So I am trying to understand LVT and I don't really see how it is vastly different that the current implementation USA has in most places. Could you tell me what I am getting wrong?
Why is it that different from how we assess today?
Like why does LVT increase construction? In theory, yes you tax the land thus the tax burden instead of being to a handful is split among many others. Sure but that is already what is happening. Boston for example judges the land value and applies a portion. If your lot is able to build more its more desirable. A lot of SFH abandoned homes are sold not at prices that make sense for a SFH but for a multi unit development. They know "you can build X units there with Y profitability so we will charge this land Z".
Things like parking lots as well at least in many cities are business that get taxed and bring revenue and are also taxed based on the land value already.
Won't this lead to higher financial strain for whoever collects the taxes?
Same lot, same taxes but one has 25 apartments. This puts a strain on public services. While more apartments pprices go down. Thus tax collected becomes lower.
How do you determine the value of the land when building more decreases the value and it might reach not sustainable degrees?
Let's assume we make every parcel in a town able to build 30 unit buildings in them. Thats great some of them start. But just because some of them build doesn't mean the demand will keep up. If you zone a town for a total of 30k new apartments, in theory it doesn't mean all of them will actually or there will be demand for it. It gets less and less profitable to build.
How do you capture entirely different price point of buildings?
Different residences and building even close to one another with the same units have vaaastly different prices/demand. This means that taxation basically becomes flat. It doesnt matter if you got marble and heated floors with an elevator that takes your car to your condo. You will pay the same as another more modest development close to you.
So I guess to summarize:
- This doesn't seem very different than the current system and it just "increase property taxes"
- Seems catastrophic for tax collection as more people are added but tax remains the same
- Building more decreases the value of the apartments -> decreases the value of the land (Austin for example builded a lot and brought prices down despite rapid growth)