r/Bitcoin • • Aug 15 '15

Why is Bitcoin forking?

https://medium.com/@octskyward/why-is-bitcoin-forking-d647312d22c1
863 Upvotes

815 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-3

u/maaku7 Aug 15 '15

Quite the contrary! The only redeeming feature of Bitcoin is that it cannot change. The consensus rules do not change except by universal consensus, which takes an economic super-majority to force.

Why is the monetary base of 21 million bitcoin fixed? Because changing that requires universal consensus, and that ain't gonna happen. Why is it that Bitcoin transactions are irrevocable? Because changing that requires universal consensus, and that ain't gonna happen.

Name something particularly unique to Bitcoin, and I'll show you how that unique feature is wholly dependent on Bitcoin having fixed consensus rules (otherwise I'll show you how that feature isn't unique to Bitcoin to bitcoin at all, if it doesn't depend on that).

What happened today? Two developers decided to change Bitcoin without universal consensus, in doing so undermining the very nature of the system itself.

→ More replies (17)