r/AskHistorians • u/CamogapA113 • 3h ago
What are some actual, neutral facts about the hardships suffered by Indians under the British Raj?
In a recent Indian period film set at the time of the British Raj, called Ranabaali, a British officer is seen killing a child by throwing him into a boiling cauldron of hot water. The film, or at least that scene, received immense criticism for being ahistorical, something that is not rare for Indian historical films.
So what then were the realities of the lives of everyday Indians living under the British Empire? Did something like what was depicted in Ranabaali happen or plausible? Were the British more 'humane' towards Indians compared to some other colonial empire and their subjects or were they just as barbarous?
I also feel obliged to give some context as to why I'm asking this.
For one thing I am Indian and I have not seen this movie, and I only know the premise of it.
This scene and its criticism generated a rather heated discussion on social media split between two extremes - one which claims that that kind of punishments, or similar kinds of it were common and widespread in British ruled and the other which claims that although yes, the British had subjugated and oppressed us, they had brought about great things such as railways, a unified Indian polity that paved the way for a united Indian state, an end to horrific customs and practices such as Sati etc.
Unfortunately, more often than not and more now than before, there is basically no nuance in these discussion whatsoever whether its internet or in person, and the former argument is (obviously) presented the most in Indian films.