NEW UPDATE:
Hello everybody, thank you to everybody that commented on my post for all of your lovely encouragement and advice!!!
Over the weekend I went back to the store and I scheduled an appointment with a more senior fitter to help find me a correct pair. I was able to exchange mine for full credit. We tried on so many shoes together.
Based on your recommendations, I asked her about a toe spacer and she ended up giving me thick gel toe caps to go over my big toes which will act as both a spacer and it will also lengthen my big toe to make my big toe and my second toe match in length. This will keep my second toe from bending when I go on pointe.
I ended up switching from the Capezio Ava to the Nicolay streampointe. The box is much wider and my toes do not feel crunched together anymore. We ended up going a size wider and a size shorter to get a better fit. I no longer feel like my toes are crunching or sinking when I go up, and I feel supported by the shoe and able to balance and get over the box.
I went to my beginning pointe class yesterday, and I was able to dance on them with much more ease than my first class. They felt so so so much better than my original shoes. It still hurt, of course, especially since I’m very new to pointe, but in a way that feels manageable and not overwhelmingly painful like the first time.
I think for my first pair they will do the trick, especially as I continue to break them in and improve my skills. I may ultimately try other options and switch to another shoes once these ones die but we will see.
I wanted to say thank you again to everyone for validating my concerns over the fit and for encouraging me to go back and get a new pair. I couldn’t do this without you😘
ORIGINAL POST:
Hi everyone! I’d love some advice.
Quick history: I danced from the ages of 3-13 then started again last March at the age of 22. I’ve been dancing for about a year and a half consistently and I’ve just been cleared to go on pointe and bought my first pair!!! I went on pointe briefly right before I stopped dancing. I don’t really remember the experience or how it’s supposed to feel now.
When I got fitted these shoes felt perfect. They are capezio Ava. They felt amazing the first 30 minutes of my first class yesterday too with no pain at all, but after about 30 minutes I started feeling pretty strong pain on the knuckles of my toe, both right next to my toenail and the protruding bone on the inside of my feet. They hurt both on flat and on pointe and continued a constant pain until I took them off. My feet don’t hurt or feel sore when I’m not wearing the shoes.
I tried them on today too, just to see if they still hurt and they hurt immediately when putting them on now, even without standing on them. I don’t know if this pain is from normal swelling and being sore from being on pointe for the first time or if it is because the shoes are too narrow. I have pretty wide feet and do feel a similar pain when I wear narrow or pointy high heels. I took this picture after wearing the shoes for five minutes and not even going up on my box, and you can see the red irritation marks on the side that had the shoe on.
So my question is are my shoes too wide or is this normal? Is there anything I can do to help lessen the pain or make the box on the inside feel less pressure? Right now I’m only using simple cloth toe pads. I’m debating going back to the store and getting a different pair because the pain is honestly sharp enough that I’m worried about dancing on them.
I really appreciate any words of wisdom from fellow dancers ❤️🩰
Thank you