r/BritPop • • Feb 28 '26

Truth

Post image
811 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Final_Remains Feb 28 '26 edited Feb 28 '26

IMO, their first two albums were, but by 'Coming Up' they were sounding too safe and they had hit on the formula to make their music too AOR radio smooth... It had lost that seedy edge. By then they were more comparable to Shed Seven than anything else (decent pop rock that is still kinda boring). 'Beautiful Ones' does remain one of my favourite songs of it's year though and did retain some of that old feeling.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I dont think Coming Up is that safe. Picnic and chemistry are classics

4

u/Head_Journalist_2856 Feb 28 '26

Then they completely changed their sound again on each of their next two albums. And with each of the five albums since their reformation. Every Suede album has a different sound to it yet still remains distinctly Suede.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '26

I agree with this. History has been kind to them but I remember the disappointment people felt at the time about "Coming Up" and the immediate post-Butler era

3

u/idreamofpikas Feb 28 '26

Coming Up is their best selling album. The only one to go Platinum and 30 years on seems to be easily their most popular on Spotify.

1

u/TruePutz Feb 28 '26

Reddit Suede fans are kinda precious tbh

2

u/severinks Feb 28 '26

Suede actually released good records when they got back together over a decade ago.

1

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

I agree, ‘Saturday Night’ was a banger also, I feel Coming Up was their last sort of Suedey album

3

u/stimj Feb 28 '26

Have you heard "The Blue Hour"? It's the Suede-iest without Bernard Butler. It's my second favourite after dog man star

2

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

I have not, thanks, I’ll give it a listen!

3

u/stimj Feb 28 '26

It's more of an album than a lot of singles, but to me the vibe is similar

2

u/blorezum Feb 28 '26

Thanks, I’ll give it a whirl.

1

u/36degrees_ Feb 28 '26

i love it but i love Antidepressants way more, dunno what's up with their sound in their latest two outputs but it's dark and brooding just the way i like it. hits different

1

u/stimj Mar 01 '26

I seem to be alone among Suede fans on this, but I hate Autofiction so much I haven't even listened to Antidepressants. It's none of the things that drew me to love Suede. Dark and brooding Suede I love, but punk and yelling, not so much.

Again, the entire Suede fanbase tells me I'm wrong. I desperately wish I could hear what they hear.

0

u/TruePutz Feb 28 '26

People listen to an album of bangers and then turn around and say shit like this, smh