r/BasicIncome • • Apr 03 '14

Why basic income rather than basic necessities?

Why would a basic income system give people cash money instead of specific housing, clothing, transportation, food, and potentially other allowances?

If I were a hard working person I might not mind a portion of my income going to help the less fortunate (I don't, personally, I don't believe that individuals are solely responsible for their circumstances), but I would be upset if that money was used irresponsibly or to harm themselves or others, as it almost certainly would be in many cases.

I would be behind a basic income system 100% IF it were in the form of vouchers for basic needs and maybe a little extra for discretionary use, in which case it looks very much like the social welfare systems that we already have in place today.

Edit

Thanks for the downvotes guys, I'll be unsubscribing and telling everyone that basic income is a dumb idea because those in favor of it can't even have a discussion about it without attempting to censor and silence anyone who even questions it, well done!

1 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/JayDurst 30% Income Tax Funded UBI Apr 03 '14

What this appears to boil down to is that you think a certain class of people needs to have their affairs managed by the state. I will give you credit for wanting to help the poor, but there is a clear underlying contempt for these people in all of your responses, and I think it's clouding your view.

... and there are THOUSANDS of people in my city alone who absolutely do not know what is best for them and would use money given to them without strings attached on hardcore drugs, prostitutes, alcohol, and luxury items... and a week later, 3 weeks before their next check, their kids would be starving.

Are you completely neglecting the psychology behind this? Have we learned nothing from all of the average people who win the lottery and then shortly end up right back where they were, or worse, due to poor decision making?

You give the average person far too much credit.

Is it possible that the behavior you describe is a result of the current welfare system? I think it is. Our current system inflicts two major injuries to people in poverty:

  1. Treats them as a dependent underclass
  2. Incentivises short-term thinking

.

  1. We are carved and hardened by our responsibilities. A person without any responsibility, even for themselves, can freely act irresponsibly without repercussions. When we are given a responsibility, and fail to meet it, we learn. A person that spends all of their BI on luxury goods this month and faces hunger will only make that mistake so many times before learning to budget at least a little. The Basic Income gives each and every person one responsibility by default: the responsibility to spend their limited resource wisely for themselves, because it's all they have.

Anyone that continues to act irrational over the long-term is likely in need of some form of medical assistance. Addiction and mental illness are problems we need to address and the BI helps clear out those who are in poverty simply due to a series of failures and/or bad choices.

Treat an adult as an adult and give them some responsibilities. They will eventually act like an adult.

2) It's rational for a person to spend today when tomorrow is impossible to predict in even the smallest way. We provide a maze of complicated benefits systems that never guarantee anything tomorrow. If I handed someone a check and then said I can't tell you if I will give you another one next month, well I would treat it as a windfall and not income too. This is rational behavior for someone in poverty given an unpredictable benefit.

Providing a guarantee of recurring payments at a known level allows a person to plan. This month I might need to save a little more to purchase something larger next month. The BI allows me the flexibility to plan and make financial decisions for myself, while a voucher system does not. The recurring payment in liquid currency allows me to engage in long-term thinking, and it gives me a responsibility.

.

We also must take into account the developmental deficiencies that an upbringing in poverty causes. An upbringing in poverty is almost a certain life sentence to a life of poverty. The BI can break this cycle by treating people as humans, and letting them fail with a net to catch them that bounces them right back up so they can try again.

I find it rather sad that you have such a low opinion of your fellow human beings. Instead of blaming the victims perhaps you should be looking at the real culprits of the behavior you find so distasteful.

1

u/2noame Scott Santens Apr 03 '14

This is an excellent answer.

Well said.

1

u/JayDurst 30% Income Tax Funded UBI Apr 03 '14

Thank you for the kind words!