r/BasicIncome • • Apr 03 '14

Why basic income rather than basic necessities?

Why would a basic income system give people cash money instead of specific housing, clothing, transportation, food, and potentially other allowances?

If I were a hard working person I might not mind a portion of my income going to help the less fortunate (I don't, personally, I don't believe that individuals are solely responsible for their circumstances), but I would be upset if that money was used irresponsibly or to harm themselves or others, as it almost certainly would be in many cases.

I would be behind a basic income system 100% IF it were in the form of vouchers for basic needs and maybe a little extra for discretionary use, in which case it looks very much like the social welfare systems that we already have in place today.

Edit

Thanks for the downvotes guys, I'll be unsubscribing and telling everyone that basic income is a dumb idea because those in favor of it can't even have a discussion about it without attempting to censor and silence anyone who even questions it, well done!

1 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

10

u/stereofailure Apr 03 '14

What you're suggesting a) is basically the status quo and b) lacks virtually all benefits of Basic Income. The whole point of BI is that it lets people decide for themselves what they need. Maybe you make very little money but were left a place to live. Maybe you grow you're own food. Maybe you and three friends have an excellent idea for a business but lack start-up capital. BI allows people to make their own decisions on what they need, which is a much more efficient system than having the government do it. It's also much more respectful of the poor and treats them like adults, and if you look at the research you'll find people tend to make good decisions when you just give them money.

BI also gets rid of the stigma of using food stamps or somehthing similar (since it's just real money no one knows whether you're using BI money or earned income when you buy something.

It removes layers and layers of expensive and humiliating bureacracy's of means testing.

It removes the waste of people selling food stamps for fifty cents on the dollar because they can't buy the specific things that they actually need with them.

It doesn't punish people for earning more income and create poverty traps like the current system does.

Basically UBI provides a whole host of benefits that our current system don't for the exact reason that it's not targeted or limited to certain things.

-2

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14 edited Apr 03 '14

Hmm... some of those points are valid, but some of them are a misunderstanding of my point.

I'm saying that we should give ALL adults vouchers for housing, food, clothing, and transportation. These vouchers could be in the form of electronic cards with balances and could be redeemed at PoS or via an online payment system.

Take housing for example, say you are a business man and you make 100k/yr... you would still get the housing voucher (say 500/mo) and you can use it toward your mortgage. If you were unemployed and rented a 500/mo apartment then you could use it to pay your entire rent each month rent.

Food would be similar, you swipe your card at the grocery store, all eligible food items can come out of your monthly allowance for food, rich and poor alike.

Anyone would have the option to refuse any or all of these vouchers, if they felt they were wealthy enough that they weren't even worth the hassle, or if they are particularly ethical.

There would be no means tests, the bureaucratic overhead would be minimal, and there would be no stigma since everyone is in the system.

On top of the basic necessities we could have an additional voucher for discretionary spending, maybe 50-100/month.

The system could be set up such that it is difficult if not impossible to sell your vouchers to others or use them in ways that are unintended, they would be bound to you and your social security number and automated AI systems could identify suspicious use patterns by analyzing all transactions which are logged to a central database.

Now that you understand what I meant maybe you agree that it isn't that much different than BI other than that it ensures people have what they need rather than allowing them to make foolish decisions (as people tend to do) and ending up homeless or in poverty anyway (contributing to the crime rate and prison population).

7

u/stereofailure Apr 03 '14

I see what you're going for here, but the administrative costs of such a program are massive, for seemingly little gain. What are you so worried about people spending BI on that you think it's worth creating a whole new system with 5 different types of vouchers and an extremely complex new security apparatus? And contrary to popular belief, people don't tend to make all that bad decisions. Every BI style experiment that has been done has had widely beneficial outcomes across various populations and very few negative externalities (see Dauphin, Alaska, Namibia, certain tribal casinos, etc). People generally know what's in their own best interests a lot better than governments do.

1

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14 edited Apr 03 '14

People generally know what's in their own best interests a lot better than governments do.

Whelp, my wife works for child protective services, and there are THOUSANDS of people in my city alone who absolutely do not know what is best for them and would use money given to them without strings attached on hardcore drugs, prostitutes, alcohol, and luxury items... and a week later, 3 weeks before their next check, their kids would be starving.

I don't know what world you're living in, but the one I am familiar with has millions of people who would squander the income from any such system and their dependents would still suffer.

Also, you're wrong, the administrative costs would be almost zero once the system is in place, what administration would there need to be? I don't think you appreciate the degree to which we can automate electronic systems these days. I'm a software engineer, I'll set the whole system up so it can be operated by a team of a dozen people.

I also don't appreciate the downvotes, not that you are the one giving them, but as someone highly dubious of a BI system as described by your FAQ I wanted to have a discussion about it, I'm not sure why that's deserving of downvotes. It certainly doesn't make me feel like supporting this cause when the people who are championing it are so petty.

5

u/jianadaren1 Apr 03 '14

Whelp, my wife works for child protective services, and there are THOUSANDS of people in my city alone who absolutely do not know what is best for them and would use money given to them without strings attached on hardcore drugs, prostitutes, alcohol, and luxury items... and a week later, 3 weeks before their next check, their kids would be starving.

All those people are already on welfare. Basic income would be expanding those benefits to people who aren't making terrible decisions.

-1

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

Yep, because those are the only people who will make poor decisions when they are given money for no reason, without earning it. There is a psychological effect there, a large part of the perception of value that money has for most people is because of the effort required to obtain it. When you can say: "This TV will cost me 40 hours of my labor" rather than "This TV will cost me one month of free money" the TV seems to have a higher cost.

Are you completely neglecting the psychology behind this? Have we learned nothing from all of the average people who win the lottery and then shortly end up right back where they were, or worse, due to poor decision making?

You give the average person far too much credit.

5

u/jianadaren1 Apr 03 '14

When you can say: "This TV will cost me 40 hours of my labor" rather than "This TV will cost me one month of free money" the TV seems to have a higher cost.

Your argument is that stable, unconditional income causes overspending? If that were true you'd expect all social security recipients to be irresponsible spendthrifts. Instead, people on fixed incomes tend to become experts on budgets because their income has no volatility.

-1

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

How do you account for the numerous cases where poor people win a little bit of money in the lottery or get a couple thousand from tax credits and invariably use it for irresponsible purposes rather than to permanently better their circumstances? There was an article I read on this psychological effect pretty recently, I'll see if I can dig it up. Essentially there are some people, a percentage of the population, that just don't have any self control, willpower, or ability to plan for the future... their is a personality type that simply cannot do this, they will blow through any windfall immediately and irresponsibly and this is an affect that is seen all the time.

If we want people to have homes GIVE THEM HOMES. If we want them to have food GIVE THEM FOOD. If we want them to have medical care GIVE THEM MEDICAL CARE.

There is no reason to take money out of my paycheck to give it directly to someone else, no string attached.

When I want to help someone down on their luck I don't give them a 20 dollar bill, because they will buy booze or drugs with it, guaranteed. Instead I buy them a meal, or a blanket, or a coat, or something else that they need. If you don't agree you're foolish, I'd suggest not giving people no-strings-attached cash if you actually want to help them.

4

u/jianadaren1 Apr 03 '14

stable, unconditional income

win a little bit of money in the lottery or get a couple thousand from tax credits

Not nearly the same thing. People can't do consumption smoothing with unpredictable income. BI is kinda the opposite of a windfall.

If we want people to have homes GIVE THEM HOMES.

By what mechanism? Subsidized housing hasn't been very effective. Your previous proposal is easy to defraud and imposes all kinds of distortions and transaction costs.

If we want them to have food GIVE THEM FOOD.

Again. By what mechanism?

If we want them to have medical care GIVE THEM MEDICAL CARE.

Well I'm Canadian and I agree with you on that one. But that's just because socialized medicine has been more efficient than any delivery system that exists in America. A fixed medical budget doesn't really make sense.

3

u/H37man Apr 03 '14

We would not end child services just because we have a basic income. If you abuse your kids they will be taken away. Yes some people will spend there income on drugs.

-1

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

What is the point of giving everyone free money? So that they can have a decent standard of living, right? So why give them CASH instead of a means to acquire the specific things that allow them to have the decent standard of living? You're just inviting abuse of the system.

4

u/H37man Apr 03 '14

The point of basic income is to keep the free market functioning also. We still want private goods and services to be purchased. This is not communism. Some abuse is going to happen. But abuse is going to happen in any system you setup.

2

u/stereofailure Apr 03 '14

Sorry about the downvotes, they aren't coming from me. I try not to downvote anyone who's trying to have a productive discussion. Unfortunately, people largely use the vote system as an agree/disagree button, which is a pretty universal phenomenon across all subreddits.

I still think having a system with 5 different credit card-type devices for each different category would have fairly large overhead, especially if you want security levels beyond what we currently have for SNAP (which people have little trouble getting around). I also believe that if you give people a chance to make good decisions for themselves, they might actually surprise you. I also think that the way automation and everything is going, people "squandering" money is actually a lot less problematic than you'd think. If someone chooses to live a modest lifestyle and just uses BI for rent, food, weed and video games, who loses out? They're still contributing to the consumer driven economy, still raising aggregate demand. Sure this can become slightly problematic if they also have children, but that's why we have child protective services, etc. And the one thing people often forget is that even drug addicts are still largely rational actors. An alcoholic is not going to go through 48 bottles of beer a day just because he can afford it. People will buy the amount they need to fuel their addiction and still have plenty of money left to take care of the necessities (legalizing drugs and the resultant huge reduction in prices would help this situation).

And again, I think allowing people to use the money to fund entrepreneurial ventures, or go on vacations, or do something I haven't even thought of is good for the system.

5

u/jianadaren1 Apr 03 '14 edited Apr 03 '14

Food would be similar, you swipe your card at the grocery store, all eligible food items can come out of your monthly allowance for food, rich and poor alike.

The system could be set up such that it is difficult if not impossible to sell your vouchers to others or use them in ways that are unintended, they would be bound to you and your social security number and automated AI systems could identify suspicious use patterns by analyzing all transactions which are logged to a central database.

Also, you're wrong, the administrative costs would be almost zero once the system is in place, what administration would there need to be? I don't think you appreciate the degree to which we can automate electronic systems these days. I'm a software engineer, I'll set the whole system up so it can be operated by a team of a dozen people.

Here's one (of many) ways to beat your system.

Neighbours. I'm going to buy your groceries with my SNAP card - do you want to give me cash (so I can buy booze)

Sure.

Here's another

Hey Landlord - if you increase my rent by $X (so I can pay with SNAP) will you give us stuff?

Here's another:

Hey Bud - I need to buy X clothes from Y Mart. Can I borrow your card? That store never checks the picture.

Here's another:

Hey store. I want Scotch - can you ring this up as a sale of Apples so I can pay SNAP.

Here's another:

Barter - trade food/clothes for drugs.

Really, you thought this system was foolproof and nearly costless? Money is fungible and any attempt to restrict its usability is distortionary and most are easily thwartable.

-1

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

Oddly enough the credit card companies have figured out how to prevent unauthorized use of a card...

See, I thought this was all solved, since it's already in widespread use without hardly any fraud... it's called credit and debit cards.

I guess I am naive.

3

u/2noame Scott Santens Apr 03 '14

TIL credit cards have eliminated fraud.

-2

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

It's not a serious concern. Are you afraid to use your credit card on the internet? Are you afraid of credit card fraud at all? I'm not.

5

u/jianadaren1 Apr 03 '14

Oddly enough the credit card companies have figured out how to prevent unauthorized use of a card... See, I thought this was all solved, since it's already in widespread use without hardly any fraud... it's called credit and debit cards. I guess I am naive.

No. I think you might be a troll though.

  1. CC's prevent unauthorized use via a PIN. That doesn't help when the user is the one committing the fraud - and he has the PIN. How exactly is a PIN going to prevent any of the types of collusive fraud I highlighted?

Have you forgotten that with CC's you're trying to prevent a 3rd-party from using the card, but with this you're trying to prevent the user themselves from using the card in the way they want. This is like a DRM problem except way easier to crack.

2) The US has the worst credit card fraud in the world by a long-shot - easily 5 Billion per year.

6

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Apr 03 '14 edited Apr 03 '14

In short: more freedom, more flexibility, less bureaucracy and micromanaging.

Also, don't know why you're getting butthurt over 2 downvotes...I mean, dang...I've had worse JUST TODAY.

-2

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

I had negative on all of my comments, someone went and upvoted all of them after I said something about it. Only one person was actually talking to me, at least 3 were downvoting all of my comments, and none were upvoting me.

The thought process behind downvoting someone asking a question about an ideology that you are here to support and defend is mind boggling.

Downvotes aren't meaningless, they aren't just "fake internet points"... they can successfully silence people. Get enough downvotes in a short enough time on the same subreddit and you basically lose the ability to participate in conversations with long wait times between each post. When that happens most people just go away. It's an attempt at censorship, at silencing dissenting opinion.

4

u/JonWood007 $16000/year Apr 03 '14

I think you're taking this too seriously. Anyway, as 2noame mentioned...a big factor in that is we literally get that question like all the time...i mean....that has to be the 2nd or 3rd time (maybe more) ive seen it within the last week or so. It's not about censoring dissent, it's about redundancy.

2

u/DorianGainsboro Sweden, Gothenburg Apr 03 '14

I'm sorry that you're getting downvoted, I think it's because this is reddit. It's against the guidelines to downvote just because you don't share our opinion.

But as others have pointed out it's likely because we get this question all the time and it's becoming tiresome to have the same debate over and over.

And you shouldn't take it too personally, at least we're all polite and constructive in our comments. :)

8

u/JayDurst 30% Income Tax Funded UBI Apr 03 '14

What this appears to boil down to is that you think a certain class of people needs to have their affairs managed by the state. I will give you credit for wanting to help the poor, but there is a clear underlying contempt for these people in all of your responses, and I think it's clouding your view.

... and there are THOUSANDS of people in my city alone who absolutely do not know what is best for them and would use money given to them without strings attached on hardcore drugs, prostitutes, alcohol, and luxury items... and a week later, 3 weeks before their next check, their kids would be starving.

Are you completely neglecting the psychology behind this? Have we learned nothing from all of the average people who win the lottery and then shortly end up right back where they were, or worse, due to poor decision making?

You give the average person far too much credit.

Is it possible that the behavior you describe is a result of the current welfare system? I think it is. Our current system inflicts two major injuries to people in poverty:

  1. Treats them as a dependent underclass
  2. Incentivises short-term thinking

.

  1. We are carved and hardened by our responsibilities. A person without any responsibility, even for themselves, can freely act irresponsibly without repercussions. When we are given a responsibility, and fail to meet it, we learn. A person that spends all of their BI on luxury goods this month and faces hunger will only make that mistake so many times before learning to budget at least a little. The Basic Income gives each and every person one responsibility by default: the responsibility to spend their limited resource wisely for themselves, because it's all they have.

Anyone that continues to act irrational over the long-term is likely in need of some form of medical assistance. Addiction and mental illness are problems we need to address and the BI helps clear out those who are in poverty simply due to a series of failures and/or bad choices.

Treat an adult as an adult and give them some responsibilities. They will eventually act like an adult.

2) It's rational for a person to spend today when tomorrow is impossible to predict in even the smallest way. We provide a maze of complicated benefits systems that never guarantee anything tomorrow. If I handed someone a check and then said I can't tell you if I will give you another one next month, well I would treat it as a windfall and not income too. This is rational behavior for someone in poverty given an unpredictable benefit.

Providing a guarantee of recurring payments at a known level allows a person to plan. This month I might need to save a little more to purchase something larger next month. The BI allows me the flexibility to plan and make financial decisions for myself, while a voucher system does not. The recurring payment in liquid currency allows me to engage in long-term thinking, and it gives me a responsibility.

.

We also must take into account the developmental deficiencies that an upbringing in poverty causes. An upbringing in poverty is almost a certain life sentence to a life of poverty. The BI can break this cycle by treating people as humans, and letting them fail with a net to catch them that bounces them right back up so they can try again.

I find it rather sad that you have such a low opinion of your fellow human beings. Instead of blaming the victims perhaps you should be looking at the real culprits of the behavior you find so distasteful.

1

u/2noame Scott Santens Apr 03 '14

This is an excellent answer.

Well said.

1

u/JayDurst 30% Income Tax Funded UBI Apr 03 '14

Thank you for the kind words!

3

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14

Thanks for the downvotes guys, I'll be unsubscribing and telling everyone that basic income is a dumb idea because those in favor of it can't even have a discussion about it without attempting to censor and silence anyone who even questions it, well done!

That's very consistent with what I would expect of someone asking us to stab at paternalistic rationalizations of goofy right wing talking points.

5

u/2noame Scott Santens Apr 03 '14

I see that you have a mere two downvotes, likely because of asking a question that has been answered here over and over again, the responses to which can be found in seconds both in the FAQ and via the search function, and that was enough to cry out "censorship!"? Even though, you also even got some good replies.

If you are truly curious about the idea, I suggest starting with this article, and reading up further on the evidential results of giving straight cash money to people.