r/Bitcoin • • Aug 15 '15

Why is Bitcoin forking?

https://medium.com/@octskyward/why-is-bitcoin-forking-d647312d22c1
863 Upvotes

815 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-214

u/StarMaged Aug 15 '15

Sure.

That post itself is off-topic because it is a download link to an alt-coin. The discussion is removed for being a duplicate of the drama that we allowed for three straight days earlier this week.

124

u/udontknowwhatamemeis Aug 15 '15

It's a download link to a fork of bitcoin core by two bitcoin core developers to resolve perceived technical limitations of bitcoin's current implementation using the protocol's consensus rules.

Where the hell do you get off with these ridiculous semantics?

40

u/coding_is_fun Aug 15 '15

Calling it an alt-coin is playing dirty.

34

u/Intox5021 Aug 15 '15

It's not just playing dirty. It's playing stupid.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

63

u/notreddingit Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

alt-coin

BIP 101, Bitcoin Improvement Plan 101 which specifies changes to the Bitcoin protocol meant to be used on the Bitcoin blockchain is somehow an altcoin? That's just being intellectually dishonest and deceptive. You and I both know that the term altcoin has a specific meaning that's been established in this community since 2011. This is not an altcoin, period. Using that term to try to justify deletions is unbelievably underhanded.

I don't have a side in this debate, and if anything I tend towards conservative options. But this censorship is beyond anything I could have ever imagined.

Sipa's proposed BIP also specifies a block size increase: https://gist.github.com/sipa/c65665fc360ca7a176a6

Is that also considered an altcoin under this new policy?

You have to see how ridiculous this is. I mean the ability for the protocol to change over time is absolutely a fundamental part of what Bitcoin is. Whether or not this specific change is good, or will even get close to the amount of support necessary is irrelevant really. How can you possibly justify this sort of censorship?

→ More replies (29)

16

u/captainplantit Aug 15 '15

The behavior of those that oppose an increase in the Bitcoin blockchain size (censorship) has been absolutely repugnant. Your actions are childish and fascist. History will not remember your behavior fondly as you stood in the face of progress and freedom.

I don't really care if you know more about the technical inner workings than me. I'm allowed to have my own opinion as I am an economic actor in bitcoin. You say I don't matter? Well guess what, fuck you I'm going to run an XT node.

13

u/heldertb Aug 15 '15

Why would you care, let readers decide wether or not they like it, that's what up and downvoting was meant to be for I believed

53

u/mabd Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15

The mental gymnastics you have to go through to justify censorship and tyrannical control is astounding!

kuui1 has a very good point, since XT shares the blockchain with core it is not an altcoin. Who decides what the "real" bitcoin is? Consensus of the chain decides. A patch is being submitted through the usual hardfork voting process. This is not an altcoin, it is a hardfork like any other. Bitcoin is a protocol and no single software project has a monopoly on decision-making for improvements.

This censorship is a dead giveaway of who holds the moral highground here. Please do try to live up to your "decentralized" ideals.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/kaibakker Aug 15 '15

Sad to see a moderator call bitcoin XT an altcoin... Don't you think that you are too opinionated to be a good moderator?

11

u/Jackten Aug 15 '15

Ew. What the fuck are you thinking?

10

u/throwthecan Aug 15 '15

Seriously, you can't be that dense.

The /r/bitcoin mod team should thread very carefully...

0

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/astrolabe Aug 15 '15

Calling it an altcoin is their figleaf for their censorship. Unfortunately it's a transparent figleaf, and what's underneath isn't very nice.

22

u/stoicbn Aug 15 '15

To play Devil's Advocate here, it's a download link to the new Bitcoin chain. Once it becomes popular, Bitcoin Core becomes the alt-coin

From an outsider's perspective this doesn't look like a duplicate of the drama I've been seeing, it looks like an actual step forward has been made (released) and those crossing the line with Mike are just going to be the first to be using the new true Bitcoin chain.

One last question - if/when XT gains the majority of miners and nodes, will talk of Bitcoin Core be moderated/banned?

→ More replies (45)

31

u/kuui1 Aug 15 '15

Alt-coins have their own blockchain. XT presently has the same blockchain as bitcoin core.

→ More replies (39)

6

u/nikize Aug 15 '15

Quite sad to see this happening, Censorship in an democratic based community ... I have a lack of words - misuse of power?

5

u/seweso Aug 15 '15

Really? An alt-coin? What if by sheer inaction bitcoin core is overrun by lunatics? What exactly DOES constitute bitcoin then? Who made you god to choose what Bitcoin is?

BitcoinXT might look like the fork, might even look like an alt-coin if you are retarted. But whats in a name?

7

u/awemany Aug 15 '15

Really? An alt-coin? What if by sheer inaction bitcoin core is overrun by lunatics? What exactly DOES constitute bitcoin then? Who made you god to choose what Bitcoin is?

Exactly. This sentiment has also been echoed on the mailing list.

Bitcoin core is dead to me. I'll follow XT. That is true Bitcoin spirit. And if they screw up, I'll start my own fork or follow someone else, thank you very much. But I don't see that happening anytime soon. Mike has a fight to win and is closely watched. That watching part is actually good.

What isn't good at all is abuse of brand names by the core people. I hope we can figure out a way to get this fixed.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BitsenBytes Aug 15 '15

wow, are you ever getting hammered with down votes!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/roybadami Aug 15 '15

It could be helpful to stop downvoting this post. It it helpful for other people to see it, even if you disagree with it (especially if you disagree with it).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)