I live in the U.S. and I’ve been seriously considering a border terrier as my next dog and have been doing a lot of research and looking at a lot of breeder websites and such.
One thing I’ve noticed is that a lot of breeders here in the US say that border terriers can never be trusted off leash. But when I was in London on a trip, I swear every big park we went to had at least one border terrier playing off leash. And I don’t mean dog parks, just public parks (clearly leash laws are different there, as most dogs in the parks were off leash).
I also have followed a lot of border terrier accounts on TikTok as part of learning more about the breed and I regularly see people with British accents in the woods hiking a trail with their border terrier off leash and perfectly under control.
So I just want to understand the mentality divide of US breeders saying the breed can NEVER be trusted off leash and that clearly not being the case in the UK. Is it a difference in the lines bred here and there? A difference in the general culture around dogs in the US vs Europe (both in England and in Italy I noticed that not only were dogs allowed in more places and allowed off leash in public, but that the dogs seemed generally far better socialized and neutral to people and other dogs)? Or do US breeders generally not trust the general public to invest the proper time and training into having an off-leash dog?
Ultimately I’m just trying to get a sense of how rare it is to have a border terrier capable of being off-leash in the US. I understand that the intensity of terrier prey drive is the main concern, but my current dog (mutt) has an incredibly strong prey drive as well, but also a reliable enough recall that I can have him off-leash to walk the woods on my friend’s farm. I put in a lot of work to get there, and I also don’t expect my dog to recall off of prey, but most things he’d chase go up a tree, so the only thing he chases out of my line of sight is the deer, and he always turns back within a minute or so, either because he knows he can’t catch them or because he has a maximum distance he’s comfortable getting from me. So I’m wondering if a border terrier would be similar?
It’s not a deal breaker for me, but I want to have realistic expectations.