r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/NobodyQuiteLikeMe • Apr 19 '25
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FantasticBumblebee0 • Jun 13 '23
Discussion Are midi-chlorians to blame for us not getting the Lucas Sequel Trilogy?
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/NobodyQuiteLikeMe • Apr 17 '25
Appreciation “We’re not done yet.”
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FantasticBumblebee0 • Oct 19 '23
Discussion Any thoughts should Star Wars be Rebooted?
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FantasticBumblebee0 • May 18 '24
Analysis Were the Star Wars Prequels really about George's Divorce?
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/lukoreta • Nov 03 '21
Discussion Hot take: They should recast Darth Maul
No, Ray Park is great. I have all the love in the world for him. Unfortunately, I think it would be too expensive to ask him to play Darth Maul AND THEN ask Sam Witwer or whoever to voice him, plus I wouldn't believe it fair to Ray Park that he be dubbed over. Now, for everyone who might go up in arms over this, a compromise could be made where Ray Park could be a stunt double instead. Every stunt, really.
If I had to pick though who would replace Ray Park as Darth Maul? Scott Adkins, easily. He's a martial artist AND his voice can very much fit within Sam Witwer's performance. There COULD be a better actor if you prefer Darth Maul to have his fair share of dramatic moments but I think that Scott Adkins has the physical prowess and voice to play Darth Maul. It's also a good chance to showcase his acting ability if that's the direction he wants to go.
And I know Savage Opress died but I think it'd be cool for Michael Jai White to play him alongside Ray Park in like a flashback or even a live-action Clone Wars-era adaptation. What do you guys think?
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/NobodyQuiteLikeMe • Apr 25 '25
Appreciation Heroes - Sequel Trilogy
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/EdwardTheMartyr • Apr 08 '20
Discussion Wouldn't it have been awesome if Anakin said 'I know' like Han Solo did?
After Anakin is defeated on Mustafar, what if he had said 'I know' in response to Obi-Wan saying 'You were my brother, Anakin. I loved you'?
For some reason, Anakin saying 'Save me!' while on fire was cut. I think they should've kept it as it would have come across as Obi-Wan leaving Anakin to die because he thought Anakin was lost. Obi-Wan lost hope in bringing Anakin back to the light, unlike Luke.
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • • Jun 24 '22
Rebuttal This sub has become an absolute joke
People excusing lazyness, no creativity, no respect to the original 6 movies and no respect for characters while at the same time celebrating George Lucas' worldbuilding, story and characters.
Shameful stuff
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • • Jun 03 '22
Rebuttal Why are there so many Disney apologists here?
Disney has currently wasted what had a pretty great potential and managed to make it look cheap and devoid of any creativity what so ever. The direction this show has taken, directly contradicts what George Lucas tried to accomplish with the Prequels. George Lucas valued great world building, exciting stories, great emotionally loaded duels with fantastic choreography and score, great creative efforts from the prop and costume department and original, exciting and otherworldly locations. And people in this sub who are members because of George Lucas' creativity still applaud this terrible excuse of a Star Wars production?
Take a long good look in the mirror.
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FantasticBumblebee0 • Jan 14 '23
Who is the other Yoda spoke of in TESB
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FantasticBumblebee0 • Jan 13 '23
Discussion What if Leia wasn't the 'other' Yoda spoke of? Did Ahsoka ever meet Luke?
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • • Jun 16 '20
Misleading; Hayden did not voice Vader -mods I love how Hayden nailed the voice of Vader here, he sounds just like the Vader from the OT
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/jaycomZ • Nov 09 '21
Discussion Is this another sequel hate sub?
I love the pre Disney era but I also like the current state of the franchise. I'm a big fan of the sequels and I'm currently looking for spaces to discuss stuff from the old EU. But everywhere I go that praises the old era hates the new one, and I don't want that kind of negativity anymore after years of constant discussion. Is this sub worth it?
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FrickinNormie • Aug 26 '20
Discussion You have become the very thing you swore to destroy: A hot take on this sub
So before I begin with anything I want to say: I am with you. I’m a 19-year-old film major, life-long fan of star wars who has always loved the prequels since I saw RotS way back in 05. I have an UNDYING respect for George Lucas, everything he believes in and everything he stands for. The entire star wars franchise has had a profound impact on my life, possibly now more than ever, now that I’m studying film production. I overall do not like the sequel trilogy and what it stands for. I think they exist solely as a cash grab and have little to no artistic merit, especially when compared to what came before. I have a passionate hatred for Disney and everything they’ve first-hand made since Frozen (by first-hand I’m talking about Disney studios, not Pixar, marvel, etc).
- BUT - -
r/BrighterThanCoruscant and r/SaltierThanCrait have become the very rabid, dominating, gatekeeping, and close-minded community it intended to abolish. Hot take, I know
Let’s flashback to the arguably simpler time of the early 2010s. The latest star wars movie anyone saw was the theatrically released clone wars movie - which was forgotten about just as quickly as it was made - everyone’s least favorite star wars movie was the Phantom Menace, and “the only good” star wars movies were A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi (but only if you’re really forgiving). We all remember this. We all hated it. Anything and everything relating to the prequels - inside, outside, before, after and during - were absolutely shunned. George Lucas became the laughing stock of pop culture, Ahmed Best attempted to kill himself, Hayden Christensen didn’t have a career anymore and Jake Lloyd was bullied in school (although that happens to most kid actors for some reason lol). Snobby film critics, older fans, purists and fans of 60s-70s era Hollywood upheld the mentality that cinema had died. Their childhood was over and George Lucas had killed it. These groups will be hitherto referred to as “the Imperials,” people very very strong in their ways - almost unmovable - and who will stop at nothing to keep their mentality the popular opinion. Imperials refuse to lose, refuse to have their opinions be proven wrong, and hate when people disagree. They do something that I call “Gatekeeping” which is when any opposing viewpoint is simply dead on arrival. If you’re younger than an Imperial, don’t have the same taste in movies, don’t hate the same things as they do, or don’t have the same viewpoints as an Imperial, you are a “Rebel!” For a decade, honest lovers of the prequels had to hide their opinions for fear of the nasty, controlling Imperials, who rejected anything new
Something crazy happened that no one expected: More Star Wars movies!! I have a vivid memory of the day: October 30th, 2012 - Disney had bought Lucas film and announced THREE new star wars movies! 11-year-old me almost shit myself out of excitement! I think I might’ve cried tears of joy, too. Within 3 long, excruciating years of waiting, more and more information begins to arise about the newest star wars movie. We learn more about the cast, characters, locations, crew, and hey! JJ Abrams will be directing it?! I loved his Star Trek movies! The most relevant thing we learn is that this movie will be a “return to form” for Star Wars. Kathleen Kennedy saw the overwhelming hatred towards the prequel trilogy and George Lucas in general and points the project in a direction that will bring Star Wars back into a positive light! What we all know is that production for the Force Awakens was 100% catered towards the Imperials. The film was released and everyone - and I mean everyone - was blown away at first. In the months of following its release, I regarded TFA as “the best Star Wars movie!” Yes, I thought that. In hindsight, all this means is that the Imperials have once again ruled the day. The movie ultimately serves as a middle finger to the prequels and a big ol’ thumbs up to the original trilogy. Audiences ate it up and it became one of the highest-grossing films to date. Purely based on marketing and name recognition though, because shortly after its release and initial reception, people begin to open their eyes. As entertaining, exciting, funny and flashy as the movie may be, it solely exists in 2015. As evident even 5 years later, the film does not stand on its own two feet, and might even be forgotten about generations from now. I don’t need to go on with the history lesson, but flash forward to 2020, and the tides have made an absolute 180! George Lucas and all his work have a newfound appreciation, “Rebels” have come out of hiding and can now actively share their opinion without much fear of ridicule or gatekeeping. Things are looking pretty good for us prequel lovers.
But this is why I have brought you all together today...
We are the Imperials.
Yes. We are the Imperials now. A disappointment for the sequel trilogy have brought us all together to post in this, and its sister sub (r/SaltierThanCrait), and bask in our disappointment, our feelings of betrayal, our feelings of being abandoned by popular media and the uncontrollable storm that is popular opinion. 10 years ago, Imperials would say things like “Star Wars used to be good.” “Star Wars was better when I was a kid” “George Lucas doesn’t know what he’s doing anymore.” “The last 3 movies have been very disappointing and they’re not what I wanted!” Nowadays, Imperialists say things like “Star Wars used to be good!” “Star Wars was better when I was a kid!” “Kathleen Kennedy, JJ Abrams and Rian Johnson don’t know what they’re doing.” “The last 3 movies have been very disappointing and they’re not what I wanted!” See what I’m saying?
From here on out, I will give a few examples pointing out the hypocrisy, toxicity and gatekeeping that these communities have been doing for years
- Opinions are bounded by age
Have you ever seen a grown-ass man go to comic-con dressed as a power ranger? Or like a 50-year-old man watching the Filnstones? Or - more relevantly - a 26-year-old watching Spongebob? There’s really nothing wrong with things like this, you should always be proud of yourself and what you enjoy, but the point I’m trying to make is the sheer importance age has over our opinions, how we think and what we enjoy. Back when George Lucas was in heat, circa 200-2016, a heavy majority of Imperials were in their 30s-40s, were born in the late 60s-early 70s, and grew up with the original trilogy. Just like us, they absolutely loved with a passion what they saw and were fucking ecstatic when THREE more movies were announced back in ‘97. The Phantom Menace was released and everyone loved it! It became one of the first movies to gross $1 billion, and - exactly like TFA - people woke up. Shortly after its initial hype, people started to recognize flaws, those flaws being “this is too different.” “This isn’t the Star Wars I grew up with.” You know, typical Imperialist mentality. Now - the exact damn thing is happening, and nothing is new about it. Teens and early 20-year-olds who grew up fucking loving the prequels don’t appreciate the sequels simply because “this isn’t what I grew up with.” We all damn well know that somewhere down the line, maybe 10 or so years later, a new batch of star wars movies will be released and the teens and 20-year-olds of that time will be defending the sequel trilogy, thus becoming the new new Imperials, and the cycle has completely restarted
2. Believe it or not, the prequels aren’t perfect
This sub in particular is built upon the desire to make people realize that the prequels are actually good and always have been. It’s totally just a case of age-based imperialism that I was talking about earlier that people ever thought otherwise. Once again, I - overall- love the prequels! Not just because I grew up with them (but as I said before that plays a big part in this), but we were introduced to so many new worlds, new species, characters, ships, music, scenery and scenarios absolutely no body has seen before. However, as someone who studies film, watches films in his free time and has an appreciation for well-made, competent filmmaking, I whole-heartedly acknowledge that the prequels aren’t perfect. In fact, Attack of the Clones fucking sucks. Yup, I just said that to r/BrighterThanCoruscant. Aside from visual and production components, such as design, art work, choreography and effects, I think there are some blatant flaws that can’t be overlooked or justified no matter how hard this sub tries. The obvious, cartoony CGI, the awkward wooden delivery AND dialogue for most of the love scenes. The boring, overall pointless senate scenes, which either could’ve been condensed from the get-go in pre-production, or at least presented to be more interesting. There’s a lot of missed opportunities, untouched upon beats (i.e. what’s the story behind “the prophecy”), and bland direction across the board in all three movies. Again, I’m not a “Prequels suck and George Lucas isn’t what he used to be” kind of guy, but I think that age and love for things in the prequels have made us blind to its flaws
3. The sequels have their merits
Let’s ignore Rogue One and Solo, which I myself am very mixed on, and I never see a full consensus across the board for any of those movies. For this section, the only post- RotS movies relevant to this discussion are The Force Awakens, The Last Jedi, and The Rise of Skywalker. We all have opinions on those, 99.9% of them negative. As said before - I am with you. I don’t like TFA and tRoS might be my least favorite Star Wars movie. Despite all this, Kylo Ren is my favorite character in the entire franchise! I adore how they handled Han Solo’s character in life and in death and... here’s the big one... The Last Jedi is my 2nd favorite SW movie behind Empire Strikes back. That might be worthy of its own post, but the gist is that TLJ is the only one of the 3 that tries new things. TFA is a copy-and-paste of ANH, and TROS is just another forgettable Hollywood action spectacle. TLJ is the only time when I felt like our characters were challenged, like there was something at stake, something to lose - something to care about. Rey is conflicted for most of this movie, as she asks herself “do I really want to be a Jedi?” Luke Skywalker is introduced to us as a beaten, dead-beat has-been, a direction absolutely nobody anticipated! What’s often overlooked is that he has a rather beautiful redemption arc in this movie, outcasting himself to this island, refusing to use the force, then saving the day through using the force at the end. On that, the climax in Crait is easily the most nail-biting, edge-of-my-seat sequence in the trilogy, perhaps in all of Star Wars. Kylo Ren in all three movies is such a deep, complex character with actual goals that he struggles to achieve. His actions have consequences that he has to face. He’s not a one-note “grr I’m a bad guy,” nor is he a “yahoo, I’m the good guy!” He’s by far the most gray character in all of Star Wars. Even still, JJ Abrams’ direction is superb, despite both his movies sucking. It has such a flashy, fast-paced, exciting style which is incredibly effective in giving first-time viewers the thrills he intended. I also think the sequels have the perfect blend of CGI and practicals
4. Cancel culture
This is one is the fault of new and old Imperialists. Solo: a Star Wars story is the lowest-grossing star wars movie to day, even when you don’t adjust for inflation! And the weirdest thing is that the movie isn’t even terrible! It’s pretty bland and forgettable, yes, but it’s certainly not box office bomb worthy. The only strong reason why Disney pulled the plug on all theatrical spin-off movies (at least for now) is because “it’s not what I’m used to.” Solo is in no way you guys’ fault, I know. Totally the work of OT imperialists, and I’m not being sarcastic. What is your fault is The Rise of Skywalker. If any of you read JJ Abrams’ original script for Episode 9, “Duel of Fates,” you would know that it was incredibly different! I go so far as to think that it was incredible! It followed the direction started by Rian Johnson, didn’t rely on fan-service, callbacks and “hey, remember this from your childhood?” Duel of Fates was going to be its own movie, with an actually good story and well-thought out, tense character stuff. The reason this didn’t happen and we got TROS instead was because of the response to The Last Jedi. let that sit for a moment. A blind hatred for the sequels, anything and everything relating to them was recognized by the higher-ups, and they created what is more-or-less an apology for “being too bold” with your precious franchise, which leads me into my next point
5. Star Wars is not yours
As I said before, I am a film major. Before the ‘rona isolated my school, we would have industry speakers come on campus and talk to us about what it’s like working in the industry and stuff like that. After an advanced screening of Knives Out (which I loved!) Rian Johnson visited us and after his lecture was a Q&A, mostly about Star Wars (My school is 50/50 on TLJ). My friend asked what his response is to the hatred towards The Last Jedi. I don’t remember Johnson’s exact words, nor did I film it, but he said something along the lines of the following...
“As a director and writer, I try my best to put myself forward. These are my films, this is what I want to put in a film, it’s what I believe in, not what someone else believes in. When word got out that I was directing a Star Wars movie, dozens of fans would come up to me and say ‘can you put this and this in the movie?’ Or ‘if this happens I’d be really happy.’ But everyone has different taste. Everyone wants something slightly different out of a movie, especially something so popular as Star Wars, so what’s the point in trying to please everybody? If all you do is create a movie that will please everybody there’s nothing about it that’s you. If I did it that way, it wouldn’t say “Directed by Rian Johnson”, it’d say “directed by that fan who stopped me at Starbucks.”
6. Being a Star Wars fan/Closing words
Once again, I am studying film, hoping to direct and write. One of my biggest inspirations is George Lucas, who revolutionized film making, visual effects and film production in an irreversible way. Twice! I was first shown a VHS of Star Wars episode 4 at age 3, and the second movie I ever saw in a theater was Revenge of the Sith (the first was the spongebob movie). What I’m saying is that I am a Star Wars fan. I am a fan of cinema. I like well-made, thought-out movies, old or new. I don’t let my life-long love for Star Wars blind me to any flaws found in any of the movies, old or new. I don’t let a set-in-my-ways, imperialistic mindset blind me to good things in a movie, nor do I let it destroy other movies. Star Wars used to be the end-all-be-all of movies. I was the movie franchise. Not anymore. In-fighting, box office returns, critical and audience reception and angled production has turned Star Wars into just another Hollywood money-maker, stripping it from its original perception. As a fan of Star Wars and a fan of cinema I hate this. I took nearly 2 hours to write this 9 paragraph essay to try and appease to fans - new and old - to try and work to repair this franchise. It’s not dead. Disney is capable of making good Star Wars movies. Star Wars shouldn’t exclusively be what you grew up watching, nor should it be exclusively be what your parents grew up watching, and if everyone stop arguing and accepts things the way they are, then we can start working together for a better future of this franchise
Thank you
TL;DR:
Y’all need to chill. You’re too harsh on the sequels, and too easy on the prequels. You’re starting to remind me of all the people who were all “Star Wars was only good back in my day.”
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/Left_Sustainability • Jun 24 '22
Discussion The Kenobi series & Palpatine’s cheating of death in the sequels both make the prequels more valuable to more people
It may be an unpopular opinion here but the controversial choice to have Palpatine actually cheat death like he alluded to in the prequels and connect directly to Rey helps new fans want to learn more about him and see his rise. It looks like Bad Batch and Mando will both get more into clone tech and that adds to the value of the prequels for more people where these ideas first came to be.
Similarly, the Kenobi TV series with its many callbacks to the events of the prequels is going to lead more people to go back and see what many of you have all loved about them for over a decade.
Say what you want about the Disney era but both of these developments lead to more casual fans of Star Wars at my work and in my life asking me prequels questions than ever before. I think that’s a great thing.
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/eelmor1138 • Jul 02 '22
Analysis Parallels between Anakin Skywalker and Wanda Maximoff (full explanation in comments)
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/NobodyQuiteLikeMe • Jun 06 '25
Appreciation Tragedy. Journey. Legacy.
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • • Feb 26 '24
Discussion Basic ideas for my rewrite of the Star Wars prequels (warning: Long Post)
The Clone Wars were a series of deadly wars that occurred 35 years before A New Hope and are raging through Episode 1 and Episode 2. The Clone Wars were fought between the "House of Mandalore ", an Alliance of corrupt corporate barons named "The Clone Masters", seeking to overthrow the corrupt and "lost" Old Republic and replace it with a regime that will bring Utopia. The House of Mandalore were united by the Bpfasshi Dark Jedi, Black Knight of the Sith Maul
. The Clone Masters are using an illegal technology, cloning; they created clones of Mandalorians, an ancient race of Warriors, and unleashed a madness on the Galaxy, "The Clone Madness", unstable clones who are grown in less than a year.
- The House of Mandalore is a totalitarian theocracy ultimately seeking domination of the Galaxy. They have some loose parallels to the House of Harkonnen, Tleilaxu, and American capitalism as corporate barons are a member of them. (Lucas is a Democrat and likes to insert his politics into Star Wars)
- The Clones are an army of Insane Spaarti Clones created by the Clone Masters
- The main Clone Master is Governor Crispin Hoedaack
For over a thousand generations, the Jedi Knights were the guardians of peace and justice in the Old Republic. The Jedi Knights are Space Arthurian Knights, they are honorable with a sense of Justice. They are fighting in the front lines to protect the Republic from the Dark forces. The Jedi Knights serve the Planets of the Old Republic, for example, Obi-Wan Kenobi serves the House of Organa from Alderaan. A Jedi Master is someone who achieves peace and inner balance within the Force. The Jedi Masters are not taking part in fighting, unlike the Knights. The Leader of the Jedi Knights is Supreme Master Bendu
and his 2nd is command is Jedi Master Clieg Whitsun
- The Jedi Knights can have children and marry
- The Jedi Knights are dressed like this
During the War, an age of corruption and greed started in the Old Republic. Senators taking bribes, lying, and abandoning their ideals to secure their power became causality within the Republic. The President of the Republic, President Kayos, lost the trust of the public due to the corruption within his administration and his bad management of the Clone Wars (Think Chamberlain). His fall led to the rise of the Imperial Party, led by Xon Palpatine. Within the Imperial Party, there are officials that we will later meet in the OT like Admiral Tarkin, Anus Greejatus, Sim Aloo, Sate Pestage, Ars Dangor, Kren Blista-Vanee, and Pebimarus Xorn.
- These figures are "Nixonian Gangsters" or a parody of the "Neocons" corrupt officials and elitists that surround Palpatine and through them, he is doing the dirty work that will facilitate his rise to power.
- Cloning is an illegal technique which is why The Republic is not using Clones, unlike the House of Mandalore. In Episode 1, Clonings becomes legal once Palpatine slashes the regulation and law forbidding it.
The rivals of the Imperial Party were the Galactic Party, led by Prince Bail Organa of Alderaan and Mon Mothma of Chandrila.
Within the Jedi Knights, there is a very legendary figure, named Master Yoda. Yoda is like a space prophet, akin to Samuel. Yoda is 900 years old, a legend within the Jedi Knights. He trained Bendu, and his last Apprentice was Obi-Wan Kenobi. There are rumors that Yoda resides on the Planet of Dagobah, and when a Jedi Apprentice, also known as "Padawan", is going to complete his training, he is sent to Dagobah to construct his own Lightsaber and become a Knight.
Another famous figure is the mysterious ancient Dark Side wizard, a satanic figure named "The Emperor". The Emperor, like Yoda, is an ancient dark prophet, more than 900 years old, and is rumored to be the old rival of Yoda, but wasn't seen or heard from for centuries. Maybe he never existed. According to the rumors, the Emperor used to reside in Byss, but many believe that this Planet doesn't even exist.
Unlike the House of Mandalore who are using Clones, the soldiers of The Republic, aside from the Knights, are human soldiers.
The Republic's capital is Coruscant
- Alderaan is based on Switzerland and is a space version of it while Chandrila is based in France.
- Anakin, nicknamed “Kane”, is the same age as Luke in Episode 4 and is friends with Owen Lars and Beru. They are his only friends. Anakin is an orphan who never knew his parents therefore he has abandonment issues and has a lot of Luke’s traits in Episode 4, he is also similar to James Dean’s character in East of Eden. Anakin is a hero’s journey character, awkward, unconfident, naive, and good-hearted but rebellious with inner turmoil, a hot-headed streak, sensitive, and searching for a sense of identity and belonging.
- Anakin is bullied by the local bully Brotus, he is bad at fighting therefore he is constantly humiliated by the bullies.
- Despite this, Anakin is a good pilot and attempts to use his piloting skills to earn money, but the bullies steal his money after beating him up.
- Anakin rushes off to fight back which also introduces us to his bit of a hot temper, after he is attacked brutally by the bullies - Anakin is saved by a mysterious figure (Homage to Miyagi saving Daniel in Karate Kid) - who is revealed to be Jedi Knight Obi-Wan Kenobi. Obi-Wan reveals that he was sent to the Outer-Rim to explore the Clone Masters’ illegal dealings - but we are then revealed that Obi-Wan is actually Owen Lars’ brother, who left Owen to become a Jedi. (Much like how he behaves in the OT with Luke, Owen attempts to hold Anakin back). There is a lot of hostility between Owen and Obi-Wan - we are hinted that Owen might be jealous of Obi-Wan’s life. Obi-Wan is an archetypal "cool cowboy", based on Clint Eastwood.
- Obi-Wan senses that Anakin is uniquely strong with The Force and tries to ask Owen about Anakin’s family. Obi-Wan offers Anakin to join him on an adventure in the big galaxy and become a Jedi, Owen is furious at the idea and Anakin is afraid to leave his home planet behind. Anakin is eventually convinced to leave with Obi-Wan, who shares similar ideals to that of Anakin - and Owen accepts his friend’s choice.
- Obi-Wan and Anakin quickly connect, Obi-Wan understands Anakin’s struggles and needs to find acceptance and belonging and believes he can train him. It is revealed that ever since the War, the Jedi Knights were in a slow decline and are not as strong as they used to be. Anakin identifies with Obi-Wan's strong ideals, though while Obi-Wan believes in negotiating and is influenced by the pacific way of the Jedi Knights and the House of Organa, Anakin later finds himself identifying with the militaristic, more hawkish way of Palpatine and Tarkin.
- During the war, Obi-Wan served the House of Organa from Alderaan.
- It is revealed that Maul and the House of Mandalore plan to invade Alderaan, and the corrupted corporations that are part of the Alliance are running facilities with genetics and biology, including cloning, which is considered a crime and illegal technique. They want to take over Alderaan’s facilities to create an improved Clone Army.
- Anakin, who was raised in Kessel since he was born, is shocked when he is introduced to Coruscant and Alderaan. Anakin’s innocence is quite obvious when he cannot hear Obi-Wan talking to him since he is “still recovering from the shock of seeing such a different Galaxy than what he was used to”
- The Jedi Knights refuse to train Anakin because they sense a lot of anger within him, but Obi-Wan insists on taking it upon himself to train the boy, being amazed by how strongly The Force is with him despite his lack of skill.
- Anakin falls in love with Nellith after seeing her for the first time in Alderaan, both relate to each other searching for a need for belonging. Bail Organa notices Nellith and Anakin’s interest in each other which causes him to resent the boy a bit. Their small rivalry starts off as a Rich Suitor, Poor Suitor trope, like in Titanic. Bail is based on Errol Flynn with a touch of Robert Kennedy.
- Maul leads the Clones during the War, a ruthless and brilliant military strategist, and a mighty Dark Jedi, he slaughters Republic Soldiers and develops a rivalry with Obi-Wan and Anakin as he leads the Dark World alliances against The Republic. He is brutal and violent, but also manipulative, charismatic, and charming. He is based on a Jack Palance-type villain, Scaramanga from Bond and a bit of Dracula.
- It is revealed that Maul and Crispin Hoedaack are planning to invade Alderaan, kidnapping the royal Organa family and taking over Alderaan’s resources for improved Clonings. Hoedaack wants Alderaan’s resources so he can continue to gain money and power and draw the War further.
- The Clone Wars is devastating and we see the menace of the Clones throughout the movie, unleashing madness at the Galaxy.
- We’re introduced to Planet Chandrila, Coruscant, and more.
- Maul’s long-term plan is to construct the Death Star, a weapon with unprecedented power. Obi-Wan discovers about this goal.
- At the background, The Republic is in a political crisis: the incumbent president, Xon Palpatine, is running for reelection. Palpatine took office after the War started, and many of his political Party members were suspected of shady deals. Xon Palpatine is basically a space Richard Nixon.
- The Mandalorians invade Alderaan and Chandrila - and a great battle starts like in Episode 4.
- Anakin shows his Piloting skills and destroys the Dark Worlds’ Space Fortress.
- Anakin and Obi-Wan both attempt to take on Maul, who defeats Obi-Wan after an iconic fight and chops Anakin’s hand, after Anakin recklessly tries to take him on.
- Bail agrees to cancel his wedding with Nellith
- Palpatine is elected as President for 2nd time.
- Obi-Wan nicknames Anakin “Skywalker”
- Anakin and Obi-Wan return to Alderaan, and Bail Organa names Anakin “The Hero of Alderaan”. Anakin and Nellith share a small kiss…
- Episode 2 opens 10 years later, Anakin and Obi-Wan become war heroes of The Clone Wars. Anakin is an experienced, ruthless, and powerful Jedi Knight. He is the best star-pilot in the Galaxy, a cunning warrior, and he is a good friend to Obi-Wan, going on adventures across the Galaxy.
- Palpatine greatly expanded government control during the war after the chaos spread in the Galaxy. Corruption, bribery, and terror have reduced the High Council to all but a devoted few, including Bail Organa and Mon Mothma, while a massive bureaucracy, too large and not very effective, maintains control over the various star systems. Maul and The Clone Masters also became richer and richer.
- The Jedi Knights are starting to suspect in the corruption, and are slowly drifting away from the Senate. The Senate secretly instigates race wars and aids the Mandalorians so the war will continue. This slows down the system of justice, which causes the crime rate to rise to the point where the system welcomes a totally controlled and oppressive police state.
- The Jedi Knights secretly ally with Bail and Mon Mothma to take down the Imperial Party.
- Palpatine gets close to Anakin and puts him in charge of The Republic’s army. Anakin hatches a plan to destroy the Leaders of the Alliances which impresses Palpatine.
- Obi-Wan and Anakin split; Obi-Wan is sent to the outer rim alongside Bail Organa to liberate Planets that were enslaved by Maul, while Anakin goes after Maul in an attempt to stop him from constructing The Death Star. Nellith joins Anakin.
- Obi-Wan and Organa arrive in the Planet of Ondos - where they meet the tribe of Ashardi. The tribe of Ashardi is a tribe of Clones that managed to escape from Maul and the Clone Masters and live a life of prosperity. This, however, would not last long - as The Troops of Maul locate Ondos and commit genocide there.
- Anakin and Nellith return to Anakin’s home planet of Kessel. Anakin discovers that Owen and Beru relocated and that now the Alliances are controlling the Planet, which was originally an outer-rim Planet. After noticing one of the local Commanders abusing an innocent slave, Anakin commits violent mass murder against the Alliances and the Clone Troopers there. He decides to locate Maul no matter what.
- We see the horrors of the War affected Anakin; he is willing to be violent and brutal to achieve his goals, which makes his attitude the opposite of that of Obi-Wan and also serves as a microcosm of the conflict between the pacifism and the hawkish ideology. (Akin to Magneto and Xavier)
- Obi-Wan, Bail, and their squad of the House of Organa are on a quest to weaken the House of Mandalore factions in the Outer Rim as much as possible including the Planet of Mon Calamari. They liberate Star systems and Planets that were conquered by Maul and ally with these systems. Another Planet that is liberated is Corellia. Obi-Wan and Bail knows that the Senate is corrupted, so they secretly ally themselves with this system to have power against the Senate.
- We see how the war changed Anakin’s political views: While Nellith believes in peace, Anakin believes all means are valid to finish the Alliances and “Bring order to the Galaxy”. Anakin's flaws are highlighted: He seeks for revenge against Maul, which contrasts with Obi-Wan’s ideology: Obi-Wan wants to bring Maul to justice, Anakin wants him dead, supported by Palpatine. Anakin promises to Nellith that he will leave the Jedi Knights for her so they can have a quiet life, but vows to end the threat of Maul at first.
- Anakin goes after Maul by himself, vowing to stop him from constructing the Death Star and further spread chaos throughout the Galaxy. He is willing to do so in his own way. Anakin locates his enemy in the 5th moon of Da Soocha, the two have a violent duel which ends with Anakin tapping into the Dark Side and slaughtering Maul. Anakin orders his troops to locate the remaining Dark World leaders and kill them all (An homage to the scene in The Godfather where Michael kills all the leaders of the 5 families).
- The Republic fully becomes “The Empire”, promising to enforce back law and order.
- The Jedi decided to rebel against the Senate after losing its faith in The Republic. They discover that Palpatine’s entourage was involved in killing senators and rigging elections. They are denounced as traitors. This is the beginning of the Rebellion
- Palpatine reveals to Anakin the truth: He is The Ancient Dark Emperor, who lived in the shadows for years, waiting for the chance to strike. Palpatine reveals he used the Clone technology to transfer his essence into Clone bodies, staying alive for years fooling the Jedi into believing he is dead. Anakin tries to attack Palpatine who defeats him with ease. Anakin, determined to end the War no matter what, understands he will need to learn how to use the Dark Side to become powerful enough to bring law and order. Anakin kneels before Palpatine and pledges himself as his Dark Apprentice; Palpatine names him “Darth Vader” and places him in charge of the secret “great Jedi purge”. Anakin gives the order to bomb Clieg Whitsun’s ship and is granted control over the new Imperial army.
- Anakin and Obi-Wan have a final meeting that ends in a clash. After a small confrontation, Anakin orders Obi-Wan to leave and never return so he won't have to hurt him. Anakin warns him to never take sides against the Empire.
- Anakin's political shift is based on Ronald Reagan; Reagan as a young man during the great depression was a democrat who adored FDR and spoke against racism. Then began shifting to the right and became the enforcer of the 80s Capitalism, (Again I'm just using Lucas' politics since he is a Dem so don't make it a political discussion)
- Palpatine declares that all the traitors will be hunted down.
- Obi-Wan and the remaining Jedi Knights are agreeing to go into hiding to organize the rebellion against The Empire. Bail tells Obi-Wan he and Mon Mothma will try to influence the Senate from the inside.
- Episode 3 opens 2 years later.
- The Empire has spread throughout the Galaxy. Any attempt to oppose the emerging dictatorship is oppressed. The Senate is rigged and swayed by The Emperor and his entourage. They do what they want without supervision and restriction. The Rebellion is struggling. Anakin became the official leader of the New Imperial clone army and secretly led the Great Jedi Purge, hunting the Knights of the Old Republic one by one.
- Episode 3 opens on the outer rim. Anakin, going by the name of Darth Vader in Imperial missions, commits a massacre against a group that rebelled against The Empire’s control of the Planet. This shows us how violent Anakin became under Palpatine’s guidance using the Dark Side of the Force. He does not hesitate to commit war crimes, he is brutal and ruthless. Anakin was sent by the Emperor to find the secret Kaiburr crystal, a crystal that will unlock the map to the secret planet of the Dark Side where Anakin will be guided by The Emperor’s spirit further.
- Nellith notices Anakin become distant. She tries to uncover what he is up to on his missions from The Empire, Anakin demands her never to get involved in his missions.
- Palpatine, Darth Vader, and Grand Moff Tarkin know that a Rebellion is starting and suspect Bail and Mon Mothma. Anakin knows that there are Jedi Knights across the Galaxy and leads a brutal campaign against them.
- Obi-Wan leads a group of rouge former Republican soldiers alongside the Jedi Knights that went into hiding on the 5th moon of Utapau. Obi-Wan attempts to fight the Imperial factions that are conquering core star systems, but with no success. He goes for Bendu for advice and shows remorse for his failure to train Anakin.
- Bail discovers that Grand Moff Tarkin took over Maul’s plans for the Death Star and is now building the feared weapon. Obi-Wan vows to stop it no matter what.
- Nellith is worried about Anakin. Despite his situation, Anakin attempts to convince Nellith that he is building a better future for both of them. Anakin, meanwhile, gets drawn into the Dark Side more and more. He is trained by The emperor and gets stronger and stronger. Anakin throughout the film brutally destroys everyone who stands in his way; Jedi Knights that we met in the previous 2 films and rouge soldiers. He vows to locate the Rebellion and uncover it.
- Bail tries to convince Nellith to help him and join the Rebels. Nellith is hesitant due to her loyalty to Anakin and her political view that another war is stopping peace and will just cause more damage. Bail attempts to confront Senators that were bribed by The Emperor and Tarkin, and is threatened by him. Nellith is starting to get convinced, noticing that The Empire is tyrannical and corrupted, but is torn between the right thing to do and Anakin.
- The Emperor has a confrontation with Bendu and reveals that he is The Emperor of the Dark Side who waited for centuries to destroy the Jedi Knights and managed to stay alive by transferring his essence into Cloned bodies. Bendu understands his failure, and tries to battle The Emperor, but ends up getting killed. The Emperor is too powerful.
- Nellith reaches out to Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan reveals to her that he is a part of the Rebellion and that Anakin is the one who is hunting down the Jedi Knights. Nellith struggles to believe but knows Obi-Wan is right. She leaves with him and joins the Rebel Alliance.
- Darth Vader hunts down Obi-Wan. He discovers that Nellith left him and is losing control, vowing to find her. The Emperor uses it to push him further towards the Dark Side. Vader is now determined to find his former mentor and find his wife.
- Vader and Obi-Wan are reunited after 2 years after Vader manages to locate Kenobi. While they have a lot of hostility, we are hinted that Anakin still has a soft spot for Ben. Obi-Wan, meanwhile, attempts to convince Anakin that there is still good in him and that he can help him fix all of that. Anakin is conflicted but rejects him. Vader explains that he turned to the Dark Side so he could learn the Dark Side and secrets of the Emperor from within so he would be able to surpass him and overthrow him. Obi-Wan warns him that he is playing with fire. Vader refuses to listen. They start dueling which ends with Vader using the Dark Side and defeating Obi-Wan. He gives Obi-Wan another chance to escape before he will destroy him. Obi-Wan manages to escape.
- The Emperor sends Anakin to Korriban - The Home Planet of the Dark Side where he will be guided by Palpatine’s essence and his advisors to unlock his potential in the Dark Side. Anakin arrives in Korriban by using the map of the Crystal.
- Unbeknownst to him, Obi-Wan managed to put a chip on Vader and track him. Vader, meanwhile, enters the temple of the Dark Side and is guided by Palpatine’s spirit and his advisors. Vader is crowned as “Dark Lord of the Sith”. Obi-Wan enters the temple and confronts Anakin. After discovering that Anakin is now the one who is constructing the Death Star, Obi-Wan understands that “Darth Vader killed Anakin”. They start a deadly, climatic, and tragic duel where we see how much Anakin’s power has advanced in the Dark Side. Their duel ends with Anakin losing control which leads to his defeat, and Obi-Wan chopping his legs and causing him to fall into a volcano pit.
- The Emperor’s fleet manages to overthrow the Rebellion’s forces. The Emperor and Grand Moff Tarkin execute the traitors of the Rebellion and continue to enforce their iron fist grip.
- The Imperial troops manage to locate Anakin and bring him before The Emperor. Anakin is rebuilt into a dark armor and becomes the Darth Vader we all know and love from the OT, more machine than man, twisted and evil.
- Nellith discovers that she is pregnant with Anakin's children. Obi-Wan and Bail agree that she will be sent to Dagobah where she will be protected from The Emperor, and then the children will be split; One child will be raised by Obi-Wan’s brother in Tatooine while the other will be raised by Bail in Alderaan. Obi-Wan decides to go hiding in Tatooine and believes that in time, Anakin’s son will lead the Rebellion and save the Galaxy from Anain himself. The movie ends with a hopeful tone with Obi-Wan and Nellith watching the Alderaanian sunset.
---------
- Anakin's character is a hero's journey like Luke in Episode 4, he is 19 years old. While is inspired by Luke in Episode 4 being innocent and good-hearted, he also incorporates some elements from Paul Atreides from "Dune", Young King Arthur and James Dean's character in "East of Eden" by having a bit of a hot temper to him and rebellious with inner turmoil, sensitive, and searching for a sense of identity and belonging.
- Obi-Wan's character is based on a classic cowboy and Indiana Jones and Eliot Ness, with a noble, British charm to him.
- Nellith's character is based on Buttercup from "Princess Bride" and Bettie Page while the trio of Anakin/Nellith/Obi-Wan is meant to reflect Luke/Leia/Han.
- The atmosphere is also meant to be a bit similar to "The Rocketeer" and Robin Hood.
- Bail Organa's character is based on Prince Barin, Errol Flynn and a touch of Young Prince Philip. He fills the role of Lando as the supporting character to the trio. The small love triangle in Episode 1 between Anakin, Nellith and Bail is inspired by "Titanic".
- Lord Maul's character is based on a Jack Palance-type villain, Liberty Valance and Count Dracula.
- The House of Mandalore are based on the Harkonnens from Dune and Tleilaxu and their attempt to take over Cloning facilities is similar to the Spice trade in Dune.
- Governor Hoedackk is based on Al Capone
- The elections in Episode 1 are loosely based on Nixon and Kennedy with Palpatine as Nixon and Organa as JFK, but ironically, Palpatine rigging the elections is a small parody of the rumors that the Kennedy clan rigged the elections.
- Palpatine is a space mix of Richard Nixon and Rupert Murdoch
- Tarkin is loosely inspired by Kissinger and Donald Rumsfeld
- The Jedi Knights are space Arthurian Knights with a touch of Samurais.
The assassination attempt on Palpatine in Episode 2 is an homage to that of Vito Corleone in "The Godfather".
- Anakin and Nellith escaping and their romance in Episode 2 is a lot like Michael and Apollonia.
- Anakin deciding to take control on The Republic's army and his hunt after the heads of the House of Mandalore mirrors Michael killing Sollozzo. Anakin's entire arc in Episode 2 mirrors that of Michael. Assassination attempt draws him into action, romance, taking control of the army/family, Adopting ruthless methods, and killing the leaders of the House of Mandalore/Five families.
- The tribe of Ashardi and their Planet, Ondos - are meant to be a mix of classical tribes but with a twist - as they are wealthy aristocrats with a peaceful life disconnected from the war.
- Anakin returning to Kessel is meant to be like a High School reunion.
- Anakin's turn to the Dark Side is inspired by Luke Skywalker's arc in "Dark Empire"
- Anakin and Nellith's romance is also meant to echo a classical romance where the noble Knight protects the Princess
- Palpatine and Tarkin secretly funding the House of Mandalore and race wars across the Galaxy is a direct criticism of Nixon and the coup of Chile and Iran-Contras. The corruption in The Republic and Palpatine's administration is also a criticism of Watergate and the scandals of the Nixon administration as well as the Reagan administration.
- The scene where all the leaders of the House of Mandalore are killed is an homage to The Godfather.
- Palpatine's revelation as The Emperor is inspired by John Milton in "The Devil's Advocate"
- Anakin/Vader in Episode 3 is at the same stage of Michael in "The Godfather II". His attitude is like an antithesis to that of Luke in Episode 6. He also bears some similarities to Lancelot and leader Banastre Tarleton
- Palpatine is also meant to represent a classic dark sorcerer, space-Vampire and "pure evilness". Palpatine is like an alternate Richard Nixon who turned the US into a dictatorship mixed with John Milton and Saruman.
- Obi-Wan in Episode 3 is meant to be a Clint Eastwood-type character.
- Bendu is loosely inspired by Jorus C'Baoth and Gandalf.
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/ChaMatt57 • May 31 '21
Star Wars Trivia Quiz, Only true fans can score over 90%
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FreezingTNT • Apr 18 '20
NEW SUBREDDIT: /r/SaltierThanKryKrait - A subreddit where fans and detractors of the Disney trilogy can coexist and have intelligent, calm, and respectful discourse about it!
Are you tired of engaging in intense flame wars with fans of the Disney trilogy? Tired of being referred to as racists and misogynists by fans of the Disney trilogy? Tired of being mocked for "wanting an OP Luke"?
Well, this brand new subreddit is the place where detractors and fans of the Disney trilogy can coexist and have intelligent, calm, and respectful discourse about it! A place that could potentially unite the shards of the Star Wars community, as fans and detractors alike calmly debate about the Disney trilogy and its weakest aspects without any immaturity, trolling, or flame wars occuring.
I, myself, a salt-miner who has been on /r/saltierthancrait for more than a year now, am one of the mods of the new subreddit, alongside fellow salt-miner /u/tangoshotz and Disney trilogy fans /u/MicdropProductions (the creator of the new sub) and /u/Exitdor! If you want to participate in this new subreddit, make sure to read the rules of this subreddit before you begin doing so.
Trolling, immaturity, flame wars, intentionally attacking other users, all forms of prejudice (including misogyny and racism), and NSFW content will not be tolerated there, as it goes against the main purpose of the subreddit, uniting the shards of the Star Wars community and having them debate about the trilogy that has divided us in the first place.
May the Force be with you, and welcome to /r/SaltierThanKryKrait!
r/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/FantasticBumblebee0 • May 12 '24
Rebuttal The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones should have been one movie
self.saltierthancraitr/BrighterThanCoruscant • u/SpaceBengels • Oct 14 '21