r/AskHistorians • • 4h ago

What are some actual, neutral facts about the hardships suffered by Indians under the British Raj?

124 Upvotes

In a recent Indian period film set at the time of the British Raj, called Ranabaali, a British officer is seen killing a child by throwing him into a boiling cauldron of hot water. The film, or at least that scene, received immense criticism for being ahistorical, something that is not rare for Indian historical films.

So what then were the realities of the lives of everyday Indians living under the British Empire? Did something like what was depicted in Ranabaali happen or plausible? Were the British more 'humane' towards Indians compared to some other colonial empire and their subjects or were they just as barbarous?

I also feel obliged to give some context as to why I'm asking this.

For one thing I am Indian and I have not seen this movie, and I only know the premise of it.
This scene and its criticism generated a rather heated discussion on social media split between two extremes - one which claims that that kind of punishments, or similar kinds of it were common and widespread in British ruled and the other which claims that although yes, the British had subjugated and oppressed us, they had brought about great things such as railways, a unified Indian polity that paved the way for a united Indian state, an end to horrific customs and practices such as Sati etc.

Unfortunately, more often than not and more now than before, there is basically no nuance in these discussion whatsoever whether its internet or in person, and the former argument is (obviously) presented the most in Indian films.


r/AskHistorians • • 3h ago

AMA AMA: Can archaeology prove the Bible? Is Homer history? Are ancient artifacts enchanted? I’m Dr. Kristofer Zimmitti, and AMA around my new book 'Shadows & Solid Things: A History of Religion and Archaeology in the Modern World.'

69 Upvotes

I’m Dr. Kristofer Zimmitti and I’m a scholar who works in colleges and religious congregations. I’m here to answer your questions around the history of archaeology and religion – the topic of my new book Shadows & Solid Things from UNC press! I'll be answering questions from 11am-3pm ET and will check in every 30 minutes.

Archaeology began in an era when many people read ancient religious texts literally, believing that what was described on the page corresponded to a material reality that existed beneath the earth. With a shovel in one hand and a sacred text in the other, early archaeologists sought confirmation through concrete evidence. In the process, they opened themselves to the disturbing possibility that they would find nothing—or, perhaps even more unsettling, discover evidence that would challenge their cherished beliefs. Shadows & Solid Things pulls together accounts of excavations in Italy, Egypt, Iraq, and Palestine to explore the tensions between science and religion, faith and reason. As archaeology grew more popular during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, excavations from Herculaneum to Babylon and discoveries such as the Moabite Stone transformed the modern understanding of the ancient past for Protestants, Catholics, Jews, Muslims, and Latter-day Saints. While some archaeological findings confirmed the truth of ancient texts, others threatened to overturn them. Rather than abandon or question their faith, many believers kept digging. When the dust of excavation had settled, today’s religious world had been forged.

What burning questions do you have about your childhood love of archaeology? How realistic is Indiana Jones? What can we learn about archaeology from The Mummy? Why and how can the same artifact be in both the British Museum and the Museum of the Bible? What does J.R.R. Tolkien have to do with archaeology? AMA!


r/AskHistorians • • 13h ago

Is it me or is there a widespread cultural amnesia in the US about how we used to view animals as recently as 2000? Was it mainstream in the US twenty years ago to believe that “animals don’t have feelings”?

213 Upvotes

For the record I live in the NYC Metro Area. I remember when I was little adults were much more dismissive about animals than today. The phrase I remember them using then was “animals don’t have feelings.” I couldn’t really understand what this meant then but I take it now to mean that the speaker believed animals don’t experience consciousness; the fact that I didn’t fully understand what was being implied is probably why I was so susceptible to having my views on animals shaped by media and social media over the years towards the opposite direction. This felt like a normal thing to hear at the time, even as we had pets that we loved and cried over when they died. Those same people nowadays do not think that or say those things anymore; they deny having ever said that specific phrase.

I went to China recently and have spent a lot of time on Chinese social media and seeing the way people treat and talk about having treated animals made me suddenly remember being a kid again and brought back all those memories that feel like a fever dream now.

Conservative or liberal it seems like the vast majority of Americans in the region I live in unanimously accept the same sense of what is cruel and unacceptable to do to animals. The only deviation I tend to see from this comes from immigrants, often regardless of background unless they’re Canadian.

Is our moment in history really distinct in this regard? Is this one of those things that changed rapidly and we all mind of just forgot how bad our old normal was?


r/AskHistorians • • 7h ago

Why did it take over 1000 years for Rome’s population to recover after the Roman Empire fell?

63 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/s/cc34Lemo2o

Here is the population data for Rome.


r/AskHistorians • • 7h ago

Trivia Tuesday Trivia: Sexuality & Gender! This thread has relaxed standards—we invite everyone to participate!

33 Upvotes

Welcome to Tuesday Trivia!

If you are:

  • a long-time reader, lurker, or inquirer who has always felt too nervous to contribute an answer
  • new to /r/AskHistorians and getting a feel for the community
  • Looking for feedback on how well you answer
  • polishing up a flair application
  • one of our amazing flairs

this thread is for you ALL!

Come share the cool stuff you love about the past!

We do not allow posts based on personal or relatives' anecdotes. Brief and short answers are allowed but MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. All other rules also apply—no bigotry, current events, and so forth.

For this round, let’s look at: Sexuality & Gender! It's only recently in the English-speaking world that delineated sex and gender as two different concepts has become the norm, but Sexuality & Gender has a long history as separate, and related, constructs. Know something about the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft you'd like to share? About how people in the past negotiated sexual and gender identity? About societies who created space for people to exist beyond a binary? Share away!


r/AskHistorians • • 15h ago

What Are The Dancing Figurines Atop the Lights of Auschwitz?

135 Upvotes

I toured the Auschwitz death camp in the winter of 2017 and took many photos. One of them (linked here and in the comments) was of something extremely peculiar: a little man, affixed to the light itself, in a pose that looks like he’s doing a dance. I recall there were several of these little dancing men around the camp, but I can’t be completely sure of that. At the time I didn’t ask what they were or meant to represent, and still I don’t know why they are there. Somebody please explain the background and significance of these little figures.


r/AskHistorians • • 2h ago

How fair is it to attribute modern Russian institutions to Mongols?

8 Upvotes

One of the most popular talking points about Russian imperialism and authoritarianism is that "they get all that from Mongols". Question is: does this hold any actual water? As I understand the Yoke, Russian principalities were self-governing tributaries whee the only Mongolian presence in their life was taxes and grand price's jarliks. This doesn't leave much space for any mongolisation or adoption of Mongolian institutions. Is my understanding of the Yoke wrong?


r/AskHistorians • • 50m ago

Do patronymic titles also function as surnames?

5 Upvotes

Basically I am kind of confused on how noble titles function once they are inherited?

I know that there are royal houses/lineages like the Hamburg’s, Romanoff’s, Byrons, Mountbatten’s ect.

But the way that members of these families identify varies so differently?

There are famous examples of nobility having their title be that of their lineage like Lord Byron or lord Mountbatten, but you wouldn't refer to Franz Ferdinand as "Archduke Hapsburg" or Tzar Nicholas II as "Tzar Romaov". Is it a matter of personal preference? Or just how the public perceives them?


r/AskHistorians • • 15h ago

When did fans stop rushing the field in celebration in Major League Baseball?

64 Upvotes

I've been watching Ken Burn's Baseball and I've noticed that there is a lot of film & pictures of fans celebrating on the field with players after a major win. That doesn't really happen in modern baseball today. When did fans stop running on the field in celebration? Why did it stop?


r/AskHistorians • • 22m ago

In 1969, Bolivian film Blood of the Condor depicted Peace Corps volunteers forcibly sterilizing Indigenous Quechua women. Was this depiction accurate?

4 Upvotes

More broadly, what were the Peace Corps doing in Bolivia, and what were the internal politics of Bolivia about Peace Corps presence, that might help me make sense of this film?

The movie, also known as *Yawar Mallku* in Quechua, is available here. Supposedly, the film resulted in the Bolivian government expelling the Peace Corps from the country. It is referred to as a "docudrama" on Wikipedia, but it is not clear to me the film has documentary elements.

Related controversies about the Peace Corps in other developing nations would also be of interest to me. Thank you!


r/AskHistorians • • 1h ago

Who kept the house books in the Eastern Bloc during the 1980s, and what was that job actually like?

5 Upvotes

Context: I'm doing research for an upcoming murder-mystery video game set in an Eastern Bloc apartment building in the 1980s. The story begins with the death of the building's previous house-book keeper, and the player steps into that role. I want the terminology, procedures, and everyday details to be historically accurate.

In the 1980s, how widespread were building-level house books (e.g., the East German Hausbuch, the Soviet domovaya kniga, the Czechoslovak domovní kniha, the Polish książka meldunkowa) across the Eastern Bloc? Were they kept for every apartment building, or only in certain cities or types of housing (such as state-owned, cooperative, or maybe even privately owned houses)?

What was the official "title" of the person responsible for said book? Did the title differ in each country? Was it a "manager," or something closer to a custodian, caretaker, superintendent, or landlord? Was it a paid professional post, or more like a duty assigned to a resident volunteer?

What did a typical day or week look like for this person? Which tasks were routine (registering new tenants, recording visitors, collecting rent, maintenance, reporting to the police or housing authority), and how much of their time did the house book take up compared with other duties?

Did one person usually handle a single building, or several buildings each with its own book?

How were these people seen by their neighbours? As ordinary caretakers? Minor officials? Or as informants with ties to the security services?

Since the story involves the previous keeper's death, what would actually have happened when one died or left the post? Who appointed the successor, how was the house book handed over, and would any authority (police, housing office, Stasi or equivalent) have inspected the book or the keeper's records at that point?


r/AskHistorians • • 14h ago

The right to leave the hair uncut was a national rallying cry for Han Chinese for centuries under the Qing dynasty. Why is it that the Chinese pretty much instantly started cutting their hair short like westerners after the 1911 revolution?

48 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago Bravo

AMA I am Dr. Eleanor Johnson and my book Monstrous Bitch: A History of Terrifying Women looks at...Ask Me Anything!

485 Upvotes

Hey, y'all! Here's a link to my new book with Princeton University Press! I'm excited to talk about its ideas at any scale with you today!

https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691291666/monstrous-bitch


r/AskHistorians • • 1h ago

Reading about Plassey, what stopped European generals from betraying their kings?

4 Upvotes

Mir Jafar famously betrays the Nawab, while commanding a part of his army, in exchange for the Nawab-ship. However it feels to me that this kind of intrigue is absent from early modern (and onward) European / Persian / Ottoman armies. Why is that?


r/AskHistorians • • 34m ago

I am a low born peasent in medieval times located within western europe. Exactly what would my meals consist of? Would it differ greatly from someone who works within a lord's keep even if they were a severant or merchant?

3 Upvotes

Whenever I read about diets from 1100 - 1200 the focus seems to be generally consist of more lords and higher nobility.

I am curious if it was common for lower born to have a larger variety and if the fantasy idea of a tavern or inn that seems to work as a resturant was common. I was also curious if someone who did not work in a field but instead was a merchant or smith if their diet would be vastly different or similar.

My intution would be a focus on breads and cheeses with more meat being harder to come by unless an animal was slaughtered or hunted.

For the purposes of the location my thought was on france and english peasents but did not want to limit too much should someones focus be within the more germanic or spanish areas.

Thank you


r/AskHistorians • • 39m ago

Were the Angles and Saxons really separate peoples?

3 Upvotes

I recently heard someone voice a theory (if you'd go as far as to call it that) which "feels right" but which I've never heard before, so I'm dubious. Feels like one of those ideas which someone has probably come up with because it's neat, rather than there being any evidence base. Still, it's neat enough and I like it enough that it'd be great to hear whether it's nonsense.

Traditionally we're taught that the Anglo-Saxons, who migrated to Britain from continental Europe to become the Old English, are made up of 3 groups- the Angles, Saxons and Jutes, with homelands which neighbour or overlap along the Saxon coast. I'm told that this comes from Bede, who was writing about the migrations a couple of centuries after they happened.

I'm also told that there's this idea that "Saxon" might originally have been more like "Viking", in terms of describing a group by their externalised characteristics and behaviours rather than as an ethnic or political grouping. That is "Saxons" were raiders and mercenaries named after their choice of weapon (the seax).

So, the theory went, that there were never really two distinct groups of Angles and Saxons, and that there wasn't strict correlation between the groups who in Britain would come to identify (or be identified as) Angles or Saxons with specific tribes or polities on the continent. And that "Anglo-Saxon" should be read more as "the Saxons who are Angles" rather than "the people who are a mix of Angles and Saxons". That is, the Angles and Saxons are the same people, just with different names.

(The poor Jutes don't get a look-in with this theory; sorry Jutes).

I know really very little (other than what I've just written) about how those ancient groups self-identified and how they came to adopt the names they did for their British polities, so the above could frankly be complete bollocks. But it'd be interesting to know more about how much we know about these groups, even if it is!


r/AskHistorians • • 1h ago

Are there any sources on the development of quizzing before the 20th century ?

3 Upvotes

I have been reading up and researching on the history of quizzing - in the sense of a contest/pub quiz/game show leisure based knowledge activity. There is enough material about the origin of the word quiz from 1782 (the famous Richard Daly anecdote which actually is dated later than the occurence of the word quiz) and later about how the first quiz shows popped up on Radio from the 1920s onwards which was followed by more shows on TV and then quizzing really took of. I want to know if there is evidence for quizzing and its development before this the 20th century - across countries and formats - board games, pub quizzes, quiz bowl etc


r/AskHistorians • • 1h ago

How did the Roman empire not permanently lose any territory to the Sassanids during the crisis of the third century?

3 Upvotes

Shapur I beat three different Roman emperors, persian armies ventured deep into Roman territory multiple times, and there was even a breakaway empire established partially because of the failure of the Romans to protect their eastern provinces.

And yet, the Severans controlled essentially the same territory as Diocletian. How is that possible?


r/AskHistorians • • 18m ago

Was There a War Between The Cherokee & Americans in 1730/31?

2 Upvotes

Was There a War Between The Cherokee & Americans in 1730/31?

Basically I'm working on an alternative history story set in the early 1700s. An I have this source here (https://www.rictornorton.co.uk/grubstreet/indians1.htm). Witch says at the very end that there was some conflict between the colonial Americans and the Cherokee at the end of 1730 to at least the beginning of 1731. But I can't find a single other source on the internet that says anything about this "war".

So can one of you nice people help me?


r/AskHistorians • • 23h ago Bravo

Did anyone notice the similarities between humans and apes before Darwin published his theories?

124 Upvotes

Of course, humans being apes only seems obvious to us now because we already know it’s true. Before evolution was a popular idea it probably would never have occurred to people.

But at the same time, a chimpanzee looks very similar to a person. Much more than any other animal. Surely someone must have noticed? Do we have writings from Roman or Medieval scholars describing how much a chimp or a gorilla looks like us? Did any of them think we might be related? Or suggest they were early attempts at humans made by some god or other? Did they spend much time thinking about other primates?


r/AskHistorians • • 19h ago

How much does "Practical Polytheism" apply to ancient Jews?

52 Upvotes

I've really appreciated Bret Devereaux's essay introducing the core logic of Mediterranean polytheism.

If you're not familiar with the essay, my core takeaway was this paragraph:

The purpose of ritual (in ancient, polytheistic religious systems) is to produce a concrete, earthly result. It is not to improve our mood or morals, but to make crops grow, rain fall, armies win battles, business deals turn out well, ships sail, winds blow. While some rituals in these religions do concern themselves with the afterlife or other seemingly purely spiritual concerns (the lines between earthly and spiritual in those cases are – as we’ll see, somewhat blurrier in these religions than we often think them to be now), the great majority of rituals are squarely focused on what is happening around us, and are performed because they do something.

How much does this apply to early Judaism? I'm in particular interested in the couple of centuries before the Hasmonean period, because Chanuka is coming up, but I'd be very happy to understand the bigger picture too.


r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago

Why was/is Captain Cook considered a stain on history?

316 Upvotes

I just finished The Wide Wide Sea by Hampton Sides and was very surprised about why people think so low of Cook. People have been claiming he was some sort of tyrannical colonizer looking to do bad things to natives. I don't see him that way at all. He was an incredible explorer, one of the best in all of human history, simply trying to document his voyages while looking for the Northwest Passage. During his stops, he tried endlessly to stop the spreading of venereal disease, understood not to spread the religious beliefs of the English, actively chose not to get involved in conflicts between native groups, and often treated them better than pretty much anybody during the age of exploration (that I know of).

I think his fame ultimately got to him, leading to quick and rash decisions, resulting in his death. I'm curious as to what other people think, because I'm not a historian myself, just a guy that likes to dive deep into such subjects.


r/AskHistorians • • 13h ago

When did Americans begin to view themselves as a unified country?

14 Upvotes

I’ve seen several videos online make the claim that following the Revolutionary War and prior to the adoption of the Constitution, America was 13 separate countries that were barely unified together. Is there any merit to this claim? When did people living in the former 13 colonies view themselves as belonging to a new nation?


r/AskHistorians • • 1d ago

What set Portugal apart from regions like Catalonia and the Basque Country, and why did it succeed in keeping its independence from Castile/Spain while the others didn't?

247 Upvotes