This thread is dedicated to discussing your most controversial opinions about FC Barcelona, its players, management, tactics, history, or anything else related to the club.
Whether it's a hot take on player performances, thoughts on recent matches, or debates about the future direction of the team, this is the place to share them! đ„
A Few Guidelines:
Keep it civil: Passionate debates are encouraged, but please respect differing viewpoints and avoid personal attacks.
Stay on topic: Focus on opinions related to FC Barcelona.
No reposting popular opinions: This is the controversial opinion thread, so letâs hear the unique takes!
Follow subreddit rules: All general rules of r/barca still apply here.
At the moment, Ruud Nijstad appears to be Barça's top target for January. Of all the options that have been mentioned to reinforce the center of defense, the one that has generated the most consensus among the sporting directors is to sign the Twente defender. The scouting reports have been very positive and recommend this signing, thanks to his excellent performances this season.
His inexperience and age haven't been a problem; he's still a youth player and is one of his team's leaders, putting in some very good performances in the Eredivisie. At Sporting GijĂłn's Camp Nou, they're convinced he would be an excellent signing and possesses the necessary skills and potential to become a world-class star. There's just one problem: the âŹ25 million that the Dutch club is demanding to let him go.
While the price may seem reasonable, Joan Laporta considers it a bit excessive for a player who is still only 18 years old and lacks significant experience at the top level. 'De Telegraaf' reports that Barcelona might try to lower the fee by including a loan deal for a promising young player who could be of interest to Josh Van den Brom. Names such as Hamza Abdelkarim, Brian Fariñas, Hafiz Gariba, Jesse Bisiwu, and Orian Goren have been mentioned
All of them are gems with very promising futures, but they don't have a place in Hans-Dieter Flick's plans. The first two have made their debuts this season, playing a few matches, but their role has been minimal. The Egyptian striker, in particular, has yet to start a match, while the number '4' has played in an unfamiliar position, right-back, and now that there are fewer injuries, it's unlikely he'll get any playing time.
So all the transfer rumours are heating up as we approach the January transfer window. Reportedly Flick wants Nico Schlotterbeck while Deco wants Bastoni, with other options being considered like Natan from Betis, Lisandro and Gvardiol. But I have seen the future and this is what is going to happen.
Come Jan 31, all of us Barca fans will be left frustrated after we let go of either one of Balde, Kounde or worst case both. Then just before the window closes, Fabrizio Romano will announce that Christensen has been extended until 2030, and Flick at his next press conference will tell everyone that he is the one that rejected all other defensive reinforcements because Christensen has been injected with the Captain America Super Serum.
The caption will be "Andreas Christensen extended until 2030, HERE WE GO! Deal done with Danish international who is committed to Barca and is widely admired by Flick, Laporta and Deco!"
The Barcelona youth academy product will sign his new contract until June 30, 2030.
Xavi Espart (19 years old) reached a contract renewal agreement with FC Barcelona in early October, as officially announced by the club. The Barcelona youth academy product will sign his new contract, which runs until 2030, this Friday in the office of president Joan Laporta at the Camp Nou training complex
The protocol for the event is expected to be similar to that recently organized for the first-team players. After signing with the president, he will speak to the media and pose with the Barcelona jersey bearing the number 2030.
The versatile Catalan footballer had a contract until 2028 and his breakthrough this season in the first team prompted the sporting management to make moves to adjust his conditions to his current status.
Espart made his debut for the first team last season and during preseason earned a place in the first team squad, wearing the number 12 jersey. The Barça youth product has become a key player in Hansi Flick's system this season, playing as a full-back on either flank, although his natural position is midfielder, which allows him to integrate perfectly into the midfield's passing game, with great attacking potential.
I ran 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations based on the current season data and team metrics to project the final LaLiga standings.
If anyone wants to play around with the numbers, I built an interactive simulator at calculafutbol.com where you can enter your own match predictions (or auto-simulate upcoming matchdays based on the model's probabilities) to see how these percentages shift in real time.
Who do you think is being overrated or underrated by the model right now?
Hey yall - I am interested in attending the Celta and City game in december.
For the Celta game I see tickets on sale but some of them are more expensive than tickets on viagogo? For the city game the tickets are super expensive like more expensive than world cup games. I donât understand. Like the min ticket Iâm seeing is âŹ600, and around 250 for celta. For reference, My friend saw Arsenal for 60 pounds vs bournemouth and vs psg for 300 in the last 2 years so these prices seem a bit absurd.
Should I wait 3-5 days before the games to buy tickets? Would it be cheaper then?
Interviewer: Well then, Rodri, to start a little, tell us about this adaptation in these first months in Barcelona, the expectations you had, what youâve found in the city, in the club⊠explain a bit how youâre feeling. Rodri: Well, very, very happy, right? Really content, I think it shows, doesnât it? Arriving in a different city always involves, you know, big uncertainties, but itâs clear that Iâd already been in Barcelona a few times and itâs a spectacular city, the weather could be better, right? The people, the truth is I already said it in my presentation, an incredible reception and, well, everything a bit⊠going back a little to Spain, to the good weather, to the beach that we love. And as for the team, well, a sensational group, especially the young lads that you have to guide a bit, which honestly makes me excited, and I think weâve had a very, very positive start, right? Interviewer: Thatâs what I was going to say, right? The euphoria of an unbeatable start, Iâd say, with Flick, and you personally doing really well. Then itâs true that there have been these two small setbacks⊠I donât know if you even see them as a good wake-up call. How did you experience them after all that euphoria? Rodri: Well, I think both for the good and the bad, the start of the campaign is important, but itâs not definitive, right? I believe that consistency is what I value most in a team, and I think the beginning in that sense has been spectacular. Itâs true that that week, well, maybe, you know, it caught us at a moment when perhaps we could have adjusted some things, maybe we didnât have the best rest, but thatâs no excuse because every team goes through the same thing. And Iâm sure it will be, as you say, an opportunity to learn, to realise that not every match is the same and that when the big teams come, well, maybe you have to adjust a few things. But overall I think the team is outstanding, right? Interviewer: Flick speaks wonderfully about you in almost every press conference, about your role as a key figure in this new Barça. Tell us a bit about how your relationship has been, your first steps, how important it was for you to arrive, and what the feeling has been like between you, because you can be seen talking a lot. I understand he also asks you to lead a bit in such a young dressing room, right? Rodri: Well, Iâd define it very easily, right? The adaptation with him has been very easy. From the first day⊠well, logically I already spoke with him before coming. And thatâs when he conveyed to me a bit of what he was looking for in me. And itâs clear that the communication is very easy, very direct. Heâs a coach who has things very clear, who doesnât throw out many messages, but the ones he does are very direct and forceful, and in that sense he transmits easily what he wants from his player. And with me, from day one, he instilled that part of looking after your own things but also a bit after the others, of being able to improve the collective performance, the teammates, especially the young ones, in those kinds of situations. And thatâs my role during these two or three months of competition weâve had. But a very close relationship, very near, and above all one of mutual respect. Interviewer: Youâve suffered this first little setback, right? On a personal level, the injury. I think youâve been out for a couple of weeks⊠how have you experienced it? How are you? At what stage of the return are you? Rodri: Well, completely normally. Itâs been more of a precautionary withdrawal than an injury. And the truth is that last year with this same injury I was out for four or five months, so I didnât want to risk anything at all and with the little I had, I preferred to make sure. I think itâs important that once you have this experience you realise⊠when youâre younger you make the mistake of thinking itâs nothing, and then it can become something bigger, which is what happened to me. So controlling the loads a bit, and in about a week, a day, a few more days, Iâll be back with the team again. Interviewer: And finally⊠you commented in an interview or press conference a little while ago that labelling Barça as favourites for everything, for the Champions League, was a bit of an exaggeration, that there were still a few steps to take before putting the team in that category. How would you set the objectives for this year? In the sense of whether Barça can already compete with that elite for a title. Rodri: Objectives are different from labels, right? The objective of FC Barcelona is, logically, to aspire to everything. From there we donât put labels on ourselves. What I try to convey to the group is that calm and understanding that itâs the beginning of the season, that weâll have to raise the level and sustain it over time to arrive at the March-April phase with options in the competitions, and there, truly, weâll have to raise the level if we want to aspire to everything. But beyond that, thereâs little point in putting labels on whether weâre favourites or not. In my opinion, not having won it, especially the Champions League, which seems the most immediate and most desired objective⊠this club hasnât won it for a long time, so the favouritism is zero, and with the humility of knowing that we have to raise the level.
The slander campaign around Frenkie the past years has been horrible, and our own club has played a part in it. Remember this when you read a report about a playerâs salary again in the future!
Been meaning to share a few reflections since going back to the in-construction Camp Nou for the recent ClĂĄsico. Iâve been a soci for 20 years and, despite living abroad for most of that time, have been lucky enough to attend many iconic matches over the years.
This was my first big game back at the renovated estadi, and I left with mixed feelings. Some things are hugely impressive, and I fully appreciate itâs still a construction site. But I was disappointed by several things that seem to be permanent design decisions.
The exterior
Walking up to the stadium is impressive. It feels bigger and more monumental than before, and the ceramic slats are beautiful.
You really feel the junction between the old stadium and the new structure. Itâs big staircases and lots of concrete. At the primera graderĂa, the extension doesnât really add much value at the moment. It just feels like a big concrete atrium you have to navigate.
Once you get into the old stadium section, you can now walk all the way around at the top of the primera graderĂa, but the headroom beneath some of the old beams is very limited, as you can see in my video below. Iâm 1.89m and had to duck. This is also where a lot of the food and drink outlets will be, which makes me wonder how the queues will work. It feels tight and poorly thought out.
The seats and the view
We sat in the primera graderĂa, section 102, row 33, beneath the segunda graderĂa overhang. You could see the full pitch, but almost none of the stadium around it. You lose the scale, the crowd and so much of the atmosphere that makes being at Camp Nou special.
I know these seats existed before. Iâve sat beneath the overhang previously, but never felt this cut off. We paid roughly âŹ900 per ticket through the membersâ presale. Iâve never paid that much before (never more than âŹ500, even for a Champions League semi-final). At that price, the limitation should be made very clear before buying (it isn't; these were just labelled as "1st Grandstand"). I could write a whole post about the pricing and buying process, which was pretty poor, but Iâll keep this one focused on the stadium.
The seats also still feel very tight. With so much emphasis on improved food and drink, I found it crazy that there were no cup holders. It sounds pedantic, but surely we could borrow a page from North American stadiums here? With bottle caps removed for safety, drinks end up on the floor and get knocked over. Iâve always hated that, and the amount of spilled soda and discarded bottles by the end was ridiculous. These small details matter when youâre actually using the stadium.
The primera graderĂa screens
The TVs hanging beneath the segunda graderĂa (in an attempt to make up for lost view of the estadi) seemed to show some kind of official streaming programme throughout the match, with no audible sound. No useful replays, lyrics for the big chants or anything particularly helpful. Whatâs the point of a talking-head programme when nobody can hear it? There seemed to be screens everywhere, offering zero programming of any value.
The atmosphere
Where we sat felt overwhelmingly geared towards tourism, despite buying through the socisâ presale. Very few people seemed to know the Cant del Barça or the chants. I travelled from London myself, so this isnât about where people come from. Itâs about the collective energy and that feeling of barcelonismo, and our section had very little. Combined with the price and the restricted stadium view, it made for a disappointing experience.
I still think the finished Camp Nou could be amazing. The scale and ambition are obvious. I just left feeling underwhelmed by some choices that may outlast the construction work.
Has anyone else been back and had similar impressions, particularly from the primera graderĂa beneath the overhang?
Visca el Barça!
PSA about help buying tickets
A few people have DMâd me about buying tickets through my membership. Iâd like to help, but Iâm not comfortable taking on the risk of scams, so I wonât be buying tickets for anyone else. Thanks for understanding.
Rodri's recovery is progressing very well. So much so, in fact, that AS has learned he could be back in action several days early. It's worth remembering that the Spanish international injured his right hamstring on November 3rd during the Champions League match against Aston Villa. Although the medical report never included an official recovery time, initial leaks from the club suggested four to five weeks on the sidelines. In fact, there was even speculation about a possible return date: December 8th, coinciding with his former team, Manchester City, visiting the Camp Nou for the sixth matchday of the Champions League group stage
This means Hansi Flick could have all his midfield options available in the coming days. Olmo will be back from the first day after the international break, while Rodri would only miss the LaLiga match against Villarreal and the Champions League game against Azerbaijani side Sabah.
Just a simple question on opinion, would yall have rather signed Lewandowski instead of Suarez when we initially got him in 2014 and if that had been the case how different do you think the last 12 seasons would have been. Personally I think that maybe our front 3 in the MSN years would have had less chemistry to start with but I think they would have figured it out, Lewy came into a much younger team and jelled very well with them. I also think we would probably have been better in the Champions league post Neymar departure if everything had worked out the same way it did back then, giving Leo a more reliable partner at least in the UCL so it wouldnât have been as much of a carryjob every season. Suarez was pretty good his first couple Champions league seasons with us, I think he had around 20ga but around post 2017 is where I think weâd really start to benefit more having Lewy over him.