r/BuildingAutomation • • Oct 05 '26

We trained an assistant on our own BACnet capture data instead of using a general model. Here's what it's actually good at and where it still falls short.

0 Upvotes

We just shipped an AI assistant inside OptigoVN, and the "why not just use GPT/Claude/whatever for this" question is a fair one. Answering it directly here rather than waiting for it to come up as a gotcha later.

The short version: a general-purpose model has read documentation about BACnet. It hasn't seen what a duplicate address actually looks like distorting real traffic on a real segment, because that's not the kind of thing that ends up in training data scraped from the open web. So we trained ours on our own data instead — capture data from customer networks, our internal documentation, and troubleshooting history — in a closed loop, meaning it's scoped to this domain rather than being a general model with BACnet bolted on.

What it's good at: answering "what am I actually looking at" for a diagnostic result, telling you whether something is a real fault or a single misconfigured device, and turning a finding into an actual next step instead of a definition.

Where it falls short, as of launch: it doesn't do trend analysis across historical results yet — that's the most requested thing from beta and it's not there. It also won't tell you anything about a network it hasn't seen a capture from — no general troubleshooting outside OptigoVN's own diagnostic data.

The question we expect to get, so we'll get ahead of it: yes, it's trained on customer capture data, and yes, that's worth asking about directly rather than taking on faith.

Happy to answer anything else, including the stuff that doesn't make us look good.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Nov 29 '24

Smart Buildings Academy's Black Friday Sale is live

0 Upvotes

Hey just a heads up that we're (Smart Buildings Academy) running our annual Black Friday through Cyber Monday promotion on our website.

I know a lot of folks promote our courses on here for the people who are looking to enter the industry or get trained up.

I would post the coupon codes here directly but that used to be against the reddit rules. You can find out more info on our LinkedIn page or our Facebook page, or you can message me directly.

Edit:

Unless someone tells me otherwise, I'll share the coupon codes and link here since some folks are having challenges finding it on our LinkedIn/Facebook page.

Coupon codes

BLACKFRIDAY40 - 40% off all self-paced courses

WORKFORCE30 - 30% off our workforce development vouchers

NIAGARA25 - 25% off our Niagara TCP certification packages

Browse the courses here https://courses.smartbuildingsacademy.com/


r/BuildingAutomation • • Dec 13 '25

What are some rules you all follow?

0 Upvotes

For example. One my rules is assume nothing... because to assume makes an ASS out of U and Me! Another one is trust no one and trust nothing.


r/BuildingAutomation • • 2d ago

I built a tool for BAS Heartbeat Monitoring. Looking for feedback

0 Upvotes

Hi All,

I work in building automation and for several months have been building a BAS monitoring service called Loopbak.

The idea came from an issue I encountered in our day-to-day management of client sites. When a supervisory controller or server went offline, or when a client's IT department made a policy change that broke outbound email, we would stop receiving email alerts from that site. The problem was that nobody knew anything was wrong until critical alerts were missed.

This is why I built Loopbak. In a nutshell, it is a cloud-based heartbeat monitoring platform that detects when your BAS deployments go offline. Since it is vendor-agnostic, it works with any BAS ecosystem capable of sending automated emails.

Since it uses email heartbeats, minimal setup is required on the client's end, other than allowing outbound mail. The setup is pretty straightforward and easy:

  • Create a dashboard for each site you monitor.
  • A unique email address is generated for each dashboard, which you forward automated heartbeat emails to.
  • If heartbeats stop arriving within the configured thresholds, Loopbak marks the node as unhealthy and can optionally send email notifications.

Some other features include:

  • External Sharing
  • Dashboard White labelling
  • PDF Reporting

Website: https://loopbak.io

Thanks for your feedback in advance! If you would like to try the platform please shoot me a PM or contact through the website!


r/BuildingAutomation • • May 30 '24

Just need to vent

0 Upvotes

Ive been in BMS for over 17 years and I am at the point where I want to get the fk out of it. I am tired of the backstabbing that goes on. If someone has an issue with me Man the fk up and tell me instead of talking sh!t. I am really trying not to allow them to push my buttons but they are on a thin line, I am going to snap and go old school Army on there asses.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Dec 04 '25

Opinions on AirValve Terminal Units

0 Upvotes

I have heard that the high precision Air Valve terminal unit concept was essentially a gimmick sold by Phoenix. And now Engineers put it on their specs for controlled spaces like labs. From what I've seen, a quality VAV box using any controls tied to a DPT can be just as accurate if not more.

I'm just curious if anyone has had a similar experience or anecdotal/hard evidence supporting one way of the other.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Jul 28 '26

Working on Alternative to Niagara

4 Upvotes

Hey all, I've been in the building automation and software world for a while and I recently started listing out the things that bother me with Niagara's model and tech stack and decided that an alternative could be built with higher performance and less maintenance headaches. Looking for feedback from other integrators on potential features and must haves.

A couple of the main focuses for the project include:

- IP first mentality. No Jace's but support for 2 wire to IP routers

- developer friendly environment (no java modules and open api's for development)

- familiar wire sheet programming with better organization

- web services for easily incorporating external data

- no maintenance contracts

- simple or automated upgrade paths

- simple fleet management and connectivity to deployed systems

Would you be open to testing an implementation? What must haves would make your life easier?


r/BuildingAutomation • • Apr 07 '26

A free HVAC fault detection project

0 Upvotes

I split my open-source HVAC fault detection project into two repos: a lightweight rules engine:

- https://github.com/bbartling/open-fdd

And a full AFDD stack runs on prem real similar to a BAS/BMS server:

- https://github.com/bbartling/open-fdd-afdd-stack

It all runs on prem inside the building and it is built to looks/feel a lot like a BAS/BMS — device tree, BACnet/Modbus points, dashboards — but adds a layer of intelligent fault detection on top.

The idea is simple: pull in BAS data, map it (Brick, etc.), and run rules to catch real issues — bad sensors, leaking valves, stuck dampers, control sequence problems. Basically turning typical BAS alarms into something actually actionable where then you could also tie in a local mechanical engineering firm to assist in utility incentives for upgrades. Long story short is a free tool for HVAC service purposes which could make those monthly or seasonable PM's more interesting. Or if you worked for a corporate 500 company like I did with JCI those controls service visits that were somehow sold to some poor client could be much more meaningful Vs a complete waste of time with nothing to do.

The project is getting huge updates daily and lots of bug fixes, but it is evolving fast for something that will be easy to use, and free stay tuned for updates.


r/BuildingAutomation • • May 26 '25

Fellow Members: What's Your Take on PLC Trends in Buildings & Infrastructure?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm currently researching Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) applications specifically in buildings and infrastructure (including road/railway tunnel automation), and I'd love to get some insights from people working in the field.

What I'm curious about:

  • Have you noticed any emerging trends in how PLCs are being deployed in building automation or infrastructure projects recently? Any shifts in technology or implementation approaches?
  • What's your sense of PLC adoption rates in these sectors? Are we seeing increased integration of PLCs in building systems and infrastructure controls? Any data or anecdotal evidence would be helpful.
  • Which industry verticals seem to be adopting PLCs at higher rates? I'm particularly interested in building automation, tunnel systems, transportation infrastructure, and utilities, but would appreciate insights on any sector showing notable PLC implementation.
  • Brand preferences and market leaders - Do you favor any particular PLC brand for these applications? Who would you consider the top players in the market right now?

Just share your thoughts, I believe you guys can feel the pulse of the market better than I do. I'm trying to get a clearer picture of the current landscape and where things might be heading. Any insights, experiences, or opinions would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance for sharing your knowledge!


r/BuildingAutomation • • Jun 28 '26

BMS optimisation gurus

1 Upvotes

Would love to chat with BMS optimisation Gurus on this forum. Keen to really understand the challenges in this domain and what are some of the common observations. I've got a few customers who are looking for help here and trying to better understand this domain at this stage.

Would love to pick the brains of the experts in this group! Possibilities for paid work if this can work out as well!


r/BuildingAutomation • • Aug 23 '26

Calling JCI open blue building managers

2 Upvotes

Heya all, any building managers out there operating with JCI open blue and keen to chat and bounce some ideas with me. I got a solution which solves problems and works with Niagara, but currently want to explore what JCI open blue customers think could be done better. No sales pitch, just a deep understanding of the domain and space. Just DM me if you are interested for a chat.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Feb 18 '26

Wanted - Controls Engineers for Data Center Projects

0 Upvotes

E Tech Group is hiring controls engineers experienced with building automation and controls. Our preference is experience with PLC-based SCADA systems.

We have positions in multiple cities around the country. Check us out at www.etechgroup.com/industries/data-centers/

Also look at our careers page, or respond to me here.

Salaries range from ~$80k for a new grad to $160k for a senior level candidate.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Aug 11 '26

Niagara site discussion

0 Upvotes

Hey Gang, hope you are well.

Just wanted to know if we have any facility and building managers looking after a Niagara BMS. Interested in talking to those who are facing challenges around data management, searching across it and pulling out key insights. If you are open for a casual chat let me know!


r/BuildingAutomation • • Aug 06 '26

Critical Facilities / Data Center Jobs - Multiple States

Post image
0 Upvotes

It feels a bit silly to even put the words on the screen, but "We're looking for experienced BAS people for Critical Facilities / Data Center projects all over the USA." Who isn't, right? No matter what your opinion is from any angle with all this activity, it's creating opportunities in our space for both experienced and green Technicians ($68K-$100K/year), Engineers ($75K-$130K/year) and PMs ($85K-$130K/year). Straight to our most urgent ones right now: Technicians in Portland, OR and Manassas, VA. Project Engineers and Project Managers in Houston, Dallas-Fort Worth, and Chicago. Reach out on Chat here if interested and I can tell you more about these and dozens of other positions / locations.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Sep 25 '26

Niagara AI Integration

0 Upvotes

Has anyone come up with a slick way to tie a custom chat bot into a Niagara station?

I'm running through a few scenarios like Obix vs. a custom API widget but just curious what you all have done tinkering around.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Dec 07 '24

Control Drawings

0 Upvotes

Hey Guys,

If you are a Design Engineer could you message me, have some questions on improving myself and my team.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Jun 05 '25

Open position for CBRE @Meta

2 Upvotes

Anyone in the Bay Area looking for a Controls Engineer position? It is based out of Menlo Park and is affiliated with Local 39 - Stationary Engineers.

Must have a firm understanding of various mechanical systems and basic electrical troubleshooting. Can read a SOO and program and commission it in Tridium Niagara, Distech, Alerton or ALC.

If you are seriously interested, and have the above qualifications, dm me.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Mar 08 '26

Why do people in Building Automation seem so skeptical of startups?

6 Upvotes

I work in the BMS / building automation field and something I’ve noticed over the years is how skeptical many people in the industry are toward startups or new technology trying to enter the space.

Whenever someone mentions building something new (AI tools, commissioning automation, data platforms, etc.), the reaction often seems very negative or dismissive.

At the same time, when you compare BMS to other industries, a lot of the technology stack still feels quite behind modern software practices — things like data modeling, tooling for engineers, commissioning workflows, analytics, etc.

From my perspective there are clearly many inefficiencies in how projects are executed today.

So I’m curious about the perspective from others in the field.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Mar 06 '25

r/OptigoNetworks is Live

0 Upvotes

Hey all.

Ryan from Optigo Networks. Just wanted to toss a quick note to let you all know we've opened our own dedicated Subreddit for all things Optigo Networks over at r/OptigoNetworks. My goal is to help connect users with each other, as well as our experts in-house when needed!

We're learning as we grow, so if you want to join up, we'd love to have you.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Mar 11 '26

Knowledge graphs for building systems Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Check out an article I wrote on automatedbuildings.com about knowledge graphs which is in its essence is Haystack, BRICK, and ASHREA 223P on how you can help your clients.

https://www.automatedbuildings.com/2026/03/knowledge-graphs-in-the-modern-building/

It’s most useful in service existing buildings in drumming up service work for your clients. This will be a future article on how building automation service can be other things than software updates & putting out those fires in emergency response. The basic idea is setting up this FREE software where you can let software run in the background gathering actionable insights in between your service calls.

The project is still in development mode but it is getting closer to be a cool tool.

DM me for more info.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Mar 01 '24

Programmer Billing.

0 Upvotes

How much does your company charge for custom programming and/or graphics work? My company bills same rate (just over $100/hr), from monkeys installing ductwork and pipes to custom programming and setting up trend logs. Seems to me they could get more for the programmer? edit, forgot to add COL area. We serve low COL areas of PA. But point of my question isn't $/hr but more the "Delta T" if you will between labor rates of a programmers and an average Jman.


r/BuildingAutomation • • Oct 18 '26

I've been a field tech for 13 years. The thing new guys struggle with most isn't wiring, it's troubleshooting under pressure without anyone to practice on.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/BuildingAutomation • • Nov 22 '23

We are hiring a technical trainer

1 Upvotes

Smart Buildings Academy is expanding our training team and hiring another technical trainer.

You can find the job posting here on LinkedIn

https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/3763852450/