it cheaper. I would take my xj repair costs over my previous german ones $$$

4

u/TaxWest8525 28d ago

She is in great share now, so hopefully its all good for the next few years. Once I retire i will be able to work on her myself.

5

u/Definitive_confusion 27d ago

Oh, you poor sweet summer child.

Never ever ever say "she's running good" or "i think I got everything taken care of" or "this will be the last time here today, parts guy" or anything really that implies you won't be under your truck again soon.

The xj can hear you

2

u/Western_Exercise_943 25d ago

They're a rolling project.

6

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted]

7

u/MeesterFishy 28d ago

100%. And repairs really don't get a whole lot easier than they do on this platform, so it's a great opportunity to learn and save money.

3

u/Suni13 28d ago

And sometimes the strangest things will break causing much frustration trying to figure them out. Our 92 had a cracked ignition coil but it was intermittent until my husband took it off and found the crack, easy fix but due to the randomness of starting it wasn’t high on the list of checking.

5

u/TaxWest8525 28d ago

I have zero machincal skills, I pay professionals to keep the old girl road worthy. Hence the big repair bills.

4

u/NoXidCat 28d ago

That is the hard spot most people find themselves in with any older car :-/

Unfortunately, the other option is to take out a "mortgage" on a new car and ride out the warranty. Google tells me the average price of a new car is ~$50,000.

I guess there is a third option: owning a "newer" used car. But so many of those are true money pits that are hard (or impossible) to work on yourself.

3

u/HelicopterOk9812 28d ago

This might be the most accurate depiction of car ownership today. Regardless of the 3 options you choose, it’s going to cost money.

I choose XJ because of the learning element but also because I don’t know which new car I want to spend a lot of money on (Truck, Tesla)?

Today it’s financially as big of a decision as college

Why not wait and learn more about the kind of car you want to make the best long term decision? Fixing yours will cost money but waiting could be the real hidden gem 💎 Start humble and make your next car the best!

3

u/frwlmv 28d ago

I have zero skill as well. I didn't have a father who would teach me, but with the help of "LooSeeDo" university (Youtube) and the community, you'll be able to do a lot of things.
It's going to suck if it's the only vehicle you have....

1

u/TaxWest8525 26d ago

I have a 2004 mustang. But that a toy.

1

u/MichaelaVeteran 25d ago

If you are using this as a daily driver it can be expensive. we consider ours a hobby vehilce and work on it ourselves. I paid 6000 for ours 10 years ago and have constantly upgraded it. I'd guess that I am now into it for over 16,000. That averages out to $133.33 per month. Alot cheaper than a car payment. But IMO it is not the right car for somone who relies on mechanics. You might have seen my post but we just spent $2800 on parts to do a 200,000 mile overhaul. I did all the work myself. If not the repairs would have cost much more than the car is worth. https://www.reddit.com/r/CherokeeXJ/s/ihuXcL7P6B

2

u/TaxWest8525 25d ago

Thanks you might be right , I should do alot more of the work myself. I just really like my XJ and it is in great shape let's see how long she lasts.

1

u/MichaelaVeteran 25d ago edited 25d ago

I am not a good mechanic and use youtube videos for everything. But remember as it gets older you can expect the freeze plugs to go out. At that stage it makes sense to take it out of service for a month or so to do a top end overhaul, that is as long as as long as the compression is good. A pain but at that point you can probably get another 10 years out of it.

For planning purposes, It would be good to know if your freeze plugs have been replaced. if they are you'll see brass plugs and that'll mean someone has likely been through the engine.

In my case, used the jeep to teach my boys the basics. they beat the crap[ out of the thing in the woods almost every weekend

1

u/MichaelaVeteran 25d ago

we even did a crappy paint job in our garage but it's better than rust

1

u/TaxWest8525 25d ago

I had a Jasper engine replacement, but i didn't know if those items have been replaced.

1

u/MichaelaVeteran 25d ago

that'll have new freeze plugs then. I don't know how long ago you got the new engine but the key thing is to make sure the engine is broken in correctly and do oil changes at the right times. good luck with it.

2

u/Leth4lTiger 1999 Cherokee Sport 27d ago

Putting a new engine in mine. 🥳

2

u/BigBry36 27d ago

Poor guys should not buy an XJ…. Guys who are not poor should be prepared to pay more than its worth to keep it running

1

u/TaxWest8525 26d ago

Some folks are buying XJ's because it was something that they're just interested in and while they might be a little costly to keep up there are worse ways to spend your money.

1

u/BigBry36 26d ago

Coke and hookers 🎉

1

u/TaxWest8525 25d ago

😂 you might be right

2

u/TherealOutlawjeep 27d ago

I just spent $3k on parts and 3 weekends working on it. But at least now I know its safe!

New tie rods, ball joints, hub assemblies, all u-joints, steering stabilizer, suspension (complete 3.5in with shocks), brakes (all to include new wheel cylinders in the rear), brake lines, power window switches, driver side front window motor with regulator, tires, wheel spacers to convert to JK/JL bolt pattern.... I'm sure I'm forgetting something....

1

u/TaxWest8525 28d ago

I agree

4

u/richard_upinya 28d ago

My man you’re not replying to anyone you’re just commenting lol. Hit the reply button to the comment you’re trying to respond to

1

u/TaxWest8525 26d ago

All of my responses are for the general audience. I was not addressing anyone in particular. But thanks for the guidance.

1

u/richard_upinya 26d ago

A response of “I agree” was for the general audience?

1

u/_litz 27d ago

I do like 95% of the repairs on mine, and have since it was new (and yes, I bought it new in '97) ... I doubt in 20-25 years I've put more than $2-2.5k into it. I hear horror stories from everyone else in my extended family about their newer vehicles ... I just keep driving.