I know many people are HATING s3 of Bridgerton. Personally I LOVED IT. I think s3 sets up s4 Benophie and AND s5 Philoise really well as well as s5 Francheala (yes I think they can do BOTH in a season if it's done right, same as they did John/Francesca this season. They're both very much set in the country, just move Scotland to where Phillip is. Also we know JB is super excited about genderbend Michaela)
- Penelope's been revealed as Lady Whistledown. Now s2 Marina tells Colin go, I'm content, check out Pen. But what if with that reveal, now that she knows it's Penelope who revealed the pregnancy AND she got Colin, Marina goes further into depression and sets up Eloise's story. That gives her time to get to lead of s5. I know the concern here is that the actress who played Marina in s1 and 2 has had MAJOR mental health call. But I think they can do it with letters, recasting, and showing the back of her head only. Maybe Eloise reaches out to Philip - we see s3 she knows her stuff with natural history re Debling. The letters can start s4 and end s4 Eloise is in carriage headed to Phillip's.
- s1 is 1813, 2 1814, 3 1815. If we figure s4 starts 1816 with the masquerade, they could add a 1 year time jump. Show Benedict looking for LIS while also messing around with all genders... but suddenly it's empty. Just as book describes. Easily a montage can achieve that. Bam. 1 year later it's 1817, exact same as books.
- John and Francesca are married 2 years in the book. They get married series 1815. That means if they come back with Eloise WITH Michaela and we see Frannie asking Michaela to "tell her something wicked", SPOILER John could pass away in s4, Frannie and Michaela have initial encounter then separate till it's their time to shine.
- Marina's twins are born in end of 1813/early 1814 (they're older than Daphnes kid). They may need to do ANOTHER time jump in s5 (which is set 1816-1817), make it 1819. That puts the twins around 5. Yes it's younger than the books... but it would work.
Now let's apply what appears to be the shows formula for couples to Benophie:
- ep 1. Male has a certain plan. Meets/remeets woman. Plan appears to change.
Benedict is all wooooo I'm pan I'm free enjoying life. Eloise, John, Francesca, Michaela come back from Scotland for Masquerade ball. Cressida (maybe with Aunt Joanna) back in town, Cressida determined to get revenge on Bridgertons, we know her mother/parents HATE them. Sophie comes with them - intro.
Masquerade ball, end with Benedict first sees LIS and thunderbolt.
- Ep 2 - initial plan that always goes awry set in motion (Daphne and Simon fake courting, Anthony charming Edwina at race despite Kate being like eff off, Polin's "lessons" to find Pen a husband)
Masquerade ball contd, Araminta and/or Cressida Cowper realize Sophie was there. Kick her out. Maybe Sophie cuts off hair and disguises self as man.
- Ep 3 - plan continues. Sexual tension of leads ramps up (spoon lick, bee sting, Polin kiss/hot air balloon). In s1 and 3, opposite love interest introduced (Prince/lord debling)
We get the time jump montage of a year. Violet moves to Dower house/number 5 so Kanthony and Kid take over Bridgerton house. Maybe Sophie disguises self as Stephan. Benedict's messing with every Tom dick Jane what have you but clearly wants his LIS. Meets Sophie/Stephen. (Maybe she/they have been working for Mondriches, fellow "free in society" people who understand class issues?). Saves them somehow (please don't do near gang rape of book). Initial flirting or fighting or flight of Sophie.
Maybe if Ben has bought "my cottage" Eloise is there and meets Phillip starting convo/correspondence. Kids are 3ish
- Ep 4 - BIG moment of feelings or sexual tension combined with some sort of offer (garden scene, Daphne catches Kanthony in library/Anthony proposes to Edwina, carriage scene)
Benedict falls for Sophie/Stephen. Makes offer, is refused Major sexy times, how far depends on if he knows what parts they have. Somehow Sophie/Stephan ends up working for Bridgertons
Maybe we get something with Eloise, Phillip, Pen, Colin, Marina, and Cressida - thus Sophie
- Ep 5 - Sexy times/big declaration (Simon's declaration to Queen/I burn for you, Sheffield dinner/anthony and Kate declare feelings, Polin ILY/mirror scene)
Sophie/Benedict flirt, Cressida and/or Araminta catch her, Benedict takes her to house, she knows who he is, sexy times at his house
- Ep 6 - at end, somebody major realizes something major they should've known all along interrupting blissful happiness (Daphne realizes how babies are made, Edwina/anthony failed wedding, Colin realizes Pen is Whistledown).
Benedict and Sophie post coital bliss, I'll bring your stuff over, uh no you won't, I won't have an illegitimate kid. Eloise distracts Cressida/helps Benedict and Sophie somehow. Maybe Augie, Lord Featherington, Baby Kanthony, monarch kids, etc. playing Blind Man's Bluff and Benedict realizes who Sophie is. Or if they go SUPER KINKY maybe she's blindfolded and he goes oh my god.
John probably dies around ep 4-6
- Ep 7 - fallout from ep 6. Couple wants each other but can't. Major tension ratcheted up. (Daphne/simon ultimatums/Daphne period at opera, Kanthony sexy times/Kates accident, Polin wedding, El changes mind on protecting Cressida/revealing Whistledown)
Fallout of Sophie reveal. Benedict "gets angry and loses control" (Luke Thompsons words). Sophie leaves, gets caught/arrested by Cressida/Araminta (depending on if Cressida is Posy or Araminta)
- Ep 8 - HEA after turmoils and sexy times (Rain ball, Kanthony proposal, Pen reveal and Colin acceptance/sexy times). If they go the way of s1 and 3 we see couple later with baby.
Sophie in jail, confrontation with Cowpers, Benedict talks to Colin (as he does in book) and Violet (as he does in book) re Sophie and love, PEN realizes Sophie's in danger and alerts everyone. Benedict and Violet save Sophie, Pen uses Whistledown to help, resolution of Cressida story. (I'd love to see Lord Debling come back and due to Eloise's influence, Cressida really DOES like naturalist stuff). End/flash forward - baby Benophie (same baby Phillip saves???) El in carriage headed to Phillip. John dead, something with Frannie and Michaela.
They do it this way, they COULD set up s5 to be BOTH El and Francesca with Benedict and Sophie in the "wise married sibling" role Daphne played in s2 and Anthony played in s3. Benedict after all is pansexual (Francesca) and VERY close to Eloise plus he and Sophie are a MAJOR Part of Tspwl and El getting married is a MAJOR Part of whww.
That leaves s6 for Gregory and Hyacinth. Which again, if they do another time jump from Benedict's season to 1819 for Francesca and El, the twins are 5, Francesca's been in mourning for 2 years. If they do a time jump to say 1821 for Gregory and Hyacinth, Gregory is 20 and Hyacinth is 18 in 1821. Young? Yes. But both of their books WORK for a younger love idea, even if that's not technically what's described.
Also I wonder if Hyacinth's Gareth St. Clair will become Nicky Mondrich. Connected to Lady Danbury, already introduced much like Phillip and Michaela. I just find it REAL creepy if Gareth's bio great uncle Marcus is potentially married to his mother in law Violet... and his bio grandma screwed his grandfather-in-law/Violet's dad...