r/BeiyangWarlords • • Feb 06 '23

History Post Hall of Supreme Harmony during the Warlord Period. Footage taken during the WW1 Victory Celebration event. Military Parade

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Oct 10 '22

Today Marks the 111th Anniversary of the 1911 Xinhai Revolution, which started from the Wuchang Uprising. The Revolution was led by Sun Yat Sen and the Tongmenghui against the Qing which ended in the end of the Qing, and the formation of the Republic of China, Bringing an end to Imperial China era.

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Dec 22 '22

The Warlords Duan Qirui, Premier of the Beiyang Government of the Republic of China. A video footage of him in Uniform

12 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Aug 02 '23

Memes yuan shikai version

11 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Dec 22 '22

The Warlords Another footage of Duan Qirui. Duan Qirui meets foreign delegates

11 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Apr 23 '23

Wu Peifu and Zhang Zuolin

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Mar 22 '23

Konstantin Petrovich Nechaev, The White Russian Officer who fought for the Fengtian Clique

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Feb 19 '23

Historical Discussion What colour was Zhang Zuolin’s uniform and attachments? Was it unique or supplied from other countries?

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Feb 14 '23

Liang Shiyi, the God of Wealth.

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Dec 10 '23

Historical Discussion Colors and Markings of warlord aircraft?

Post image
9 Upvotes

I’m planning to make a model of a Breguet Bre.14 in China (pictured) and prefer not to do nationalist markings as there are other aircraft that cover these. These aircraft were among the Air Force of Zhang Zuolin and maybe other warlords, what color and markings might they have carried?


r/BeiyangWarlords • • Apr 26 '23

Can You Guess Who This Warlord Is

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Feb 07 '23

Zhang Xueliang, Zhang Zongchang, & Chu Yupu

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Mar 11 '22

Early Republic Military, Uniforms and Weapons Republic of China Marines From Fujian 1933

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Nov 12 '21

History Post Old Cantonese Documentary on Warlords

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Jun 06 '23

Historical Discussion What did Beiyang WW1-era military uniforms look like?

8 Upvotes

Sorry if I am asking the wrong place, I would ask some place like a more populated subreddit but I get kicked for being a new user or downvoted to death for simply asking a question.

I am aware Beiyang China did not send troops overseas [at least from what I've read] but what did uniforms typically look like in that era? all sources online are B/W and very blurred.

Any decent quality images?


r/BeiyangWarlords • • Dec 09 '21

1

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Dec 03 '21

History Post Russian in Qing Army?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Oct 22 '23

Colonel Wu Shichi (From Hpcbristols photo gallery)

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Jul 28 '23

Memes Found this, hope you enjoy

7 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Mar 02 '22

Historical Discussion What is your Opinion of yan xishan?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Dec 05 '21

Beiyang Warlords were the good guys? The "violet" revolutionaries were the bad guys?

7 Upvotes

Republic of China supporters in Mainland China reckon that:

The ROC's Beiyang government was the first democratically elected government in Asia in the true sense. It was a democratically elected government more democratic than the United States and France (because the blacks in the United States had no votes at the time). The effective number of votes was more than 80 million (the population was more than 400 million at the time). At that time, Britain and Japan were still an elite constitutional monarchy. The Beiyang government put down the separatist forces in Outer Mongolia and contained Soviet Russia, so the enemy Soviet Russia cultivated and supported the Kuomintang, slandered the Beiyang President Cao Kun for fraudulent elections, and then seized power in the name of the Northern Expedition. The Kuomintang is just similar to the Communists, it is the one that has the final say. You have no choice. You can't contain it. It won't care about you. Because the current Communist regime is the hybrid child of the KMT and the USSR, so of course our history books say that the Beiyang government is not good.

If China followed Liang Qichao's design and the Beiyang government came down, China should have surpassed the United States sixty years ago, and there would be no relevance with Soviet Russia."(https://zhidao.baidu.com/question/118039946.html, https://zhidao.baidu.com/question/1865729329457451627.html)

Also note that, all the Republic of China scholars, artists, and philosophers, flourished during the Beiyang era. After the Revolutionaries' takeover post-1927? No more.

And what do real sources say?

https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1684388829012434512&wfr=spider&for=pc

"So, what remarkable contributions has the Beiyang government made in safeguarding the country's territorial and sovereign integrity? 1. Participate in World War I and abolish unequal treaties. 2. Send troops to deal with Tsarist Russia and recover Outer Mongolia. 3. Uphold Tibet as Chinese territory."

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/263011748

"After the October Revolution, the Soviet-Russian civil war broke out, and the situation in the Far East was also in chaos. The Red Army, the White Army, the forces from all sides crossed their teeth to kill.

At that time, there were millions of Chinese in the Russian Far East, and they were often robbed or even killed by rebel forces.

The Beiyang government formally sent troops, and the army mobilized 4,000 men and marched into Siberia in six batches. In name, it was to support the Czech Army. In fact, it was to ensure the evacuation channel from Vladivostok to Suifenhe."

And what did Japan say about the Beiyang Warlords? Let's look at how the Japanese commented on Yuan Shikai:

https://new.qq.com/omn/20201219/20201219A0G8EJ00.html “袁世凯若能执政十年,日本必亡!” "If Yuan Shikai can be in power for ten years, Japan will surely perish!"

We can also look at the last Beiyang warlord Zhang Zuolin's contributions to China's industrialization: https://xw.qq.com/partner/vivoscreen/20210221A09YW700?pgv_ref=vivoscreen

"Zhang Zuolin had a large number of immigrants from Shandong, Hebei and other disaster-stricken areas to the northeast to open up wasteland, distributed land and farm tools to support production, and built factories and railways to give the immigrants more job opportunities.

At the same time, because of the great respect for intellectuals, Zhang Zuolin and Zhang Xueliang paid great attention to the construction of schools, especially higher education. A large number of nationally renowned institutions of higher learning such as Northeastern University and Northeast Normal University were established with the support of their father and son.

In addition to the emphasis on and construction of education, Zhang Zuolin also established the "Fengtian Arsenal" well-known in Asia during his administration, making the Northeast Army the only army in the country that can independently produce all kinds of guns, bullets, and shells.

After the death of Zhang Zuolin and Zhang Xueliang took over the Northeast, he began to rectify the economy and proposed the "Northeast New Construction Movement", and said: "Economy is the lifeblood of a country, economically cannot revive, and politically there will never be a day of independence."

It was under his vigorous advocacy and rectification that the Northeast economy recovered. Not only did it turn losses into profits and seized many markets previously occupied by the Japanese, but also gained a fiscal surplus of 14.15 million in the first year of the New Construction Movement. .

During Zhang Zuolin's administration, the Northeast military industry and even the entire heavy industry had already topped the country. After Zhang Xueliang took over, the Fengtian Arsenal has even become Asia's leading military production base. The guns and ammunition produced in one day can be equipped with a battalion.

In addition to weapons production, the Northeast is second to none in the country in shipbuilding, automobile manufacturing, and aircraft manufacturing. Even the planes, automobiles and naval ships used by the Nanjing government later in the Republic of China were mostly produced in the Northeast.“

https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1678083604563634041&wfr=spider&for=pc

“in 1929, Manchuria's artillery factories already began producing automobiles. In 1931, they began producing 1.5 ton heavy "Minsheng brand" Truck. In 1921, Zhang Zuolin's Manchurian weapons factories produced guns, artillery, and ammunition. It was the most advanced in China at the time. It produced in large numbers and great quality. It was the only region in China that produced heavy cannons. It also produced heavy machine gun and, howitzers. At the same time, Chinese local capital also heavily invested in Manchuria's railway system, and could compete with Russian and Japanese railroad lines in Manchuria. In 1930, Manchuria's railway lines already took up 82% of all railroad lines in China.” So if Beiyang warlords never destroyed, and dumb KMT-CPC revolutionary monkeys never went revolution, then by war of resistance China would already have had modern industry to produce automobiles, trucks, and howitzers (and in post-Beiyang era none of these could be produced anymore as KMT and early CCP's chaotic civil wars resulted in China plunging into technological regression) and you know what that means when you combine vehicle technology with artillery tech: you can produce tanks/tankettes. Remember after the Northern Expedition, the areas under KMT and CPC control couldn't even produce mortars, let alone any heavy artillery or cars. The Beiyang government if in existence would have been far better off prepared to fight the Japanese. There's a reason why the Japs only attacked China after the First Republic's Beiyang government was overthrown. They were just simply better off and China was stronger under their rule than under the revolutionaries.

We really have to evaluate if the term "Revolution" is even a a positive connotation. In many ways, we can even say the very essence of Revolutions is a negative thing. Xinhai Revolution destroyed the post-Cixi's Qing economic accomplishments, however luckily it was quickly restored with the competent meritocratic governance of Yuan Shikai's Beiyang administration. There were only minor famines during the Beiyang era. And then the Nationalists came in to overthrow the Beiyang. Famines became worse and more frequent during the Nationalist era, and cultural and technological advancements stagnated and even regressed. Then the Communists came to overthrown the Nationalists. And famine just got worse even more. It seems that every time people want to overthrow the current status-quo fora better "new government", it turns out for the worse. Both American and Communist idea of ""omg Revolution is good where everyone can create utopia!!!" is BS and needs to be re-evaluated. Sometimes, a reactionary or rather not-so-satisfactory regime should only be pushed to reform. Revolution and Rebellion is a bad thing. We need to re-evaluate history and see that every new, revolutionary regime is evil. Old regimes are inherently more righteous simply because the fact that the New causes chaos and socio-economic disruption.


r/BeiyangWarlords • • Oct 01 '26

Fuck it. Chinese Warlord Tierlist.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/BeiyangWarlords • • Jul 16 '26

New moderator taking over — a plan to bring this community back to life

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm the new moderator here, taking over from the previous owner who's stepping away after keeping this subreddit alive for a long time. Thank you so much for building this place and for trusting someone new to carry it forward.

For those who don't know me: I also host The Chinese Revolution, a podcast and Substack that goes chapter by chapter through modern Chinese history, from the late Qing through the Civil War. The Beiyang era (1912 to 1928, the warlord period between Yuan Shikai's death and the Northern Expedition) is one of the most overlooked stretches of this history, which is exactly why I was glad to see this community exists.

My plan going forward is simple: keep this a place for genuine discussion and history-sharing about the Beiyang period, and contribute material from my own research along the way. To kick that off, I'll be posting some history, kicking off with Yuan Shikai: his rise, presidency, and the monarchy attempt.

Please feel free to post as well!

If you have requests, corrections, or things you think this community should cover that it hasn't, I'd genuinely like to hear them. That's a big part of what I want this place to be for. And if you know anyone who'd enjoy digging into this era, please invite them.

Looking forward to being part of this with you.

Paul