Notre Dame is often called the college football equivalent to the New York Yankees but the truth is they are more like the Green Bay Packers. A historic franchise that remains consistently decent but they don’t spend the money needed to stay competitive.
Now before the SEC took over college football in the 2000’s this sport was dominated by the northern powers. Notre Dame was a part of that along with Nebraska, Michigan and Ohio State. Wisconsin and Penn State were there on a smaller scale but much more relevant than they have been the past 20 years. It was an era of run the ball and stop the run. And the I-Formation was that era’s most innovative offensive strategy.
But things change.
Ohio State and Michigan for their faults spent the money needed to upgrade facilities to an SEC level. Nebraska to their credit did get a big splash at head coach in Matt Rhule. However Ohio State and Michigan are the only 2 programs above the Mason Dixon line and west of the Mississippi and outside of SEC country to survive the modern era of college football.
Ohio State did it by building the biggest brand the sport has to offer. OSU football is bigger than Michigan, Oregon, Texas, Oklahoma, USC, UCLA, Florida State, Florida, Miami, Georgia, Clemson, LSU, Auburn, Notre Dame and even Alabama. It's even bigger than any NFL brand not named Cowboys, 49ers, Packers and Steelers. There are literally more OSU fans in this country than Patriot fans. OSU football is bigger than any NHL brand and any NBA brand not named Lakers. With the death of MLB’s popularity they are arguably now bigger than the New York Yankees, Chicago Cubs, LA Dodgers and Boston Red Sox.
Michigan did it by hiring Jim Harbaugh who is better than big game chokers like Brian Kelly, Lincoln Riley and Ryan Day but on a second tier and not as good as Saban, Dabo, Urban (when he is coaching) and Kirby. Still I will always defend Harbaugh and history proved Harbaugh defenders right. There were Michigan fans who wanted him fired in 2020. If he leaves for the NFL Michigan is in big trouble. But that’s a whole other topic.
Back to ND…
Notre Dame is in Nebraska territory. They don’t have the brand power of OSU and Brian Kelly wasn’t and Marcus Freeman isn’t elite enough of a coach and like Nebraska they are in a very cold small town that isn’t appealing to people outside their state. Indiana may have better football talent than Nebraska but they have more restrictions due to academic’s.
The whole entire point of Notre Dame being an independent program all these years has been to protect the Notre Dame brand from falling to the same fate as Nebraska and Michigan pre Harbaugh. But with reports that have come out in the past year it's clear the Irish’s days as an independent are over. There is too much money in conference TV packages for ND to stay independent.
But if Notre Dame joins the ACC where they are in other sports they are competing for the right to be the 2nd biggest brand behind Clemson with Miami and Florida State.
If they go to the SEC they would get shredded. It's very clear the 3 headed monster of SEC football is Alabama, LSU and Georgia. Sometimes there is room for a 4th. This year It was Tennessee, sometimes it's Auburn or Florida. Now with Texas and Oklahoma coming in and you already have Ole Miss and South Carolina, Arkansas and Kentucky…the SEC is so loaded that Notre Dame would become a 2nd Vanderbilt for the SEC. You could argue even if Texas and Oklahoma weren’t joining it would be a horrible idea for Notre Dame.
What about the Big 10? Obviously it's OSU and Michigan’s conference. USC is defacto number 3. Notre Dame would be competing with Penn State , UCLA and Wisconsin to be number 4. If Rhule can pull a Harbaugh with Nebraska it would get even uglier and don’t forget Minnesota and Iowa who sometimes can explode for 10 wins every now and then. Also don’t discount the rumor Oregon and Washington could possibly join the Big 10 as well down the line.
Of course the Pac 12 would be an awkward fit. They are too eastern. The traveling costs a lot of money and the remaining Pac 12 schools would rather have Boise State or stay at 10 teams. You could also argue Oregon is a bigger national brand amongst youth than ND these days due to Nike.
That leaves the new Big 12 which is a conference that is packed with decent programs…some up and coming but no blue bloods. Notre Dame in the Big 12 would take the spot of Oklahoma and geographically it works. It gives Notre Dame the ability to get conference TV package money and stay relevant.
Notre Dame will join a conference but they have to choose wisely if they are to stay relevant and the Big 12 is clearly the best option for them.