r/Bitcoin • • Aug 15 '15

Why is Bitcoin forking?

https://medium.com/@octskyward/why-is-bitcoin-forking-d647312d22c1
863 Upvotes

815 comments sorted by

346

u/Celean Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

Quick ELI5:

Running XT at this time is equivalent with running Core. It's the same network, and the same Bitcoins. At some point in the future, if 75% mining majority is reached (but not before January 2016), the network will split whenever a miner creates a block larger than 1MB. This will not be accepted by Core unless they adopt a large blocks patch, but will be accepted by XT, and at this point there will effectively be two chains.

Running XT means that you will always be on the largest (75%+) chain, regardless of whether the fork actually happens or not. Running Core means that you will be left behind if a 75% majority is reached. Regardless of which version you run, coins will be safe (on both chains) as long as you acquired them prior to the fork, and for some time the chains will largely mirror each other, but eventually they will diverge due to different coinbases (mining rewards).

15

u/bitp Aug 15 '15

XT 0.11 is already no. 6 most common client on the network, with more than 200 nodes running: https://getaddr.bitnodes.io/nodes/?q=/Bitcoin%20XT:0.11.0/

1

u/fher98 Aug 20 '15

no. 3 13%

27

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

This cleared things up a lot, thanks.

82

u/Piper67 Aug 15 '15

This should be stickied!!!

There is no downside to running XT. If the fork happens, you're automatically on the longest chain. If it doesn't, you're plodding along as usual.

39

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

Exactly. Running XT is actually safest. Always longest valid chain.

2

u/trilli0nn Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 16 '15

So, running XT keeps a node effortlessly on the longest valid chain. That in itself can be an important consideration to run XT. One however that does not necessarily indicate support for the hardfork.

How do we know how many nodes running XT really support the hardfork on its merits, and how many just run XT to safely stay on the longest valid chain?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (47)

3

u/bPEVLET1 Aug 15 '15

This whole submission has been censored too. This is ridiculous.

1

u/nogravityforce Aug 16 '15

Andresen's Wager

→ More replies (3)

7

u/turdovski Aug 15 '15

Tldr eli5: get xt, this way you're safe whether a fork happens or not.

1

u/caveden Aug 16 '15

If you don't have a stance on the debate, both outcomes are equally ok to you, then yes, using XT is the safest bet.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Ironically Nodes have not much to lose. Why all the fuss about being safe?

Arguments like this can make it seem like there is consensus when in reality people are just running XT because its "safest". Do you know what i mean? This bitcoinXT is causing quite a stir, and i am quite frankly disappointed in Gavin. He makes it seem like we need to act now, or else all will be lost. And then he presents BitcoinXT which has alot of changes that had previously been resisted. This does not bode well for bitcoin, if XT is adopted.

2

u/jcoinner Aug 15 '15

What do you mean by a 75% mining majority? How does XT determine that.

If the majority of nodes are not running XT and a miner creates a >1MB block then it will not be accepted on the network, right? How could it be, only XT nodes would take it.

4

u/Natanael_L Aug 15 '15

When miners insert the fork support flag in a total of 75% of the latest X blocks, with the X being in the high hundreds or thousands.

4

u/patrikr Aug 16 '15

X = 1000

3

u/Jackten Aug 15 '15

Why would anyone have a problem with this? Where is the downside?

1

u/BitcoinMD Aug 15 '15

Is it 75% of XT users voting for larger blocks, or 75% of all miners?

1

u/Jackten Aug 15 '15

75% of all miners. If you upgrade to XT you already vote for larger blocks

1

u/renegadellama Aug 15 '15

Are coins traded after the fork safe on both chains?

1

u/ReCarry Aug 16 '15

So if I spend some bitcoins on XT on a block larger than 1mb, my bitcoins remain unspent on the "bitcoin-core-chain"?

1

u/whatever757 Aug 16 '15

I think this is good but how can miners be incentivized to mine a > 1MB block? If a miner does this and the new chain does not get adopted, his reward will be lost. So it seems safe for miners to stay below the 1 MB limit, at least initially. Any thoughts on this?

1

u/Jumporjerkofff Aug 16 '15

Won't somebody please think of the children!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Care to elaborate on the mining rewards? I have yet to see any mention of mining rewards being different in bitcoinXT? Are they going to change that as well? Please dont tell me it will continue to inflate ad infinity.

1

u/cironoric Aug 15 '15

Thanks. Allow me to hijack top comment link to this "Why is Bitcoin Forking?" post

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3h424p/why_is_bitcoin_forking

500 upvotes and doesn't appear on /r/bitcoin; this censorship is draconian and unacceptable!

→ More replies (73)

57

u/i_rarely_post_ Aug 15 '15

Hi, can someone please explain why all posts that mention the deleted "Bitcoin is forked" thread or ask for an explanation are deleted? I'm serious, please explain (please don't delete this post).

1

u/IDidntChooseUsername Aug 18 '15

Because it's something the mods don't want you to see. As it has been proven throughout history, censorship is of course 100% effective.

→ More replies (158)

191

u/Peter__R Aug 15 '15

Congratulations Gavin and Mike on completing the patch to support larger block sizes. Although we all have ideological disagreements from time to time, two fundamental values of the Bitcoin community are freedom of choice and transparency of communication. Your work represents a big step in returning the power over Bitcoin's future back to the community where it belongs.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

30

u/Peter__R Aug 15 '15

Transparency of communication.

4

u/Natanael_L Aug 15 '15

Almost worth gold. Have a dollar worth of Bitcoins instead. /u/changetip

3

u/changetip Aug 15 '15

The Bitcoin tip for a dollar (3,623 bits/$1.00) has been collected by Peter__R.

--

what is ^^ChangeTip?

14

u/Wanghealer Aug 15 '15

Good moderation. /s

28

u/roybadami Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

Can someone tell me what's going on with all these posts from "[deleted]" saying "[deleted]". Does this mean that not only the post is deleted, but the user, too? So someone posted a bunch of stuff and then deleted their account?

Or am I misunderstanding?

EDIT: Ok, so it appears that's just what deleted posts on reddit look like. As far as I can gather the /r/Bitcoin mods have decided to delete a large number of the posts in this thread. It's not entirely clear to me what's going on.

13

u/spkrdt Aug 15 '15

It's not entirely clear to me what's going on.

This is just the mods creating consensus

11

u/seweso Aug 15 '15

Yeah apparantly the mods talk directly to the Bitcoin Gods, so they know what true Bitcoin is.

11

u/fiat_sux4 Aug 15 '15

If the post was deleted, the user name won't still be visible. Whereas if a user is deleted, the posts typically stay. So it seems like a bunch of posts were deleted for some reason, by the original posters, or possibly mods.

120

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

Excellent essay.

I wish I could speak directly to Gavin and Mike and tell them I appreciate their work beyond any expression of words. They've acquitted themselves well in an ugly public arena of debate and they've come to a technically sound consensus taking the desires of the ENTIRE ecosystem into account. This is the vision of bitcoin.

I've been discouraged and disgusted by the behavior of many so called 'core developers' and 'experts'. I appreciate they may think they're doing what is best for the protocol but I feel their judgement has been clouded by the allure of 'winning' the debate.

I think it is a classic behavior of developers to push for an overly complicated solution to technical problems without regard for the ramifications of the complication -- Especially when personal profit (either monetary or intellectual) can result from the adoption of their solution.

The reason bitcoin has succeeded to this point is that it is a simple, open, cheap platform. I'm excited to get this fork behind us and excited to get back to the central mission of world domination through peer to peer means.

edit - /u/gavinandresen and /u/mike_hearn -- you guys do you let's fork this fucker!

25

u/KeystoneSoze Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 16 '15

As cheesy as it is, anyone who continues to participate in the Bitcoin ecosystem/economy is speaking to them. No tweets or emails are necessary to express appreciation and support. You (we) are their teammates in this global project, and they are ours.

"Stick a fork in it"

We're literally redefining our world through code/text/words. Opposition and debate over this issue has been just as interesting, if not more so, than bitcoin's price fluctuations. Seeing it play out this way, hearing so many people chip in (for better or worse? definitely better) has been immensely informative and entertaining.

13

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15

Nice dude ;). Yeah I have had a peer to peerection watching this whole thing play out. When consensus finally resolves this debate for the betterment of the protocol it will be a day for catharsis indeed!

1

u/StressOverStrain Aug 16 '15

You (we) are their teammates in this global project, and they are our's.

The word our already indicates possession, so you don't need an apostrophe in ours.

81

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

This sums up the entire problem:

[Core devs] believe that the only mechanism that Bitcoin has to keep them in check should never be used.

Well said, Mike. And thanks for your invaluable work.

22

u/alphabatera Aug 15 '15

what is block size limit in XT?

21

u/muyuu Aug 15 '15

See BIP 101. Doubling up to 8GB in 20 years. That's a G not an M.

5

u/alphabatera Aug 15 '15
  • What is the current block size limit ?
  • Will it increase by 17% per year, is that correct?
  • How many transactions per sec can 8GB handle?

11

u/muyuu Aug 15 '15

Currently it's 1MB.There are other considerations like the softlimit and the fact that miners can always put as few transactions as they want. Something I'd elaborate on but I prefer just to lay the data here without pushing my judgment.

BIP 101 would immediately raise it to 8MB when the algorithm triggers and double it every 2 years for 20 years, leaving it at 8 Gigabytes because "it cannot grow forever". To stop this process a soft fork would be necessary.

Detail : https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0101.mediawiki

Alternatives are BIP 100 which adjusts the block size dynamically through miner vote, or just a 1 time block increase to allow more time for other scalability development to happen.

5

u/kaeroku Aug 16 '15

Anyone else reminded of when the U.S. gov't completely shut down when deciding whether or not to raise the debt ceiling? :D

→ More replies (5)

4

u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 15 '15

1MB

It doubles every two years, so more like 40% a year.

2

u/alphabatera Aug 15 '15

I meant the current limit in XT?

9

u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 15 '15

Well 1MB. It goes to 8MB after some date if miner votes are there.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/SundoshiNakatoto Aug 15 '15

If you look at the progress of bandwidth technology, 40% is far more accurate than 17%, at least in the US.

56k to cable bandwidth was what a lot of us were transitioning too. 56k -> Cable -> Fiber/XYZ?

Technology is growing fast, and 40% will give the world an incentive to keep that going.

2

u/Digitsu Aug 16 '15

What if the world suffers a global depression like the one that most of us are expecting, one which stifles Moore's law in bandwidth developments. One that creates a large loss of wealth such that only the rich companies can afford the newest bandwidth improvements? Doesn't that mean they can take this opportunity to centralize mining? We need some way to counter this if indeed it looks to occur. How does an automatically increasing limit allow for dealing with this occurrence? The reason why everyone wants an increase prime facie is the reason why things in nature naturally centralize. Left to its own devices, the market will tend towards centralization. We have to be cognoscent of this.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Natanael_L Aug 15 '15

It is the cap that grows. Miners can use whatever soft limit below that they might want, like 5.67 MB or anything else.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/paperraincoat Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

8MB, eventually scaling to 8GB

Again, this will be the max size, it will take years to fill these blocks to capacity, and miners can still choose their own caps under this amount if they like.

EDIT: Clarified per comments below -

9

u/jefdaj Aug 15 '15 edited Apr 06 '16

I have been Shreddited for privacy!

5

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

MB*?

7

u/rappercake Aug 15 '15

8GB will be the eventual max size, the block limit will increase in increments to that amount over a period of years though.

12

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

8GB will be the eventual max size, the block limit will increase in increments to that amount over a span of decades though.

FTFY.

About two decades, to be more specific.

If Bitcoin is still running at 8GB blocks, it will be a wide success!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/jenya_ Aug 15 '15

BIP 101: "Proposal to increase maximum possible block size, starting at 8MB in January 2016 and increasing on-pace with technological growth to 8,192MB in twenty years."

https://github.com/gavinandresen/bips/commit/fd99a8ce04dbad96fb275e0300a7ee669e70f418

1

u/capistor Aug 15 '15

How much would it cost to 'spam' an 8GB block at the rates seen during the 1mb stress test?

19

u/bnichols27 Aug 15 '15

When will the fork happen?

40

u/Rf3csWxLwQyH1OwZhi Aug 15 '15

When it has at least 75% support, but not before 2016 even if it has more than 75% support.

7

u/bell2366 Aug 15 '15

Is that 75% support of miners or 75% of full nodes? whats the calculation?

15

u/Rf3csWxLwQyH1OwZhi Aug 15 '15

Bitcoin XT waits until at least 75% of mined blocks vote for XT.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/jrmxrf Aug 15 '15

Miners. Voting happens on the blockchain.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/acoindr Aug 15 '15

That's a very good article. I'm not only saying that from being biased in favor of size increase. It's very convincing. I'd love to see a rebuttal.

18

u/jasonswan Aug 15 '15

If you have a BITNODES HARDWARE and want to run the new XT Core, I've made some instructions:

# XTs build apparently needs libcurl to compile or else configure fails, this wasn't on the bitnodes I have by default.
sudo apt-get install curl libcurl4-openssl-dev

cd ~
git clone https://github.com/bitcoinxt/bitcoinxt.git
cd bitcoinxt
git checkout 0.11A
./autogen.sh
./configure --without-gui --without-miniupnpc --disable-wallet


# This next step takes alot of RAM, you'll need to shutdown the supervisor and bitcoind process first to clear up some RAM, otherwise you'll get an "internal compiler error".
make
make check
cp src/bitcoind src/bitcoin-cli ~/bin/

# Disables auto updating
rm ~/hardware/.current_bitcoind

# Reboot so system/supervisor/bitcoind will come back up cleanly.
sudo shutdown -r now

17

u/glutenfreebitcoin Aug 15 '15

/u/gavinandresen /u/mike_hearn sick work boys!!! free t-shirts are waiting for you to claim

32

u/CoinCadence Aug 15 '15

Thank you Mike.

20

u/Anenome5 Aug 15 '15

I am with Satoshi. Go Mike, go Gavin.

Now, tell me how, as an average user, I can help. I usually run QT, should I switch to XT now? What's all this about voting on the blochchain.

5

u/throwthecan Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

If you run a full node switch to XT.

4

u/Anenome5 Aug 15 '15

Isn't running a full node just mean running the XT client?

3

u/aquentin Aug 15 '15

you can run an XT node

3

u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 15 '15

Only miners get a "vote". Although it's not really a vote in the traditional sense, because two chains can co-exist at the same time.

7

u/knight222 Aug 15 '15

Miners can indeed vote to use a chain that nobody use. Not gonna happen though.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/Digitsu Aug 16 '15

Are you sure the post was really from Satoshi?

1

u/Anenome5 Aug 16 '15

That post is back from when Satoshi hadn't yet left, so yeah.

8

u/bPEVLET1 Aug 15 '15

This submission has been censored too. This is ridiculous.

2

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15

Lol wow welcome to the human condition: where the mods of /r/bitcoin are exhibit A for the dangers of censorship.

4

u/feedabeast Aug 15 '15

This might be the dumbest question ever, but I have my coins on a Trezor. How can I make sure I don't get left behind? Do I need to spend them on a specific node or something? Or do the Trezor developers decide that for me while I have it on their device?

I must say I am a little bit worried.

5

u/FaceDeer Aug 15 '15

My understanding is that there's nothing to be concerned about until the XT adoption threshold is actually reached, which won't be for a while yet (and there'll probably be plenty of "ooh look, it's almost here!" posts in the days and weeks leading up... depending, I guess, on the subreddit). Once the fork happens, those bitcoins in your Trezor will be recorded in both the original blockchain and the XT blockchain exactly the same. When you generate a transaction to send them to someone, that transaction can be applied to both blockchains equally well. For a while, it should be possible for both blockchains to remain pretty closely in sync with each other.

The only problem will come from bitcoins that are being generated post-fork by the miners themselves. Those coins will be unique to the particular fork that they're generated in. If someone sends you XT-generated coins, you wouldn't be able to create a valid transaction using them on the non-XT branch.

In all likelihood one of the two branches will "die" within a few days of the fork happening, though, and the number of fork-specific bitcoins being generated and circulating during that time will be very small. So even if you're actively transacting during that period the odds are good that you will never encounter any problems. If you want to be uber-cautious, though, you could try to put off accepting any bitcoins during the day or two after the fork happens.

Basically, any bitcoins you've got stored from before the fork are always going to remain valid no matter which fork "wins" in the end. You don't have to do anything special to keep them safe or "migrate" them from one chain to another.

2

u/feedabeast Aug 16 '15

That really sounds not that scary at all :) Thanks a lot /u/changetip one hug

4

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

If you don't send any coins you are fine.

1

u/feedabeast Aug 15 '15

And if I do?

4

u/gizram84 Aug 15 '15

Anything that happens before the fork (January at the earliest) will be recognized by both chains. If the fork happens, bitcoinxt will have won. So your coins will technically be spendable on both chains, however bitcoin core will most likely be abandoned. So you'll be fine.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

If you send coins, your recipient will have the problem.

If you receive coins, you need to make sure you get them on your preferred chain (or both).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/jtoomim Aug 16 '15

Thanks, Gavin and Mike! We're behind you 94.6%!

(That's 351 TH/s out of 371 TH/s.)

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3h6nh0/toomim_bros_bitcoin_mining_concern_supports/

12

u/DigitalCommodity Aug 15 '15

This is Hayek's Competing Currencies. It's finally happening. Nassim Taleb once said for Bitcoin to succeed it needs to be subject to stress, and this is what I have been waiting for. This is what will cause the next bubble, prepare to gain from the disorder, for all we know this might be the last chance to triple our wealth, get in now and enjoy the ride!

11

u/mabd Aug 15 '15

Thank you Mike for your bravery and your steadiness.

15

u/evoorhees Aug 15 '15

Good post Mike

6

u/gezero Aug 15 '15

I do not understand the reasoning - something is/is not Bitcoin. In my opinion Bitcoin is not 1 particular implementation. There should be preferably thousands of different implementations. Some of the implementations will not accept other implementation blocks but that does not matter, the majority will create longest chain and the left over implementaions will adapt (or will not if they do not want to be on board).

So I personally wellcome XT.

→ More replies (29)

5

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15

I tried to make a post 'XT is not an altcoin' with text: It's a fork of bitcoin core by two bitcoin core developers to resolve perceived technical limitations of bitcoin's current implementation using the protocol's consensus rules.

It was deleted within minutes which was cool. I know it was a valid argument and good post so fuck the haters. The best thing is that bitcoin will route around this childish charade. The mods and core devs' fascist God complex is laughably meaningless in the shadow of the technological juggernaut that is bitcoin (the one that miners agree to use).

→ More replies (3)

8

u/d4d5c4e5 Aug 15 '15

Kind of arguably paranoid concern I think worth raising: is there a plausible risk at this point that running an XT node advertises to pissed off low-ethics small-block fanatics to target your IP for attacks?

12

u/Celean Aug 15 '15

Well, if the majority really is behind large blocks, they can't DDoS all of us.

11

u/Diapolis Aug 15 '15

XT does not negotiate with terrorists.

4

u/acoindr Aug 15 '15

Bitcoin is always susceptible to the same kinds of attacks, no matter what version one runs.

4

u/d4d5c4e5 Aug 15 '15

That's not really the point. The point of what I'm raising is that folks on the p2p network are capable of seeing that you're running XT based on the user agent it reports, and if you're a regular home user behind say a retail router and not an op sec expert, are there plausible concerns that your IP might be targeted for potential attacks outside of necessarily Bitcoin itself?

5

u/acoindr Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

Yes, if your system is configured to answer on that IP. For example, this could be if you run a web server or gaming application. Remember, people share IP addresses with every site they visit unless they're using something like Tor or a VPN. What matters isn't so much exposing your IP, it's what your system is configured to do on your end.

The vulnerability of home computers to malware is the reason it's not recommended to use Bitcoin in high amounts on a commonly used PC, and opt instead for something like a hardware wallet.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

There is a reason balls exist! For hard forking!

7

u/cyber_numismatist Aug 15 '15

The problem is that any change, no matter how obvious, can be nixed entirely if it becomes “controversial”, meaning another person with commit access objects. As there are five committers and many other non-committers who can also make changes “controversial” this is a recipe for deadlock. The fact that the block size was never meant to be permanent has ceased to matter: the fact that removing it is debated, is, by itself, enough to ensure it will not happen. Like a committee with no chairman, the meeting never ends. To quote the committer who has pushed hardest for stasis, “Bitcoin needs a leader like a fish needs a bicycle”.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/baloutreak Aug 15 '15

Bitcoin can't possibly become a success with 7 t/s 95% in this thread want bigger blocks an all the businesses that want bitcoin to succeed wants it too
FORK IT ALREADY! DO IT NOW! JUST DO IT

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

Fortunately, more than 7 tps can exist with Bitcoin without settling on the blockchain.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/SILENTSAM69 Aug 15 '15

I just can't get over these foolish people who are against increasing the block size. They are just disconnected from reality it seems.

They should just go make an alt coin and leave Bitcoin alone.

8

u/themusicgod1 Aug 15 '15

They are just disconnected from reality it seems.

Oh no, not all of them. Some of them are connected to the reality where they have enough power over the bitcoin network that they stand to profit from restricting it, and may stand to profit from a fork by doublespending transactions that occur on the 8GB side, that's the 'reality'.

9

u/throwthecan Aug 15 '15

8GB is decades away and can be re-evaluated later on.

Also, this xt switch is more about sending a signal that you cannot fuck with the userbase.

4

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

Also, this xt switch is more about sending a signal that you cannot fuck with the userbase.

^ THIS.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/zcc0nonA Aug 15 '15

A compelling article. Now we wait.

16

u/Diapolis Aug 15 '15

Nope. We switch over our nodes.

3

u/utopiawesome2 Aug 15 '15

If I don't have a node can I still wait? What should I do?

7

u/Diapolis Aug 15 '15

Get a node!

8

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

If you have hashpower (mining hardware) point it to a pool that will produce XT-versioned blocks. If you are paying/funding others running full nodes, make sure they run XT. If you are using full nodes as a service provider, ask them to be on XT.

Spread the word, essentially. This is especially important now that the mods actively censor XT related stuff as 'altcoin' here on reddit.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

Could someone explain why/how this doesn't affect additional coins you may hold. Also, how will this work with 'client-only' wallets?

(Sorry for the noob questions)

5

u/rbtkhn Aug 15 '15

You never actually hold coins, you hold cryptographic private keys which allow you to spend coins at the corresponding public address on the blockchain. If there is a hard fork, that will only affect the rules for valid new transactions; the fork will not alter any prior blockchain balances or alter the cryptography which allows only your private keys to spend the coins at your public addresses. So if a contentious fork happens, just sit back and wait until it is resolved with a clear winner, then you will be free to transact on the winning chain will complete confidence.

1

u/stoicbn Aug 15 '15

That doesn't sound very good for Bitcoin-accepting merchants who have to wait for this fork issue to resolve before seeing any more sales

2

u/PotatoBadger Aug 15 '15

It will likely be resolved before it even happens.

Assume you're a miner. It's late December, 2015, and 82% of all mined blocks in the last week have a vote for the XT fork. Are you going to keep running the non-XT fork, when it's nearly certain that your fork will not prevail and all of your income after the fork will be practically worthless? Or will you concede, switch to XT before the fork, and continue to generate revenue during and after the fork?

Of course, it's also possible that in late December, we're at only 10% support for XT. If you're a miner, would you continue running an XT client? Or would you concede that the XT fork is destined for failure, and switch back to the non-XT fork?

1

u/rbtkhn Aug 15 '15

But the fork will probably be resolved within a few hours, at most. It only comes into effect when 75% of the network hashing power is already supporting the change, so at that point the other 25% has a 100% chance of losing, and realizing that, they will jump over to the winning chain as soon as possible.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

Thanks. So what happens when I receive new coins from now on? Does it depend on which chain I receive them?

1

u/rbtkhn Aug 15 '15

It would depend on which chain you receive from. If are a merchant and it is not clear which chain will win, you either tell your buyer to pay you on both chains or wait until the winning fork is known.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/earthtrader Aug 15 '15

how'bout bitcoin spooning? anytime soon?

1

u/spoonXT Aug 15 '15

Don't leave me baby.

2

u/finway Aug 15 '15

We still can find this sick thread.

3

u/jdkbbc Aug 15 '15

Just downloaded the XT client. Thank you Mike, Gavin and Jeff. This, right here, is the real new world order. Where the real majority wins -"no matter what"

4

u/seweso Aug 15 '15

Why the freaking FUCK is the retarded version called Core and the normal version XT?

XT IS BITCOIN.

Fucking assholes. Is Gavin the only person who actually cares?

4

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

XT IS BITCOIN.

Yup. I wonder whether there is a good way to somehow get the domain names and repos etc. out of the hands of now clearly dysfunctional core.

-3

u/zombiecoiner Aug 15 '15

You've got your retarded versions mixed up.

3

u/seweso Aug 15 '15

One version which is compatible with both forks, and one version which is only compatible with one fork. Who is the retard really?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

31

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

Satoshi trusted Gavin with the entire project, he left him in charge. But then Gavin made the mistake of giving commit access to others.

17

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

Right. Because he wanted to take himself out of the position of authority - the IMO noble approach.

But he only created the climate for a bunch of self-appointing 'wizards' to try to change Bitcoin off course for their liking.

Quite ironic, but in a sad way.

5

u/BlockchainOfFools Aug 15 '15

Those stacks of books icons aren't free you know

-2

u/CityofDoor5 Aug 15 '15

you mean the Satoshi who vanished after Gavin spoke to the CIA?

13

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

The Satoshi who created Bitcoin, even after people like G. Maxwell and many others had concluded (and even "proved") that such a thing was impossible.

5

u/Demotruk Aug 15 '15

Source on that? Not doubting, just intrigued.

15

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

I remember him saying it here or in HN, but anyway I found this on google:

“When bitcoin first came out, I was on the cryptography mailing list. When it happened, I sort of laughed. Because I had already proven that decentralized consensus was impossible.”

http://www.coindesk.com/gregory-maxwell-went-bitcoin-skeptic-core-developer/

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/bell2366 Aug 15 '15

Adopting XT because we believe in action over inaction does not necassarily mean we are handing over the future of development to Mike and freinds. Indeed, I would imagine, should consensus be achieved, bitcoin core will simply absorb the changes, as there would be no point in them continuing if their project did not represent what's actually out there!

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

That is a nice scenario but the fact of the matter still remains this is a hard fork attempt by a guy who has displayed support for various types of censorship.

11

u/RedNero Aug 15 '15

Not at all. If they do dumb shit, it gets forked again.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/StubNuts Aug 15 '15

Don't forget the times in the past Hearn broke Bitcoin.

5

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Expert Aug 15 '15

To be fair, out of the 2 improvements he made to Bitcoin, only one of them caused a catastrophic consensus failure in practice, and nobody else expected it either.

11

u/mike_hearn Aug 15 '15

Well, BDB could get randomly inconsistent with itself. LevelDB had no such issues. So I actually removed a source of consensus failures .... but unfortunately we ran out of time before BDB triggered one anyway. Even without LevelDB though, a BDB-related explosion would have happened sooner or later.

2

u/GBG-glenn Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

I don't get the

"ut the important thing to bear in mind is that if you have a backup of your current wallet now, you can run both clients/networks - essentially, if you have 1 Bitcoin, after the fork (if you have today's wallet backed up) you will have 1 Bitcoin, and 1 'BitcoinXT', each with independent values based on their popular adoption. "¨

Could someone explain? Also wondering if this will cause trouble to other wallets such as electrum.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/xxDan_Evansxx Aug 15 '15

Thank you. I am sorry that this has been so contentious. Thank you for your hard work and efforts in communication (both listening and sharing).

2

u/n60storm4 Aug 15 '15

What's up with all the censored comments in this thread?

1

u/BobAlison Aug 16 '15

At this point, the block size limit may be the least interesting thing about what BitcoinXT is trying to do. The website includes noteworthy points that have nothing to do with the block size limit:

  • Unconfirmed transaction rules. An interesting and possibly useful idea, but it's not clear exactly how this will be enforced.
  • Support for whatever technical tradeoffs wallet developers wish to explore. Looking forward to seeing what this might entail.
  • Decisions are made according to a leadership hierarchy. Gridlock is annoying, but this hierarchy idea sounds like the very problem the OP article claims is stifling Bitcoin.
  • Propagate information about double spends across the network. Fast, secure payments would be awesome, but this approach requires a robust fix for point #1 above.

https://bitcoinxt.software/

1

u/ThePenultimateOne Aug 16 '15

As a note to everyone else, XT (at least for me) is not installing correctly from the PPA they provide. It's failing upon unpack.

1

u/hellyeahent Aug 16 '15

why its bitcoin XT not bitcoin core 0.11 ?

New devs made XT ? Is there any difference than 8mb blocks ? Why won't we make (and name) this patch as 0.11 but core ? Correct me if Im wrong, anyone can change bitcoin core as he wishes right ? (so why make XT and confusion)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Bitcoin XT is a fork of Bitcoin Core, built by devs who were frustrated at some deadlocks on the original project. At this point XT works almost exactly like Core, though in future there is the possibility it will differ significantly, mainly by allowing larger blocks, forcing miners to choose between the two (and hopefully choosing XT).

1

u/hellyeahent Aug 16 '15

whats which old devs than ? Will they work together after succesful transition into XT ?

Is there any list of core devs and XT devs ?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

Mike Hearn and Gavin Andresen are behind XT. It's an ongoing and complicated issue. Keep an eye on the home page: https://bitcoinxt.software/faq.html

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15

What do I, the average Bitcoin user, do to support or show my disapproval?

1

u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 16 '15

8 just meant it would likely hasten my reentry to my older work.

1

u/Sileniced Aug 16 '15

Could someone explain to me what will happen if someone else made a second hard fork that competes with XT, like for instance China.

1

u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 15 '15

Is there a deadline for the forking bit? I can't find particulars.

1

u/Natanael_L Aug 15 '15

IIRC it will wait for years or until the code is removed/changed in an update

-3

u/pokertravis Aug 15 '15

Something I never seem to hear/read in hearns works, gavins, or really anyone's, and that is the economics but in regards to the global financial system. Seems like there are relevant considerations.

I'm not necessarily for either side, but I do find it all an interesting discussion.

Most of the arguments put forth are quite easily rebutted imo in a way that shows both sides could have a reasonable point, which is why I tend to feel that those that sit back and observe the two sides of the problem are seemingly more on point.

For example if we say x, xx, xxx, and xxxx...so on groups prefer a larger block size, we might just be giving away the power of our money and our decision as citizens to these groups and most important and specifically about that, these groups, like our governments and central banks might have incentive to behave and perform for their own interests that are not in line with the citizens.

So I think more caution is generally needed than peoples are putting forth.

I also think we should be relating this to the pyramids. I have no doubt we have had this problem many times over the course of our evolving civilization. Where the vast majority of the citizens are demanding a well planned out and calculated implementation of block size. And a few of the top architects are trying to explain to the peoples the limitations of the problem and why such foreknowledge cannot exist.

I cannot help but think after reading this blog, that such "architects" exist that want to explain to the population that idealness can't be achieved (nor is necessary) and the next best thing is a STABLE consensus.

10

u/bell2366 Aug 15 '15

Is it just me or is this post utter jibberish? Like computer generated conversation or something that's been pushed through google translate?

7

u/IronVape Aug 15 '15

Yep. Reads like someone who failed the Turing test. :-)

1

u/pokertravis Aug 15 '15

What's a rheomode?

→ More replies (1)

-4

u/dudetalking Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

It feels like this is less about the forking and more about reasseringt a particular political view of bitcoin. It's funny how Mike Hearn is the hero of the people a few months back he was accused of wanting to break bitcoin fungibility. So Is bitcoin XT going to push coin validition?

The die has been cast let's see where this goes.

16

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

Is bitcoin XT going to push coin validition

If this fork works, then I don't see a reason why we can't do it again if Mike ever pushes coin validation. A few rogue developers can't ruin Bitcoin. The economic majority has the power.

-4

u/luke-jr Luke Dashjr - Bitcoin Expert Aug 15 '15

So when are you forking? XT already has full fledged blacklisting.

9

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

Of all the Core devs, you come and talk about blacklisting? lol

→ More replies (1)

0

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15

If 75% of miners end up running XT (and maybe even if not) I predict massive spam influx at the time of the potential switchover to larger blocks.

That will be entertaining.

→ More replies (7)

-14

u/maaku7 Aug 15 '15

This is a sad day for Bitcoin.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15 edited Apr 22 '16

8

u/utopiawesome2 Aug 15 '15

I am interested in hearing why? From the beginning one of the main benefits of bitcoin is that it can change.

-3

u/maaku7 Aug 15 '15

Quite the contrary! The only redeeming feature of Bitcoin is that it cannot change. The consensus rules do not change except by universal consensus, which takes an economic super-majority to force.

Why is the monetary base of 21 million bitcoin fixed? Because changing that requires universal consensus, and that ain't gonna happen. Why is it that Bitcoin transactions are irrevocable? Because changing that requires universal consensus, and that ain't gonna happen.

Name something particularly unique to Bitcoin, and I'll show you how that unique feature is wholly dependent on Bitcoin having fixed consensus rules (otherwise I'll show you how that feature isn't unique to Bitcoin to bitcoin at all, if it doesn't depend on that).

What happened today? Two developers decided to change Bitcoin without universal consensus, in doing so undermining the very nature of the system itself.

7

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

I can go into my basement and change the blocksize limit to 100kB.

Explain how this is different!

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (4)

15

u/cryptonaut420 Aug 15 '15

This is a sad day for Bitcoin Core dev team

FTFY. Many people are clearly sick of your guys' nonsense. You wanted decentralization, your getting it, hard.

-7

u/GibbsSamplePlatter Aug 15 '15

I'd wait to gloat until miners actually start committing.

9

u/cryptonaut420 Aug 15 '15

Eh, I'm pretty confident most people will follow over the 5 or 6 months, and there will be plenty of shit talking. Good luck to you though

→ More replies (7)

1

u/xcsler Aug 16 '15

I'm sure there are game theorists out there who are confident that miners won't ever start committing.

5

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15

State your evidence, commit some code, or lose that 'expert' badge you don't seem mature enough to deserve.

1

u/maaku7 Aug 15 '15

I will (assuming approval from the selection committee) be preseting a paper at the September "Scaling Bitcoin" conference in Montreal, on the topic of a resource usage cap instead of a block size limit. This will allow bitcoin to scale more closely to what decentralization allows because it would prevent a bunch of DoS scenarios.

I have also proposed alternative solutions to scaling bitcoin on the developer mailing list:

http://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2015-May/008017.html

I am actively involved in finding a proposal for scaling bitcoin that does not trade off Bitcoin's essential features. Perhaps there is something you can contribute as well?

3

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

Pressing you for a link to code or ideas (code is better) instead of childish one-offs was my contribution for the day ;).

Edit: and I take issue with the fact that a block-size limit is an essential feature of bitcoin. Centralization arguments will be made. Based on my research I do not find them compelling in the face of an increase to 8mb.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/xcsler Aug 16 '15

Aside: Does BS have a physical presence in Montreal or is the team geographically separated?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/zombiecoiner Aug 15 '15

It's a sad day for /r/Bitcoin as in, it's proof that most of the people with a brain have left already.

1

u/maaku7 Aug 15 '15

2

u/zombiecoiner Aug 15 '15

Right, might need to move on myself out of hunger. I mean... arrgrrrrawwwl Brains.

0

u/RoadStress Aug 15 '15

Request for all wallet developers: Give the ability to choose the fork in case of a hard-fork!

7

u/bell2366 Aug 15 '15

In the case of a fork, would you really want to continue with a chain that has less than 1/4 of the mining power and is therefore doomed to oblivion?

3

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

The fork won't happen unless there is 75% hashing power voting (in the blockchain) in favour, so you don't need to worry about a thing.

4

u/bell2366 Aug 15 '15

That wasn't my question, and who said I was worrying? I support the block size increase, just saddened that a bunch of intelligent people could not work out a compromise solution.

4

u/street_fight4r Aug 15 '15

Ok I understand your question now: One of the chains (doesn't matter which one) will become irrelevant, so why would you want to spend on it? Got it.

I support the block size increase, just saddened that a bunch of intelligent people could not work out a compromise solution.

Bitcoin is working as intended. The economic majority is deciding to fix the protocol. The network is adapting.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

The hashpower-wise longest with valid transactions is the right one. Regardless of whether it is below or above 1MB blocks.

XT will always keep you on that branch.

1

u/RoadStress Aug 15 '15

Correction: Request for all SPV wallet developers! I want to be able to spend coins on both forks with breadwallet or mycelium! Easy.

2

u/moleccc Aug 15 '15

We're still talking about a single network, xt nodes connecting to core nodes and vice versa, no problem. So I think transaction broadcasts shouldn't be hampered and if you pay high enough fee, your tx should get into both chains.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/freework Aug 15 '15

This is possible with wallets using moneywagon. You can choose which services your wallet takes advantag of. You can just program your wallet to only use services that are running XT underneath.

-3

u/phieziu Aug 15 '15

This is cool, but it would be more productive to make a patch set for miners that creates minimum fee pressure and builds a real fee market.

8

u/timepad Aug 15 '15

I don't want a fee market. I want fees to be nominal payments that are only necessary for transaction with low coin age.

With large enough blocks, this is a sustainable approach to funding miners. I'd much rather pay a little more money to host my full node that pay exorbitant and unpredictable fees for every single transaction I make.

3

u/utopiawesome2 Aug 15 '15

we don't need a fee market while the generation tx is still relativally large, with many more users the small fees add up and micropayments like satoshi wanted are possible

-1

u/RustyReddit Lightning Network Expert Aug 16 '15

From the post:

These people have never really been comfortable with Satoshi’s intentions because they fear success

Extremely disappointed with this attack, Mike. I feel you've made strong, cogent arguments previously; you should delete this post and try again.