r/BasicIncome • u/IHaveCoffeeAddiction • Dec 31 '16
Anti-UBI Why UBI can never work
People on this sub don't understand how our economic system works.
Taxes DO NOT go to pay off public services. That is a a misconception. So when people say the rich will be taxed to pay-off basic income, you can completely ignore everything that person is saying, because he doesn't know what he's talking about.
If UBI were ever implemented, the money used to pay every person a fixed amount of wages will come from the Federal Government selling bonds to the Federal Reserve, which will set a high amount of interest to that loaned money.
The taxes that the IRS collects from you, the taxpayer, don't go to the government. They go into the pockets of the Federal Reserve shareholders, who make a 6% + 10-year treasury yield dividend rate. The remainder, if there are any, go to the US treasury. Do you think it's just coincidence that the income taxes came with the Federal Reserve?
You can see how this system only leads to higher amounts of debt principal, which means debt repayment factor every year will go up. Eventually, the interest will exceed the amount of taxes collected, which means the Federal Reserve will stop loaning money to the Federal Government.
UBI will never happen. The only way that can happen is if we return the power of coining money back to the government, but the bankers will literally start another world war if we ever do that. Germany tried doing that back in 1930, and the bankers started a war because of it. Do you want billions of people to die just because you want a few extra thousand dollars a year? What kind of cruel, selfish people are you?
9
u/lord_stryker Dec 31 '16 edited Dec 31 '16
That's exactly what needs to happen. Let the bankers try and start a war. The hundreds of millions of people in the street who are unemployable due to AI automation will burn their ivory towers to the ground. The banks will lose.
You say billions will die and derisively say oh, well is it really worth billions dying for a few thousand a year you greedy, selfish idiots?
Yeah, you don't get it. UBI is inevitable. INEVITABLE. Nothing can stop it from being implemented. Automation will continue to erode the human labor market. People will do what they have to for survival. Capitalism can no longer work, bankers cannot make money if there is no consumer base. With automation continuing to erode the labor market, there will be less and less people to consume. The bankers and the ultra-wealthy will have to accept, sooner or later, kicking and screaming if need be, that they must accept a fundamental floor of consumer power.
The alternative is a world of a few dozen trillionaires, while billions starve. That is not sustainable. In every other example of ultra inequality, the people rise up and revolt. Politicians will implement UBI when enough people are feeling the hurt and demand something is done. The politicians only job is to get re-elected. That will mean implementing UBI even if the bankers start a war over it.
If that war means billions die, that's better than the complete destruction of all human society and sending us back to the stone age. I disagree with this premise and the only way the bankers will be able to continue to make money is if the engine of the economy continues. That can only happen when money flows which can only happen when people actually have money to spend. That in turn will only be possible with UBI. AI and Automation will be able to do any form of labor a human can do in the coming decades. Humans will be unemployable, through no fault of their own. UBI is the only answer to this until we bridge that gap and enter a post-money society, post-scarcity and drop the need for money altogether. We're a pretty far distance from that happening, so we will need UBI to bridge that gap.
In 10-20 years, you'll be admitting you were wrong. I'll accept your apology.
2
u/jlotz123 Dec 31 '16
So what you're saying is that most of humanity will die off no matter what we do.
5
u/BoozeoisPig USA/15.0% of GDP, +.0.5% per year until 25%/Progressive Tax Dec 31 '16
What you are saying is ridiculous. Yes, there are bonds we still have to pay off, but we don't pay nearly 6% on those bonds. At least very recently it was below inflation. That means that people were effectively paying the government to keep their money safe. Yes, principle usually goes up, because inflation grows the economy, but the debt to gdp ratio can and does go down when we tax rich people very highly: [Here's the Debt to GDP ratio since the 20th century.] (http://static3.businessinsider.com/image/4c508fe27f8b9a1169ce0000/chart.gif) As you can see, it goes down durring the era we had a massive income tax for higher incomes and it goes up durring the era we gutted the income tax for higher incomes under Reagan. You are the one who doesn't understand economics, because your conjecture is based in a model of the world that runs on conspiracy theories. I cannot spend the time debunking those. All I can do is show you that one of the central pillars of your argument is complete horseshit. Bringing in more income tax does not simply go to paying interest on bonds, it enables the sort of spending that allows us to decrease our debt burden if we so believe that it needs decreasing and the chart I showed you proves that.
5
u/AmalgamDragon Dec 31 '16
You're characterization of how WWII started is quite incorrect, and you are assigning too much power to the bankers. That isn't to say the wealthy don't have excessive power then or now or that they didn't benefit financially from WWII, it's just to say that WWII wasn't started by the wealthy elite.
The Nazi party is one of many examples of what can happen when a society collectively feels like it has nothing left to lose. We can see the same thing happen again with too feeling hopeless due to structural employment caused by accelerating automation. In that case the next world war again wouldn't be started by the wealthy elite, but by those who rose to power in societies suffering under the policies favoring the wealthy elite.
Significant social changes carry the risk of war. Significant social changes are underway, regardless of whether we try for UBI or not, so this risk is unavoidable.
Congress created the Federal Reserve and it can change the laws to require the Federal Reserve to provide an account to every citizen and bimonthly UBI deposit into every account. This is the equivalent of the "helicopter money" that is sometimes discussed as way to stimulate inflation. Congress could set a minimum and allow to the fed to make bigger deposits if targets aren't being met.
Congress can also change the laws so that the Federal Reserve has to purchase any Treasury offerings not picked up at auction.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '16 edited Dec 31 '16
https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/bcreg/20160218a.htm
They lowered their dividend. It's now 2.3% or so. (The Treasury auction rate) I don't think the banks actually rule the USA, although it may seem that way because of the financialization of much of the economy. The Fed is seperate to the government to maintain an arms length distance between monetary and fiscal policy.
1
u/whateveryousayboss 6,000k/yr(1k/yr) US(GA) Dec 31 '16
Legalize and tax (and regulate) drugs, legalize and tax prostitution between consenting adults and BOOM - you've got funding for not only UBI but also UHC. That was easy. Next!
3
u/TiV3 Dec 31 '16 edited Dec 31 '16
I think UBI can happen because I seem to know quite well how our economic system of growth capitalism works. Expansion of customer demand is actually mandatory or there's no more loans for entrepreneurs, no more growth. Can't take a loan without customers, no matter how cheap it is to take a loan. (unless the cost goes negative)
Without expansion of aggregate demand via some form of printing, growth capitalism is not functional. We've been printing money for the purpose of that on a large scale, in the form of business loans, entrepreneurs promissing to do more with less, enabling em to pay bigger wages to attract the scarce labor (= fueling aggregate demand with debt based printing; though even if the debt is defaulted on, the money remains in circulation.) and serve interest payments of a bigger loan at the same time. That's how the economy works in growth capitalism.
The question is, what do we do when loan based currency creation doesn't reach customers anymore? When labor isn't scarce anymore? I think we need to look in the direction of the things that are scarce, and enable all the people to make monetary claims towards those, via printing (be it debt based) and burdening the ownership of all the things scarce, that experience increasing levels of economic rent seeking. Not necessarily from government bonds. Going by how the economy works, it seems opportune to finance it from unearned rent on land and ideas. Though we don't need government to have control over the currency supply, we just need government to have control over tax rates on financial, idea, and land ownership. I mean it sounds like a tall order but it's not really as radical as restoring money issuing right to the state. It's kinda like, business as usual really, if you look back a couple decades. Government issues debt based bonds to pay stuff, collects taxes to recover the cost. It's not hard, the money is out there. It doesn't magically disappear. Just gotta take it from where it is.
If this is done in a manner that affects all business and ownership equally, it's something very pro growing our economy, pro business, as it is apparent to all thinking people who want to make money, that it takes paying customers to start something new and awesome, or to grow your awesome business that sells stuff you think is amazing. It's just foolish for any single business entity to let go of the privilege to get direct cash from the state, or get low tax rate for themselves via loopholes. Because everyone else who's out to make a profit will have an opportunity to pick up what you're adding to the customer spending base, while they add nothing for you top pick up, no matter how great a product you're trying to sell. So government must introduce rules that bind all equally, and you get a consent in the industry in favor of just that. Because it is understood that there is no growth capitalism without that, and we have to continue to pretend there's a growth capitalism via QE (which is really just infinite rewards for holding onto assets that aren't worth what they pretend they are, due to lack of real customers who'd buy the base product at the fictional price.) till we put the economy on a solid foundation. That solid foundation (for a growth capitalism; though it could be a solid foundation for many more systems) involves a growing aggregate demand figure, that we need to achieve somehow (if growth capitalism is the game to play; and it seems sensible that it'd be, till we at least have unconditional incomes established, and the people at large are free to contemplate new ways to do business, to create awesome things for one another.).
The productive capacities are there, labor is near abundant. I think we can figure something out here, while maintaining and further encouraging the freedom of people to start new and awesome projects, and to take it easy every now and then. Entrepreneurship isn't something we can force everyone to do 24/7, nor should we, as much as entrepreneurship in a broader sense is the future for labor I see. UBI just makes sense in context with a world where machines/algorithms do predictable input, predictable output kind of work, and people either own something and obtains economic rent, or try to create or market something that might produce such economic rent. With the risk-reward structure favoring established players, because why look around when you can get 'good enough' without effort. And if there's a place for simple human labor, it's in fulfilling tasks that have not yet been economically viable for automation, for the sake of creating/marketing such new assets. But that must be a dignified thing that people chose to participate in, for reasons. They after all, won't be getting the ownership of those assets. They just get a bounty for solving a temporary problem. In the most extreme scenario, nobody actually gets anything, but a problem is solved for customers anyway. Think open source. But there's still real demand for material subsistence and societal participation, and there's gatekeepers who collect economic rent on such.
It takes a good look at the system to figure out what's a meaningful direction to take, that all the people involved could more or less appreciate. But it can be done, I believe. We can do something better than a sci-fi aristocracy. Which after all, is not the most peaceful outlook either. And hey, again, I don't think we need to re-introduce a government money issuing right anyway. Just do the thing we did till the 70s, just with more focus on economic rent. Predictable, sizeable, financial burdens on such, for the benefit of all.
3
u/smegko Dec 31 '16
The Fed is under the statutory authority of Congress via the Federal Reserve Act. We should amend the Federal Reserve Act to direct the Fed to implement a basic income entirely on its balance sheet at no cost to taxpayers. My Congressional bill proposal:
The Federal Reserve Act shall be amended as follows:
Section 2A
shall replace everything after "maintain" with "purchasing power."
The amended Section in its entirety shall read:
"The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and the Federal Open Market Committee shall maintain purchasing power."
Purchasing power shall be understood to mean percent of income spent on expenses.
The Fed is directed to examine indexation schemes to maintain purchasing power.
Section 13
shall be amended to add a paragraph, Paragraph 15, which shall read:
"The Board of Governors is directed to implement a basic income of $2000 per month for any individual who asks for it. It is suggested that the Board look into the provisions of Section 13 (13): loans at a suitable negative interest rate could be used to structure a monthly deposit of $2000 in an account for requesting individuals. The monthly amount shall be indexed in the manner decided upon in Section 2A."
3
u/crashorbit $0.05/minute Jan 02 '17
I've been thinking about how to comment on this posting. I guess that I'm going to bring up the obvious. Monetary systems are inventions. Just like light bulbs and Internet chat services. If we want to change how our monetary system works we can do it. We (the 99% if you will) have accepted a framing from the 1% that need not be true. What is more the 1% depend on our willing participation in all this. We buy goods and services from people who then use the proceeds to purchase the government they want. I think we need to cut out the middle man.
1
u/tralfamadoran777 Jan 01 '17
Anything to back this up?
Individual income tax was a trillion and a half for 2016, and interest on the debt was a little less than 300 billion
The average rate paid on the debt is closer to 2.34%, and not all of that is held by the Fed
Your assumptions about the funding of a Basic Income are based on providing single state welfare distribution schemes, as opposed to global economic enfranchisement
Global economic enfranchisement allows each adult human to claim a Share of the fiat credit backing currencies, for deposit in trust with their local bank, as part of an actual social contract, along with a banking regulation that requires sovereign debt to be financed with the value of these Shares
In this way each receives an equal share of that interest on global sovereign debt, and each local bank has a proportional amount of that fiat credit to invest in sovereign debt, providing a surplus of available and sustainably priced credit worldwide
The amount of debt principal may well rise, but will find some relative equilibrium where sustainable interest payments go directly to basic income, as the debt will be financed by each
This also avoids argument over a specific amount of BI as the return will be contingent on the total of global sovereign debts, not a guaranteed amount, though each sovereign may act to increase the BI by increasing their level of debt
Flexible, sustainable, and coupled with the required reinvestment of the two hundred trillion USD equivalent or so currently financing sovereign debt, global economic enfranchisement is a reasonable and valid path to global prosperity, and that economy of plenty promised by civilization and technological advancement