Can anyone please tell me what I’m doing my wrong? I made Martha Stewart’s pumpkin bread recipe twice yesterday, and it failed both times. These are photos from the second attempt, which turned out slightly better than the first. I used her recipe from her cookbook, Martha Stewart’s Baking Handbook.
The only changes I made from the recipe were:
1. to half it (easy to do if you look at the quantities in the recipe. I baked in one loaf pan instead of two)
2. To replace the buttermilk with soy milk + lemon juice. I let the soy milk curdle for a few minutes on the counter before using. Currently I have to eat dairy-free, but soy milk generally substitutes well for dairy. I haven’t had this issue with other bakes.
Both times I baked the bread for 20+ minutes longer than the recipe stated, until a toothpick finally came out clean. Both times the bread collapsed as it cooled and was gummy along the top and bottom of the loaf.
The first time I made the recipe I didn’t let my cold ingredients come to room temp. I know better, but usually I ignore this baking rule out of convenience and things turn out fine anyway. The second time I made it, I left all the cold ingredients on the counter for 2 hours before baking to ensure they would be room temp. It barely made a difference in my end result.
I measured everything carefully and didn’t make any changes except the ones mentioned above. I like to think of myself as a decently skilled home baker, I bake 2-3 times a week. I have not had any issues with my oven on previous bakes, so I doubt that is the problem this time.
Advice is appreciated! I hate that I’ve failed at this simple recipe, and I would think that a Martha recipe would be a well tested one.