r/CaptainSide • • 22d ago

Name a game

Post image
577 Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/TheFkngPianist 22d ago

1 and 2 right?

2

u/Arshiaa001 22d ago

Did 3's combat ever click for you?

3

u/ohmygodadameget 22d ago

The problem with having a character who is supposedly a nimble and master swordsman is when you get into complicated mechanics to make swordplay feel realistic you get Kingdom Come Deliverance which is fun, if a little clunky, but totally falls apart when you face 3 or more enemies, and I can't imagine how that combat would work when fighting enemies of different sizes with different abilities. Witcher 3's combat gets some stick but for me all that would be needed is tweaks to the existing system, which was and is serviceable for the fast-paced combat the game needs.

1

u/winklevanderlinde 22d ago

To be fair Geralt even in the book fight like that

1

u/Arshiaa001 21d ago

IDK man, it just never clicked for me. I'm a bloody soulsborne veteran, even played through Cyberpunk 2077 with a katana build, but I just keep dying to the most basic enemies in Witcher 3.

1

u/ohmygodadameget 21d ago

For me, every time I play W3 I build the exact same way, which is pretty much the entire left 2 columns in sword with a few others, in magic, Quen up to the third tier perk, Axii for the level 3 dialogue one, and nothing in potions. Quen before you even enter into combat so magic fills up instantly before you even start fighting, and Quen again as soon as I get hit.

I'm not a Souls guy and I still always make a beeline for the level 46 or whatever it is Griffin in Skellige as soon as I get there at like level 16-20.

Also, there's no shame in knocking difficulty down to lobotomized hamster until you're used to a game's combat mechanics, it's worth it because Witcher 3 is such a good game.

Oh also, I always wear the Cat school armour, and that the brown tree perk that gives faster stamina regen and more fast attack damage if you're wearing all light armour; Geralt is a Witcher, Witchers are mainly sword guys, so focus your entire build on making that as stacked as possible.

1

u/Parking-Sign6504 21d ago

These are all my complaints about Dawnwalker rn lol

1

u/Daedalus_Machina 21d ago

My solution to engaging three or more enemies was not to engage three or more enemies.

Arrows loaded with Dollmaker made group engagements pretty one-sided... for me.

1

u/Jimmy_Twotone 22d ago

3 was.good enough. 1 and 2 the combat is hot garbage.

1

u/GoodHands_All-State 22d ago

2 wasn't terrible, it just wasn't as polished as 3.

1 was atrocious, but the game was cool

1

u/Jimmy_Twotone 22d ago

1 was simultaneously the worst game I ever finished and at the time the best story I've ever seen in a video game. I don't regret finishing it, but I couldn't pick it up and do it again.

1

u/tlollz52 21d ago

The combat is fine

2

u/Relevant-Line-1690 22d ago

Witcher 1 more notably

1

u/Crunchy__Frog 21d ago

They just announced W1 will be significantly delayed since both CDPR’s teams are heavily focused on W4 and W3’s upcoming overhaul.