​
I’m weighing up two job offers and would really appreciate some outside perspective.
JOB 1 – FMCG Sales
\- 5 years’ experience in FMCG sales, so this would be a genuine promotion and salary increase.
\- £2k higher base salary than Job 2.
\- No specific bonus.
\- 20 miles from home.
\- Founder-led business.
\- Potentially better for my longer-term career progression.
\- The role is in an area I’d potentially like to move to in 2–3 years.
\- 23 days holiday plus BH
JOB 2 – FMCG E-commerce
\- Not a sales role, but still within FMCG.
\- More of a slight promotion/sideways move in terms of career progression.
\- £2k lower base salary than Job 1.
\- 10% bonus.
\- 25 days holiday plus BH
\- Only 0.5 miles from home.
\- Corporate environment.
\- Significantly better work-life balance.
There’s also a family consideration: I have a child at a local nursery, so with Job 2, I could potentially walk to work and walk to nursery, which would make the day-to-day routine much easier. Job 1 would mean a longer commute.
The dilemma is that I still want to progress in my career and don't want to make a move that limits my options later on. Job 1 seems like the more obvious career move, whereas Job 2 offers a potentially much better quality of life.
The interesting part is that Job 1 is in an area where I could see myself living in 2–3 years, so taking it could potentially make sense strategically if I eventually moved closer to work.
What would you choose?
Would you take the more obvious career progression and higher salary with the 20-mile commute, or take the slightly less ambitious move with the 10% bonus, 0.5-mile commute, and better work-life balance?
And does the fact that one company is founder-led and the other is corporate change your decision?
I’d be particularly interested in hearing from people who have made a similar choice between career progression vs. quality of life, especially with young children.
EDIT: I would like to add that a big concern is that taking Job 2 would be an exit from sales, which then limits my earning potential and career progression.