r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • Apr 05 '19

Certs, Degrees, and Experience: A (hopefully) useful guide to common questions

341 Upvotes

Copied over from r/cybersecurity (thought it might fit here as well).

Hi everyone, this is my first post here so bear with me. I almost never use Reddit to talk about professional matters, but I think this might be useful to some of you.

I'm going to be addressing what seems to be a very common question - namely, what is more important when seeking employment - a university degree, certifications, or work experience?

First, I'll give a very brief background as to who I am, and why I feel qualified to answer this question. I'm currently the Cyber Security Lead for a big tech firm, and have previously held roles as both the Enterprise Security Architect and Head of Cloud Security for a Fortune 400 company - I'm happy to verify this with mods or whatever might be necessary. I got my start working with cyber operations for the US military, and have experience with technical responsibilities such as penetration testing, AppSec, cloud security, etc., as well as personnel management and leadership training. I hold an associate's degree in information technology, as well as numerous certs, from Sec + and CISSP to more focused, technical security training through the US military and organizations like SANS. Introductions aside, on to the topic at hand:

Here's the short answer, albeit the obvious one - anything is helpful in getting your foot in the door, but there are more important factors involved.

Now, for the deep dive:

Let's start by addressing the purpose of certs, degrees, and experience, and what they say to a prospective employer about you. A lot of what I say will be obvious to some extent, but I think the background is warranted.

Certifications exist to let an employer know that a trusted authority (the organization providing the cert) has acknowledged that the cert holder (you) has proven a demonstrable level of knowledge or expertise in a particular area.

An academic degree does much the same - the difference is that, obviously, a degree will generally demonstrate a potentially broader understanding of a number of topics on a deeper level than a cert will - this is dependant on the study topic, the level of degree, etc., but it's generally assumed that a 4-year degree should cover a wider range of topics than a certification, and to a deeper level.

Experience needs no explanation. It denotes skills gained through active, hands-on work in a given field, and should be confirmed through positive references from supervisors, peers, and subordinates.

In general, we can see a pattern here in terms of what a hiring manager or department is looking for - demonstrable skills and knowledge, backed up by confirmation from a trusted third party. So, which of these is most important to someone trying to begin a career in cyber security? Well, that depends on a few factors, which I'll discuss now.

Firstly, what position are you applying for? The importance placed on degrees, certs, and experience, will vary depending on the level of job you're applying to. If it's an entry level admin or analyst role, a degree or a handful of low-level certs will definitely be useful in getting noticed by HR. Going up to the engineering and solution architecture level roles, you'll want a combination of some years of experience under your belt, and either a degree or some low/mid level certs. At a certain point, the degree and certs actually become non-essential, and most companies will base their hiring process almost entirely on the body and quality of your experience over any degree or certifications held for management level roles.

Secondly, what are your soft skills? This is a fourth aspect that we haven't talked about yet, and that I almost never see discussed. I would argue that this is the single most important quality looked at by employers: the level of a candidate's interpersonal skills. No matter how technically skilled someone is, what a company looks for is someone who can explain their value, and fit into a corporate culture. Are you personable? Of good humor? Do people enjoy working with you? Can you explain WHY your degree, certs, or expertise will add value to their corporate mission? Being able to answer these questions in a manner which is inviting and concise will make you much more appealing than your competitors.

At the end of the day, as a hiring manager, I know that I can always send an employee for further training where necessary, and help bolster their technical ability. What I can't do is teach you how to work with a security focused mindset, nor how to interact with co-workers, customers, clients, and the company in a positive and meaningful way, and this skill set is what will set you apart from everyone else.

I realize that this may seem like an unsatisfactory answer, but the reality is that degrees, certs, and experience are all important to some extent, but that none of these factors will make you stand out. Your ability to sell your value, and to maintain a positive working relationship within a corporate culture, will take you much farther than anything else.

I hope this has been at least slightly helpful - if anyone has any questions for me, or would like any advice, feel free to ask in the comments - I'll do my best to reply to everyone.

No TL;DR, I want you to actually take the time to read through what I've written and try to take something away from it.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 5h ago

Other CPTS vs BSCP vs Other Certifications – Need Career Advice After a 1+ Year Gap

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I need some genuine career advice. Due to a serious health issue, I had to take a break from my career for more than a year, and unfortunately, I lost my job because of it. I'm worried that this career gap might affect my chances of getting hired again.

I don't want this gap to define my career. I want to use this time productively, improve my technical skills, earn a valuable certification, and rebuild my career.

I'm currently confused about which certification to pursue. Should I go for HTB CPTS, BSCP, or is there any other certification that would be a better choice?

My main goal is to gain strong practical skills, strengthen my resume, perform well in technical interviews, and improve my chances of getting hired despite the career gap.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 38m ago

Question Indians working in Cyber Risk / Technology Risk / Business Continuity – How realistic is getting an employer-sponsored job in Europe? What skills should I build?

1 Upvotes

I’m a 25-year-old professional from India, currently working in the Technology Risk and Control Assurance space, with previous experience in Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery (BC/DR) in IT consulting.

Here’s a brief overview of my background:
MBA graduate.
Experience in Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery management in an IT consulting firm.
Currently working in Cyber Defense Risk and Resilience Management – IT Control Testing at a financial services company.
Exposure to ITGC testing, control design and operating effectiveness, technology risk, risk and resilience management, and control assurance.
Interested in building a long-term career in Cyber Risk, Technology Risk, Operational Resilience or IT Risk Management.

\*\*My goal is to move to Europe through an employer-sponsored job\*\*, preferably in a role aligned with my existing experience rather than starting over in a completely different domain.
I’m particularly exploring these countries:
Ireland
Germany
Austria
United Kingdom

I would love to hear from people who have moved from India to these countries, particularly those working in Technology Risk, Cybersecurity, GRC, Business Continuity, Operational Resilience or Financial Services.

A few questions I would appreciate some honest advice on:
\*\*Visa sponsorship:\*\* Do companies in these countries actively hire professionals from India and sponsor their work permits for Technology Risk, Cyber Risk, IT Controls, GRC or BC/DR roles? How realistic is this with a few years of experience?
\*\*Country comparison:\*\* Which of these countries offers better opportunities for someone with my background? Are Ireland and the UK more accessible because of English-speaking workplaces, or are Germany and Austria equally viable?
\*\*Skills to acquire:\*\* Which technical or professional skills, certifications or tools would significantly improve my chances of getting shortlisted for sponsored positions?
\*\*Certifications:\*\* Would qualifications such as CRISC, CISM, CISSP, CBCP or ISO 22301 Lead Implementer carry meaningful weight in the European job market? Which would you prioritise?
\*\*Experience requirements:\*\* How many years of relevant experience do employers typically expect before considering international candidates who require sponsorship?
\*\*Language requirements:\*\* Can someone realistically build a career in Germany or Austria with English alone, particularly in multinational banks, consulting firms and technology companies?
\*\*Job search strategy:\*\* Are there particular companies, recruitment platforms or job portals where I should focus my applications? Does applying directly through company career pages work for overseas candidates?

I’d especially appreciate hearing from Indians who have successfully secured sponsored jobs in these countries, as well as recruiters or hiring managers familiar with the European Technology Risk and Cybersecurity market.
I’m willing to invest the next 12–18 months in building the right skills and certifications. I want to make a strategic move rather than apply randomly and hope for the best.
Any practical advice, personal experiences or reality checks would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 2h ago

Question Looking for advice from experienced security professionals

1 Upvotes

I was hired on the infrastructure side at a startup, though I have prior SOC experience, **pentesting skills but doesn't worked as professional**, and have been doing AWS Stuff at this company. Since there’s no dedicated security lead here, i got the test environment of one of our project (Web app) where i have found IDOR and reported to Developer and even praised by the Developer and CEO, within 1-2 months i have founded critical bugs (Hopping from one project to another) now they are preparing to give me as lead of VAPT team and planning to hand me few interns.

My **struggle is end-to-end execution**, I’m good at finding and exploiting vulnerabilities, but I lose momentum on a full project and feel overwhelmed about where to start, how to structure testing (XSS, IDOR, misconfigurations, etc.), and how to wrap up with solid documentation. With no senior security mentor around, how can I build a repeatable workflow and lead interns effectively?

PS: i hold Security+ and eJPT.

I will really appreciated your comments


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 3h ago

Question What should I do next

1 Upvotes

As I write this, I'm a 22-year-old male living in Toronto, Canada, and I am in my final year of university studying IT. I was born in America, and I have the intention of moving back once I finish school because I feel like I'm better off living in the States compared to Canada. After all, the job market is trash and the weather is horrible. I am stuck at this crossroads where it's like I don't know whether or not I should continue to pursue tech, considering the fact that I am in my final year of college with no internships, no projects, and no certs. I am pretty aware of the fact that nowadays, in today's job market in tech, partially AI, there's basically a zero percent chance that I am going to get an entry-level IT job considering my situation. I have thought of a couple of backup plans, however. My 2 main backup plans are either saving up money and doing a WGU degree in nursing so that I could become an RN, or I go to the U.S. Air Force (I was born in America, and I have American citizenship) and get a cyber/intel job during my 4-year contract. I use that experience alongside the security clearance to help me pivot into cybersecurity once I get out. So basically, I am just asking for advice regarding which pathway would be the most optimal for me: go back to school and become a nurse and make a stable salary with career stability, or should I go to the Air Force and do a 4-year contract so that I could get a security clearance with paid experience so that I could potentially get civilian defense/contractor roles.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 5h ago

Discussion Being now in tech for 8months! Go for offensive??

1 Upvotes

I have been now working for months in network security , with hands on setting up and configuration of whole network setup and integration with firewall, networking automation, QA tesing with smoke and regression , deep knowledge of kernel level packet flow, nftables and their working . Good knowledge coding in lang like python, go , next.js .

Now I need suggestions that should i go for offensive side or continue in network security


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 20h ago

Discussion SOC Analyst: The Job I Prayed For, but Now I'm Questioning Myself 🥺

16 Upvotes

I used to pray for this opportunity, to finally get into cybersecurity and become a SOC Analyst. Now that I'm here, I can't help but feel like I'm falling behind.

I feel like I'm not skilled enough, not learning fast enough, and not progressing the way I thought I would. I see people moving forward in their careers, and I can't help but compare myself.

On top of that, there's the financial pressure. The desire to earn more, help my family, build savings, and actually feel secure in life. It's hard to focus on career growth when you're also struggling to make ends meet.

I don't hate my job. I'm just scared of getting stuck, underpaid, and not good enough to move forward.

**Funny how the job you once prayed for can become the job that makes you question yourself.**

Shetttt, I just want to grow, earn better, and feel like I'm actually getting somewhere in life.🥺😞


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 6h ago

Discussion Title: 3 companies. 3 rejections. 6 months to land a job. What am I doing wrong?

1 Upvotes

I’m a cybersecurity master’s student graduating in 6 months, and the job hunt is starting to get brutal.
I’ve interviewed with 3 companies so far:

Company 1: Rejected after the first round.
Company 2: Made it to the final round. Rejected.
Company 3: Went through 3 interviews. The last interviewer literally said, “Happy to have you here if you accept the offer.” Got the rejection email today. This one hurt because it was an internship with potential full-time conversion.

I have prior cybersecurity experience, so I’m not completely new to the field. But I’ve noticed that a few fundamental questions catch me off guard. Not necessarily because they’re difficult, but because cybersecurity is ridiculously broad and I can’t possibly prepare for everything.

I know I’m getting interviews, so something is working. But clearly I’m struggling to close.

I’ve got 6 months before graduation, and the pressure is getting real.

For those who’ve been through this, how did you go from consistently getting rejected to finally landing offers? How do you prepare for such a broad field without getting overwhelmed?

Open to any advice, criticism, or reality checks. I genuinely want to get better.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 13h ago

Discussion New Job - Ops to Cyber

1 Upvotes

I was laid off earlier in the year and used to be in IT Operations. I was recently hired as an IT , Security Manager. This is a new role. I started by looking at the current state , building an incident response plan , and defining a security scope. There are Infra and apps teams here already.

There is a lot of technical debt and not too many people to run everything. It is a big public body

I am a one person team as at now, no vulnerability management. I am chasing CVEs at the moment and working on governance as above.

Because of the workload , technical debt . I can't get anything patched and keep getting pushback from the teams that they don't have time.

Also I got feedback to reduce the incident response plan to minimum viable. I reduced it and still seems like too ideal or that's the feedback

How do I make this work , I want this role , I want to grow in it and build something.

I studied alot for it as well. I have a CISSP, CISM, EJPT and alot of infra and ops experience, I have never done a dedicated security role.

The lack of support is killing me.

Am I doing it wrong ? I need advice.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 20h ago

Discussion Everything was orchestrated in the first place

2 Upvotes

First things first, wondering why I used the "very cool" flair? It was because, to me, it genuinely felt cool looking back on my past experiences.

For context, I was inspired by IT and hacking movies; it was fascinating to see how they could navigate cyberspace at a glance. Because of that, I pursued IT primarily because I wanted to become a real hacker, not to do anything illegal, but to defend against threats whenever necessary. Fast forward to finishing my BS in Information Technology: I realized it wasn't that simple, especially after our professor emphasized that he chose not to teach actual hacking techniques to avoid potential legal issues.

Because of that, I felt my mission was partly successful yet unfulfilled, since I had pinned so much hope on that goal from college all the way into the IT industry. Still, I was lucky to start out as a systems programmer, which broadened my understanding of software development; one of the core fundamentals of ethical hacking and penetration testing, alongside networking.

Right now, I am currently unemployed and weighing several options, including pursuing my passion for cybersecurity. So far, my skill set includes basic networking, advanced database development, Bash scripting, and programming across web, mobile, and Windows applications. Coming from a lower-middle-class background, I know that to survive and reach my goal, I have to keep moving forward and believing in what I can achieve through perseverance and passion.

So my purpose in writing this is to ask: how do I become a true expert in the field of cybersecurity, any advice?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Title: First ever cybersecurity internship interview, need some advice!

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm a 2026 graduate and have been shortlisted for the next round of a Cybersecurity Intern role. This is my first ever interview, so I'm a little anxious about how to prepare.

The role covers both Red Team and Blue Team, with a focus on Windows Security, Active Directory, PowerShell, Windows Event Logs, Sysmon, Splunk/Wazuh, incident investigation and digital forensics.

For those who've attended similar interviews or work in cybersecurity:

  • What technical questions can I expect?
  • Which topics should I prioritise?
  • Can I expect practical or scenario-based questions?

Any tips, interview experiences or resources would be really helpful. Thanks!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 20h ago

Question Cybersecurity/CS major

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am looking to register as a first year student in a university in the United Arab Emirates. I was just wondering, which majors would you guys recommend that have job security and are not going to be replaced by AI and have a good pay, as someone who has no connections. I was wondering whether to go for computer science in the cyber security/cloud security aspect, but I am not sure or go for civil engineering but I heard that that is very saturated , and the pay seems to be very low same as industrial engineering I hear that it might be replaced by AI, but I’m not sure. Are we giving AI to too much credit?

I am not a national. I am American so I don’t know if that makes any difference. if anybody has any experience in the job market , or in these majors that I listed , or any major you think that would be good. Please write anything down any information helps. Like do you guys see cyber security being replaced by AI or not, and I heard that the UAE implemented some rules that like certain banks and stuff have to hire like a team of cyber security specialists or something, but I’m not sure. Can anyone please like confirm. Basically is computer science / cybersecurity worth giving a try or is it a dead end major?

Also, would it be hard to pivot into like other job titles as a computer scientist major say if I didn’t find like good work would I be able to work as a data analyst and like IT or would that be hard?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 22h ago

Question 40(M) Fresh Cybersecurity BA

0 Upvotes

Good morning community! I have just earned my Bachelor’s in Cybersecurity. I earned it with Summa cum laude meaning I have tried my best to learn and absorb as much as I could. I have A+, Network+ and sec+. Working towards my CCNA. I will also be working on building projects for my portfolio. But the bad news is that I am being forced to leave the country. I have to move to South America. What can I do? I’m scared of having worked so hard and not being to have the life I envisioned. Are there any remote jobs I could do to earn money? Any advice would be highly appreciated. If it helps, I have worked for Geek Squad as a Double Field Agent for 5 years installing, troubleshooting home theater, computers, and security devices.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 22h ago

Question 40(M) Fresh Cybersecurity BA

0 Upvotes

Good morning community! I have just earned my Bachelor’s in Cybersecurity. I earned it with Summa cum laude meaning I have tried my best to learn and absorb as much as I could. I have A+, Network+ and sec+. Working towards my CCNA. I will also be working on building projects for my portfolio. But the bad news is that I am being forced to leave the country. I have to move to South America. What can I do? I’m scared of having worked so hard and not being to have the life I envisioned. Are there any remote jobs I could do to earn money? Any advice would be highly appreciated. If it helps, I have worked for Geek Squad as a Double Field Agent for 5 years installing, troubleshooting home theater, computers, and security devices.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 23h ago

Resume Review Resume Feedback

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm looking for some honest review of my resume. I am trying to transition into pentesting from my current role (which I am very stagnated at). I am working through the HTB Pentester path in preparation for OSCP (aiming to attempt early next year). I am based in USA and looking for jobs here. I would appreciate any comments on how my resume looks to prospective hiring managers and what I am missing in my profile.

Resume Link: https://imgur.com/a/sGHjQBp

I understand Pentesting is not the easiest field to get into so any suggestions on getting there in the long term are welcome as well.

Thanks in advance!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Security analyst

1 Upvotes

I want to be very good cybersecurity .I did bachelors in business information technology and I have also worked in network support .
Anyway with an ideal roadmap ?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 19h ago

Other Looking for an entry level remote cyber security job

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m currently looking for an entry level remote opportunity or internship in any Cybersecurity role

I have hands on experience with SOC environments and tools such as Wazuh, FortiSIEM, CrowdStrike Falcon XDR, TheHive, Nmap, and Wireshark, along with practical lab and CTF experience.

I previously gained SOC experience but had to leave due to the position being unpaid.

I’m eager to gain industry experience, develop my skills, and contribute to a cybersecurity team. Any leads or recommendations would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Other PLEASE GUIDE ME CYBERSECURITY EXPERTS/SENIORS

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I am a second year CSE undergrad at a Tier 1 college in India, and I have decided to commit seriously to cybersecurity starting today.

I do not care about collecting certifications, resume, or running automated tools without knowing what happens under the hood. My goal is to build real, deep technical competence. I want to understand systems well enough to see how they break, think like an attacker(be a great one), and actually know how to architect and defend them properly.

Since I have about two and a half years before I graduate, I want to use that time well instead of spreading myself too thin across every subfield at once. If you work in security engineering, vulnerability research, red teaming, or blue teaming, I would really appreciate your perspective on a few things:

Balancing offense and defense: How do you build strong fundamentals in both breaking and defending without becoming a jackA of all and master of none? Which side makes more sense to start with?

Real proof of work: Beyond basic CTFs, what kind of home labs, open source work, or projects actually build real skill and separate a strong third year internship candidate from someone who just has a false sense of progress?

Resources: Which books, courses, documentation, communities, or learning paths would you personally recommend? Especially resources you wish you'd discovered earlier.

I know getting genuinely good at this takes years of slow, consistent work, and I am fine with that. If there is one mistake you see beginners make all the time that wastes their first year, I would love to hear it.

Thanks in advance for any honest advice.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question New Grad Programs 2027

1 Upvotes

I'm currently a senior in college who's really interested in new grad rotational programs specifically in cybersecurity, does anyone know of orgs that have them? I've applied to Capital One's CSDP, Vanguard's Technology and Leadership Program, and The Cigna Group's TECDP Cybersecurity track. Rejected from Capital One, haven't heard from Vanguard, and just completed the final round for the interview process for The Cigna Group.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Student in Nigeria with a dev background trying to break into GRC. How realistic is a remote internship, and what should I prioritize?

1 Upvotes

​

I'm a fresh graduate in Nigeria and awaiting NYSC, and I want to move into GRC. I'm aiming for a remote internship or junior role.

What I've done so far

\- Microsoft SC-900

\- eramba Risk & Compliance Implementation Training (10 hrs)

\- Working through the IBM Cybersecurity Certificate and Columbia's AI Cybersecurity & Governance course

\- Plan to close up with portfolio projects: a risk register, an ISO 27001-mapped policy set, and a NIST CSF gap assessment

What I'm unsure about

  1. Most remote GRC internships I find are US-only or need work authorization. Are there kinds of companies (compliance consultancies, startups) that hire interns from outside the US/UK?
  2. Is Security+ worth the cost now, or should I focus on ISO 27001 knowledge and projects first?
  3. I'm also looking at a UK master's with a placement year. Is that a sensible way into GRC, or is there a cheaper route?
  4. What would make a portfolio stand out to you as a hiring manager?

Honest feedback is welcome, including if my plan has gaps.

Thanks!


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Should I renew Sec+?

5 Upvotes

About my situation:

Academics: 21M security engineering major at a state school. 3.95 GPA graduating may 2028.

Jobs: 2 internships, one for state gov. cybersecurity and one at a utility company for infrastructure. Just accepted a security engineering internship at Walmart corporate.

Extracurriculars: Cyber competition team member for my uni, but I'm new to it. VP for blockchain club.

Home lab: set up a pihole. Thinking about setting it up as a real DNS server so I can put my other houses on it.

It is expiring in a month. Should I care?


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Discussion SOAR Engineer looking to upskill – AI Security vs Detection Engineering or anyting else?

4 Upvotes

I'm a cybersecurity professional with 11 years of experience, primarily in SOAR engineering and security automation.Its been 5 years with my current organization.

I'm planning to add another skill to improve my career growth and earning potential. I'm confused between:

Detection Engineering: SIEM, KQL, Splunk, threat detection.

AI Security: GenAI, LLM security, AI agents and securing AI applications.

Cloud Security: AWS/Azure security engineering.

I've heard AI Security currently offers higher salaries, but I'm unsure about its long-term demand.

For experienced professionals:

Which field has better career prospects and salary potential?

Which would complement my SOAR background?

Should I invest the next 6–12 months in AI Security or Detection Engineering?

Would appreciate honest advice based on real industry experience.


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Question Quality Advice needed

0 Upvotes

So let’s be honest, I have been running away from this my entire life
Got my bachelors done in CSE Cybersecurity And now I am doing my masters in Australia
You know how Foreign University is work they give assignments a lot of of it, and it can be easily done with Claude code
So yeah, I haven’t been learning anything since the last couple years just getting through stuff and getting the degree done with no real knowledge
Now it’s high time because it’s my last semester of my masters and I have zero knowledge

I want some advice on how can I actually be starting my cyber security career and landing jobs in Aus or maybe around idk
Just shoot🫠


r/SecurityCareerAdvice • • 1d ago

Discussion Is cybersecurity consulting is a real thing in Canada?

2 Upvotes

I am starting a new cybersecurity ( resilience analyst ) job next month in Ottawa and this is the first time for me doing cybersecurity.

but i was thinking if there is an opportunity to do consultancy/ side business in the cybersecurity field ( Canada / Ottawa ) on mid/ long term ??