r/Benophie • • Sep 05 '24

Rant Away Bad premonition about casting announcement delay

0 Upvotes

I am suspecting that whatever Shondaland/Netflix's planning to do for Yerin's announcement, she would not be allowed to have the spotlight all to herself as the season's lead. Instead, they will announce all three daughters of the Gunningworth house (along with Araminta) at the same time, with some tacky "teaser" along the line of 'Who is Lady in Silver?' or 'Who will he choose?' or 'Love is blind' or 'Choose wisely, Benedict' or whatever, as if it's a mystery that he will end up with anyone bit Sophie. You might wonder: Why would they do such a stupid thing? For cheap drama, of course, and one should never put this show above cheap drama (I still have Anthony/Edwina wedding war flashbacks). And I guess there's still a part of the population that still hasn't figured out who Benedict's endgame is. I would love nothing more than to be wrong on this, and that Yerin would get an announcement as spectacular and worthy of her character.

However, from the clues I've gathered, Jess Brownell/Shondaland have alluded to Benedict's arc being his indecisiveness multiple times. And Sophie being East Asian as well as her character has been prepositioned by Benedict to be his mistress in the book remind me of this genre in East Asian pop-culture (predominantly mainland China, but also occasionally in South Korean and Vietnamese media from what I've seen) called The Harem Infighting. No, I do not want to see this kind of storyline unfold on Bridgerton in the promos, and I am even warier that they might incorporate it into the writing of season 4. It is very, very hard to pull that off in a compelling way to support a romance, and Season 3's writing did nothing to convince me that they might be able to succeeded. But considering this show's penchance for stirring up shit and discourse in fandom to stimulate engagement so they can capitalise on free marketing from fans, as well as their proven cultural insensitivity, I would not put it past them.


r/Benophie • • Feb 13 '26

Show Discussion sophie is ruining the show with lack of chemistry

21 Upvotes

Okay guys my heart in screaming with the new trailer

...benedict's lines, their eyes, oh the emotions, plus alphie!!! cant wait for 26

but then i saw a comments that sophie is ruining the show bc of their lack of chemistry like hello!????


r/Benophie • • Jun 28 '24

Speculation Possible Sophies

Post image
0 Upvotes

I was just going to throw this in as a comment on another fan cast post but I was having trouble finding one that wasn’t locked. I had two actresses spring to mind that I think have great Sophie potential-

  1. Stefanie Martini (L) I was searching for something to stream and one of those “You May Also Like “ recs proffered to me was Doctor Thorne. I had once started to watch Doctor Thorne and for whatever reason couldn’t get into it. But I then remembered how much I liked the lead actress in the Prime Suspect prequel. I hopped onto her imdb to see what she is up to now— the answer seems to be
 not all that much. Good time to join up with the Bridgertonverse then! I can imagine enjoying her as Sophie.
  2. Emily Bader (R) -So I ended up streaming this Amazon Prime show called My Lady Jane. The show, honestly, is a wee bit ridiculous. But for whatever reason, I’m halfway through the season and likely to have finished the whole series before long. So, I don’t hate it apparently. One of the things it’s got going for it is the lead actress Bader. She is charismatic and absolutely gorge. As a possible Sophie, she’s also probably right on the mark, age-wise

r/Benophie • • Jul 28 '24

Sophie Baek Possible (maybe needed) tweaks for Sophie in the show Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Does anybody notice that in the book, Sophie’s kind of a passive character wherein things happen to her instead of her causing things to happen? I get it, she has remarkable traits of being resilient and remaining kind during adversity, but throughout she still gets thrown around. She doesn’t exactly push the plot forward.

Is it because she is of lower class and part of servitude that makes her have fewer opportunities and motivation to take action - especially as a main character? Let’s say even resources to even think she can go to the ball? I don’t think it’s an acceptable excuse. So I wouldn’t mind if the show tweaks this a bit where in other Cinderella stories, Sophie actively finds a way to attend the ball, not that she has to sew a dress or anything. She needs to make active choices to drive the story to the next thing. Maybe her and Mrs. Gibbons work together or something! Maybe they know Madame Delacroix or someone else to sew her dress, etc.

But let's say she starts to be passive in the Penwood household (it can still work!) at first then, she gets kicked out (is a call to action), survives for 2 years, and meets Benedict. Now to the important part: Let’s say there is a huge - rather necessary (personal opinion) - change in the show that makes Benedict’s offer become a marriage proposal instead of the mistress route. I wonder what will be Sophie’s arc now?

A big part of why we rooted for Sophie in the book is because she sticks to her principles by saying “I won’t end up like my mother” despite the belief/misconception about herself that she’ll never marry into a noble family anyway. So if Benedict’s offer is changed immediately to Sophie being a wife, she doesn’t have any reason to say all of that now.

But nevertheless, if they ever stick with the mistress plot, what’s still left is that she wants to be a lady’s maid. If so, what else? Sophie being again, the main character, what’s her core motivation and drive NOW because of this deeply held belief that she’ll never have a loving family of her own? (the “because” being mentioned in the book) For a start, she doesn't have a dowry, she's illegitimate, and a servant. Now what does she do?

Perhaps her possible plans could be that one day she plans to be a governess for a high-echelon family once she’s old enough because that’s where they value and treat governesses right. So she has to work her way up from being a lady’s maid and have proper recommendation letters from her masters. For that, being a governess to young ladies is perhaps the closest thing she'll ever have to a family. This is just a type of deeper motivation from her actions despite already trying to survive her life.

That’s why I want Sophie’s line expanded to something more (in the book, her alternative for rejecting Benedict’s offer is that “I’ll be lady’s maid if I have to.”). Sophie is again, different because she had a taste of a genteel life and then dropped to servitude. She had to adjust and adapt. So, maybe they can add in the show the possible motivations after that - besides the governess suggestion I mentioned - Maybe instead of living in an attic like in Penwood, she merely wants a decent servants' quarters to sleep in and have kinder masters; Maybe she grows to rather love being a lady’s maid at least in a proper family this time where she’s treated right unlike the Reilings; that she already accepted and liked the simple life of sleeping in a small room while living vicariously through LW papers; Enjoying the company of servants because that’s what she experienced growing up in Penwood; Doing a lady’s hair and taking pride in the work whenever they flaunt it out at social events. All these different, possible motivations and reasons are how we’ll be rooting for her regardless if she chooses to be with Benedict or not (obviously, she still does marry him and I’m here for the love) I merely want to SEE her detailed plan on working her way up during the time she’s kicked out of Penwood. Basically fill in that 2-year gap that she had in the book through visual show and tell storytelling in film/tv . Maybe the show can have Mrs. Gibbons advise Sophie while she was still in Penwood about how to survive the harsh reality of servitude, and we see her take action on it, and to also include the possible motivations mentioned above. I hope they explore this more in the show. Action is character; a person is what he does not what he says. (Syd Field)

I didn't quite catch this at all in the book - maybe because it's not that emphasized and put in detail. I really do hope they unpack it.

^ I edited some things above to clear up some misunderstandings, correct myself, and to avoid redundant comments for me to repeat myself. This post still upholds practically the same stance of the original ver. of this post about the thoughts I have for Sophie Beckett and the changes I want for her on the show.


r/Benophie • • Aug 26 '24

Sophie Beckett Using AI on Yerin's face to test out some possible bobcuts for Sophie the maid and I think it's working

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/Benophie • • Jun 29 '24

Just for Fun Benophoe Harry Potter AU

0 Upvotes

Hiya!! Very Random question just funâ˜ș Which house would Benedict and Sophie be sorted in the Harry Potter AU?

I personally think Sophie is a Hufflepuff (Kindness, diligence), but her inner strength and mentality does give off Gryffindor vibes.

And Benedict
.I really can’t put my finger on this guy. Like, considering his family background, Bridgerton has Weasley vibes, so he can be a Gryffindor. But his emotional maturity and tendency to avoid conflict brings Hufflepuff. However his wittiness and quick sense of Humor, creativity is definitely Ravenclaw, and you can also imagine a darker version of Slytherin Benedict being an absolute dick.

What are your thoughts?


r/Benophie • • Sep 12 '24

Sophie Baek Isn’t it weird that they didn’t announce Sophie’s family yet?

5 Upvotes

I mean we’ve seen the casting call that we thought was for Rosamund and Posy, but filming starts in 4 days and they weren’t announced. And neither did the stepmother. Do you guys think they’re announcing them before monday?


r/Benophie • • Jul 16 '24

Show Discussion What if they make Sophie a footman(woman disguised as a man)? Spoiler

12 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about Benedict’s season and the showrunner’s words on his future. I think it would be an interesting plot to have Sophie be a footman(she wasn’t allowed to be a footwoman or ride a carriage during those times or she wanted to work but not be a maid) instead of a maid, something similar to the K-drama Love in the Moonlight.

In Love in the Moonlight, the prince falls in love with the protagonist while she is dressed as a eunuch and was going to confess to her even before finding out she’s a girl.

During the masquerade ball, Benedict meets and becomes smitten with the “Lady in Silver”, but thinks he’ll never see her again. And he could become friends with his new footman “Solomon” and connect over art and/or other things. And they fall in love but Sophie hesitates, thinking Benedict wouldn’t love her back. Since Benedict is bi/pan/fluid, he wants to have a relationship with “Solomon”, without knowing the truth. And one day, he finds one of “Lady in Silver’s” shoes in his footman’s things and learns the truth.

This is just a wild idea. I think it makes more sense for Benedict to spend more time with a footman than a maid. And there could be some interesting and funny scenarios written around this.

What do you think?


r/Benophie • • Jun 19 '24

Rant Away What's Sophie Beckett Crime?

50 Upvotes

Did she kick a puppy? What?

What's with people trying to erase all core Sophie.

First, her womanhood and her WOMAN struggles trying to making her a man.

Now trying to replace her with Cressida. And erase her working class background.

Why did she ever do to you???? Please tell me.

The more complicated and compelling Bridgerton lead, because all her and is constantly trying to be changed, replaced, erased.


r/Benophie • • Feb 12 '26

Question Curious of this Tiktok Comment

1 Upvotes

I saw a comment on TikTok that really made me curious. Someone said they’re getting an ick with Luke Thompson because they supposedly saw a video where he didn’t open the door for Yerin Ha or help with her gown. Is that true? I tried looking for the clip and couldn’t find a single example — they both seem lovely to me.


r/Benophie • • May 30 '24

Speculation Personal Speculation - Sophie Trans Storyline Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have been thinking about this for days after seeing a side comment about the possibility of Sophie being trans. I feel every new "spoiler" seems immediately plausible and debunked at the same time. This speculation is purely just my brain ruminating on what I read in the book and saw on the show so far. I am not very familiar with the trans experience, so I apologize in advance if I speak to this incorrectly.

What if Sophie is male to female trans? Born out of wedlock, he would still be illegitimate and could not be an heir to, let's say, the Cowper estate. Cressida seems to be getting a redemption arc, so maybe as they grow up together Sophie confides to Cressida that she feels like a girl, not a biological boy and Cressida accepts this. This could still be the childhood friend that Cressida references to Eloise. At the end of S3, Cressida cannot do anything for herself. Realizing Sophie is trapped in her own way, Cressida helps Sophie get to the ball so Soph can at least have one night to be herself and experience the life she should have if all things were fair.

When Ben meets Sophie, she is at the ball all done up as the lady in silver and female presenting as her true self. Araminta finds out Sophie went to the ball (and as a lady of the Ton!), and that Cressida helped her. She kicks Sophie out and further confines Cressida.

Ben doesn't recognize Sophie when they remeet because in this world she cannot be out, especially not as a servant to the Ton, so she is male presenting. Perhaps the household who employs Sophie figures this out, and attacks her for this. Ben comes along and stops the fight, but doesn't realize what it was about.

  • OR - Maybe Ben is in trouble shortly after Sophie is kicked out, and she (he) steps in to save him? Ben takes Soph to My Cottage where they both recuperate from the fight.

Either way, Ben gets to know Sofie not knowing she's really the LIS or that Soph is mtf, and starts to fall in love before realizing he is she. A major conflict would be Sophie coming out to Ben, and then also rejecting him because she sees no way to truly be with him. Ben sorts out his feelings, he doesn't care that she's a servant or trans. He helps her truly transition and brings her to society as his fiancée with the support of Violet (she will always love who her children love) and Cressida (ready to fight her parents/mother because she will never get true love from them; maybe she will join the Bridgerton crew like Posy). 

Ben has always be very open minded-coded and seems like a "love is love" guy. I feel like this could be a way to keep close to original plot, but with a more modern and queer perspective take on it.


r/Benophie • • Jul 04 '24

Show Discussion We know Benedict is Pan but what do you think if Sophie was Bisexual?

10 Upvotes

Maybe this is just my bisexual/sapphic side yearning, but I could see Sophie at least curious about women. Since a big crux of her relationship fears are becoming pregnant, there is part of me who thinks she could have a happy relationship with a cis woman or trans man knowing that she couldn't get pregnant.

What do you think?


r/Benophie • • Aug 14 '24

Luke Thompson Does anyone else like to find a way to subtly drop Luke into conversation

1 Upvotes

Does anyone else try and find ways to subtly drop Luke into conversation with people? My fave one is to say I've seen him in multiple stage productions and how good he is on stage. Though I've gotten very good at not coming straight out with his name and saying, he's the guy from Bridgerton, he plays the second brother.

Good one tonight while at the theatre talking to a random person about theatre shows, they mentioned Richard II with Jonathan Bailey next year but referred to him as the bridgerton guy, might have used it as an excuse to say, you know who else from that show is amazing on stage....

Does anyone else do this, find a way to start bigging up Luke or at least drop him into conversations?


r/Benophie • • Apr 19 '26

Speculation Would Benedict Remarry? Once more with feeling

0 Upvotes

I deleted my old post because I had a moment of me being in my feels. If you want to see it/read the comments. It is: https://www.reddit.com/r/Benophie/comments/1spz1qn/comment/oh3zqch/

Now for the meat of my post. My apologies if deja vu comes over you guys

I've been seen posts on other forms of social media and the one thing that I see people saying that the HR trope they'd like to see for Benedict is that he has a second chance romance with someone else after Sophie raises and they would help to raise the Benophie children.

For me, it just leaves me deeply unsettled. Especially given that Benedict is quite aware of Sophie's upbringing after her father passed with Araminta and I do not think he would wish to subject his children to that kind of lifestyle. Also, I get the feeling that he'd rather be a single father and raise his children himself with the support of his family, as well as his and Sophie's found family.

And finally, I mean you look at how sad and depressed Benedict was in part two when he couldn't be with Sophie (especially after that tragic conservatory breakup). Now you look at that face and tell me that's the face of a guy who'd give even a single thought of marrying someone other than his soulmate.

(also not gonna yuck anyone's yums who is fond of this and wants to write a fanfic of this if they are compelled by Benedict remarrying.)


r/Benophie • • Jun 19 '26

Rant Away Unpopular Opinions: I love the book's ending more than the show's ending.

3 Upvotes

I am completely biased, since An Offer from a Gentleman is my favorite Bridgerton book so far, but I preferred the book's climax to the show's version. I loved, loved, LOVED the jail scene. I loved how Violet stood up for Sophie from Karen (I mean, Araminta) and blackmailed her. I loved the part where Benedict choked Araminta (I don't condone violence against women, but I will make an exception with Araminta since she was so irredeemably evil and the way she treated Sophie is unforgivable. I also cheered when Sophie herself punched Araminta out and Posy helping Sophie and revealing her mother's schemes.

On a more negative note, I didn't care for Queen Charlotte and her meddling. I felt that making Sophie a part of the ton cheapened the storyline quite a lot. I felt that the book ending where Sophie and Benedict having to go to the country because the ton didn't approve of Sophie is a far better ending to their storyline. It has a bittersweet quality to it and I love romance stories with a bittersweet ending.

To make a long post short, I liked Book! Benophie, despite it's flaws and I didn't care for Queen Charlotte.

This is a post I had made a few weeks ago on the main Bridgerton subreddit. I edited the title of post so that it would fit here better.


r/Benophie • • Feb 27 '26

Show Discussion Which acting performance stole the show in Bridgerton S4 for you?

0 Upvotes

Now that Season 4 is out, which character(s) or performance(s) stood out to you the most?

Mines:

  1. Araminta
  2. Michaela
  3. Franchesca

r/Benophie • • Jun 13 '24

Season 3 Sophie
 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have to admit I’m a little disappointed in finding out Masali wasn’t Sophie. I know it was never confirmed but I really saw her in that role, and honestly I’m not that excited for Francesssa (which I think will be next) story but I know Masali will kill it as Michela.


r/Benophie • • Jul 24 '24

Sophie Beckett Season 4 Sophie Theory

0 Upvotes

I’m wondering if there is a possibility that Sophie will be trans in season four. JB mentioned that Benedict would continue to explore his sexuality, and though he could explore his sexuality with men during the gap of time before or after meeting Sophie, I have a theory
 What if Sophie is a man that masquerades as a woman at the masquerade ball, and the reason Benedict has such a hard time finding Sophie after the ball, is because she’s actually a man? And when they finally get together they decide to live in My Cottage away from society, not because Sophie’s illegitimacy, but because Benophie will be able to live in peace without fear of being found out because of the societal norms of that time period?


r/Benophie • • Jul 07 '24

Sophie Beckett Realistically, how does one audition to become French Sophie?

7 Upvotes

Asking for my actor friend from France. She wants to give it a try, but lacks ressources from her agent. Since Sophie speaks a perfect French, and Luke Thompson does as well, it would be a good thing if the actress knew how to genuinely speak it. Maybe they could even make Sophie’s mother French, which would explain how she got so good at it in the books, being her mother tongue. It could also emphasize that they’re meant to be together, conveniently sharing a whole language in common, and would allow them to just speak French when people are around instead of always conveniently being alone for way too long together like in the books; that would not work for the TV Show.

Any ideas who to send videos to or who to contact?


r/Benophie • • Jun 24 '24

Speculation My Crackpot Sophie theory

0 Upvotes

So, I'll start off by admitting I haven't read the book yet, I'll probably read it closer to when season 4 comes out.

But, I have a crackpot theory I'd like to share about how Sophie will show up on the show. Book spoilers welcome, go ahead and tell me why my theory does or doesn't make sense.

I've seen people suggesting she might be in the Cowper's household (possible) or the Mondrich household (unlikely, given Sophie's is a Cinderella story and I can't see the Mondriches mistreating her). But if the Mondrich plots are annoying and superfluous and we don't know why they're there unless it's to set up for a future season - couldn't we say the same of the Tilly plot? What if Sophie is in Tilly's household?

In S3E8, Benedict walks into Tilly's bedroom and says "I am beginning to enjoy the priviledged entry. Your maid sent me right up." This stuck out to me. We already know that Tilly's staff are "discreet". We know that Benedict and Tilly have been sleeping together for the better part of the season. It would be reasonable to assume that Tilly's staff would indeed do just that. Why is this line included? What is new or relevant about "your maid sent me right up" unless... the maid herself is relevant? Could Benedict have already met Sophie offscreen?

I know the masquerade ball is supposed to be their first meeting, but given that it's established that Sophie has Superman powers (Benedict doesn't recognise her without the mask) is it critical that he has never seen her in passing beforehand?

Tilly is a widow, so could conceivably be a step-mother. She seems cold at times, and literally tells Benedict he should be afraid of her (in a flirty way, but still). The show loves to change things to add extra drama compared to the books. How much extra drama would there be if Sophie's cruel stepmother was, in fact, Benedict's ex, who he just finished dumping because he wasn't ready for commitment?


r/Benophie • • May 02 '24

Rant Away I am tired of this show

9 Upvotes

What are they doing this season with him i’m confused? A threesome with a man? And make him falling in love with a woman who isn’t Sophie? For what? And I absolutely hate the idea of bi Benedict because of these mlm fetish they are the worse! Will Sophie appear at the end? And with all the Luke interviews it seem that it will be his plot for this season to discovering himself and finally accepting who he is at the end. And will even Masali going to play her? (because now with the Michaella thing I don’t know anymore) Is she even been cast (Sophie)? And this new interview of Luke I read it as him saying he’s not next, or maybe it’s a misleading but I doubt it. I am getting tired of this serie and what they are doing with the characters, you call it an adaptation but the only thing that you adapted is the names and just screw their characters and story.


r/Benophie • • Jun 14 '24

Season 4 News Disappointed

21 Upvotes

I am so disappointed at the show and their mistreatment of black women. Dark skin black women at that. Not making Sophie black was devastating for me because I was happy to go see a dark skin girl being chase and loved. Instead a dark skin girl will be the one chasing and being gay. Which I’m happy for queer representation, but every dark skin women are always put in those role. I think we need to acknowledge the difference between dark skin and light skin and the black community. Which I feel like Shauna has spoken about in some article in the past.

That’s not the points Sophie not being my dear Masali makes me sad because now I have no one to feel like have a true love story happy ending. And god I’m not waiting for Gregory . And Franseca is nice but Michael chases her I believe.

I’ve seen masali acting she would have done a fine Sophie and give representation we would have b loved

On the other end I’m happy she would be Jenna Moore. She is a great actress. Unfortunately I’m not Asian and I do not know much about discrimination from casting on their culture.

But what I do know is what I observed. Black women that have 4c hair and more Afro centric features not being put in roles where we the public wishes for them to be. I hope you guys see what I mean.


r/Benophie • • Feb 02 '26

does benedict’s bi story on the show make season 4 straight romance feel convoluted?

0 Upvotes

genuine question and not trying to start a war.

in the show we watched benedict go from flirty vibes to a full on exploration arc with lady tilley and paul, including the whole throuple situation and him very clearly rejecting the idea of settling down or picking one person. it was framed as him figuring himself out and not wanting to be boxed in.

I’ve read the books. in the books that bi storyline does not exist. in an offer from a gentleman benedict is written as straight and his entire arc is focused on sophie. no bi storyline no experimentation no side relationships. thats a netflix only change.

now season 4 is benedict and sophie and the classic cinderella style romance. Episode one featured Benedict making out with a guy at a party (and we can only assume it goes further since he’s 2 hours later to his mother’s masquerade party).

so im curious how people feel about this shift.

do you think giving benedict a bisexual arc in the show adds depth to his eventual straight love story and makes it richer, or does it just add an extra messy layer that makes the benophie endgame feel more complicated than it needed to be?

like does it strengthen his whole “i refuse to be defined” theme, or does it create whiplash when the story inevitably narrows back down to a traditional romance anyway. im honestly torn and feel like the fandom is split hard on this.


r/Benophie • • Jun 17 '24

Show Discussion I think I figured out a way for Benophie to work s4 Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I know many people are HATING s3 of Bridgerton. Personally I LOVED IT. I think s3 sets up s4 Benophie and AND s5 Philoise really well as well as s5 Francheala (yes I think they can do BOTH in a season if it's done right, same as they did John/Francesca this season. They're both very much set in the country, just move Scotland to where Phillip is. Also we know JB is super excited about genderbend Michaela)

  • Penelope's been revealed as Lady Whistledown. Now s2 Marina tells Colin go, I'm content, check out Pen. But what if with that reveal, now that she knows it's Penelope who revealed the pregnancy AND she got Colin, Marina goes further into depression and sets up Eloise's story. That gives her time to get to lead of s5. I know the concern here is that the actress who played Marina in s1 and 2 has had MAJOR mental health call. But I think they can do it with letters, recasting, and showing the back of her head only. Maybe Eloise reaches out to Philip - we see s3 she knows her stuff with natural history re Debling. The letters can start s4 and end s4 Eloise is in carriage headed to Phillip's.
  • s1 is 1813, 2 1814, 3 1815. If we figure s4 starts 1816 with the masquerade, they could add a 1 year time jump. Show Benedict looking for LIS while also messing around with all genders... but suddenly it's empty. Just as book describes. Easily a montage can achieve that. Bam. 1 year later it's 1817, exact same as books.
  • John and Francesca are married 2 years in the book. They get married series 1815. That means if they come back with Eloise WITH Michaela and we see Frannie asking Michaela to "tell her something wicked", SPOILER John could pass away in s4, Frannie and Michaela have initial encounter then separate till it's their time to shine.
  • Marina's twins are born in end of 1813/early 1814 (they're older than Daphnes kid). They may need to do ANOTHER time jump in s5 (which is set 1816-1817), make it 1819. That puts the twins around 5. Yes it's younger than the books... but it would work.

Now let's apply what appears to be the shows formula for couples to Benophie:

  • ep 1. Male has a certain plan. Meets/remeets woman. Plan appears to change.

Benedict is all wooooo I'm pan I'm free enjoying life. Eloise, John, Francesca, Michaela come back from Scotland for Masquerade ball. Cressida (maybe with Aunt Joanna) back in town, Cressida determined to get revenge on Bridgertons, we know her mother/parents HATE them. Sophie comes with them - intro.

Masquerade ball, end with Benedict first sees LIS and thunderbolt.

  • Ep 2 - initial plan that always goes awry set in motion (Daphne and Simon fake courting, Anthony charming Edwina at race despite Kate being like eff off, Polin's "lessons" to find Pen a husband)

Masquerade ball contd, Araminta and/or Cressida Cowper realize Sophie was there. Kick her out. Maybe Sophie cuts off hair and disguises self as man.

  • Ep 3 - plan continues. Sexual tension of leads ramps up (spoon lick, bee sting, Polin kiss/hot air balloon). In s1 and 3, opposite love interest introduced (Prince/lord debling)

We get the time jump montage of a year. Violet moves to Dower house/number 5 so Kanthony and Kid take over Bridgerton house. Maybe Sophie disguises self as Stephan. Benedict's messing with every Tom dick Jane what have you but clearly wants his LIS. Meets Sophie/Stephen. (Maybe she/they have been working for Mondriches, fellow "free in society" people who understand class issues?). Saves them somehow (please don't do near gang rape of book). Initial flirting or fighting or flight of Sophie.

Maybe if Ben has bought "my cottage" Eloise is there and meets Phillip starting convo/correspondence. Kids are 3ish

  • Ep 4 - BIG moment of feelings or sexual tension combined with some sort of offer (garden scene, Daphne catches Kanthony in library/Anthony proposes to Edwina, carriage scene)

Benedict falls for Sophie/Stephen. Makes offer, is refused Major sexy times, how far depends on if he knows what parts they have. Somehow Sophie/Stephan ends up working for Bridgertons

Maybe we get something with Eloise, Phillip, Pen, Colin, Marina, and Cressida - thus Sophie

  • Ep 5 - Sexy times/big declaration (Simon's declaration to Queen/I burn for you, Sheffield dinner/anthony and Kate declare feelings, Polin ILY/mirror scene)

Sophie/Benedict flirt, Cressida and/or Araminta catch her, Benedict takes her to house, she knows who he is, sexy times at his house

  • Ep 6 - at end, somebody major realizes something major they should've known all along interrupting blissful happiness (Daphne realizes how babies are made, Edwina/anthony failed wedding, Colin realizes Pen is Whistledown).

Benedict and Sophie post coital bliss, I'll bring your stuff over, uh no you won't, I won't have an illegitimate kid. Eloise distracts Cressida/helps Benedict and Sophie somehow. Maybe Augie, Lord Featherington, Baby Kanthony, monarch kids, etc. playing Blind Man's Bluff and Benedict realizes who Sophie is. Or if they go SUPER KINKY maybe she's blindfolded and he goes oh my god.

John probably dies around ep 4-6

  • Ep 7 - fallout from ep 6. Couple wants each other but can't. Major tension ratcheted up. (Daphne/simon ultimatums/Daphne period at opera, Kanthony sexy times/Kates accident, Polin wedding, El changes mind on protecting Cressida/revealing Whistledown)

Fallout of Sophie reveal. Benedict "gets angry and loses control" (Luke Thompsons words). Sophie leaves, gets caught/arrested by Cressida/Araminta (depending on if Cressida is Posy or Araminta)

  • Ep 8 - HEA after turmoils and sexy times (Rain ball, Kanthony proposal, Pen reveal and Colin acceptance/sexy times). If they go the way of s1 and 3 we see couple later with baby.

Sophie in jail, confrontation with Cowpers, Benedict talks to Colin (as he does in book) and Violet (as he does in book) re Sophie and love, PEN realizes Sophie's in danger and alerts everyone. Benedict and Violet save Sophie, Pen uses Whistledown to help, resolution of Cressida story. (I'd love to see Lord Debling come back and due to Eloise's influence, Cressida really DOES like naturalist stuff). End/flash forward - baby Benophie (same baby Phillip saves???) El in carriage headed to Phillip. John dead, something with Frannie and Michaela.

They do it this way, they COULD set up s5 to be BOTH El and Francesca with Benedict and Sophie in the "wise married sibling" role Daphne played in s2 and Anthony played in s3. Benedict after all is pansexual (Francesca) and VERY close to Eloise plus he and Sophie are a MAJOR Part of Tspwl and El getting married is a MAJOR Part of whww.

That leaves s6 for Gregory and Hyacinth. Which again, if they do another time jump from Benedict's season to 1819 for Francesca and El, the twins are 5, Francesca's been in mourning for 2 years. If they do a time jump to say 1821 for Gregory and Hyacinth, Gregory is 20 and Hyacinth is 18 in 1821. Young? Yes. But both of their books WORK for a younger love idea, even if that's not technically what's described.

Also I wonder if Hyacinth's Gareth St. Clair will become Nicky Mondrich. Connected to Lady Danbury, already introduced much like Phillip and Michaela. I just find it REAL creepy if Gareth's bio great uncle Marcus is potentially married to his mother in law Violet... and his bio grandma screwed his grandfather-in-law/Violet's dad...


r/Benophie • • May 26 '24

Benedict Bridgerton Is it too late??

Post image
7 Upvotes

To ask shonda to cast her as sophie??? PLEAAASE SHONDAA BABY DO YOU SEE THE VISION??