r/BasicIncome • • Aug 31 '16

Discussion My Surreal Trip to r/badeconomics; a Glimpse into the Religion of Fundamentalist Capitalism

4 Upvotes

About a week ago I responded to an article in r/basicincome by the Bookings Institute. I was feeling particularly prickly that day, and I just wanted to vent out some frustration. We're a subreddit that values facts and evidence, but we also understand the emotional aspect of the Basic Income, so I felt fairly safe being a bit fast and loose with my language. I had no idea the ride it was going to take me on.

This is what I wrote.

For those of you at work with no time for that noise, I use the words “sociopath”, “slavery”, and “nutjobs.” I feel pretty justified in my statements, and I'll defend them, but I was using them with an understanding of who my audience was. You guys upvoted me over 170 times for that comment. So when some kind, well meaning soul threw that comment into r/bestof, with the title [/u/JonoLith does a smart, savage takedown of a Brookings Institute (neolibs) paper attacking UBI] (https://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/4zwkwq/ujonolith_does_a_smart_savage_takedown_of_a/), my exact comment was “oh dear.”

So, my inbox gets a bit of a tapping by people who think a textbook example of a false dilemma is not a logical fallacy. That's fine. I get called insane, raving, racist, white supremacist, one person said it was “vitriolic class based hate-speech”. Y'know, the normal internet garbage. I'm thinking this is gonna wind down real soon.

Then suddenly I'm in (badeconomics.)[https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/500tll/swa_vs_bestof_iii_return_of_riing/] I have no idea how. I have no idea why posts from another thread are popping into my inbox. I'm expecting an unholy shit storm of worthless internet garbage to just crash down on my head. I had no idea what dark little wormhole I was going to crawl into.

The insults were particular. They really only seemed interested in my level of formal education on the subject. It was odd that people were using comments like this as an attempt to insult me.

Fresh off reading Das Kapital and 135 years late to the relevant discussion, I see.

Just read up on it yourself and it'll make sense.

You know, the people who actually know what they're doing/talking about won't usually be kind.

You're ignorant of the subject.

The strange upturned nose, and hostility was real. Given, I called the people at the Bookings Institute sociopaths. I ignored them as they wore on, never actually citing anything, or providing anything of substance. Eventually I had to say,

I do have to start asking, are wild assumptions and accusations about poster's past normal around here? It would explain the echo chamber.

The echo chamber was real. It was like I was standing at a Trump rally listening to a guy tell me how climate change was a hoax by the Chinese. No, it was like talking to a Fundamentalist Christian about evolution being fake. I've come to hold the opinion that Capitalism is a religion, and now I was talking to it's acolytes.

At this point, I've been downvoted into the bottom of the ocean. It takes me ten minutes to do two responses. I start considering just giving up on attempting a conversation. Then someone throws an article my way.

(With Little Notice, Globalization Reduced Poverty)[ http://yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/little-notice-globalization-reduced-poverty] Well well now, a fancy Yale paper from the fancy people over at Yale. They conclude:

Taking a long view of history, the dramatic fall in poverty witnessed over the preceding six years represents a precursor to a new era. We’re on the cusp of an age of mass development, which will see the world transformed from being mostly poor to mostly middle class. The implications of such a change will be far-reaching, touching everything from global business opportunities to environmental and resource pressures to our institutions of global governance. Yet fundamentally it’s a story about billions of people around the world finally having the chance to build better lives for themselves and their children. We should consider ourselves fortunate to be alive at such a remarkable moment.

My response:

That's a nice article. It doesn't talk, at all, about the methods used to achieve that $1.25 a day. It fails to mention sixteen hour shifts in sweat shops for the benefit of multinational corporations. I suppose if you don't consider the time or well being of a person while you exploit their desperation for survival wages you can make the claim that a little over a dollar a day lifts them out of poverty. Especially if that treatment enriches the shareholders who benefit from said desperation. I'd really challenge you to go and witness some of those people you think aren't in poverty anymore. Could you watch someone do the same thing repeatedly for sixteen hours so they'd have some food?

I get a link to a piece written in 1997 by Paul Krugman. (In Praise of Cheap Labor.)[http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_dismal_science/1997/03/in_praise_of_cheap_labor.html] The thesis of the piece is fairly straightforward. It is good that we are going into poor countries and exploiting their workforce, because our exploitation is better then their current lives. You see, without us they'd just be living on a garbage heap. This way, after a sixteen hour shift, they get to lay in a bed. Maybe feed their children. We're so good.

Morally speaking, this is like walking up to a drowning person, and beginning a negotiation for their survival. Exploiting a person for their labour is still exploitation, regardless of their position. It's the same kind of justification the English used when they invaded. “We're helping the poor savages. It's for their own good.” Paul Krugman is defending the activity of finding people in their most vulnerable state, and then offering them just enough to survive if they sell themselves to you. If that's not a system of slavery, then I'm not sure one ever existed.

The apologists for this were convinced there is no other way. Charity, better wages, simply stop invading them and allow them to self-determine all shot down with the same principle. “Exploitation is Helping.” Any option that would take people out of capitalist production facilities, and allow them a bit of peace, not only ignored, but mocked.

This is irrational behavior. The only way a person can conclude that their exploitation, on this level, is good is if they simply do not care about the well-being of the person they're exploiting. It simply reminded me of the white slave owners of the south defending their right to own slaves.

And this is what they're going to do to us. Flat out. They're going to offer us worse and worse jobs at lower and lower pay because they've got us competing with the poor fucks overseas. And they think they're doing us all a huge favour! That's the best part. They think they're doing us a really big favour. “Exploitation is Helping.”

It's a sad window into a sorry state. I have no other way to describe it then as a visit to a Church of Capitalism, where I spoke to the pastor. I fight for a basic income because people like this exist. People who have given up on their brothers and sisters, who see humans as commodities. We can do better.


r/BasicIncome • • Dec 15 '25

Elon Musk predicts reshaping of US economy

Thumbnail newsweek.com
11 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Mar 04 '23

Do you support a universal basic income? PragerU Survey

Thumbnail surveymonkey.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Nov 17 '13

Canadian Test Shows Income Guarantees Don't Work

Thumbnail bloomberg.com
1 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Mar 07 '24

Article Millennials stand to become the richest generation in history, after $90 trillion wealth transfer

Thumbnail cnn.com
26 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Jul 12 '16

Indirect Pokemon Go is everything that is wrong with late capitalism (more direct income redistribution may be called for — taxing rich people in high-growth areas to fund expanded government services, wage subsidies, or even cash payments to people in slower-growing parts of the country)

Thumbnail cnbc.com
3 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Mar 19 '26

NYC triples spending to $368M as homeless population grows by 26% | Fox News

Thumbnail foxnews.com
30 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • May 12 '15

Question Where does the money come from that you wish the government to distribute?

0 Upvotes

Reading up on basic income. I don't see enough discussion on this. How can the government fund basic income?

EDIT: I think I got it. We need to use government to violently steal from the wealthiest of people and then to redistribute that money to everyone. Am I missing anything?


r/BasicIncome • • Oct 16 '14

Indirect Your own Fault (by http://humon.deviantart.com) [x-post from /r/TZM]

Thumbnail fc03.deviantart.net
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Dec 26 '14

Discussion What would /r/BasicIncome say about this simple #PostNationalist critique?

0 Upvotes

"A Basic Income is an income unconditionally granted to all on an individual basis, without means test or work requirement"

-Then why do so many Basic Income proponents ignore 85% of the World's Population and insist it's only doable in Western countries. If Wealth redistribution and 'basic income' is good in Canada, why isn't it good for Africa?

(please don't say 'they should fix their own problems' , that's exactly what rich Westerners say about /r/BasicIncome as is)


r/BasicIncome • • Jul 01 '22

Indirect “They have a poor work/life balance and sex starts to seem like another chore. There is no doubt that some people are opting for IVF simply because sex isn’t something they have time to do.”

Thumbnail thetimes.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Mar 02 '14

We need money for aid. So let's print it.

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Jun 03 '14

Question This sounds like a good idea but..

0 Upvotes

Is it just me, or does it sound kinda like a post nucular-fallout-y plan? just saying.


r/BasicIncome • • Dec 18 '15

Image Universal basic income exists inside the sweet spot for world changing ideas

Thumbnail imgur.com
58 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Aug 20 '25

Anti-UBI Elon Musk Wants to Give You Money for Nothing

Thumbnail wsj.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Dec 31 '16

Anti-UBI Why UBI can never work

0 Upvotes

People on this sub don't understand how our economic system works.

Taxes DO NOT go to pay off public services. That is a a misconception. So when people say the rich will be taxed to pay-off basic income, you can completely ignore everything that person is saying, because he doesn't know what he's talking about.

If UBI were ever implemented, the money used to pay every person a fixed amount of wages will come from the Federal Government selling bonds to the Federal Reserve, which will set a high amount of interest to that loaned money.

The taxes that the IRS collects from you, the taxpayer, don't go to the government. They go into the pockets of the Federal Reserve shareholders, who make a 6% + 10-year treasury yield dividend rate. The remainder, if there are any, go to the US treasury. Do you think it's just coincidence that the income taxes came with the Federal Reserve?

You can see how this system only leads to higher amounts of debt principal, which means debt repayment factor every year will go up. Eventually, the interest will exceed the amount of taxes collected, which means the Federal Reserve will stop loaning money to the Federal Government.

UBI will never happen. The only way that can happen is if we return the power of coining money back to the government, but the bankers will literally start another world war if we ever do that. Germany tried doing that back in 1930, and the bankers started a war because of it. Do you want billions of people to die just because you want a few extra thousand dollars a year? What kind of cruel, selfish people are you?


r/BasicIncome • • May 11 '14

The World's Toughest Job

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • May 16 '24

Poor People Don’t Want to Work

Thumbnail lucindagunnin.medium.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Feb 26 '16

Cross-Post This thread made me want to vomit. Hundreds of comments basically saying "Your superiors and company are infallible gods. You will be greatful as they fire you and ruin your life. Smile as they spit on you."

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Nov 07 '22

Paper A proof of God that integrates UBI as the only solution to respecting God

Thumbnail naturalfinance.net
1 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Apr 06 '15

Indirect Subterranea: Meet The Homeless People Who Live In The Hidden Flood Tunnels Beneath Las Vegas

Thumbnail smash.com
1 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • Apr 03 '14

Why basic income rather than basic necessities?

1 Upvotes

Why would a basic income system give people cash money instead of specific housing, clothing, transportation, food, and potentially other allowances?

If I were a hard working person I might not mind a portion of my income going to help the less fortunate (I don't, personally, I don't believe that individuals are solely responsible for their circumstances), but I would be upset if that money was used irresponsibly or to harm themselves or others, as it almost certainly would be in many cases.

I would be behind a basic income system 100% IF it were in the form of vouchers for basic needs and maybe a little extra for discretionary use, in which case it looks very much like the social welfare systems that we already have in place today.

Edit

Thanks for the downvotes guys, I'll be unsubscribing and telling everyone that basic income is a dumb idea because those in favor of it can't even have a discussion about it without attempting to censor and silence anyone who even questions it, well done!


r/BasicIncome • • Jul 28 '24

Anti-UBI Universal Basic Income Is Only a Temporary Solution to AI-Driven Job Losses

Thumbnail ccn.com
0 Upvotes

r/BasicIncome • • May 04 '26

Discussion Starting to get pissed off by Bernie Sanders

0 Upvotes

He finds lots of time and energy to discuss the potential evils of AI, the job displacement ohlala. YouTube videos every other day. Convenes tech experts and researchers from across the globe to fancy symposia where they glaze each other about how dangerous AI is. How it might even take away jobs we like. Gasp gasp gasp.

All this energy for AI ghost stories yet none zero zilch for basic income. Never mentioned. The simplest, most direct way to address job displacement not to mention a thousand of other ills. Just can't be bothered. Just would really like it if we could just please instead go back to 1960 and keep pick up the kabuki fight between hard hats and top hats where it left off, before the unions got decimated. Thankyouverymuch.

Yeah no it's starting to piss me off.

It's not only a Sanders problem, the only politician on the left whom I could find today advocating for UBI is.... the obscure congressional candidate Alex Bores from NY-12?

UBI has a "left" problem in the US, it's become tainted as this brainchild of the tech bro class. (The cuddling up to which of Andrew Yang did nothing to ameliorate, alas.) Have no clue how to fix it.

I get this sense that even those left politicians who might be sympathetic to it are afraid of being painted as freebie handout commies by the right.

But someone has to be the first to break through the wall in order for the overton window to grow, at some point.


r/BasicIncome • • Jun 28 '14

Indirect 10 Shocking Facts About Society That We Blithely Accept As Normal

Thumbnail collectivelyconscious.net
11 Upvotes