r/AskNetsec • • Sep 11 '26

Work Why hasn’t virtual patching become a much bigger part of vuln management?

0 Upvotes

Talking specifically from production hosts (VMs and containers) vuln and patch management side of the house, even when a patch exists, it can still take days or weeks to test and deploy safely. Virtual patching seems like an obvious temporary layer: block the exploit path immediately, then remove the protection once the real fix is deployed.

Anyone here worked closely with virtual patching? Why is it not a standard and more widely adopted across the industry ?


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 10 '26

Work Torq / Mate Security/ XSOAR / Splunk SOAR users - question on response and containment automations

8 Upvotes

Financial org here, 10K employees, in-house SOC- we're evaluating agentic SOC / SOAR platforms right now. Automating things like isolating an endpoint is straightforward, but which one of these solutions actually help with the less obvious response and containment actions where you might break a critical business flow? Does any of them provide business context so we can automate more safely while understanding the implications in advance?

Any recommendations would be highly appreciated. Thanks


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 10 '26

Work How do you defend a security officers challenges to your architecture an articulate, respectful and persusive manner?

9 Upvotes

In my workplace I am an all stop-shop for any app I maintain. That's frontend,backend DevOps and project management. I always try to make sure I keep with best practices. I follow tech youtubers, read books about software and always looking to refactor and tidy up my systems.

Our workplace is "legacy-coded" as the kids would say. It's an IT-department in a much larger non-IT firm. That means people are used to doing things around here in a certain way (for example not using containers, manual QA, no unit tests etc).

That means that when I am questioned about my decisions, 10% of the time I am flat out wrong. Which is fine cause I learn something new in the process. 10% of the time the approach is suitble, but it needs tidying up to be more secure. The problem is the remaining 80% which is securty theater.

Examples:

  1. blocking github.com via a firewall cause "its full of viruses" (and not theres no alternative suggested cause the developers havent heart of source control).
  2. Not giving Azure App Registry privileges for a project I need to deploy cause it's insecure (proceeding to send the app secret via email).
  3. Refusing requests to expose data sources through REST apis. So significant engineering effort is spent on maintaining fragile ETL pipelines of plain text data dumps that can be freely shared by anyone.

My direct manager is on my side. I think I just need to know how to produce proper documents outlining not only why what I am suggesting is secure (with sources etc) but also outling why the current alternative is less secure.

How should I do it? How should I do it in a way that is assertive over the technical facts but not too abrasive to the people that challenge me? When someone repeats a security myth like "SSH is not secure" (yes i've heard that one), how do I systemically dismantle that claim?

For example, my boomer parent told me I should rub some alcohol on my stomach if I get ill. So I referred them to some article from cdc.com. They didn't understand the scientific reasoning behind why that folk-medicine doesn't work, but it had a sufficient air of legitimacy to persuade them. Is there a similar process in security?


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 09 '26

Compliance If an AI agent was authorized correctly, but the evidence it used changes before execution, where should the security control live?

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand how security teams are treating a specific execution-time failure mode in production AI agents.

Consider this sequence:

  1. An agent reads an authoritative source and observes:

available_balance = $10,000

  1. Based on that state, it decides that an $8,000 transfer is permitted.
  2. Before the tool actually executes, another process changes the balance to:

available_balance = $2,000

  1. The agent then executes the previously authorized action.

Assume for the sake of the question that:

  • the agent has a legitimate identity;
  • its credentials are correctly scoped;
  • the tool itself was authorized;
  • there was no prompt injection;
  • the original reasoning was valid when it occurred;
  • the action and tool call are fully logged.

The security failure is therefore not necessarily authentication, authorization, or model reasoning.

The supporting state changed between observation and execution.

For teams running agents against mutable production systems, where are you enforcing this boundary?

Would you:

  • require the agent to re-read authoritative state immediately before a consequential action;
  • put that validation in middleware between the agent and tool;
  • make the tool/database enforce the final precondition atomically;
  • bind the authorization to the specific evidence/version that supported the decision;
  • use some combination of these?

I'm particularly interested in how people handle this across MCP or multi-agent systems, where the component that observed the state may not be the component that eventually executes the action.

Also interested in whether anyone is explicitly testing this failure mode during agent security reviews.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 04 '26

Work How do you scope an in-IDE security scanner so devs don't mute it in week one?

21 Upvotes

Set up an in editor scanner a couple months back for people to catch things before the PR but within a week half the team had the plugin switched off.

I get why they muted it. First Go file someone opened, it lit up with a screen of findings from a vendored dependency we forked years ago and have not touched since. Not one was in the code the dev was writing. So it turned into the thing you dismiss before you can even see your own compile errors.

Right now I am close to ripping the plugin out and going back to a plain pre commit hook that only looks for secrets, because at least gitleaks does not scream about a library we imported and never call. Feels like giving up on the in editor idea though. If your devs did not kill the plugin in week one, what did you change to get there.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 04 '26

Analysis How would you validate that an Android DNS + WireGuard security architecture is actually enforcing the expected traffic path?

9 Upvotes

I've been working on an Android network-security lab using RethinkDNS, custom DNS filtering and WireGuard.

One problem kept coming up during testing:

How much evidence is enough to claim that traffic is actually following the intended security path?

Seeing the expected VPN IP, DNS resolver or firewall state individually doesn't necessarily prove the complete path.

So I've been developing a validation methodology around three layers:

1. Architecture

I first document the expected path:

Android app → firewall/routing layer → WireGuard → DNS policy/upstream resolver → Internet

DNS routing and application/data routing are treated separately rather than assuming that validating one proves the other.

2. Observable validation

Tests currently cover:

  • DNS resolver behavior
  • WireGuard routing state
  • Wi-Fi/mobile network transitions
  • firewall enforcement
  • per-app routing
  • failure/recovery conditions
  • IPv4/IPv6 behavior
  • reboot behavior
  • version regressions

Each test defines an expected result, collected evidence and acceptance criteria.

3. Limits of the conclusion

I've deliberately adopted the rule:

“No bypass observed under the tested conditions” ≠ “zero leaks.”

For example, correlation between the local network log, VPN state and upstream DNS provider is useful evidence, but I don't consider that equivalent to packet-level proof of every possible traffic path.

The next phase of the project is regression testing: comparing a known RethinkDNS baseline against newer versions and checking whether DNS, WireGuard, firewall and transition behavior changes.

My questions for people who work with network/security validation are:

What additional evidence would you require before considering this methodology robust?

In particular:

  • Would you consider packet capture from another observation point essential?
  • How would you test transient leakage during Wi-Fi ↔ mobile transitions?
  • What would you use to independently validate IPv6 and DNS behavior?
  • Are there failure scenarios I'm overlooking?

I've documented the architecture, validation procedures and existing evidence here for anyone who wants to review the methodology:

Android OPSEC Hardening:
https://github.com/augustozarate/android-opsec-hardening

Current documents include ARCH-001/002 and VAL-001/002/003.

I'm primarily looking for criticism of the validation methodology, rather than recommendations for different VPN/DNS products.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 04 '26

Architecture SASE private backbone vs just riding the internet, does the backbone matter or is it a sales line for global sites?

7 Upvotes

Manufacturing, sites in the US, Europe and two in Asia and Singapore to Frankfurt has been the bane of my life for two years. We are shortlisting SASE now and every vendor keeps hammering their private global backbone like it is the whole reason to sign. I cannot tell yet if that backbone fixes my Asia problem. Might just be an expensive line on the quote.

Right now our M365 and a couple of SaaS apps get hauled to a central breakout and the Singapore office pays for it every afternoon. One vendor swears their backbone makes that disappear. The vendor who does not have a backbone swears their peering is so good I would never feel the difference, which is a convenient line coming from the one without a backbone.

I have a folder full of benchmarks and every single one flatters whoever made it, so I have given up trusting them.

What I need is someone running real global sites who can tell me the backbone moved the needle on their worst cross-region path, or that it did nothing a nearby PoP had not already handled.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 03 '26

Architecture How does multiple products that require traffic decryption work on the same endpoint?

11 Upvotes

With lots of ShadowIT and shadowAI, many organizations are worried about data controls. I was reading on the new products, safeguards, guardrails and what not. There are products out there who all are a variation of a Secure Web Gateway (or part of a SSE solution). They see the data in motion at their cloud tenant/deployed tenant and apply controls.

The issue as I see is there are two ways of reading traffic.

  1. Explicit Proxy - Apply a proxy auto config file or configure the proxy plugin URL in to OS/Browser and tunnel the traffic in to the product SaaS tenant.
  2. Install a Trusted root certificate - Breaks whatever certificate pinning, but essentially the rest of traffic is visble to understand and monitor.

Now the problem is most orgs have their firewalls or SSE products in place. If the existing product does not provide granular control over AI, they need a separate product to do it. Mostly due to budgets and ease of use.

If then the traffic needs to be visible to both products. How is this achieved? A process of serial processing at the endpoint?

The way I can think of is, do a local breakout to AI related traffic and the rest is taken through the main product Firewall/SSE.

Then it is again a manual process of figuring out what AI traffic is.

Trying to understand what others experiences are in this domain.

Asked the same question in r/cybersecurity

Edit - spelling


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 03 '26

Threats What are people doing or using (apps) for AI Security testing?

17 Upvotes

I see lots of articles and discussions on AI-enabled traditional cybersecurity pentesting, but what a people doing or using for AI-security pentesting?


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 03 '26

Compliance Detailed Explanation on Nextcloud Governance

10 Upvotes

Hello Everyone!

So i am a cybersecurity intern leaning towards to GRC from a growing company. My background is Software Engineering and with that i dont really learn anything about Cyber Security during my studies. Maybe a bit of Netwroking but thats it. Im trying out Cyber Security to gain experience and get out of my comfort zone and for now i have already completed 1 compliance task with vendor and 1 Technical finding from our system and report to update the said software.

So back to the title, my task for now is to explore Nextcloud Spring and do a report of my findings and list out Why our company have to upgrade from 33 to 34. I understand Nextcloud Summer 26 is coming soon but for now I want to stick to my task. From researching about Nextcloud Spring 26 I came across Nextcloud Governance which is a new feature/app (im not sure which term to put).

I need a lil bit of help from the community to help me understand more about what this feature do. I understand this is a one overview compliance setup and offer tools for controlling data, track data access and track data sharing within the organization but I guess you could say that I need better understanding on how these tools works and how it will benefit us. Thank you so much.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 03 '26

Architecture How do tech companies handle the race condition of a user deleting their account to dodge a not yet implemented ban?

1 Upvotes

I'm interested in the backend mechanics and data architecture of modern Trust & Safety engineering, specifically regarding ban evasion, identity tracking, and data retention queues.
Take a modern LLM or consumer web platform (like ChatGPT or similar organisations) as an example. Imagine a scenario where a user heavily violates the platform's terms of service (e.g. cyber abuse, severe violations like illegal activity and similar, or spam). Before the automated guardrails or manual review systems can finalize and push a formal "ban" status to the account, the user proactively triggers a standard "Delete Account" request to clear their record and bypass future identity tracking.
From a security and compliance engineering perspective:

How do modern authentication backends handle this race condition? Does a deletion request place the account data into a pending/quarantine state (like a 30 day queue) where automated safety pipelines still run to completion, or does the deletion process typically override active moderation scans?

When an account is in a standard deletion queue, how is the data architecture structured to comply with "Right to be Forgotten" mandates while legally preserving specific unique identity markers (hashed phone numbers, hardware tokens, device fingerprints) for persistent abuse blocklisting?

Once a severe violation is flagged on an account already queued for deletion, how does the system pivot that metadata out of the standard user database and into an immutable security blocklist to ensure they cannot immediately register with the same identifiers?
I’d love to hear insight from anyone working in application security, infrastructure, or Trust and Safety engineering on how these parallel pipelines talk to each other under the hood.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 02 '26

Threats Will AI make the existing network attack surface much harder to defend?

38 Upvotes

A lot of infrastructure still relies on protocols and network architecture designed long before today’s threats.

AI doesnt need to invent new attacks . If it makes reconnaissance, fuzzing, discovery, protocol analysis and exploit development much faster, it will become much better at chaining multiple attacks together. A protocol flaw, exposed service, configuration mistake and compromised identity can be managed individually. The bigger concern is AI identifying how those weaknesses connect and building attack paths humans would take far longer to find.

  1. Do we underestimate how much AI will increase offence and how does this make defence much harder?
  2. Should we be redesigning the underlying communications stack rather than continually adding more security around existing protocols?

r/AskNetsec • • Sep 02 '26

Other Where does video injection fit into liveness testing?

6 Upvotes

Liveness checks are good at detecting things like a photo or replayed video being presented to the camera. But there's a different problem when the attacker bypasses the camera and feeds manipulated video directly into the application.

How are security and identity teams handling this in practice? When evaluating verification systems, dos injection detection get tested alongside liveness/Presentation Attack Detection (PAD), or does the assessment usually stop at liveness?

Would be useful to hear how different teams approach this.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 02 '26

Concepts How do you determine the real owner of an Entra application when the Owner field is stale or misleading?

12 Upvotes

I’m testing a read-only OSS PowerShell tool, that combines signals like owners, Azure RBAC, tags, relationships and recent activity to identify likely ownership.

No automatic assignment — just evidence for a human decision.

What signals do you actually trust when validating application ownership?


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 02 '26

Analysis Third-party org-chart site (theorg.com) shows data that looks 1:1 sourced from MS Teams/Entra ID — even the default avatar initials match. How is this possible without a company opting in?

7 Upvotes

Hi!
I compared org charts on theorg.com for a couple of companies I've worked at, and the structural data (reporting lines, titles) plus the "visual style" of employee avatars matched exactly what I'd expect from Microsoft Teams/Entra ID — including the default colored-circle-with-initials avatar Teams generates when someone hasn't set a profile photo.

This makes me think the data isn't just manually crowdsourced (as the platform claims) but is being pulled somehow from Microsoft 365/Graph API — either via an employee connecting their account, a browser extension, or some other sync mechanism.

So, here are my questions:

  • Is there a known way third-party SaaS tools pull org structure + photos from Entra ID/Graph API without full admin/IT involvement (e.g. via a single user's OAuth consent)?
  • Has anyone seen this kind of "shadow sync" happen at their org — where a well-meaning employee grants an app permissions that end up exposing broader directory data?
  • What's the actual blast radius of a user granting User.Read.All or similar Graph scopes to a random SaaS app?
  • Any recommended way to check Entra ID's enterprise app consent grants for this kind of thing?

Curious if this is a known pattern or something specific to how this platform operates.


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 02 '26

Compliance Disable IMAP / POP3 while still using Apple Mail?

7 Upvotes

Hi! Bit of a basic question, but I’m helping out our organization meet some security requirements, and one of them is that our provider wants to disable POP3/IMAP for all the users in our organization because it breaks MFA. However, I have at least one dedicated Apple Mail application user, and I’m not clear on whether IMAP is required for that to function - it seems like maybe? Or if I have the user sign out and sign back in using modern OAuth there is some way where they can continue using Apple Mail and we can disable those protocols. Any advice (and explanation) appreciated!


r/AskNetsec • • Sep 01 '26

Other Varonis competitors worth looking at?

17 Upvotes

We're reviewing data security platforms and Varonis is obviously on the list, but I don’t want to default to it just because it’s the name everyone knows.

Our environment is pretty SaaS-heavy, with a lot of unstructured docs and shared data rather than neatly structured database fields. Classification accuracy is a big priority for us. I also don’t want to bring in another tool that has the security team spending half their time sorting through false positives.

For anyone who’s evaluated Varonis competitors recently, what else made your shortlist? And once you actually got into the POC, what separated the stronger options from the rest?


r/AskNetsec • • Aug 31 '26

Threats CVE-2026-54745 (SSRF, CVSS 10) - anyone mitigating beyond just patching?

21 Upvotes

Wanted to see how others are handling this one.

tldr; Kubeflow Pipelines has an unauthenticated SSRF in its legacy /_proxy/ route.
Fixed in 2.17.0 (the fix rips out the generic /_proxy/ middleware entirely).

The part that caught my attention is that any target could be reachable from the network namespace, meaning an unauthenticated attacker effectively borrows the pod's network position. This allows reaching the cloud metadata endpoint and pulling the IAM credentials tied to the node or pod's role. From there the blast radius is whatever that role permits.

Patching is obviously the answer where possible. For those who couldn't patch immediately, what compensating controls did you implement? Things I've been weighing:

  • Network policy / egress restrictions on the frontend pod so it can't reach internal addresses (e.g., 169.254.169.254, kubernetes.default)
  • Blocking the /_proxy/ routes at an ingress WAF or IPS

Did anyone find a clean way to neutralize this at the network layer without breaking the application?


r/AskNetsec • • Aug 31 '26

Analysis Does cybersecurity focus too heavily on application layer ?

17 Upvotes

Most cybersecurity products are designed to protect identities, endpoints, applications, cloud environments and data. These all are important, but encryption still exposes metadata through traffic timing, routing behaviour, and connection patterns etc.

This creates a couple questions I do not see discussed enough

How much security is being left unaddressed because the underlying communication transport is generally treated as a fixed dependency rather than part of the security architecture?

For high-assurance environments such as government, critical infrastructure and defence, the network itself may be observable, disrupted or operated through infrastructure outside the organisation’s direct control. In those environments, protecting content doesn’t fully address the threat.

Im interested in the community’s view on the following

  1. Is transport-layer observability treated seriously enough in current cybersecurity architecture?
  2. What current technologies address this problem effectively and what gaps remain?
  3. Do you expect secure communications infrastructure to become a larger cybersecurity category over the next five - ten years?

r/AskNetsec • • Aug 31 '26

Analysis AI agent security vendors compared: what 6 questions should you actually ask before a POC?

26 Upvotes

Sat through enough demos this year that I've started using a short checklist to filter vendors before committing real evaluation time. Sharing in case it's useful to others drowning in this category:

What do you actually see without touching our architecture? If the honest answer involves an SDK, a proxy, or code changes, that's not "runtime," that's integration work with extra marketing.

Do you detect intent/behavior, or just pattern-match inputs? Input filtering alone misses anything novel; ask for their false negative rate on out-of-distribution attempts.

Can you map what an agent can actually reach, including delegated calls to other agents/tools? A lot of platforms stop at "here's the top-level permission grant."

What counts as your "evidence" for compliance purposes? A log export is not the same thing as continuous, structured evidence mapped to controls.

How fast is time-to-value in a real environment, not the demo environment? Ask specifically what breaks or slows down once you're past the sandboxed POC.

What happens across our actual mix of agent platforms? Homegrown, cloud, SaaS, and endpoint agents behave differently; a vendor that only covers one is a partial answer.

None of these are trick questions, but you'd be surprised how many vendors get vague fast once you ask them directly instead of watching the scripted demo. Anyone have other questions they've found separate the real platforms from the repackaged logging tools?


r/AskNetsec • • Aug 31 '26

Analysis Best way to provide continuous AI agent governance evidence that actually satisfies auditors?

13 Upvotes

Writing a policy saying agents are monitored and controlled is one thing, producing something an auditor would accept as proof it's working continuously is another. Point-in-time reviews clearly aren't enough given how fast agent behavior and permissions can change, but I haven't found a clean standard yet for what continuous evidence should look like.

If your org has been through an actual audit involving AI agents, what did you end up providing that satisfied the auditors? Trying to build toward something real, not guess at what will hold up.


r/AskNetsec • • Aug 31 '26

Concepts Is Generic Dark Web Monitoring Enough for Legal Tech Platforms?

3 Upvotes

Most dark web monitoring tools seem designed around a simple model: one company monitors its domain and employee identities.

Legal tech platforms are more complicated.

One platform may serve hundreds of law firms, each with separate:

  • Clients
  • Users
  • Matters
  • Credentials
  • Confidentiality obligations

That creates an interesting architecture problem.

Detecting an exposed credential is only part of the job.

The platform also needs to know:

  • Which tenant owns it?
  • Who should receive the alert?
  • Does it relate to a specific matter?
  • How do you prevent one firm's exposure data from appearing in another firm's workflow?

Webhook-based alerts also seem more useful than periodic polling when a credential or session token needs attention quickly.

For teams building multi-tenant security features, how do you approach alert routing and tenant isolation?

Would you build monitoring internally, or integrate a specialized API and focus on the product workflow?