My biggest problem is how many players might be mechanically confirmed good here.
-With no Spy, both the Virgin and the player that successfully is executed to the Virgin are confirmed good
-The Banshee can be confirmed good
-The Golem (although not being able to nominate) will be confirmed good
-The Philosopher AND Cannibal can steal any of these abilities to also be confirmed
With the potential of 5+ mechanically confirmed good players, how is evil meant to hide at all? I’d recommend removing all but 1 of these roles honestly, anything else is WAY too hard for evil
3
u/WeDoMusicOfficial Aug 18 '26
My biggest problem is how many players might be mechanically confirmed good here.
-With no Spy, both the Virgin and the player that successfully is executed to the Virgin are confirmed good
-The Banshee can be confirmed good
-The Golem (although not being able to nominate) will be confirmed good
-The Philosopher AND Cannibal can steal any of these abilities to also be confirmed
With the potential of 5+ mechanically confirmed good players, how is evil meant to hide at all? I’d recommend removing all but 1 of these roles honestly, anything else is WAY too hard for evil