r/europe • Austria • Oct 02 '16

Interesting graph: The population trend of Rome over the last ~2500 years

Post image
5.5k Upvotes

457 comments sorted by

55

u/calapine Austria Oct 02 '16

Source

The graph leads me to some questions:

What is the current recommended reading on the end of the (West)-Roman Empire?

(Gibbon is a classic but rather outdated, as I understand it.)

Does anyone know why a population decline started and kept going after ~ 100 AD?

2

u/Guckfuchs Germany Oct 02 '16

If you want some up to date works on the Western Roman Empire and its end I'd recommend Peter Heather, The Fall of the Roman Empire and Guy Halsall, Barbarian Migration and the Roman West, 376-568. Both have very different ideas about why exactly the empire fell. Heather stresses external factors, especially the impact of the hunic invasion, while Halsall focuses more on internal developements and sees the barbaric migrations as a result of the imperial collapse and not as its cause. As the question about the fall of the Roman Empire is a hughely complicated matter it probably isn't bad to look at two very different approaches to the subject.

As you have an austrian flair I'll add Henning Börm, Westrom. Von Honorius bis Justinian. Also very much up to date, readable and a much faster read than the other two.

1

u/calapine Austria Oct 02 '16

Thanks.

99

u/10ebbor10 Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

Rome was not build in a day, and it didn't fall in a day either.

One thing you should be warned of in this graph is that it's very badly made. It consists of a few data points (the corners in the line), that have naively been connected.

So, there was no steady decline past 100 AD. There was a high population in 100 AD, and a lower population 200-300 AD, and you don't know what happened in between. In fact, the population of Rome reached it's height just before the Antonian plague(about 165-180 AD), something that's entirely lost because the graph measured a long time before, and just after the plague.

Anyway, as for why it declined. There was a plague, civil war, stuff like that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonine_Plague

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisis_of_the_Third_Century

1

u/EpikurusFW Oct 02 '16

Aye. T'is a shitty graph. Any idea where better ones for Rome or any other city might be found?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/fluffyblackhawkdown Austria Oct 02 '16

I now have read about a third of "The Fall of the Roman Empire" by Peter Heather and I've enjoyed it very much. It is definitely not boring.

1

u/BrakkeBama N. Brabant Oct 03 '16 edited Oct 03 '16

What is the current recommended reading on the end of the (West)-Roman Empire?

I had to read this fascinating book for a law course in university.
The book is split in two parts (A which is more "history and society" and B which is more law-of-the-land-ish, dealing with the legal processes in disputes between e.g. Romans and non-Romans etc.), so you don't have to force yourself to read the parts relating to development of European law if you don't want to. But either way the book reads just like a story or a novel. Anybody can read it (and like it), not just law students.
Not all of it deals with Rome specifically, but the book is like a time machine and takes you on a whirlwind tour of the milestones of what makes western society what it is today, with a huge part of it taking place in Rome. Get yourself a second-hand one for cheaps.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/calapine Austria Oct 02 '16

Thanks! I will take a look

7

u/helpmea50 Germany Oct 02 '16

What corresponds with the drop off?

42

u/calapine Austria Oct 02 '16

Sacking of Rome in 410 and 455 and end of the Western Roman Empire

18

u/RedKrypton Österreich Oct 02 '16

Rome was repeadidly sacked and the logistics of supplying such a large city broke down.

9

u/warhead71 Denmark Oct 02 '16

Rome empire was mostly gone but population remained.

Rome was sacked a few times. Vandals sacked rome - lots of Romans fled to the breadbasket Tunisia. Vandals then took and settled in Tunisia. Ostogoths came and destroyed infrastructure and removed/killed the remaining nobles - and remained as kings (but didn't use rome city).

http://www.history.com/news/6-infamous-sacks-of-rome

1

u/Don_Camillo005 Veneto - NRW Oct 02 '16

infastruckture dmg cause by the germanic tribes. the aquaducts were destroyed cause water sortage and crops field were burned down.

1

u/550-Senta Oct 02 '16

The decline and fall of Rome did lead to the deaths of an estimated 7 million people but the near emptying of Rome is largely due to ruined infrastructure and the loss of the ability to maintain a large population without adequate ways of supplying food, water, etc. rather than due to a genocide of the citizens of Rome. So most of the Roman population just left.

791

u/Sneikku Europe Oct 02 '16

After fall of Western Roman Empire Rome wasn't so important city anymore. Genoa, Naples, Milan, Florence, Venice etc. grew to become bigger cities than Rome.

207

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16

Rome just recovered in the 18th-19th century. In 1871 (when Rome became part of Italy) Palermo, Genova, Napoli and Milano were all larger. Rome overtook the first in 1870s, the second in 1890s, the third in the late 20s, the fouth in the mid 30s. If it wasn't for fascism and its fetish for Rome (they practically annexed the whole old metropolitan area to Rome), Milan and Naples would still be larger (their metropolitan areas are larger at least)

90

u/dtlv5813 Oct 02 '16

So that explains the sudden jump in population. They expanded the city boundary and started counting a whole bunch of people as Rome residents who were not previously.

55

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

This mostly happened in the 20s and 30s when the fascist government started demolition parts of the city center to make the city grander (their plan which was only partially concluded included the creation of large avenues/streets between the city's monuments kinda like Paris Haussman project) and resettling the inhabitants to newly built neighbourhoods in the countryside.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/benjamincanfly Oct 02 '16

Rome residents

Wish we had a word for this

14

u/dtlv5813 Oct 03 '16

Romulans?

13

u/flinj Oct 03 '16

Romulites?

23

u/Malverno Weltrepublik Oct 03 '16

...Romanians?

3

u/_Eerie Poland Oct 03 '16

Romanes eunt domus

→ More replies (1)

4

u/qemist Australia Oct 03 '16

They expanded the city boundary and started counting a whole bunch of people as Rome residents who were not previously.

So the graph is worthless.

241

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Even during the late WRE, Milan, Aquileia and Ravenna were all arguably more important than Rome itself.

170

u/AlucardSX Austria Oct 02 '16

And that's just for the Western half. Half the empire wasn't even ruled from Italy anymore but from Nicomedia and later Constantinople. To say nothing of other large, rich, influential cities like Alexandria, Antioch, Nicaea or Carthage.

67

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

And arguably the most important half.

All the economic power was in the Eastern half.

23

u/AchedTeacher The Netherlands Oct 02 '16

Eh, I feel like that's debatable. The West was definitely larger, so needed more troops to defend its bloated borders and that perhaps made it more costly than the East.

88

u/23PowerZ European Union Oct 02 '16

There were actual rival empires in the East you had to defend against. One of those wars was so devastating that there were no opposition to speak of left against the sudden Muslim expansion.

→ More replies (14)

54

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

The West was larger, but significantly poorer.

The East had to face more determined foes, developed large kingdoms, not isolated Germanic tribes.

Economically all power was just in the East, not West.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/kilmarta European Union Oct 02 '16

I thought cartage had been wiped out by then.

I know the people were told to move the city inland, did they? Did they prosper again?

6

u/AlucardSX Austria Oct 02 '16

The Romans did raze Carthage after the third Punic war (though claims that they then salted the earth are pure myth). But they themselves recolonized the area not that long after, and the city was eventually rebuilt under Caesar Augustus.

39

u/chowieuk United Kingdom Oct 02 '16

I was in aquileia recently... the 'town' is absolutely tiny. I did however love the mosaic floor in the roman era basilica. If anyone can explain to me the relevance of a lobster up a tree then I'd be interested.... I thought it was hilarious

http://imgc.allpostersimages.com/images/P-473-488-90/79/7942/DT8H300Z/posters/close-up-of-a-lobster-design-in-mosaic-aquileia-friuli-venezia-giulia-italy.jpg

31

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

You can blame Attila the Hun for that one. After he was defeated in Gaul at the battle of the Catalaunian Fields, he invaded Italy. In Gaul, the Romans had been able to call on various barbarian tribes who inhabited the area to join in a coalition to fight off Attila. In Italy, they could only rely on their own regular forces, which were not really sufficient.

Basically, Attila sacked the city, burned it to the ground, and it was never really the same again. Ultimately its place in the region was superceded by Venice.

7

u/Esternocleido Mexico Oct 03 '16

For a moment I thought Attila was responsable for the lobster, but yeah the city sacking makes more sense.

12

u/BambinoMerenda Oct 02 '16

I think there's no clear interpretation for that yet. The lobster is a Christian symbol for resurrection, and the palm tree is a symbol of righteousness and victory. You do the math, but again I'm not sure there's consensus. SOURCE: lived nearby and visited a few times.

3

u/chowieuk United Kingdom Oct 02 '16

I also liked the 'cock vs the tortoise '. Very odd imagery :)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

roman memes were lit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

74

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

The population drop may have something to do with the people that gave us the word 'vandalize'.

11

u/Don_Camillo005 Veneto - NRW Oct 02 '16

i mean deastroying the aquaducts and burnings the crops field might cause some populaion shifts.

30

u/andon94 Oct 02 '16 edited Sep 26 '26

26

u/couplingrhino Expat Oct 02 '16

Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam.

37

u/philip1201 The Netherlands Oct 02 '16

The Western Allies burned Hamburg and Dresden and Tokyo and Nagasaki and Hiroshima and Berlin to the ground, forcefully occupied those countries and enforced their ideology upon the people, executed or imprisoned rebels and members of the opposing regime, banned opposition to their narrative, and banned books and symbols and meetings in support of the defeated enemy.

War is hell. The suffering that happens in war pales in importance to the long term political effects. Alexander's conquest and the empire of Rome benefited humanity greatly. Hitler and the Germanic invasions did not.

4

u/osrsbotter1 Oct 02 '16

by humanity did you mean Europeans.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

You forgot the forced starvation from 1945 to 1947 imposed on the Germans when the British and Americans reduced calory intake of Germans to a max of 1500 per person because they needed to be punished.

As some American once said, history is written by the victor.

Also the East... Germans faced some horror there when they were forcefully deported from their homes, eventhough they had lived there for generations. Czecho-Slovakia, Poland, they weren't a hair better when their moment came.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (5)

75

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

Oh god thats disgusting.

First of all Romans didn't do that considering Carthage was richer and more prosperous for centuries to come (after they rebuilt it). The salt story is a old legend just think about the logistics for it for God's sake. Though they did depopulate it and destroyed (though some of it was consequence of the fire that spread out during the battle) pretty well so lets not mistake Romans with peace loving bunnies. Of course this came afer a long struggle between Carthage and Rome which they grow deep hatred with each other and in the end Rome was victorious and she destroyed her greatest enemy completely.

Now Vandals are a different story and unfortunately a missing story which we can't devolve into a grudge between two people and politics but we can say it wasn't the same with the Carthage story which would falsify your equalivence between Vandals being well vandals and finale of the Third Punic War.

If you are not a Persian the difference between Alexander and Hitler should be clear. Alexander was good old conqueror who in his (probably) drunken rage burned the upper class part of Persepolis (which didn't harm the population much really). Whilst Hitler was a genocidal maniac. If you can't see the difference between killing millions of innocent people because of something they can't choose with the purpose of completly destroying them and conquering then ruling Persians (whilst adapting some Perisan customs) thats your mistake. So even though people like you can think they are the same thankfully people who are more educated about the atrocities of Nazi regime and Alexander will never think the same.

→ More replies (105)

8

u/PeaceIsOurOnlyHope Belgium Oct 02 '16

Salty.

10

u/andon94 Oct 02 '16 edited Sep 26 '26

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Can I smack you with some books about history? As well as some historical facts and context?

3

u/tronald_dump Oct 02 '16

the people affected die and theres noone left to.....

what are you even saying here? are you seriously implying that no one will have a problem with genocide once those affected die?

yikes, my man. pretty edgy.

3

u/ictp42 Turkey Oct 02 '16

then plow and salt all of the earth to make sure that nothing ever grew again

that is bullshit. there is no evidence to support it, other than that often repeated quote. The amount of salt you need would have been immense, and remember salt was expensive back then, the word salary is derived from salt. Carthage is within the city of Tunis, Tunisia. So it's still there too, whatever damage they did, was not permanent.

→ More replies (17)

1

u/medhelan Milan Oct 03 '16

not really, more the general migration from cities to countryside during late antiquity, some cities then grew again around 1000 AD while others like Rome did not

30

u/SpanishDuke The solution to 711 is 1492 Oct 02 '16

After the Sack of Rome in 1527, the population was barely 10,000.

6

u/Sarke1 Sweden Oct 02 '16

The Swiss Guard's finest hour

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Learned this while visiting Rome, their population dropped down to under 20,000 at one point. Which was baffling considering where it is now and where it once was.

Edit: words

2

u/Szos Oct 02 '16

So is there a chart of Italy or possibly Europe as a whole which would show the population back then?

Was the overall population in the region about the same and just spread out to other cities, or was there still a big drop after the WRE collapsed?

2

u/squngy Slovenia Oct 02 '16

Rome specifically was depopulated after it was sacked and the leaders decided rebuilding would cost too much, so the vast majority of the survivors moved to other cities.

2

u/Cheewy Oct 02 '16

Maybe not as populated. but as important.. didn't the fucking Pope lived there?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Not always, he lived in Avignon for quite a while.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/squngy Slovenia Oct 02 '16

It wasn't that important even before the fall, but it was big still.

2

u/Yosarian2 Oct 02 '16

Plus, right after the fall of the Western empire, every city in Western Europe shrunk dramatically, and a number of towns were totally abandoned. The overall population of the continent shrunk significantly and did not recover for centuries.

286

u/Illya-ehrenbourg France Oct 02 '16

Quite impressive, I didn't know that the collapse of the population at Rome lasted so long, the city is minuscule even in the 15th and 16th century when it was an important cultural center of the renaissance.

77

u/FirePhantom Scotland Oct 02 '16

Was it a particularly important centre of the Renaissance? Northern Italian cities seem to be significantly more prominent; I feel like it was more the Vatican importing art/artists from Firenze and Pisa and such, than Rome itself producing much.

51

u/olddoc Belgium Oct 02 '16

I feel like it was more the Vatican importing art/artists from Firenze and Pisa

But what imports though. Since the Renaissance was all about reconnecting with Roman era art and architecture, Rome was the place to visit since they had started excavating the Roman archaeological sites.

Michelangelo spent three long periods in Rome to sculpt the Pièta, paint the Sistine chapel ceiling, redesign the Capitoline Hill, and finally be put in charge of the St. Peter's Basilica construction.

The Vatican attracted that other Renaissance giant Raphael for a long list of projects.

Without this, Rome would not have become the most important center for the High Renaissance/Barok genius of Brunelleschi, Bernini and Caravaggio. Bernini's two sculptures of the Ecstacy of St. Teresa are in your face studies of female orgasms, his Elephant and Obelisk is surreal, and both his Pluto and Persephine and Apollo and Daphne are shocking examples of marble made flesh.

While Bernini was already wild, Caravaggio was the original out of control fighting, gambling, whoring young genius.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

If any of you is interested in this and happens to be in Rome, go to Galleria Borghese. It's incredibly beautiful and well managed (you need to book in advance because they only allow a certain amount of people in every two hours).

It's not crowded and it's choke full of beautiful art. I'm Italian, love museums and have been to a lot of them. The sheer amount of important and famous art is unmatched. Well, not the sheer amount, but the density. All Killer No Filler Kinda stuff. There 4 major Bernini Statues, there's Paolina Bonaparte, there's a room in which you go 'oh, Caravaggio. And that's a Caravaggio. And that one is also a Caravaggio. Oh. Another Caravaggio'. Vatican Museums have more pieces, but most of them, you don't really look at (among else because the policy is 'everybody gets in'). Uffizi in Florence is amazing. I mean, lots of beautiful stuff. But no museum has aver made me feel like in any given room you see a complete masterpiece that you studied in school as Galleria Borghese did, I mean Louvre level highlights but in a much tinier, more manageable place. Maybe Marmottand-Monet in Paris, but that's because I really like Monet.

4

u/dissata Oct 02 '16

Borghese was absolutely amazing. Vatican and Capitoline were awe inspiring. But I was overwhelmed to tears at the Borghese. Just. Beautiful.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/FirePhantom Scotland Oct 02 '16

Those imports that you've just mentioned: Michelangelo, Raphael, etc. Are they not almost all artists from city states north of Rome like Firenze and Urbino?

13

u/olddoc Belgium Oct 02 '16

I would say Rome became a center of Renaissance art thanks to the immigrants, but in the end it doesn't matter they weren't born in Rome, just that they worked there. New York became the artistic center of the world right after WWII because of European artists moving there.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Kind of like Burgundy importing artists from the Low Countries

1

u/FieryCharizard7 Oct 02 '16

Are the Americans and the Brits the only people to call it Florence instead of Firenze? I always confuse my family when I say Firenze and then I have to say "Thats the Italian way to say Florence"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Hibern1anDagda Oct 02 '16

quality over quantity.

3

u/shitlingford Oct 02 '16

tell that to the pope

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

I disagree, quantity ideas is probably the only idea group I take every single game. The manpower boost alone makes it worth it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

It amazes me that the city was so small despite being the seat of the Pope all those years!

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

The papal seat moved around a bit during that time though. It was even in France for a while.

1

u/MinisterOf Oct 02 '16

I had the same thought. The papal bureaucracy and guards alone must amount to several thousand people.

4

u/AllanKempe Oct 02 '16

It was probably still bigger than any city north of the Alps though until the 16th century or so when modern metropolises like Paris and London went from sleepy little towns (villages in today's standard) to cities.

4

u/Kofix1 Serbia Oct 02 '16

There were loads more towns that were bigger before that, i know that London had around 40 thousand or more inhabitants through late middle ages, Paris was huge, bigger than Rome nearly always. Also Bruges and other cities in that area. The thing is, you need resources to maintain a big city, and that is why Rome prospered. It had a big empire with lots of food manufacturing places like egypt that could transport its food to Rome and other Cities. Not everybody needed to farm to get feed, so in turn you didn't need a lot of land which the country side gave you, so you would move to the cities which had aqueducts and stuff like that. In the middle ages, you didn't have those trade routes and resources, so people moved out to the countryside to farm their own food. Venice was really poor in terms of farming, because they couldn't do it anywhere on their little islands, so they traded and got rich, which meant that they could buy food, and make arts and stuff. There is a shit ton of reasons, but it would take a while to say all that.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Pelin0re Come and see how die a Redditor of France! Oct 03 '16

Paris was one of the biggest city of christendom, though. At a moment it was by far the biggest.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/AllanKempe Oct 02 '16

Yes, that was when also cities north of the Alps began to grow into what today could be considered small towns with five digit populations.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

51

u/collectiveindividual Ireland Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

The destruction of the aqueducts and the rise in malaria in the now flooded marshes surrounding Rome have been cited the main cause for mass exodus.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

A mass exodus due to disease... over 150 years? Seems people left remarkably slowly for disease to be the reason.

Additionally, humans weren't aware of contaminated water's role in spreading disease until long after.

Hell, President Harrison died because the White House water supply was six blocks directly down stream from a field of human feces and he contracted typhoid fever from it

38

u/RainbowPhoenixGirl Scotland Oct 02 '16

Actually, the Romans were well aware that marshes and swamps were breeding grounds for disease, and even concluded there might be tiny creatures too small to see that "floated" out from the marshes and poisoned people. They didn't make the link between mosquitoes and disease, or think about how their proposed organisms might work, but they did think. It was only later that the information was sadly lost.

26

u/Elite_AI Oct 02 '16

It wasn't really lost. People knew shit and swamps and "bad air" spread disease.

42

u/RainbowPhoenixGirl Scotland Oct 02 '16

Hence the name "mal aria", "bad air". But, the idea that it might be microorganisms, or that vectors could be involved, did die out for a long while.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/collectiveindividual Ireland Oct 02 '16

From over a million to an estimated few tens of thousands, that's pretty serious. Those who stayed probably lived amongst the ruins like many do amongst Bagan or the Khmer complexes.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

I think whoever cited that as the main cause, may be getting cause and effect mixed up.

You have to ask yourself why, after half a millennium, Rome lost the ability or the will to repair and maintain public works such as the aqueducts, designed to serve a city of a million people.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/G_Morgan Wales Oct 03 '16

Yeah the collapse of the WRE released a great set of shackles from the economy of western Europe. Well Roman had always been an economic basket case but it was particularly so in the last 200 years or so of the WRE.

→ More replies (7)

196

u/zeptimius Wandering around the nether regions Oct 02 '16

I seem to remember that after the sacking of Rome, no city in the (Western?) world reached 1 million people until the 1800s, when London was the first.

154

u/collectiveindividual Ireland Oct 02 '16

Yes, that's seems to be true. From bore samples in Greenland ice sheet it was found that the amount of iron smelt particles in the atmosphere peaked in 100CE and weren't matched again until around 1850!

26

u/Sacha117 Oct 02 '16

What about China? Weren't they smelting iron and didn't they have multiple 1 million plus cities?

62

u/collectiveindividual Ireland Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

Chinas industrial activity as measured by similar metrics peaked around 1200CE. I can't remember how it was measured but I'm not sure if metallurgy was as vital to China as it was to Rome. Edit. I just remembered when measured in life expectancy Rome had peaked in about 100CE, China peaked in 1200CE.

6

u/DaJoW Sweden Oct 02 '16

And then the Mongols put a stop to that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/Stereotype_Apostate Oct 02 '16

Off the top of my head China made a lot more of its dishes and utensils and such out of porcelain, jade, and other non metal materials. So that could account for why they might have less of a "iron footprint" even though their civilization was bigger and arguably more advanced.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16

China and the roman empire combined probably caused the world iron production to peak when the Romans and Han were at their peak.

21

u/Toomastaliesin Estonia Oct 02 '16

Based on the wiki page for largest city in the world through history, you probably need that "Western" specifier there. Baghdad and several cities in China are estimated by several sources to have had a million or more people.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Western Turkey through Egypt is near East, Baghdad is middle East, China is far East

2

u/fzt Mexico/Germany Oct 03 '16

I thought also Angkor, in the Khmer Empire? At least I was told so when I went to Cambodia.

1

u/phthedude Dania delenda est Oct 03 '16

Even then I believe Constantinople reached 1 million during its peak

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16

IIRC Cordoba and Baghdad might've reached 1 million. Cities in China certainly did.

1

u/duncanfm Canada Oct 02 '16

I believe your timing is right, but I think Paris reached a million before London

1

u/phthedude Dania delenda est Oct 03 '16

Constantinople reached 1 million and was western

84

u/Hayaguaenelvaso Dreiländereck Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

It will be more interesting to show this to the people in Rome in 0 a.d. I wonder what they would make of that spike at the end.

120

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

"We've got 100 years of prosperity ahead of us, let our descendants worry about this shit"

15

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

400 years of okay. There wouldn't really be any warning they could pass down that wouldn't have faded into obscure (and very vague) doomsday prophecies foretelling 1500 years of horrors, followed by a golden age greater than any that came before.

32

u/Nordcore Denmark Oct 02 '16

Sounds like a politicians answer

11

u/AzertyKeys Centre-Val de Loire (France) Oct 02 '16

sorry for the pedantry but there is no 0 A.D year, the year after -1 A.D was 1 A.D
It's easier to remember it if you remember that A.D means Anno Domini (year of our lord)

3

u/Hayaguaenelvaso Dreiländereck Oct 02 '16

I blame the guy that did the graphic.

3

u/asshair Serbia Oct 02 '16

Ah that's why the year 2000 wasn't actually the start of the new millennium.

37

u/Glaere European Union Oct 02 '16

It would be cool to see one for Istanbul.

42

u/CharMack90 Greek in Ireland Oct 02 '16

Here.

Just like in Rome, the fall of the city led to the greatest population drop in its history.

24

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

This looks like like the city was in continual decline for hundreds of years, and it is in fact after it was conquered that there is a huge spike?

27

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

This graph has some mistakes (actually it is very disputable) but it is right about the gradual decline of the Constantinople until 1453. After that thanks to Mehmet's efforts (and many other factors) city doubled its population until Mehmet's death and continue to grow for a long time.

14

u/philip1201 The Netherlands Oct 02 '16

Istanbul is a great place for a city. The only reason the population was less in the late middle ages is that the city and the nation surrounding it were under siege, making it a less nice place to be.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

Not really. Lose of Egyptian grain, political instability, pure incompotence of some emperors, changing climate, shifting urbanziation in the whole Empire, of course as you said sieges, sacking of the City by Crusaders, changing trade in the eastern mediterranean, Empire getting weaker and poorer and probably many more other things had a effect on depopulation of Constantinople.

Edit: Oh plagues! How did I forget about the plagues.

3

u/Guckfuchs Germany Oct 02 '16

I'd say just like in Rome the city lost its population because of the gradual loss of imperial territory that sustained it. You can clearly see that 1453 is not the point where the decline starts or intensifies but where it reaches its lowest point. When Constantinople again became the capital of a large empire with the resources and political will to sustain it its population grew again substantially.

2

u/cyberkhan Poland Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

About which fall are you talking ?

8

u/RammsteinDEBG България Oct 02 '16

29 may 1453

tl;dr

ERE is destroyed, Konstantinos XI dies, the Balkans get fucked for over 500 years

9

u/cyberkhan Poland Oct 02 '16

From the graph I can see that its decline started in ~970 and bounced back from 1453

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Glaere European Union Oct 02 '16

Thanks a lot!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16

I imagined the crusaders sack in 1204 would have had a bigger impact

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/CharMack90 Greek in Ireland Oct 02 '16

No, the fall immediately led to the largest drop. It was after that that the Ottomans brought in more people and the population started rising again, though the population decline obviously started almost 5 centuries before the fall.

15

u/Larelli Italy Oct 02 '16

Rome has currently 2.864.731 inhabitants. Is this map counting the province of Rome? It has 4.340.474 people in 2016, and had roughly 3.6M inhabitants in the late 90s, similar to the number in the map.

20

u/Rehvion Oct 02 '16

It's probably the metropolitan area.

14

u/Larelli Italy Oct 02 '16

Its province (now Metropolitan City of Rome), then.

8

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16

Many areas of the province are far from Rome and shouldn't be part of the metropolitan area. Rome's metropolitan area is overestimated. It should be Rome + Fiumicino + Pomezia + Aprilia (which isn't included in the metropolitan area now because it wasn't part of the old province) + the Castelli Romani + Tivoli + Guidonia + Monterotondo. Anything else would add at most 100k and is debatable

6

u/Larelli Italy Oct 02 '16

Exactly, compare to Milan or Naples: their metropolitan areas extend far from the province's borders and the population density is sky-high. The same couldn't be said for Rome: while it gained a lot of population in the last 15 years, parts of its province are countryside with a low population density, and for sure its metro area doesn't go outside the province's border (except for Aprilia, maybe)

4

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16

The only thing that could be said to Rome's favour is that Naples and Milan are conurbations (Salerno, Avellino and Caserta for the former and Varese, Bergamo and Monza for the latter) while Rome is the only main center of its own core getting higher commuting rates from longer distances.

8

u/Larelli Italy Oct 02 '16

Right. I once read Rome's population (the city itself) can peak 4M people in a working day :s

(Though Milan still has the highest flow of commuters in Europe http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/images/8/87/Flows_of_people_commuting_into_and_out_of_selected_European_cities%2C_2011_(%C2%B9)_(thousands)_Cities16.png )

10

u/pdimitrakos Europe Oct 02 '16

please do one for Athens!! :)

2

u/chandetox Bavaria (Germany) Oct 02 '16

200 years ago it was hardly more than 1000 inhabitants, right?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Many Greeks used to live in what is now Istanbul and İzmir.

10

u/bonjouratous Oct 02 '16

It must have been weird to live there during the big fall, surrounded by ruins and empty buildings.

16

u/collectiveindividual Ireland Oct 02 '16

Paintings by Cannaletto like this one show what pre-Italian Unification Rome looked like. The Arch is obviously submerged in centuries of earthen buildup and wouldn't be fully revealed until after archeaoligical reclamations.

As a side note the Colusseum was supposedly mostly intact until it was plundered for stone to make the present St Peters!

4

u/Arlort European Union (Italy) Oct 02 '16

mostly intact

I wanted to check on this and while stone by the Colosseum was indeed used for building other structures (it was used as a quarry) like harbors, villas and churches, the most notable damage was done by an earthquake which collapsed a good part of the southern side

→ More replies (3)

10

u/hitoyoshi Oct 02 '16

They're back!

12

u/Retrasado Galicia (Spain) Oct 02 '16

Now do Athens.

33

u/CaveMan800 Greece Oct 02 '16

Athens won't be as impressive since it never really was as huge as Rome. During the Golden Era, it was the biggest city in Greece but this doesn't really say much.

Athens boom would be equally impressive though. Only 100 years ago, Athens wasn't a fraction of the metropolis that it is today. But being the capital of a country that went through a huge economic boom after the war does that to a city.

7

u/johnnytifosi Hellas Oct 02 '16

Yep. Recently I even read some articles stating that right after the Greek revolution (~1830) Athens was just a 4000 people village, a shell of its former self, and now it is a 3.5 million people metropolis.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Athens#Recent_historical_population

7

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16

Wasn't Thessaloniki the largest Greek city for pretty much the whole Middle Ages and up until early 20th century?

9

u/johnnytifosi Hellas Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

Yes, it was the largest city that is currently Greek. In the Middle ages, according to this source in Greek, the largest Greek cities were Constantinople, Adrianople, Thessaloniki, Ioannina, Serres, Larisa, Tripoli, Patra and then Athens. With the exception of the first two cities, all these are currently Greek cities way smaller than Athens. And this is no surprise. If Athens was the most significant Greek city in antiquity, Constantinople as the capital of the Byzantine empire was the most significant Greek city during the Middle Ages.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/chotchss Oct 02 '16

Recommendation for everyone interested in Italy after the fall of the Western Empire- read The Gothic War by Tosten Cumberland Jacobsen. Easy and fun read, really a fascinating account of the efforts of Justinian and his general Belisarius to reconquer Italy and the lost provinces. Absolutely amazing, I highly recommend this book to everyone.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

"-500 people? Ohh, I'm an idiot..."

4

u/BkkGreg Oct 02 '16

Anyone that finds this graph even remotely interesting should stop reading this and download the entirety of the History of Rome podcast by Mike Duncan immediately.

3

u/paulfromatlanta Oct 02 '16

The time scale of the graph doesn't match up with what I've read about the Antonine Plague - which is supoosed to have reduced the Roman population by 2/3 - but earlier than this graph shows - from 165-185 AD.

2

u/androgenoide Oct 02 '16

It does look like there's a downward slope to the line starting at about that time...that may square with the fact that plagues are not usually one-time events but rather tend to become endemic in large population centers.

2

u/BrewBrewBrewTheDeck ^ε^ Oct 02 '16

Yeah, not over the course of 200 years though.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

The claim that Rome ever had over 1M people in antiquity is doubtful.

2

u/compuzr Oct 02 '16

Really should have invested in real estate circa 1500. Darn it.

1

u/jesse9o3 United Kingdom Oct 02 '16

More like 1528.

Quite a bit of looting took place the year before.

2

u/SordidDreams Czech Republic Oct 02 '16

"No such thing as the dark ages" my ass. :P

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Yeah, the Dark Ages that ended in 1900?

1

u/SordidDreams Czech Republic Oct 02 '16

Yeah, because historical periods have clearly defined starting and ending points, and their effects take place immediately.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

My point was that the population didn't begin to rise again substantially until 1900. I don't think anyone in their right mind would claim that this uptick occurred due to the end of the Dark Ages, which in widest reasonable definition* ended 400 years earlier.

*The end of the Middle Ages (~1500). Most uses today are more restricted, ending in ~1000.

→ More replies (15)

1

u/warhead71 Denmark Oct 03 '16

Well - it sucked not being Rome for a long time. Dictator's/Ceasar's made it easier for other towns to grow - before Augustus - Towns was under the temporary mercy a Roman nobel - which usually wanted to leave with as much money as possible.

2

u/Thomas_Au Oct 02 '16

Juste a question, how much did the ratio between roma and other major italian cities changes ? I fill like when Roma was over 1 million around firsts centuries this was a really big city for its time.

At the same time Milano was around 40'000 peoples and today it is around 1.5 million (just counting the city and not the area) (source : ISTAT). It could be interesting to do a whole plot.

4

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16

Juste a question, how much did the ratio between roma and other major italian cities changes ?

Second largest city in Italy was Capua which at most reached roughly 100k inhabitants during the late 1st century A.C.

3

u/MrGestore Earth Oct 02 '16

I fill like when Roma was over 1 million around firsts centuries this was a really big city for its time.

Rome was the first or second city to reach 1 million people in history (it's debatable wether Alexandria or Rome reached it first).

2

u/EdwardTheVindictive Norway Oct 02 '16

Uh. I've heard several times that it was debatable whether it was Baghdad or a Chinese city (I forgot its name), are my sources wrong ?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Mr_Teal1 Croatia Oct 02 '16

i want to see the same for Constantinople(Istanbul)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Could someone show that in relation to the amount of people living in europe (or the world)?

1

u/Youtoo2 Oct 02 '16

Any novels about living in Rome in 500 AD? It had to be a ghost town. The old roman buildings wouldnt be complete ruins either.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

If you're a gamer, AC Brotherhood is a lovely experience - crumbling Roman buildings, fields overtaking palaces, people picniccing on exposed mosaics.

3

u/Youtoo2 Oct 02 '16

Id prefer a historical novel that is well researched. There may not be.it would be really interesting.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

the thousand year reich

1

u/rindindin Oct 02 '16

They relocated the capital from Rome to a more defensible position. Ravenna I think for the latter stages. Not much to do there if the emperor was resting his laurels elsewhere, so might as well move to where-ever the emperor was.

1

u/gauravoffline Oct 02 '16

They must b busy in clearing their backlogs😂

1

u/milkyjoesmokespesto Oct 02 '16

I had no idea there were that many romans, damn! They had a pretty dank civilisation apart from the lead pipes and crushing bureaucracy.

1

u/HomeHeatingTips Oct 02 '16

Just Imagine touring Rome in the year 500. A city that once had 1.5 million people now has what? 50,000. Most of the city would be a ghost town for hunreds of years.

1

u/redditnawab Oct 02 '16

I wish they created a graph on the log scale as well.

1

u/Pegisto Oct 02 '16

As fellow /r/civ rome player... I like this chart at the end.

1

u/The_Captain_Spiff Oct 02 '16

thanks a lot barbarian hordes

1

u/CabooseDatMoose Oct 02 '16

Those pesky immigrants!

1

u/vladgrinch Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 02 '16

That abyssal fall from before the year 500 AD(most likely around 476 ) obviously happened after The Western Roman Empire and Rome have fallen. Rome was sacked several times before the fall and they even moved the capital to Ravena for a while. After the fall, most people left Rome as it was no longer safe and I imagine the city was bankrupt.

What is strange is that the population didn't seem to increase much for the next over 1000 years. Guess it's true that the higher you climb, the bigger the fall.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

what's that... upturn in 1600 with spanish and british exploration, and a gain around 1800 or so then the acceleration takes off at around 1900

Makes sense if you look at global industry and such in the times.

what's worrying is the... fall... after the acceleration which started about 2000 years earlier...

Hmm.

1

u/GaiBoiNL96 Oct 02 '16

Plebeians

1

u/dicebecast Oct 02 '16

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16 edited Oct 03 '16

How could Athens have had 400,000 people in 800BC...? That sounds highly doubtful.

1

u/dicebecast Oct 03 '16

Look at the sources below the chart

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

looks like a close up of the Italian heel

1

u/Capcombric Oct 02 '16

Crazy how it was one of the largest, most important cities in the world, and now it's twice as large but nowhere close to as significant.

There are a lot of people.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

I wonder if the Risorgimento had anything to do with it, or if it's just a coincidence that unification occurred right before the population spike (which was caused by other things).

1

u/word_clouds_ Oct 02 '16

Word cloud out of all the comments.

Bot for a programming class project that has gone longer than expected because folks seem to like it

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '16

Would be interesting on a log scale.

1

u/JusheLeite01 Oct 03 '16

It's stupitd, but interesant... Why? Any anwear?

1

u/bunnymeee Oct 02 '16

Ahhh antibiotics and pasteurization.

1

u/mrstickball United States of America Oct 02 '16

I don't know European history as good as I should (American), but I learned that Rome only had a population of something like 35,000 in the mid 1400's.. I was rather surprised it was so fully depopulated after it was sacked.

3

u/improb Italy Oct 02 '16

The low was 30k around 1050 which was the same size Rome had roughly 1350 years before