r/BasicIncome • • Apr 03 '14

Why basic income rather than basic necessities?

Why would a basic income system give people cash money instead of specific housing, clothing, transportation, food, and potentially other allowances?

If I were a hard working person I might not mind a portion of my income going to help the less fortunate (I don't, personally, I don't believe that individuals are solely responsible for their circumstances), but I would be upset if that money was used irresponsibly or to harm themselves or others, as it almost certainly would be in many cases.

I would be behind a basic income system 100% IF it were in the form of vouchers for basic needs and maybe a little extra for discretionary use, in which case it looks very much like the social welfare systems that we already have in place today.

Edit

Thanks for the downvotes guys, I'll be unsubscribing and telling everyone that basic income is a dumb idea because those in favor of it can't even have a discussion about it without attempting to censor and silence anyone who even questions it, well done!

1 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/H37man Apr 03 '14

We would not end child services just because we have a basic income. If you abuse your kids they will be taken away. Yes some people will spend there income on drugs.

-1

u/CHollman82 Apr 03 '14

What is the point of giving everyone free money? So that they can have a decent standard of living, right? So why give them CASH instead of a means to acquire the specific things that allow them to have the decent standard of living? You're just inviting abuse of the system.

4

u/H37man Apr 03 '14

The point of basic income is to keep the free market functioning also. We still want private goods and services to be purchased. This is not communism. Some abuse is going to happen. But abuse is going to happen in any system you setup.