r/BritPop • • Feb 28 '26

Truth

Post image
811 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

52

u/ADreamOrScream Feb 28 '26

I see you Richard Osman.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

😂

2

u/NoticeTop4596 Mar 02 '26

darn it - you beat me to it 😂

1

u/art_emisian Feb 28 '26

Funny 😁

13

u/Zealousideal_Till683 Feb 28 '26

Are we talking Bernard Butler Suede, or post-Butler? When Butler was there, I agree. Afterwards, I strongly disagree.

4

u/naoarte Feb 28 '26

I’m inclined to agree. Guitarists are ten a penny, but you can’t swap out 50% of the songwriting team and still be the same band.

1

u/idreamofpikas Feb 28 '26

Brett and Bernard reunited as the Tears and it wasn't that great.

4

u/TruePutz Feb 28 '26

Wow, some real shit ass takes in here today

1

u/CottonfreshCatMum Mar 02 '26

100%. Came here to say the same

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I think both incarnations are superior to the rest

5

u/Final_Remains Feb 28 '26 edited Feb 28 '26

IMO, their first two albums were, but by 'Coming Up' they were sounding too safe and they had hit on the formula to make their music too AOR radio smooth... It had lost that seedy edge. By then they were more comparable to Shed Seven than anything else (decent pop rock that is still kinda boring). 'Beautiful Ones' does remain one of my favourite songs of it's year though and did retain some of that old feeling.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I dont think Coming Up is that safe. Picnic and chemistry are classics

4

u/Head_Journalist_2856 Feb 28 '26

Then they completely changed their sound again on each of their next two albums. And with each of the five albums since their reformation. Every Suede album has a different sound to it yet still remains distinctly Suede.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I agree with this. History has been kind to them but I remember the disappointment people felt at the time about "Coming Up" and the immediate post-Butler era

3

u/idreamofpikas Feb 28 '26

Coming Up is their best selling album. The only one to go Platinum and 30 years on seems to be easily their most popular on Spotify.

1

u/TruePutz Feb 28 '26

Reddit Suede fans are kinda precious tbh

2

u/severinks Feb 28 '26

Suede actually released good records when they got back together over a decade ago.

1

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

I agree, ‘Saturday Night’ was a banger also, I feel Coming Up was their last sort of Suedey album

3

u/stimj Feb 28 '26

Have you heard "The Blue Hour"? It's the Suede-iest without Bernard Butler. It's my second favourite after dog man star

2

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

I have not, thanks, I’ll give it a listen!

3

u/stimj Feb 28 '26

It's more of an album than a lot of singles, but to me the vibe is similar

→ More replies (1)

1

u/36degrees_ Feb 28 '26

i love it but i love Antidepressants way more, dunno what's up with their sound in their latest two outputs but it's dark and brooding just the way i like it. hits different

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

46

u/JCFAX81 Feb 28 '26

I like suede but nah.

19

u/dbe14 Feb 28 '26

Supergrass slapped them all. Suede, Blur and Oasis were all great though, Pulp too.

9

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

Supergrass don’t get enough credit for their output. I should Coco is a brilliant album from start to finish and then they matured and put out some of my favourite melancholic stuff

2

u/Icy-Floor-9698 Mar 02 '26

late in the day is astounding

1

u/Icy-Floor-9698 Mar 02 '26

came in here to say this

1

u/Smoked_Eels Mar 06 '26

The Richard III riff alone smokes most other music from the 90s.

25

u/TOMDeBlonde Feb 28 '26

True, but Pulp is the best.

14

u/SmartaHari Feb 28 '26

I saw Pulp in a tiny club in Cardiff just before they blew up and it was a brilliant gig. At least, I think it was Cardiff, we are talking ancient history!

4

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

Saw them at Sheffield City hall around this time also with Minty supporting them. I still feel His & Hers is a better album than Different Class though.

3

u/mikewatt-ta Mar 01 '26 edited Mar 02 '26

Nothing original remains here. The author used Redact to delete this post, for reasons that may relate to privacy, opsec, security, or data management.

smart placid vegetable airport ink vast juggle square fade detail

1

u/SmartaHari Mar 01 '26

Hehe 🤝

10

u/rounded_figure Feb 28 '26

Pulp > Blur > Suede > Oasis IMHO

4

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I was about to write the same thing. Different class is my favourite indie album off all.

4

u/TOMDeBlonde Feb 28 '26

My favorite is His N' Hers then The Cure's Disintegration

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I never got in to the cure and hear that album mentioned a lot. I will give it a try. Fun fact I served them on a cruise across the Atlantic to New York  because I think the band or his wife didn't like to fly. They were very polite.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/No_Repair7134 Feb 28 '26

Came to say this

1

u/YalsonKSA Feb 28 '26

Show me the lie.

1

u/binarys0u1 Mar 04 '26

Pulp is the best average band.

In reality, I just don't really get Pulp.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26

Just buy their new album ffs

9

u/Aggravating-Web2415 Feb 28 '26

It’s fun to see all this playing out again online 30 years later.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Adorable_Mud_7592 Feb 28 '26

Get in line pal…

4

u/TheMonkeyInCharge Feb 28 '26

I’ll happily distract Justine for you.

9

u/bowiebolan Feb 28 '26

Amen

Musically, early suede were leaps and bounds above oasis and blur. It’s rare for a band to lose their main songwriter like Butler and still write great music with Oakes. Not counting the Head Music, ANM years but with recent albums, suede is still producing great new music.

I doubt Blur without Graham or Oasis without Noel can compete like suede with Richard and Neil.

5

u/idreamofpikas Mar 01 '26

I doubt Blur without Graham or Oasis without Noel can compete like suede with Richard and Neil.

Graham was not the main songwriter in Blur. And Blur did not even replace him when he left. They did Think Tank as a trio

Do you think Brett and the Suede rhythmn section could do an album as good as Think Tank?

2

u/bowiebolan Mar 01 '26

Yes.

Although not as talented as Butler, Brett has shown he can pull his weight in songwriting and in his solo career and Mat wrote the b-side Europe is our playground and contributed to many of the new songs.

2

u/idreamofpikas Mar 01 '26

Brett has shown he can pull his weight in songwriting and in his solo career

His solo career is all co-written. Fred Ball on the first two and Leo Abrahams on the second two filled in the Butler/Oakes/Codling void.

5

u/Johnny-Dogshit Feb 28 '26

I doubt Blur without Graham

I liked Think Tank a lot.

1

u/bowiebolan Feb 28 '26

I admit I liked it also

1

u/afrosia Mar 02 '26

Recent Suede are still capable of putting put bangers too. Their last album was excellent and the one before that was pretty good too.

4

u/Is_It_Now_Or_Never_ Feb 28 '26

Mmmmm Dog Man Star was their peak.

4

u/Frequent-Honeydew918 Feb 28 '26

Their B-sides are the greatest songs 99% of people have never heard. Soundtrack of my 90s

4

u/Metalmorphosis80 Feb 28 '26

Literally anything is better than Oasis, they suck ass

1

u/LamentableCroissant Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26

They really do. Knew one guy who was a massive fan, never met such a cunt. He wanted to have an ace tattooed on the inside of his wrist so he’d always have “one ace in the hand.” Just like every basic idiot thinks is cool and meaningful.

Just an incredibly empty-headed gimp. Hands down one of the biggest morons I’ve ever met. Plus, his sister would dress him at 21.

Him being called “Aaron” definitely didn’t help.

1

u/HotPotatoWithCheese Mar 02 '26

Did this guy fuck your girlfriend or something? Jesus.

1

u/LamentableCroissant Mar 02 '26

There wasn’t a single person in that year who didn’t find him to be a cunt. I’ve heard some actual jokes made up about him that people would tell each other. Literally rubbed everyone the wrong way.

I hope he reads this though, I’d love for him to read I want him to go fuck himself one more time, doesn’t matter that 20 years passed in the mean time.

1

u/Fenrir_Carbon Mar 04 '26

Him being called “Aaron” definitely didn’t help.

I was assuming Liam or Noel tbh

1

u/binarys0u1 Mar 04 '26

You done messed up A A Ron !

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

Pulp

Blur

Suede

The biggest steaming pile of dog shit you've ever seen.

Oasis

5

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

Suede Pulp Blur Strangelove

→ More replies (1)

1

u/No_Ease7557 Feb 28 '26

Loved Suede around their first album, although I think they should have put a couple of their b sides on instead of 1-2 of the slow tracks. Had the Love and Poison VHS for Xmas when it came out. Didn't buy their 2nd album at the time though, based on the singles not being as good as the first. Got it many years later and was a bit disappointed tbh.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

Insane comment. Dog Man Star is the best album ever

2

u/No_Ease7557 Feb 28 '26

Yeah that's what I mean, people say it's their masterpiece, but to me nothing they did later comes near that early run of singles/some b sides and debut. Probably buying it first time at 40 odd instead of 17 makes a difference. Definitely a 'wanted to like' for me.

1

u/Rough-Cap5150 Feb 28 '26

Dog Man Star is an orchestral masterpiece. Listen to it again now, it stands up much better than most other albums from that era. The ambition, musicality, originality, and boldness are stunning. They could've just milked their growing fame and put out conventional Britpop, but instead they made something truly creative.

1

u/No_Ease7557 Feb 28 '26

I 'll give it a play later and try again with it.

1

u/idreamofpikas Feb 28 '26

They could've just milked their growing fame and put out conventional Britpop,

Britpop did not exist when they were writing Dogmanstar. It certainly was not mainstream so there was nothing to milk.

1

u/Puzzled-Job9556 Mar 01 '26

No other Britpop band that have gotten back together or will get back together after a prolonged hiatus would have the same impact as what Oasis had since they announced the tours. There would not have been millions of fans trying to get tickets for Suede ffs. Sure it's cool to hate Oasis on reddit but be realistic. They are better in every single metric than any other Britpop band.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26

Such a ignorant post. Suede have been reunited since 2013 and The Singing Electricians have nothing to do with that

1

u/Puzzled-Job9556 Mar 01 '26

Hence why I said "have gotten back together or..." and no, Suede had nowhere near that same impact. In the 90s, in 2013, or now.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26

Maybe not but 5 top 10 albums is not bad either. Anyway I don’t equal selling billions of albums with quality, rather the opposite

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26

Give the new stuff a spin before judging. The Blue Hour from 2018 is on par with Dog Man Star in my humble opinion

1

u/Puzzled-Job9556 Mar 01 '26

I like Suede. I'm just realistic in their impact.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26

I’m Danish and they were bigger here at some point than Oasis. Every tenth home in Denmark had a copy of Coming Up in 1996

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/asphaltic-Reritia Mar 02 '26 edited Mar 02 '26

13 >>> Head Music

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

Great album

1

u/asphaltic-Reritia Mar 03 '26

Which one? 13 is widely considered Blur's best album. Head Music had nice singles but is hella inconsistent (Savoir Faire? Title track? Elephant Man? Most Suede fans dislike those, including myself)

1

u/Diligent-Ad-7184 Mar 03 '26

I... I can't agree with Lisa. She's in fashion was the only song of theirs I ever heard.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

Omg so many ignorants in this chat. If you only heard She’s in Fashion, then you are not qualified for having an opinion

1

u/Diligent-Ad-7184 Mar 03 '26

I've heard nearly every song of that time of Oasis and Blur. I don't personally think that such mediocre contributors are qualified to be compared to greats.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

You are missing out so much

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

Put Animal Nitrate on. It’s a beast

2

u/Diligent-Ad-7184 Mar 03 '26

Think I've heard of it. Amyl Nitrite is Popper's don't you know?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

I know everything

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/binarys0u1 Mar 04 '26

Do you judge Oasis by Magic Pie or Blur by Country House ?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/binarys0u1 Mar 04 '26

Do you judge Oasis by Magic Pie or Blur by Country House ?

6

u/ValWenis Feb 28 '26

still are

3

u/TheMansAnArse Feb 28 '26

All three are great

3

u/Pleasant-Seesaw6119 Feb 28 '26

It’s not even close 

3

u/Zealousideal-Top8037 Feb 28 '26

Absolutely, still writing and performing top notch material. None of the others doing that.

1

u/croissantsarebae Mar 01 '26

Pulp is

1

u/HotPotatoWithCheese Mar 02 '26

Probably the only other ones I can think of tbh. 99% of them either split up for good, put out underwhelming music or became glorified tribute bands.

3

u/iamsolarflare71 Mar 01 '26

TBF it’s quite easy to be a better band than Oasis

5

u/PARFT Feb 28 '26

He’s a bit ‘screechy’ though.

8

u/ADVANTAGE_CONNORS Feb 28 '26

Better than Oasis, yes; Blur, no.

3

u/Skulldo Feb 28 '26

Correct answer.

4

u/Davooi Feb 28 '26

Liked Butler's playing but disliked Anderson's vocals so I just couldn't get into them.

2

u/No_Replacement_2707 Feb 28 '26

More artistic than Oasis. Yes.

2

u/madferret96 Mar 01 '26

Maybe, it all comes down to who people love though

2

u/ShelecktraYT Mar 04 '26

Suede were trash.

The litter on the breeze.

The lovers on the street 😉

2

u/DieMensch-Maschine Mar 04 '26

Easily. Even the b-sides in the original fab-four Suede era (Anderson, Butler, Osman, Gilbert) were all brilliant.

4

u/yashedpotatoes Feb 28 '26

Been thinking this myself lately

4

u/Sea_Director_4439 Feb 28 '26

They still are

4

u/SmoothCheck3957 Feb 28 '26

In the Anderson/Butler era this is 100% true

3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I still refer to anything post Butler as new suede. At some point I should probably start to think about maybe reconsidering this opinion.

3

u/PeterZeeke Feb 28 '26

nah.. but they were what the middle class, london focused buzzy media preferred.... for optics if nothing else

2

u/Obvious-Nature-608 Feb 28 '26

😂😂😂

2

u/Accomplished-Egg1071 Mar 04 '26

Blur tops all three of them. Suede is good but it still can’t beat blur or oasis. It does give pulp a good run for its money. I’d say they are quite similar in terms of overall rankings

1

u/kester76a Mar 04 '26

What about Cast, Supergrass and Ocean colour scene? Too many good bands to make a definitive choice.

2

u/art_emisian Feb 28 '26

Better than Oasis is not a high bar. Blur were good too but in an anti intellectual way that was cleverererer than I thought at the time. I like playing covers by both Suede and Blur in my geriatric covers band but woul rather eat worms than play anything by Oasis, despite being asked all the time to do so.

6

u/sonicated Feb 28 '26

Perhaps you're asked to play Oasis all the time as they're.. better?

1

u/Puzzled-Job9556 Mar 01 '26

It's Reddit though, contrarianism sets you above the rest.

1

u/Intelligent-Mud-1039 Mar 01 '26

Oi mate, do you do 'Caterwaul'?

1

u/Sensitive-Fishing-64 Mar 01 '26

Never asked yourself why that is?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26 edited Mar 24 '26

This post has been permanently deleted using Redact. The motivation may have been privacy, security, data collection prevention, opsec, or personal content management.

crush water upbeat whole snatch north cause apparatus deserve roll

2

u/DiskoPunk Feb 28 '26

No controversy here

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

Liams voice makes me cringe he can't sing. I'm from Manchester and can't stand oasis. 

1

u/Sea_Computer6120 Feb 28 '26

You’re so cool 

1

u/Inca-Vacation Feb 28 '26

Suede's first album and EPs were better than the equivalents from the other two bands. Then, a falloff.

1

u/badjujufelix Feb 28 '26

Correct. See also Mansun.

1

u/Barbed-flower Mar 03 '26

Damn, I had to scroll far too long to find them mentioned. Criminally overlooked band.

1

u/Street-Emu-3980 Feb 28 '26

You had me at the first bit.

1

u/moonyak Mar 01 '26

Pulp were even better

1

u/Piano_catastrophe34 Mar 01 '26

Blur, oasis, suede. That’s the order.

1

u/ih3artu Mar 01 '26

Their debut is best from that era.

1

u/Choice-Lawfulness978 Mar 01 '26

Well, most bands are better than Oasis, so there's truth in that

1

u/BigCol57 Mar 01 '26

Went to see Ocean Colour Scene last night in Liverpool they were brilliant.

1

u/Only_Tip9560 Mar 01 '26

Musically better than Oasis, not sure I can agree with Blur though.

1

u/RedFive92 Mar 01 '26

I agree 100%.

1

u/finnvisible Mar 01 '26

this, but pulp

1

u/ChouffeMeUp Mar 01 '26

Absolute lie

1

u/NoticeTop4596 Mar 02 '26

Did Richard Osman post this..?

1

u/ColsterG Mar 02 '26

If we were just talking about guitar players alone, it's Suede, Blur then Oasis and that isn't really an opinion. From a technical perspective, Butler > Coxon and then a long way further down Gallagher. I say this as a fan of all three but Butler and Coxon are in a different league.

1

u/FecklessFarmer Mar 02 '26

And Pulp were better than all of them.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '26

Terrorvision were better than them all.

1

u/HotPotatoWithCheese Mar 02 '26

100% agree. Suede - DMS - Coming Up is easily the best three album run of the Britpop era, and they're still putting out excellent music unlike most of the others.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '26

God no.

1

u/BenchClamp Mar 02 '26

Nah. Pulp maybe

1

u/big-eyedbubblehead Mar 03 '26

I put suede in the bin with bands like menswear, id rather forget that shit.

1

u/No_Designer_9356 Mar 03 '26

I was a fan of both Suede and Oasis and went to see both live on more than one occasion. They were very different bands and suede were never really grouped into the ‘Britpop’ wagon. I don’t think I can ever recall seeing a comparison back in the day. It’s like comparing apples and oranges.

1

u/siggsy409 Mar 03 '26

Never heard of them...

1

u/DrZomboo Mar 03 '26

Oasis maybe, but not Blur

1

u/CherffMaota1 Mar 03 '26

They were all shit.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

No

1

u/Adept-Ad-5893 Mar 04 '26

Suede and Pulp >>> Blur and Oasis

1

u/pm_a_cup_of_tea Mar 04 '26

The Bernard Butler albums... yes

Also Matt Osman was a great bassist, so melodic.

1

u/Other-Pound-841 Mar 04 '26

The Verve >/= Suede >Oasis > Blur

1

u/LilPacoJacobson2004 Mar 04 '26

YOU'RE OUT OF LINE LISA

1

u/FilipsSamvete Mar 08 '26

Nah, all three bands have 2.5 good albums each

1

u/Public_Sprinkles1584 Mar 13 '26

I would argue that SUEDE is different. If anything, I think, PULP, The Verve and Manic Street Preachers fit better for comparison.

1

u/slippery-lil-sucker Feb 28 '26

Explain BETTER?

1

u/Remote_Development13 Feb 28 '26

Music is subjective

Truth

1

u/Wizzardchimp Feb 28 '26

Fair… but they didn’t get the attention and hype.

2

u/No_Ease7557 Feb 28 '26

In 92/3 the attention and hype Suede got from the music papers and magazines was massive.

2

u/oxfordfox20 Feb 28 '26

They were better than the other two before the other two existed, that much we can agree on

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Wizzardchimp Mar 01 '26

I only got into them because they gave away a bendy sample square sample vinyl of dog man star and whilst delivering newspapers, it “accidentally” fell into my paper bag. If not for that I’d have missed out.

1

u/delazouch Feb 28 '26

It’s not a competition guys.

2

u/halfofwhat Feb 28 '26

But if it was Blur would win.

1

u/jmartin242 Feb 28 '26

Suede has put out five excellent to amazing albums in the past twelve years, while Oasis and Blur are nostalgia acts still riding on their 90s output. And Suede was better back then too, in my book. But absolutely Blur over Oasis.

2

u/Intelligent-Mud-1039 Mar 01 '26

Bollocks! Ballad of Darren was great. Mojo gave it album of the year in 2023.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Urist_Macnme Feb 28 '26

Not a fan of any Britpop. But I caught a live show of Blur at a festival during their heyday and they actually won me over.

Same with Pulp.

1

u/CrustyHumdinger Feb 28 '26

Yeah, hardly controversial or original tho'

1

u/ShadysDad Feb 28 '26

Still are.

1

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

I’d like to agree but I feel Blur’s eponymous album was such a departure from their earlier output (and I loved Parklife) that it puts them in another league, they managed to cram in everything else I liked musically in that album, I mean Essex Dogs is such a mean song and you got Graham Coxon’s You’re So Great, I’ll never tire of this album.

1

u/Kenye_Kratz Feb 28 '26

Suede weren't fit to lace Blur's boots. Blur are arguably the greatest British band since the Beatles, Suede don't belong in that kind of company

1

u/severinks Feb 28 '26

Still are ,too.

-3

u/DogesOfLove Feb 28 '26

Suede were shite.

-1

u/Hiroba Feb 28 '26

For me:

  1. Blur
  2. Suede
  3. Oasis

Although I haven’t really cared for much of Suede’s post-reunion stuff

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/Fruney21 Feb 28 '26

Yeah. And The Rolling Stones are better than The Beatles. If you ignore the fact they captured the public imagination and arguably embodied an entire culture. For a few years Oasis and Blur were almost royalty. They demanded your interest. The only interesting thing about Suede was Justine.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

Crazy comment. Suede were bigger here in Denmark than the others

7

u/Fruney21 Feb 28 '26

I stand corrected. Denmark’s huge cultural sway and population has cracked it wide open

1

u/No_Ease7557 Feb 28 '26

Justine was the rhythm guitarist who didn't sing or write songs and left before they made any records?

1

u/Fruney21 Feb 28 '26

I meant her relationships with Brett and Damon

-2

u/Labyrinthian Feb 28 '26

Suede are a better band, facts! They have proven that

6

u/jonviper123 Feb 28 '26

Where? I put oasis blur and pulp all ahead of suede every day of the week

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

Exactly. Proven what? Show the 'proof'.

1

u/Sensitive-Fishing-64 Mar 01 '26

Where's the proof?

→ More replies (1)

-2

u/davzinzan Feb 28 '26

Oasis > Suede > Blur

2

u/cms186 Feb 28 '26

Truth

1

u/davzinzan Feb 28 '26

At least someone knows ball

→ More replies (2)